4 ms·
> Since all taxes are ultimately borne by land ... Objection, your honor. Assumes facts not in evidence. How is income tax ultimately borne by land? Sales t
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
> Since all taxes are ultimately borne by land ...
Objection, your honor. Assumes facts not in evidence.
How is income tax ultimately borne by land? Sales tax? Inheritance tax? Gasoline tax? Corporate income tax on corporations like SpaceX, Goldman Sachs, and Intel?
"Ultimately borne by land" may have made sense a century or three ago, when (almost) all income ultimately came from the land. That's not the world we live in any longer.
- prichino 5y agoThe username checks out; where do you think wealth comes from if not land? Paper money in the end is just a representation of claims for assets generated from land. Food, minerals, energy, actual things all come from land. You cannot eat a metaverse.
- AnimalMuppet 5y ago> The username checks out; where do you think wealth comes from if not land? I gave several examples of wealth that doesn't come from land. I asked for an explanation of how, in those examples, wealth came from land. You reply with an insult to my chosen username. That's... not a very good argument. > Paper money in the end is just a representation of claims for assets generated from land. Here you're using the assumption that all wealth comes from land (the exact assumption I was questioning) in your argument. That's circular, and therefore flawed. You can't assume X and use that in your proof of X. > Food, minerals, energy, actual things all come from land. The silicon that goes into Intel chips comes from land. The chips themselves? Not so much. The single biggest factor in Google's prosperity is the google.com domain name. How big a real estate footprint does that have? I hear that Taylor Swift has a pretty big income. How much of her income is based off of land? It's derived from a musical imagination. > You cannot eat a metaverse. This I will grant you. All food (currently) is derived from land. There's a lot more to wealth than food, though.
- prichino 4y agoI apologize for the uncalled snark. My point is that at the end of the day everything valuable at some point came from the land. The Intel factory is just wealth that was extracted and accumulated earlier, it is an actual, valuable asset.
- snidane 5y agoGeorgists divide into two categories. They define land differently, or emphasize different aspects of it. 1. Left wing georgists. Land = resource needed for human life. Humans cannot fly, therefore land is a life necessity. Food grows on land and nowhere else, therefore land is necessary for life. 2. Right wing georgists. Land as a monopoly. Electromagnetic spectrum (5g, wifi, radio waves) cannot have too many owners of a band otherwise you get interference. Google.com domain can be owned only by one entity otherwise you get mess. For actual land (geographical parcel) you hold exclusive use rights, that others have to respect, otherwise you get fights for territory. All of these - geo area, name system, electromagnetic spectrum - constitute a form of land. There are grades of it which differently priced and only one owner can operate it at a time. Land is still the most important section of economy. Real estate is mainly land speculation. You can observe billionaires investing in real estate and land when there is nowhere else to invest, so it definitely is not piece of worthless nothing that only had value in 19th century when majority of population was still employed in agriculture. Except homeless, 100% of population is invested in real estate. Only tiny portion of money is spent on stocks comparatively. Georgist philosophy lives completely ouside of the current left right spectrum, both on the political and cultural level. However, if it become the next societal paradigm, you'll see this divide again. It is becoming a real possiblity it'd become the next paradigm because after zero interest rate policy, quantitative easing, helicopter money and debt amnesties, the only choice is between a war and georgism.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoSo, if you define "land" as including domain names, patents, copyrights, trade secrets, and electromagnetic spectrum, then sure, almost all money comes from "land". I would say that at that point, calling it "land" is pretty misleading, though. A right-wing Georgist who wanted to communicate ought to call it something else, like "monopoly control" or something. > after zero interest rate policy, quantitative easing, helicopter money and debt amnesties, the only choice is between a war and georgism. Objection, your honor. Assumes facts not in evidence. Many Georgism advocates seem to have this idea that Georgism is this magic formula that is going to fix everything, and the only alternative is catastrophe. Even by those standards, though, this statement seems rather extreme. Can you defend it, rather than simply assert it?
- andrewjl 5y agoYou can't eat sunlight or the wind either yet both seem pretty useful.
- igorkraw 5y agoAnd where do you plant the crops or build the wind turbines and solar plants to harness these?
- andrewjl 5y agoYou're begging the question here. Currently we need land for these but that can change.
- igorkraw 5y agoNo, I'm simply asking the inconvenient question, that's different. How can it change?
- prichino 4y agoAnd to add, and where do you get the materials to build the wind turbines and solar plants?
- klyrs 5y agoIf you take the view that "land" is where all the matter on earth comes from, it kinda makes sense. It's the strictest interpretation of materialism I've ever heard, though; there would be nothing of value without input of the sun's energy.
- imtringued 5y agoThe exact proximity of earth to the sun is what gives the land on earth value. In fact, this implies that humans did none of the work, they just took what was already there and labeled it their own.
- prichino 4y agoNot quite, owners DID the work and labeled it their own.
- imtringued 5y agoHow do you plan on existing without a universe, without any laws of physics? Ownership of land extends into the ground and into the sky. You are owning a slice of the universe. The earth is conveniently located near a nuclear fusion reactor the energy it radiates is embodied in the value of land on earth. The value of land on Pluto is very low. Nobody wants to live there. The fossil or nuclear fuels you dig out to power your car or fridge are ultimately born from land. Energy is derived from what is below our feet and extraction rights are literally the ownership of land. >How is income tax ultimately borne by land? Sales tax? Inheritance tax? Gasoline tax? Corporate income tax on corporations like SpaceX, Goldman Sachs, and Intel? Gasoline must be refined from crude oil which is extracted from land. SpaceX needs aluminium, steel and rocket fuel which all must be extracted from land. Goldman Sachs just manages incomes derived from land. Intel obviously depends on an uncountable number of chemical compounds derived from the land