5 ms·
Since all taxes are ultimately borne by land (specifically, by resources in fixed supply), it's not at all clear that compensation is required for a neutral tax
by zozbot234 5y ago
Since all taxes are ultimately borne by land (specifically, by resources in fixed supply), it's not at all clear that compensation is required for a neutral tax shift.
- TimPC 5y agoSome people argue no compensation is required but I think in reality an LVT at 100% reduces the price of all land to $0. Given that land is substantial portion of retirement savings in our current economy, completely obliterating land prices without any compensation seems morally dubious. Perhaps if you do it slowly enough that you give everyone time to adjust and make the market adjustments gradual enough that people who need to sell land for retirement can still get something like 90% of the value initially it could work.
- zozbot234 5y agoNobody is arguing for a literal 100% LVT. You'd want to still leave a fraction of land rent (say 10% or so) untaxed, since this introduces a desirable market mechanism in property assessment - and George even acknowledges this. What's nutty is to let land speculators capture all of that value for no real reason.
- TimPC 5y agoI think the group that is capturing the most value is actually landlords, followed by speculators. I also agree that 90% LVT may be better in practice, although I do know people who still argue for 100% and various auction mechanisms to determine the LVT.
- MiddleEndian 5y agoAs much as I think LVT makes sense, having to go to some sort of annual auction for my own land does seem worse than just paying taxes. Along with that being a tedious process, that could put you at the mercy of malicious actors who may just dislike you and have enough cash to outbid you. Any implementation would have to not include this for people to be able to have stable lives.
- imtringued 5y agoA yearly auction is overkill. Do it every 5-10 years with a fee the longer you delay the next auction. (Like banks charge more interest the longer a fixed rate loan is)
- MiddleEndian 5y agoEh still sounds pretty terrible really. The assessment people should be able to figure it out however they normally figure out taxes.
- zozbot234 5y agoYou could use "auctions" to capture that residual value if those were long-term land leases. But you'd still want to assess and tax land rent afterwards, because in practice high-stakes leases have proven vulnerable to government corruption.
- imtringued 5y agoSilvio Gesell proposed an auction mechanism but I honestly don't care about the details. You can lease land. Tax it or auction it off. There are so many good enough solutions that one does not have to be picky.
- prichino 5y agoThat's the gist of it. If land is so worthless even rich people don't want anything to do with it, why would it make someone poor better off to have it?
- TimPC 5y agoBecause you can put structures on the land and capture the entire value of the structure? There is a difference between something being intrinsically worthless and the taxes driving the market price to $0.
- imtringued 5y agoNo, if land was worth $0 people would bid it up until the value of the land is how much they are willing to pay per year in taxes.
- AnimalMuppet 5y ago> Since all taxes are ultimately borne by land ... Objection, your honor. Assumes facts not in evidence. How is income tax ultimately borne by land? Sales tax? Inheritance tax? Gasoline tax? Corporate income tax on corporations like SpaceX, Goldman Sachs, and Intel? "Ultimately borne by land" may have made sense a century or three ago, when (almost) all income ultimately came from the land. That's not the world we live in any longer.
- prichino 5y agoThe username checks out; where do you think wealth comes from if not land? Paper money in the end is just a representation of claims for assets generated from land. Food, minerals, energy, actual things all come from land. You cannot eat a metaverse.
- AnimalMuppet 5y ago> The username checks out; where do you think wealth comes from if not land? I gave several examples of wealth that doesn't come from land. I asked for an explanation of how, in those examples, wealth came from land. You reply with an insult to my chosen username. That's... not a very good argument. > Paper money in the end is just a representation of claims for assets generated from land. Here you're using the assumption that all wealth comes from land (the exact assumption I was questioning) in your argument. That's circular, and therefore flawed. You can't assume X and use that in your proof of X. > Food, minerals, energy, actual things all come from land. The silicon that goes into Intel chips comes from land. The chips themselves? Not so much. The single biggest factor in Google's prosperity is the google.com domain name. How big a real estate footprint does that have? I hear that Taylor Swift has a pretty big income. How much of her income is based off of land? It's derived from a musical imagination. > You cannot eat a metaverse. This I will grant you. All food (currently) is derived from land. There's a lot more to wealth than food, though.
- prichino 4y agoI apologize for the uncalled snark. My point is that at the end of the day everything valuable at some point came from the land. The Intel factory is just wealth that was extracted and accumulated earlier, it is an actual, valuable asset.