6 ms·
I may have to pick this up -- as someone with no economics training at all, a land value tax seems extremely appealing and intuitive to me. I'd already like to
by bee_rider 5y ago
I may have to pick this up -- as someone with no economics training at all, a land value tax seems extremely appealing and intuitive to me. I'd already like to become a complete partisan in favor of this policy, but I guess it would make sense to read what the actual justification is, for it, haha.
- scythe 5y agoThe biggest problem with LVT is surprisingly simple: accurately assessing the value of land is very hard, and ensuring that the assessment process is fair is therefore extremely hard. LVT experiments in history tend to run into problems when people feel that their land has been valued incorrectly, leading to a vocal minority that despises the law. That results in something like this: https://nassimtaleb.org/2016/08/intolerant-wins-dictatorship-small-minority/ https://nassimtaleb.org/2016/08/intolerant-wins-dictatorship...
- markdown 5y agoCould you tell us where these experiments were held, and how far they went? For example, were other taxes eliminated at the same time?
- notacoward 5y agoSee my sibling comment to yours. The most notable examples are in New Zealand, Australia, and several towns in Pennsylvania. Some of those ran into problems with execution, others were abandoned for purely ideological/selfish reasons, but overall it's not a bad record.
- bee_rider 5y agoHuh. Property tax is already a thing of course, but I guess if the LVT was going to replace all taxation the stakes would be much higher. In an urban setting, it seems to me that the land value should be... reasonably uniform, unlike property, which should make assessing much easier, right? But that's just getting the number. Whether people are happy with the number is a whole 'nother problem.
- its_ethan 5y agoI would have assumed exactly the opposite in terms of urban land being uniform in value. 10 acres that are 30 minutes from Des Moines, IA are going to be very similar in value (price people are willing to pay) compared to 10 acres that are 10 miles down the road. Rural land is generally quite uniform and more likely to be functionally the same. In an urban area, say Los Angeles, 10 acres in Malibu (an area with very high demand for property) is going to have a totally different value (again, price people are willing to pay) as compared to 10 acres 10 miles away in skid row. The problem, that other people have highlighted, is how do you (the government/IRS/agency in charge) determine the value of each of those land areas? Letting some city planners in LA decide that those two areas should have the same LVT, or allowing them to determine what tax each should have, is gifting a lot of power to people who may or may not be qualified, and may or may not experience any sort of consequence for poor decision making/ biased value assessment/ etc. The exact way that sort of value/tax-setting would play out would be very interesting, but the unintended consequences could end up being pretty bad. I've always thought it was interesting that property tax assessments don't just use the previous purchase price, and instead rely on a relatively arbitrary valuation. That could be one way to more accurately determine an LVT - make it a set percent of the previous purchase price of the land, that would allow the taxes to be priced in to land transactions. I still just don't love the idea at its core.
- colinmhayes 5y agoNow you've brought the horror that is prop 13 to a tax that is supposed to replace all other taxes. Things change in value, we have to account for that.
- bee_rider 5y agoWith a land value tax we could at least come up with pretty straightforward equations, right? Some starting value from being in town, then add something for oceanfront property, then add something some extra bump based on distance from some set of amenities provided by the community (parks, subways, etc). It is at least possible to come up with something, unlike, what, the assessor's gut feeling about how nice your house is? This seems like it is putting much more arbitrary power in the hands of some random person.
- mrob 5y agoPeople who disagree with their assessed value should be given the option to declare whatever value they like. If they take this option, the state should have the option of buying their property at the declared value, plus some extra to cover transaction costs.
- colinmhayes 5y agoThe problem is that most land has stuff on top of it. The government can't buy the land without the building that comes with it.
- CuriousSkeptic 5y agoAt the surface it seems there should be a market solution for this. One approach might be to do something clever with mortages and property rights. Basically keep trying to keep the current mechanics of borrowing and just shifting around the parties involved so that the all the interest gets collected as LVT. Might even let the central bank handle both collection and dividends of it all. Another option might be to create economic incentives for some party to get the assessment right. Like insurance companies and banks loose either customers or revenue when getting it wrong. Perhaps can play with some margin for speculation such that lender and borrower get to share some profit. Or just make lenders outbid each other on who can extract most rent for the property. I guess one concern here is to make sure the commons have a representation, so that not all land get appropriated to private use
- bee_rider 5y agoThis is a 'clever' solution to property taxes. But a land value tax specifically just taxes based on the value of the land. This is supposed to incentivize people to use their land as productively as possible -- with a property tax, any improvements you make increases your tax bill, with a land value tax, it doesn't. A moral argument for it is, if you own an empty lot which is gaining in value as the community grows around it, you are essentially leeching extra value from the community through no work of your own. This sort of behavior is punished heavily with an LVT, as your taxes go up but you don't get any extra revenue from your empty lot.
- notacoward 5y agoFocusing on that one issue presents an incomplete picture, to say the least. LVT has been tried many places, and has been no less successful than other tax systems. Here's a pretty thorough analysis and discussion of empirical results. https://www.lincolninst.edu/sites/default/files/pubfiles/assessing-theory-practice-land-value-taxation-full_0.pdf https://www.lincolninst.edu/sites/default/files/pubfiles/ass... Of course there are secondary and/or orthogonal problems that need to be solved. Of course there are some people who complain, either because they are truly being overtaxed or (more often) because they think they personally would do better under some other system. Just like literally every other tax system including the ones most of us live under right now. LVT is no panacea, but there are legitimate reasons to believe it's a fundamentally better starting point than the mishmash of income, sales, and property taxes we have now.
- notahacker 5y agoThe biggest problem with it as presented in Progress and Poverty (i.e. as a Single Tax to fund the government budget, not some small supplementary levy to fund something like local services) is that the size of the tax bears relatively little relation to the ability of someone to pay it (at least, to pay it without selling their house). Turfing pensioners out of their house because the land it sits on gained in value faster than their pension whilst others earn millions virtually tax free obviously isn't a natural vote winner.
- TimPC 5y agoMost modern day versions proposed allow you to defer the tax until the sale of your home or pay it as part of the settling of your estate.
- zozbot234 5y ago> Turfing pensioners out of their house because the land it sits on gained in value faster than their pension This is a well-known canard. If someone can't pay their tax on a primary residence, you put a lien on the property that becomes enforceable when the ownership changes hands, whether by sale or inheritance. No one gets "thrown out" of their homes.
- notahacker 5y agoProposing children are kicked out of family homes isn't necessarily more politically palatable, and deferrals introduce revenue issues (especially if LVT causes land value to fall over time, which is often mooted as an advantage by Georgists...) But that's a minor issue compared with the second part of my post, which is that if a proposed tax reform reduces the tax burden on almost every corporation and high net worth individual (bar a few land speculators and domestic oil well owners), ordinary people have to pay more to the government or get less from the government. LVT might be perfectly viable as a tax, but as a Single Tax replacing the existing set of taxes (which arent exactly optimal from the point of progressitivity to start off with) it's a wealth transfer on an unprecedented scale from people whose wealth is mainly the property they bought (including the land it sits on) to people whose wealth is mainly the shares they own. The latter category is much richer than the former.
- TimPC 5y agoMy city already does a two-factor assessment that includes land value and structure value for assessing my property tax. I don't think just doing the land value component is substantially harder although I do agree it's slightly harder.
- mynameishere 5y agoIt seems extremely unappealing to me. It seems like something a wealthy apartment-dweller in a tall building in a dense city would come up with to move taxation from himself to the guy in the country with two acres and a mobile home. The more I think about it, the more I'm sure that's the actual motivation.
- danbolt 5y agoWouldn’t a LVT mean that the taxes on the mobile home be much less than the apartment in the dense city?
- zozbot234 5y agoCorrect. Land "in the country" is worth zilch compared to a similar plot in a dense urban core. GP has it backwards, they're perhaps thinking of some flat tax on land based on square footage whereas LVT is based on assessed value.
- mynameishere 5y agoI'm just going by the headline definition: "A land value tax is a levy on the value of land without regard to buildings, personal property and other improvements." That's the basic idea. I think people need to keep in mind the actual purpose of taxation: One group is taking resources from another. Nobody is pushing this tax (or any) because it's "efficient" or whatever. They are pushing it because they will come out ahead. A person who lives in a 600 square foot apartment in a 60 story tower will effectively be paying taxes on 10 square feet of actual land. That land might be very valuable, but I suspect no matter how you twist the numbers, it's going to be less than two acres anywhere in the country. Especially if you go by the spirit of the LVT, which is to ignore improvements. I could be wrong. I'm just guessing at "who fucks over whom" here.
- colinmhayes 5y agoThe more I read about LVT the more clear it is to me that it legitimately solves many, many problems society is currently facing. The housing price crisis is effectively solved by LVT. The "greedy landlord" meme is effectively solved by LVT. Income tax being distortionary is solved by LVT. NIMBYism caused by people wanting their home to be worth more is solved by LVT. Yes, some are better off, some are worse. It's not as clear as you think though. Rural land is worth very little compared to urban. The real losers are people who have single family homes in desirable areas.
- mcguire 5y agoAbsolutely! The biggest advantage for most, particularly readers of HN, is described in part II (http://gameofrent.com/content/can-lvt-be-passed-on-to-tenants http://gameofrent.com/content/can-lvt-be-passed-on-to-tenant...): "...landlords cannot pass Land Value Tax (LVT) on to their tenants..." Renting an apartment in SF would therefore both be cheap, because the LVT encourages high-density, and tax-advantaged, especially if the LVT is (as it is supposed to be) the only tax. The bottom line is that this idea has literally no downside.
- TimPC 5y agoRenting the apartment in SF will not be cheap because the land has extremely high value. It's just the government will capture the high value of that land instead of landlords and that high value land capture will be used to remove other taxes like income tax and property tax. Land prices in SF would fall slightly as the LVT removes most speculation. So likely rents go from $6000/month to something like $5400/month. But the government might capture $4500 of that to reduce other taxes. If we still had 1870's small government the idea would be to put most of the LVT into a Citizen's Dividend which functions like a UBI and helps people pay for their cost of living (including some of the land taxes).
- colinmhayes 5y agoRental prices would not change, it's just that more of the money would go to government instead of the landlord, especially for low density housing.
- TheCoelacanth 5y agoThey probably would decrease somewhat, because there's no longer an incentive for landowners to prevent people from building housing to keep the supply low.
- ryukafalz 5y agoThis is something I’ve been wondering about with LVT. Wouldn’t they still have an incentive to stop people from building more dense housing near them? Even more of an incentive than now, in fact? Because the more people that can live and work in the immediate area near them, the more valuable the land is, and the more they’ll pay in tax.