3 ms·
I would like to have a bike with this drive system for doing structured training workouts outdoors. Cyclists and triathletes often do workouts involving multipl
by nradov 5y ago
I would like to have a bike with this drive system for doing structured training workouts outdoors. Cyclists and triathletes often do workouts involving multiple steps with a prescribed power output, for example 10 one minute intervals at 300 W with two minutes of recovery at 140 W plus 15 minutes of warm up and cool down at 170 W. It's simple to execute that workout on an indoor smart trainer in erg mode since it will dynamically adjust the resistance to hit the exact target power, but even with a game like Zwift indoor training is super boring. You can do the same workout outdoors on a real bike, but then you have to keep watching the power meter to stay in the target range which is distracting and somewhat of a safety hazard. So this system could offer the best of both worlds if the target power is externally controllable through ANT+. Of course that would probably be only a small niche market.
- user32489318 5y agoI see your point, and I can see some application in group rides, social events with a less fit SO, but 1) in TT, or even in any regular bike climbing, holding constant power is an important skill to master. Try doing a 45min varying gradient climb at 5-15% below FTP. It is not only your legs, but also your brain anticipating the gear shifts. Give the Alpe du Zwift a try, turn ERG mode off, and you'll understand what I mean. Variance in the power output wears you down. (that's why we use Normalised Power numbers for fatigue). You've to train that, not by doing3min on-1min off intervals, but by riding on real tarmac. Also, after few thousands hours of training you don't need to look at your head unit to know if your power is constant or not. 2) Power is not the only bottleneck for riding 300W, 400W, 450W for 10min, that where the handling skills of your bike come in play. That one of the reasons why we do 'speed training', cycling behind a buddy on a scooter/car. To get used to the cadence, braking, steering, ... Imagine participating in a race, riding 50+km/h without any fast cornering/breaking experience, that's a hazard! 3) Imagine doing an all-out interval session on TT bike, in a full aero position, and getting passed by an elderly on e-bike. Everyone will think "that guy is a bit weird", won't they? 4) Max. power output of this motor is 250W, I believe this to be an EU regulation. That is 20% less power on the rear wheel than the FTP of an average amateur racer. There are also speed regulations in EU, 25-28 km/h. That's certainly the Strava numbers to show off! You can make it a motorcycle/scooter and remove these limits, but then you'll need to wear motorcycle helmet in many EU countries. Also, you are no longer allowed on the bicycle lanes. 5) People who are serious enough about their cycling are generally quite serious on the bike position. For example, the Q-factor is the distance between your shoe cleats. Favero released power meter pedals for Shimano SDP-SL cleats, but added 1cm to the q-factor, just look at the flame war it caused. 6) Most people train on their 'race-day' bike. Some have a spare 'bad weather' bike. Now, you want to train on an additional training bike, with a different geometry to the race-day bike? Or are you expecting to have a TT bike with this drive train + a race day TT-bike? TT-bike will run into 5-15k USD, I might like my hobby, but won't put extra 5-15k for this nice to have feature. I think 'niche market' is an underestimation, since there are already assisted racing/MTB bikes (limited to 28km/h), just slap power meter pedals on and you're ready to go.
- Mildlypolite 5y agoHi, I remember that an app similar to what you are talking about were developed for the specialized evo ebikes. You could set a fixed power output and if you went higher the motor would come in to help you stay in the power You choose. Pretty cool.