4 ms·
I thought SIDS had been debunked as more ordinary suffocation aggravated by a few types of respiratory irritation or development issues combined with unsafe sle
by colechristensen 5y ago
I thought SIDS had been debunked as more ordinary suffocation aggravated by a few types of respiratory irritation or development issues combined with unsafe sleeping conditions. A dying child being so traumatic that reasons beyond the ordinary have been searched for quite hard without finding any real underlying condition beyond baby can’t breathe and is too small to wake and rearrange itself.
- bpodgursky 5y agoIt's really hard to tease out given the sensitivity of the issue but while the vast majority of SIDs deaths are environmental or situational (smoke, unsafe sleep, cushions, accidental parent suffocation, intentional parent suffocation...) afaik there does seem to be some low base rate of SIDs deaths which have no obvious explanation.
- kazinator 5y agoEven if a SIDS death takes place in such an environment, it has to be unexplained in order for that diagnosis to be applicable. > low base rate of SID[S] deaths which have no obvious explanation. All SIDS deaths have no obvious explanation; that is how SIDS is defined.
- clucas 5y agoDo you have any source for this? I didn't see anything to that effect on Wikipedia (which cites articles from NEJM and other reputable journals when discussing the phenomenon) or the Mayo Clinic's page. You (and others in this thread) are talking about this debunking as if it's common knowledge, but I'm not seeing it. Am I looking in the wrong places?
- colechristensen 5y agoHere's one https://safetosleep.nichd.nih.gov/activities/SIDS/progress https://safetosleep.nichd.nih.gov/activities/SIDS/progress The SIDS rate dropped from ~1.4 to ~0.5 per thousand with a pretty strong correlation to back-sleeping and a campaign to promote it, combined with shifting cause of death diagnoses to "accidental suffocation". If you can reduce the prevalence of a diagnosis by 65% by having babies sleep on their back, there's a good chance the cause of death in a good few of the remaining cases (and ones not prevented in the path) ought to be something like "suffocated while not sleeping on their back" instead of a mysterious illness. Even the linked paper quotes >The “triple risk model” hypothesises that SIDS deaths result from coincident occurrence of a vulnerable infant, a critical developmental period, and an exogenous stressor which if this is the model for SIDS should get real philosophical questioning as to the appropriateness of bundling this together into a syndrome instead of labeling the actual cause and trying to fix it specifically (as in, promoting back sleeping as it is a risk for infant suffocation) I don't want to vet individual claims of physicians to quote them, but there are many out there questioning the merits of SIDS as a diagnosis. There is, however, not a boss in charge of science who is going to stamp SIDS as "doesn't exist", and the diagnosis will likely stick around for a long time because of the social issues attached with the trauma and attempts to find non-blaming answers for why a child died.
- sonotathrowaway 5y agoTrying to write off the rest of the deaths as improper sleeping doesn’t really make sense to me - that’s like saying that since the majority of strep cases can be treated with broad spectrum antibiotics, therefore MERS doesn’t exist.
- colechristensen 5y agoThere are indeed always going to be unknown causes of death at any age, sometimes it is just hard to determine. It seems inappropriate to give a name and diagnosis to “cause unknown” MERS and strep both have easily attributed causes. SIDS seems really not to, it really seems that there is not an underlying cause that doesn’t already exist. “Babies are more susceptible to suffocation and more care needs to be taken in their sleeping arrangement” doesn’t seem like a disease, even if some babies are more susceptible than others (and those many individual susceptibilities already have names) Baby humans are vulnerable to lots of things because that’s what they are, SIDS and modern attempts to attribute it to things seems to be a harmful distraction from the actual causes of death.
- clucas 5y agoInteresting. Would you consider type 2 diabetes to be a disease? There are clear, well known steps people can take to reduce the likelihood of it happening, after all... I would be more sympathetic to your position if it were likely for death to occur if an infant sleeps in their belly, but that doesn't seem to be the case. It sure seems like SIDS is pretty rare even when belly sleeping, it just increases the risk factor. But, I've only started reading about it in the past two hours, so who knows. Thanks for the reply, in any case.
- colechristensen 5y ago> I would be more sympathetic to your position if it were likely for death to occur if an infant sleeps in their belly Given the statistics of back sleeping campaign success it seems fair to say that having your baby sleep on its belly instead of its back would kill 1 in 1000 babies. That doesn’t seem particularly rare. Riding in a car without a car seat is considerably safer, getting covid is considerably safer. It would make up about 20 percent of child mortality deaths in the US, that’s not insignificant.
- kazinator 5y agoThat is false. SIDS is a term that refers to an unexplained death. Any death which can be root caused in any of the ways you refer to, or any other manner, cannot be diagnosed as SIDS. It is not possible to root-cause SIDS because the term semantically refers to deaths without a known root cause. If a death can be attributed to a cause, it stops being SIDS.
- colechristensen 5y ago"SIDS is a catchall term that refers to an unexplained death" and "SIDS doesn't exist" would seem to really mean the same thing.
- kazinator 5y agoNo, because that entails the proposition "unexplained deaths don't exist".
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> I thought SIDS had been debunked as... SIDS is a generic catch-all for unexplained sudden infant deaths . That's why it's literally "sudden infant death syndrome". At population scale, certainly some deaths would be counted in the SIDS bucket due to missing ordinary suffocation during the autopsy, but it's not correct to say that every SIDS case is just suffocation or that SIDS has been "debunked".
- colechristensen 5y agoAnd that diagnosis should be considered harmful if it is just a catchall for "unknown cause of death" because people go looking for answers which won't exist like this study while ignoring actual causes of death which may be preventable (like encouraging back-sleeping saves a huge percentage of SIDS-attributed deaths).
- roguecoder 5y agoNope! The narrative of individual responsibility has been pushed for a long time because it was all we had, but it's always been the case that even doing everything perfectly correct doesn't reduce the risk to zero. We discovered in the past decade that infants have a neurological difference where, when deprived of oxygen, instead of trying to get more air they simply stop breathing: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fneur.2015.00220/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fneur.2015.0022... It's not "ordinary suffocation". Instead, anything that reduces how much oxygen an infant is getting, including colds, mild allergic reactions, rolling over onto their face, acid reflux, not enough ventilation, etc, will potentially trigger a complete shut-down of their breathing & eventually death.
- jjeaff 5y agoThat would explain why mitigation measures seem to help. Even though they may not be the true cause.
- colechristensen 5y agoYou have to be cautious here, babies need to be protected from many things that don’t necessarily need to be classified as diseases. Babies are just vulnerable. There is a point where a vulnerability gets classified as a disease, which is sort of the core of the issue.