5 ms·
> I'm simply pointing out that there are genuine policy reasons to endorse this and if you oppose this it would be wise to find other ways of solving the concer
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
> I'm simply pointing out that there are genuine policy reasons to endorse this and if you oppose this it would be wise to find other ways of solving the concerns people like Kutcher are raising.
If I propose putting an unobstructed streaming camera in every room of every house, that would also solve a lot of problems. That does not mean people who oppose my solution need to come up with alternatives. They can simply oppose cameras in every room due to the problems of cameras in every room.
- ng55QPSK 5y ago" Any sound that Winston made, above the level of a very low whisper, would be picked up by the telescreen; moreover, so long as he remained within the field of vision which the metal plaque commanded, he could be seen as well as heard. There was, of course, no way of knowing whether you were being watched at any given moment. How often, or on what system, the Thought Police plugged in on any individual wire was guesswork. " — Part I, Chapter 1, Nineteen Eighty-Four
- tremon 5y agoAnd that is even less of a dystopia than what we're capable of now: there is no reason for any person to be plugging in to the telescreen to watch someone live, because it can all be recorded and then retroactively browsed at will.
- loufe 5y agoEven worse, everything can be processed by efficient and reliable algorithms which reduces administrative load.
- Tozen 5y agoThe great thing about using "the algorithm", is that when if fails or is wrong, you blame it and not the creators, administrators, and authorizers of it.
- ng55QPSK 5y agoThat's the point here. We are living in a post-1984 world. Already.
- RC_ITR 5y agoIt will never cease to amuse me that Orwell intended to write a book about geopolitics and the downsides of a fractionalized world, but instead accidentally wrote a book that everyone interprets as an anti-government manifesto.
- ImPostingOnHN 5y agoI'm glad we can all take away from literature something personal to us. Your view is no more or less wrong than anyone else's, and I'd like to hear more.
- scarecrowbob 5y agoWell, as I understand it he literally was an anarchist, correct?
- foldr 5y agoOrwell was not really an anarchist in his political views. You can get a fairly good overview of his political views from The Lion and the Unicorn: https://www.orwellfoundation.com/the-orwell-foundation/orwell/essays-and-other-works/the-lion-and-the-unicorn-socialism-and-the-english-genius/ https://www.orwellfoundation.com/the-orwell-foundation/orwel...
- pengaru 5y ago> everyone interprets as an anti-government manifesto It's been a while so maybe my memory is just flawed, but my feelings about 1984 are more that it's a cautionary tale of living in a dystopian surveillance state. That's not the same as anti-government. I actually expect my government to assist in preventing such outcomes considering there's obviously lucrative and powerful corporate interests pursuant to these machinations.
- 5y ago
- HWR_14 5y agoAssuming a human even watches it as opposed to some ML algorithm.
- Verdex 5y agoYeah, this was the part that also occurred to me. With 1984 the threat that someone could watch is chilling. With our tech level everyone could be constantly watched and evaluated in real time by some sort of AI. There are two directions the updated 1984 can now take. The AI is reporting you to the government. Or the AI just takes care of your punishment itself. Are you actually a dissident or did you just sneeze and the AI interpreted that as some code phrase? Doesn't matter.
- ng55QPSK 5y agoYou could read O'Brian as non-human and Emanuel Goldstein as GAN.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoTrue, luckily the mind reading from the book has yet to be invented.
- Dma54rhs 5y agoI propose this to politicians homes since they are the greatest risk vector for nations. It sounds justified.
- winnipeg 5y agoWhat you're missing is, at best, the tech to achieve this without actually needing the camera placed inside the room, will exist at scale in this century. At worst, it is already deployed in "hot" areas (areas significant to national security, experimental areas). The question becomes how to control the inevitable proliferation of commoditized mass survelliance. Privacy in the future will require a level of defense not available via common residential/commercial construction methods. Hell, even a SCIF eventually won't help..
- sitkack 5y ago> If I propose putting an unobstructed streaming camera in every room of every house, that would also solve a lot of problems. This line of rhetoric doesn't help the conversation.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoWhat does line of rhetoric mean? The example was to show the poor logic of “you should have an alternative solution if you oppose this solution”. One can simply prefer the downsides of the status quo rather than different downsides of a change.
- riversflow 5y agoSo you prefer your perceived absolute privacy (how sure are you that the NSA doesnt have a backdoor in the baseband?) over the enslavement of over 10,000’s of people world wide each year?
- BlargMcLarg 5y agoThat's not the comparison you can make. You're going to have to sell us a bit harder on how fully breaking the commoner's privacy is going to ensure those enslavements won't happen. Until then, it's all assumptions. More reasonable is you're going to make things maybe a little safer for kids to do stupid things you could educate them on, at the cost of trading any potential privacy on the internet. You'd even have to cover private channels, as the mere threat of blackmail would be enough to cause problems.
- riversflow 5y agoYou make the assumption that the commoner’s privacy will actually be broken, make it so that using the backdoor requires a warrant, and can only be used legally on suspected traffickers. Rapists and slavers shouldn’t have access to military grade encryption, full stop.
- 5y ago