68 ms·
I stopped to watch kids playing at recess – security was called
- sleepymoose 5y agoThe way I see it, if they didn't want people to look through the fence, then they should replace the fence with something that can't be looked through. Change it to a solid fence type, put up a wall, or even just put inserts through the chainlink to block the view.
- DeathArrow 5y agoIn my Eastern European country, I can still watch kids playing and take pictures when I get my kids to the playground without anyone accusing me or looking weird at me. What happened to everyone is innocent until proven guilty?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- goncaloo 5y agoInteresting article. I feel this is more a problem in the US. I live in Switzerland and you often see kids walking alone or in pairs going to and from school all by themselves - and yet no kids seem to be kidnapped or exposed to inappropriate behavior.
- Miner49er 5y agoThat's how it was in the US until fairly recently. It changed in the last decade or two. I'm not sure why. Crime hasn't gotten any worse, as far as I know.
- rendall 5y agoIt started in the 80s, related to the Satanic Panic, particularly the McMartin preschool trials. Before that, it was expected that even very young children could be outside alone even in urban settings.
- msmenardi 5y agoThe kids who were raised in that era grew up, had kids, and passed the generational trauma down the line. We'll grow past it eventually, but it takes time for people to heal and the trauma to filter out of the population.
- trashtester 5y ago> We'll grow past it eventually, Don't take this for granted. I suspect this behavior is actually caused by an inherent anxiety in some subset of the population. When they don't have real (and likely) dangers to worry about, they will find some kind of tiny risk and overamplify it as something to focus their anxiety on. Removing all things dangerous from the environment will only serve to amplify their tendency to do so. A mum in a high risk high crime neighbourhood is probably more likely to let her kids roam free (and less worried) than mums in upper-middle-class neighbourhoods where there is virtually zero crime. My hypothesis is that the solution is to let children experience activities that are moderately dangerous (ideally through risk of pain, minor injury or some social stress, with risk of death or permanent injury kept minimal). This helps (I think) callibrate their ability to estimate risk as they grow up. This would allow them to ignore imaginary risks like the one discussed here, and may help them identify situations that come with real danger.
- int_19h 5y agoThe people who were the driving force behind all the "Satanic Panic" stuff are still around, too. And some of them still pose as experts on "recovered memories" and other stuff like that.
- greenglass 5y agoThis too was a media driven hysteria. You can see how the news amplifying a few rare kidnapping and molestation cases, if it bleeds it leads style, is directly correlated to the public intrigue. A lot of movies and tv shows took on these themes as well. Much like the red scare and more recent mass hysterias driven by an unscrupulous news industry political complex.
- _fat_santa 5y agoThe problem we have in the US is we tend to placate to the vocal minority, rather than realizing that they are in fact just a vocal minority. Say you have 10 parents that let their kids play outside. No one has a problem with this until an 11th parent shows up and it mortified, think the kids will all get hurt if they are allowed to be outside like this. That parent makes a stink, take it to the city council, and a rule is put in place that you can't let your kids go outside without supervision. The folks making the rules think to themselves "well we had to act, there was such an outcry". Meanwhile the outcry is really just the outsized screams of one parent, and you've just screwed the other 10 parents.
- foobarian 5y agoI think it's more subtle than that. If you are the city council member, doing something about it is a lot easier than not. Saying "I don't think we should make our children safer" is politically difficult. So the rules slowly ratchet up.
- pessimizer 5y ago> The problem we have in the US is we tend to placate to the vocal minority, rather than realizing that they are in fact just a vocal minority. I think it's related to trauma fetishization combined with child worship. Trauma fetishization: The person who is most traumatized by a thing should be the one who dictates policy about that thing. People who have lost children qualify, and we literally name the laws after their dead children. Child worship: Children are without trauma, and therefore without neurosis. When you traumatize them or through inaction allow them to be traumatized, you have created neurosis, which is the source of all problems in society.
- unethical_ban 5y agoThere was a post about an abortion rights rally, with the poster saying "Keep our women safe". Someone came in and said, essentially, "I appreciate the message and the support, but can we drop the possessive 'our'"? It was called out that the "our" was itself supportive and indicative of community. The person replied "I came from a small town where men used 'our women' as a signal of ownership and I shudder when I hear it". My internal response: Okay? You're asking everyone to change a good-faith saying because it triggered a bad memory for you? Get over it.
- dariusj18 5y agoBecause people got super freaked over the risk of pedophiles, though they should worry more about their family members perpetuating sexual abuse than a random stranger.
- aksss 5y agoTo some degree perhaps aggravated by people having less kids, therefore the kids they do have are extremely valuable to them, driving demands that the world be nerfed up.
- t0mas88 5y agoI'm not sure it works that way. It's not like you care less about your first child after having a second. They're all the most loved thing you have in life.
- aksss 5y agoIt's all anecdote, but I believe I've witnessed it many times - families with four kids don't love them any less, but they are less attentive to any one, less photos are taken, by kids 3 & 4 things aren't really "new" and scary like they are with kid 1. Couples with a single kid, particularly after trying for a while, have come across as highly protective and hyper-focused. I'm just speculating here - I recognize I don't know nuffin about it, ultimately.
- BenjiWiebe 5y agoI'm an oldest child, 3 siblings. My experiences and observations would agree with you. Sometimes it even gets just a little annoying - how come my youngest sibling gets to do things at a much younger age then I was allowed to? :)
- kbelder 5y agoI've had four... five? I lose track. You're right, in that it's not that you care any less about your later kids, but you tend to be more pragmatic about child rearing. Better at recognizing the important events and problems, while shrugging off and ignoring the trivial stuff. You learn that you don't need to worry about a kid eating a crayon, and you recognize that certain pain cries mean "I'm not really hurt." You realize that sometimes the best thing you can do for a kid is ignore them and let them figure stuff out themselves.
- somethoughts 5y agoConversely - it'd be interesting to investigate whether other statistics have improved over the past decade with parents being increasingly responsible for their kids after school - reduced shoplifting, reduced graffiti, reduced smoking/drug use, reduced teen pregnancy, etc. Its quite possible that increased organized sports and after school activities (particularly robotics, math, computer science) could actually improve the capabilities of society as compared to just leaving the kids unattended after school.
- jhugo 5y agoI'd suspect quite the opposite; kids who have their time filled with organised activities and have no time to come up with their own may be less likely to develop important skills like creativity, self-reliance, and be more reliant on structure and authority.
- lamontcg 5y agoWatch the local news or get on your nextdoor group and it is all packed full of crime stories. A lot of people are addicted to feeling scared all the time, and the media is feeding them.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoPerception of crime has gotten worse as people consume more fear driven media.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dudul 5y agoAs mentioned in the article, people don't care about facts. Kidnapping is at an all time low in the US. The only instances are family members during a nasty divorce or things like that. "Think of the children" is the main weapon politics have to push regulations and more control. It is important that everybody thinks that kids are in danger at all time otherwise it would stop working.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tablespoon 5y ago> As mentioned in the article, people don't care about facts. Kidnapping is at an all time low in the US. The only instances are family members during a nasty divorce or things like that. I agree that kidnapping is probably at an all-time low, but it's an unbelievable claim that it's all "family members during a nasty divorce or things like that." I personally know a family who's kid was kidnapped (briefly) by a non-family member. > "Think of the children" is the main weapon politics have to push regulations and more control. It is important that everybody thinks that kids are in danger at all time otherwise it would stop working. That's not what's going on here. It's a cultural issue. You've got a longstanding issue with crime, especially particularly "worst fear"-type crime, getting disproportionate attention in the media, creating false impressions and seeds for fear-fantasies. Now, added to that is new cultural obsession with abuse and victim-hood; and the idea of completely stamping that out is possible, and it should be achieved whatever the cost. You might have a politicians exploiting this cultural issue to accomplish other things, but they certainly didn't create the phenomenon of hyper-vigalent school paraprofessionals.
- mgkimsal 5y ago> I personally know a family who's kid was kidnapped (briefly) by a non-family member. Sorry to read that, but it's still a statistically small percent that happens to. One can say "but even one is too much", and I appreciate the sentiment, but optimizing for the .1% isn't always a good path. > they certainly didn't create the phenomenon of hyper-vigalent school paraprofessionals. "they" probably contributed to the culture that produced the current school paraprofessionals. EDIT: Some interesting numbers at https://www.missingkids.org/theissues/nonfamily https://www.missingkids.org/theissues/nonfamily - of abductions reported to them, 1% are by non-family members, meaning... 99% of reported cases (to their org) are by family members. That may not line up with 'law enforcement' numbers exactly - there's not a clear indication as to what gets reported to them. But the ~1% matches up with other numbers I've seen in the past on missing children. It's almost always a family member or someone known to the child.
- ido 5y agoSame for me. I live in Berlin (biggest city in Germany) & have 2 kids of my own and haven't seen anything remotely as paranoid here as what you read about US cities.
- twothamendment 5y agoI'm not saying there aren't bad things in the US, but the things in the news are not normal everywhere in the US. But for big cities? I think I'll take my chances in Berlin.
- marban 5y agoMost parts of Europe are fine but Japan's the best by far.
- mmcgaha 5y agoAs a parent in the US, here is how it feels. If I let my young kids roam and something happens to them, there is a high likelihood that some goody-goody-holier-than-thou prosecutor will decide to make an example out of my "neglect".
- roguecoder 5y agoSwitzerland is so much more heavily controlled than the US, which is part of what leads to that outcome. Most Americans would flip out if anyone told them what weekend to plant their flower box or that they aren't allowed to hoard ammo for their guns at home.
- thematrixturtle 5y agoSwitzerland actually has a legal requirement for all men to store ammo for their state-issued assault rifle at home. Also, many Americans live in HOA communities with regulations that make Switzerland look like libertarian utopia.
- int_19h 5y agoSwitzerland banned reservists from storing issued ammo for their assault rifle at home 15 years ago. However, this only applies to issued ammo (and IIRC the identical govt-subsidized stuff you buy at the range). You can still store your own ammo just fine. Most of those in US who saw that story didn't understand this distinction and believed that it applies to all ammo storage at home. Which is how we got all those memes about Swiss being "heavily regulated" in that regard unlike US.
- christoph 5y agoI can't find the exact article I was thinking of that was posted here a year or two back about young Japanese children being set free out into the world, almost as a right of passage, to run errands etc., but this Bloomberg captures a lot of what I remembered. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-09-28/in-japan-small-children-take-the-subway-and-run-errands-alone https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-09-28/in-japan-... Personally, I believe there is a compounding net good for society allowing children a decent amount of independence at a young age. Japan is certainly different to many other countries in terms of public safety, but I don't believe the outside world is the awful, scary, dangerous place the media constantly paints it out to be. It breaks my heart that I rarely see children playing outside in the streets anymore in the UK, when my youth in the 80s was basically spent largely outside without adult supervision.
- mateo1 5y agoUrbanisation, rates of internal migration and car-centric cities make some places objectively more dangerous for kids than others.
- dudul 5y agoDid the school actually have any legal ground to force someone to leave a public sidewalk?
- tssva 5y agoThe school can't force someone to, but they can call the police who most likely would side with the school and threaten to charge them with loitering if they didn't move.
- baisq 5y agoLoitering is illegal?
- dekhn 5y agoCalifornia takes loitering near a school very seriously. Loitering at or near a school is a misdemeanor that is punishable by up to six months in jail and a $1,000 court fine. If the defendant is a person who is required to register as a sex offender under California Penal Code Section 290 PC, the maximum fine amount on a first conviction for loitering at or around a school increases to $2,000. If the defendant is required to register as a sex offender and has a previous conviction under California Penal Code Section 653b PC, he or she must serve a minimum of 10 days in jail. And if the defendant is required to register as a sex offender and has two or more prior convictions for loitering in or around a school, that person must serve a minimum of 90 days in jail custody.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoIt's effectively illegal if the police will prevent a person from doing it.
- baisq 5y agoIf loitering is not against the law how can a policeman prevent you from doing it?
- technothrasher 5y ago"I founded Free-Range Kids in 2008" This story sound either exaggerated, misrepresented, or possibly wholly made up. Not that it is that hard for me to believe in overeager security at a school, but it is just a little bit too convenient an incident for somebody with such a large preexisting interest in the subject. I would suspect that she was looking for a confrontation, even though she claims to not be confrontational.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dekhn 5y agoI live across the street from a school. I'd walk my kid in through a side door, the only one that was unlocked, early in the morning. I asked if the front door could be opened at that hour- nope, for "security reasons" they could only have one door open (oddly, that door was completely unobserved, while the front door had cameras, and was next to the main office). Even though I live literally next door and standing in my yard, I can see kids playing, I am exceptionally cautious. In particular, I introduced myself to the staff (they park in front of my house every day) so they knew who I was, smiled and made direct eye contact, and acted in a non-aggressive way. This greatly improved my ability to move about my yard without suspicion. They never did unlock the front gate, though. Security through theatre.
- nobody9999 5y agoI live immediately next door to a school (~6 foot sub-street walkway between my building and the school building). I've lived here for >25 years and am often outside my building smoking cigarettes(!). The "play area" for the kids is on the other side of my (and one other, total ~100 feet distance) building and classes are brought in and out most of the day. No one has ever even looked at me (AFAIK) as a potential threat, and no one (school staff, parents or police) has ever asked me to "move along," or wanted to know why I was hanging around next to a school. And living in NYC, it's not like folks will recognize me as one of the people who live in one of the 20 apartments in my building either. In fact, I've only had positive interactions with school-related adults despite the "suspicious" behavior I display as an adult male "hanging around" an elementary/middle school "watching" the kids. I can't say whether my experience is more common than that of TFA's author. I do note that many parents (not that it's a bad thing necessarily) drop off/pick up their kids at school (this is NYC, so mostly not in cars, but to walk them home/wherever they need to go) at ages (8+) when I (and most of my classmates) walked to/from school (my elementary school and and this one are less than a mile apart, but 40+ years distance in time) all by ourselves with no issues. In fact, we'd usually just go straight out to the park and play until dark, then go home. Back then (mid-late 1970s), NYC was much more dangerous too. As such, it seems to me that these changes are less about "keeping kids safe" and more about "security theater" to appease helicopter parents. I could be wrong, but it seems like that's the most likely driver.
- incomingpain 5y agoIt seems wierd to me where society has gone. In my dad's high school, they literally brought rifles to school. There was a gun range at the school. Yes, it had to be bagged up and unloaded but you literally brought a 22 with rounds to school. My era? Zero tolerance for mean words. I got suspended 1 day because I told people I got a highlighter. They thought I said lighter and tattled on me. Teachers never found the lighter but I was suspended no less. I got suspended once because a friend of mine was planning to come to my house after school. Asked me to carry his bag. Unbeknowst to me he was running off to try to get into a fight off school premises. Never actually got into a fight. But I was suspended for zero tolerance helping/assisting a fight. Now we are in the era where schools have metal detectors, police on staff and actively walking around in the schools, and harassing people over literally nothing. It's interesting to me. Obviously lots of science have determined all of this was bad. https://supportiveschooldiscipline.org/zero-tolerance-policy https://supportiveschooldiscipline.org/zero-tolerance-policy But instead of admitting there was a mistake... they just doubled down on bad policies? Idiots.
- lbriner 5y agoIsn't it similar to the "Nobody was ever fired for buying IBM". If there is any kind of concern over safety, any incident affecting any school, some well-meaning supplier/council/school admin suggests adding security whether fences, ID badges, maglocks, security guards etc. Why not? Anything is better than nothing? The problem is that no-one would get away with saying, "maybe we don't need the fence anymore, it separates children from the community". "Maybe we don't need to repair the metal detector when it breaks" etc. Sad really. The idea that somehow ID cards are a proportionate measure for some kind of security at a high school is very worrying.
- incomingpain 5y agoOh yes, I'm sure all these efforts have been entirely with good intentions. Afterall, fundamentally they are 'protecting the children'. The saying goes though, the road to hell is paved with good intentions. We proactively need to defund the road to hell.
- 5y ago
- spacemanmatt 5y agoI always faced greater danger from administrators, student-bullies, and teachers (in order of descending harm) than strangers, ever, at any age.
- sdflhasjd 5y agoAnd student-bully parents who excuse & enable.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoNow they're running for school boards.
- cortesoft 5y agoStrangers are always way less dangerous than people you know. People just refuse to accept that fact.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoAlways is a strong word. I know someone who had a caring family and friend group, yet it was a stranger that tried to assault them. This was during that idealized era before all the modern safety practices. Thankfully they were smart enough to escape to a neighbor's house. Statistics may indicate greatest risk is people you know, but that's an average. Ultimately it's best to take reasonable precautions and teach kids what behavior to watch for, healthy boundaries, and how to react.
- cortesoft 5y agoOf course they aren't ALWAYS more dangerous, I should have said almost always.
- deleted_account 5y agoLenore paused. She stared wistfully out the window and thought of the third graders she watched earlier in the day, "What would it take to give every one of them a nice, sharp pin?" Yeah, maybe shoo her away from the playground.
- ultrarunner 5y agoThe actual quote is: > And so I was shooed along, collateral damage in the quest to wrap every child in a bubble of perfect safety. Now I sit at my computer, wondering: What would it take to give every one of them a nice, sharp pin? Obviously the pin is to pop the confining bubble "every child" has been placed in, thus improving their lives. She follows up: > (Though some authority would no doubt accuse me of distributing weapons to children)
- deleted_account 5y agoI got the metaphor; it's a dumb metaphor. Ignoring the r/thathappened premise of the article, what, specifically, is the wall were tearing down here? We should let adults watch children for recreation because society imposes too many restrictions on child development out of an irrational fear of their safety? The dots don't connect.
- InitialLastName 5y agoMaybe it's that we shouldn't let fear of a bogeyman be used as a justification to weaponize law enforcement and collapse social trust in the name of "think of the children"?
- ultrarunner 5y agoAs a parent, the answer is yes. I have literally, on multiple occasions, had middle-aged women stop their vehicles and ask my children in a panicked voice where their mother is. This, despite me being ~30 feet away in the front year overhearing the whole thing. My neighbor has shoed them off on our behalf. It startles my kids. They're asking to ride their bikes in the neighborhood and my main concern is that someone will call the police to "save" them from whatever fantasy they dream up. This doesn't comprise 100% of our experience of life, but it definitely impacts my children's freedoms and my friends have conveyed similar experiences. A person wistfully contemplating their own childhood experience is different than "watching children for recreation" and the punishment thereof is a symptom of a greater problem with (U.S.) society.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- krnlpnc 5y agoAssuming this was an American school this really surprising? America has school shootings regularly. Children have to perform regular active shooter drills in American schools. Like a fire drill. There are also significant pressures put on a shrinking number of underpaid teachers and staff to care for an increasing number of children. More kids being cared for by fewer adults. With this mindset why would school staff not err on the side of caution and ask an unknown person to move along? It's a sad state of affairs, but it is not the fault of the teacher or school staff that America got here.
- hn_version_0023 5y agoIt’s even less the fault of the kids, who bear the brunt of this monumental stupidity— particularly if their parents face consequences that separates them. Edit: spelling
- mbrameld 5y agoThose all sound like really good reasons that the teacher should NOT engage with anyone they think is up to no good.
- roguecoder 5y agoTeachers are taught & expected to sacrifice their lives to protect their students.
- l33t2328 5y agoThey are? How? They’re unarmed. Are they really expected to just die for the sake of making a show of protection?
- barry-cotter 5y agoNo they’re not. Neither are police officers. Police have no duty to respond to emergency calls. Teachers are not held to a higher legal standard than police officers.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago
- lkxijlewlf 5y agoI still blame John Walsh for this. He scared an entire generation of parents and now everyone lives thinking everyone is a murdering pedo. Look, what happened to him and his family, his son, is awful and I can't imagine what that was like, but he fucked America up.
- hn_version_0023 5y agoDon’t forget Chris Hansen!
- throwawayboise 5y agoIt wasn't so much him, like you say it's understandable given his personal experience. The blame should be on the people who gave him the microphone.
- mgkimsal 5y agoFriend of mine runs a local eatery. She told her 9-year old son to walk across the street - literally to the candy shop where she knows the owner, and told the kid to do some homework for an hour. Police brought her son back and threatened to charge her with endangerment or abandonment or something similar. This was... 2018 IIRC. They live about 1.5 miles from the eatery. She would let her 9 year old walk home sometimes in good weather - low crime with actual tree-lined suburban streets. Police apparently threatened her over that as well - that's somehow endangering the child too much, and she might be charged with some misdemeanor. I don't get it. Really. As someone who grew up in the 70s/80s... I can't say 'nothing bad ever happened'. Obviously it did. But the pendulum has swung far too much the other way now.
- simplehuman 5y agoWhich city is this?
- skrebbel 5y agoSounds absurd. What country are we talking?
- mgkimsal 5y agoNorth Carolina, USA. I've heard some similar stories from friends back in Michigan as well, though not quite as severe. Re 'candy shop' - it was about 400 feet from the restaurant.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoAnd what kind of neighborhood is this? I take it's not a "daycare is a cash only business and cops know what real crime looks like" type place.
- mgkimsal 5y agoPicturesque small town America. The sort of place with a general store still selling picture postcards of the downtown area. 15th-safest city in the state of around 10 million.
- hprotagonist 5y agoNow try it as a guy.
- dudul 5y agoI didn't check the name of the author before reading and was surprised when I realized she was a woman and had to deal with that. Had she been a man, I can assume the police would have been called without first approaching her.
- dakial1 5y agoIt surprised me that it was a woman. Usually people are more lenient to them than man. I was discussing that, some time ago, with a female friend (I am a male) who also loves doing street photography. We talked about how difficult it is for a man to do street photography, specially around places with a lot of kids, as you will always receive strange looks or even threats. If you're a woman taking photos? Probably a mother or mother-to-be, if you're a man? Pedophile. I wonder if there are that many people exposing themselves to kids as the security lady said in the article. Seems like an excuse to justify the action, or something that happened once and they are overreacting to it...
- wccrawford 5y agoWhen I read the headline, there was no doubt in my mind that it was a man. I'm quite surprised, too. I guess the over-protectiveness has just continued advancing. Not a huge surprise.
- trashtester 5y agoI suspect there is an element of survivorship bias. If a man is treated like she was, it would not be news. Most (normal) men also know that they may be seen as a threat, and would move along quickly if asked to. (If they call security over a woman, they may call the police over a man.)
- belorn 5y agoI guess it similar for people of color. They know that they may be seen as a threat and thus they normally act accordingly. Otherwise people may call the police.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- trashtester 5y agoI agree, especially if the color is "black". Similarly, I suppose you will find that people with traits of low social class or people that are physically large/muscular, especially if they're not good-looking will experience this. So, a black guy on 190+cm, large and muscular with a hoodie + some gang-related tatoos and a lower-class behaviour may experience it more than a petite female white upper middle class lawyer in an expensive dress suit. No surprises here.
- blisterpeanuts 5y agoI was jogging on the bike trail and passed by a class of kindergarteners the teacher was taking out into the park from the nearby Waldorf school. A friend of mine's daughter was at that school and I thought she might be amongst the kids. However I knew better than to slow down and scrutinize them, looking for her. I just averted my eyes and ran on by. It's sad that we have to be like this, but it feels necessary, in a world seemingly full of child molesting creeps.
- droopyEyelids 5y agoThe other day I was walking my dog and saw a pack of kids on a walk from their daycare, and I thought my friend's kid might be among them. I slowed down and started looking through the kids, till the proctor(?) woman noticed, at which point I said my friend's kid goes to your daycare and then we found him in the group and introduced ourselves, joked around a bit with her, and I took some pics of his kid to show my friend, said goodbye, and went home.
- t0mas88 5y agoThe world isn't really full of child molesters. And sadly a big majority of molesting happens by people the child knows, like family and friends, not strangers. So this extreme reaction to strangers and people walking on eggs around schools is all for very little benefit.
- blisterpeanuts 5y agoI said "seemingly".
- probably_wrong 5y agoI didn't notice the author until she mentioned founding the "free-range kids" movement. For those who are unfamiliar with her, she was labeled "America's Worst Mom" in 2008 for a column she wrote about letting her son ride the subway alone when he was 9. She has been on a crusade against overprotected children since then [1]. I always found her advice extremely reasonable, but then again, I don't have children. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lenore_Skenazy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lenore_Skenazy
- lifefeed 5y agoSome of the reactions against her were unreal. People were wishing for her children to be kidnapped to teach her a lesson. And 14 years later America is now watching "Old Enough!" on Netflix.
- azth 5y agoWhat's wrong with some people, honestly no words.
- aksss 5y agoThe desire to control and to punish those who don't comply is strong. Used to be religious element of society that did this. Now social control doesn't wear the mask of religion anymore.
- brandonmenc 5y ago> social control doesn't wear the mask of religion anymore The new religion is "safety."
- moistly 5y ago“Old Enough!” is a cute, amusing, and quite surprising show. It follows 3 and 4 year olds as they run their first errand for their parents. The kids are generally clueless about the cameras, and they’re wired with a microphone. They are usually sent on a surprisingly long journey, although along a familiar route, involving several tasks. FWIW, we’re childless & in our fifties, and really enjoyed the season.
- francisofascii 5y agoJust last week there was a local news story about police investigating a possible child luring incident near a school. The news story and Facebook posts had a picture of a white van from surveillance video. The teachers saw what was happening and made sure the girl was safe. The story was light on details, and there has been no follow-up, so it makes you wonder if the interaction turns out to be innocuous. The idea of "bad guy with white van" is so ingrained in our culture, that maybe we see danger that is not always present.
- CuriouKoala 5y agoI faced this a year back, same thing but this time a cop showed up and not the school teacher :P, I just spoke calmly with the officer, that I was just having lunch while in the car.... she left.
- etaioinshrdlu 5y agoDoes anyone know which countries are least affected by this trend of “safetyism” and less likely to develop it in the future? I don’t think it’s healthy to raise children in this environment.
- can16358p 5y agoI've seen so few people be successful who are grown in a safe bubble within perfect control of their families. Children need to be (controlledly) exposed to the truths of the world instead of being raised like Polyannas. There is good and bad in this world and if we show them only the good, they will have very hard time as grown up adults.
- aantix 5y agoWe host a German foreign exchange student from Hannover. He talks a lot about meeting friends after school, that the late afternoon is his (not taken up by sports or clubs like in the U.S.). That everyone rides bikes or public transit, and it doesn't sound like there's much parental oversight (not a judgement, just my observations from our conversations).
- aidenn0 5y agoI went on exchange to a small town in Thueringen, and can confirm that elementary school aged children got to school on their own, including Gymnasium students (starts at age 10) who had to take public transit to the next town (there was no Gymnasium in this town).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nmeagent 5y agoWell at least some people in the world are still allowed to grow up with some measure of independence intact. This sounds a lot like my environment growing up in suburban Indianapolis in the 80s and early 90s (though probably with a lot less public transit); I'm not sure what kind of person I would be today without the freedom to roam unsupervised for much of the day. I wonder what kind of adults we're ultimately producing in the US today...
- zwieback 5y agoI know there are a ton of examples like this but our kids were free to roam when they were like 8 or 10 and not a single thing happened, ever. There are probably many more cases like mine.
- corrral 5y agoBeen letting mine roam the neighborhood, unaccompanied, on foot and on bikes since the oldest was 7, I think. Youngest will be coming up on six, this Summer, when I let 'em join the others and roam (only with their older siblings—next Summer they can go out solo, if they want). No cop visits yet. Probably only a couple years left before they're old enough that no-one's likely to bother us about it. Hoping we make it out without trouble. So far, so good. We have had neighbors from other streets come over a couple times to "make sure we know" our kids are way off in the neighborhood, but they've not made a thing of it past that, so I think they're chill-enough and really were just wanting to make sure we were aware.
- prepend 5y agoIt seems like the author is contributing the problem by avoiding a light confrontation and perpetuating the problem. I think part of the solution is standing up to these kind of light idiocies. If she had time, she should have just let them call the cops and been polite about wanting to just watch the kids.
- compiler-guy 5y agoThe author is a long time free ranger kids person and a leader in the movement. That she chose not to fight this particular battle is a perfectly reasonable thing to do she has done far more than most on this score. Picking your battles wisely is hardly contributing yo the problem.
- low_tech_love 5y agoI’m not sure you read the whole thing but she did go back and talk to “security”. Also, this author specifically is known for her activism. At any rate, I wouldn’t judge her if she didn’t…
- prepend 5y agoI did read that part. She went back and talked to security, they told her to leave, she left. Had she stuck around and talked with the police, security and the childcare would have learned that the author was allowed to watch the kids. I’m not judging her as a bad person or anything. But I think she’s part of the reason society has these behaviors. Because she’s not willing to fight stupid policies when the cost is just to wait politely. If people were more stringent to try to help others learn right and wrong we’d be in a better place. It’s quite possible that this security guard does think it’s illegal and wrong to watch kids. No one is willing to teach them what’s correct. If not people like the author, then who?
- nmeagent 5y agoThe state of the country right now is such that encounters with the police are potentially volatile and can escalate in bizarre and ridiculous ways. IMO it's not worth the risk for something like this and she's much better off going away quietly and writing a blog post on the subject later on.
- C4K3 5y agoIn South Park in San Francisco there's a little playground that has a sign saying adults are not allowed without children, which if anything feels backwards to me. It's a nice place to sit, eat and chat, and I've never seen anybody complain about adults being there, but I imagine there has to be some busybody who thought a rule like that would be a good idea. Maybe they have the rule so they can selectively enforce it against people?
- low_tech_love 5y agoI live in Sweden and it’s forbidden for me (or them) to take pictures of my kid at school, ever. I have all these great pictures of me and my friends in the 80s doing theater plays and christmas singing and whatnot from when I was a kid. My children will get none of that. Actually, they do send me pictures sometimes: of headless bodies, hands or arms in weird angles apparently doing something fun (I can’t really tell). Are people simply too lazy to deal with the responsibility of living in human society?
- aiilns 5y agoI do understand where you're coming from, but I was growing up in the 2000s and the (primary & later secondary) school took photos that were shared first on official blogs/sites and then later posted on facebook/twitter without asking for permission. It's not the photos that are the problem, it's that people don't really understand or respect others' privacy in the internet age. February before covid, I was at a college in Manchester and was pleasantly surprised when they asked us to complete consent forms on where the photos that were to be taken were going to be uploaded. I was very happy to check the "I don't consent to photos of me shared on social media", consequently they took some photos with me & some without me. No pressure to be part of the group & not be left out.
- alistairSH 5y agoIs there an actual expectation of privacy when enrolled at a public school? There certainly isn’t when out in truly public places (in the US). And students certainly don’t have any/much right to privacy with their bags and lockers (school employees are allowed to search them, in the US). Between the two, I can’t see there being a compelling legal argument to disallow photos for things that are in full few of tens or hundreds of other people already.
- HarryHirsch 5y agoHow about "expectation of impermanence"? In the past, people had film, and the farthest any photo got was that person's album. Now every last ass on earth can post their photo in Facebook for all the world to enjoy and it won't ever get taken down. US law needs to catch up.
- roguecoder 5y agoMaybe parents just don't want strangers creeping on their children.
- recursive 5y agoWhat constitutes creeping? That might affect whether these parents are being reasonable.
- mayregretit 5y agoYou get a creepy feeling when a person might be a threat but you aren't sure yet. Often triggered by noticing something incongruent about the person's demeanor, appearance, or location, which suggests that they may be concealing their intent from you, for possibly malicious ends. It's a valuable survival behavior but like most pre-crime strategies is easily confused by racism, neuro-discrimination, or other (un)conscious bigotry.
- recursive 5y agoI don't put too much weight in "creepy feelings" unless they can be described with a specific reason about what's causing it. It sounds like a thin cover for busybody neighborhood watch-type behavior. Or worse.
- ok123456 5y agoWon't somebody please think of the children????
- mensetmanusman 5y agoPeople that call and raise false alarms should be fined until the rates of false alarms equals the rates of positive discoveries.
- markdown 5y agoI'm surprised nobody's mentioned the Japanese show about kids and their first errand https://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2022/apr/07/old-enough-the-japanese-tv-show-that-abandons-toddlers-on-public-transport https://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2022/apr/07/old-eno...
- woodruffw 5y agoThis is going to be a polemical comment, but I feel compelled to share it: It's my opinion that a great deal of the blame (if not the outright majority) for this state of affairs can be levied against suburban culture (and, by extension, car culture). The communities that hand-wring the most about predators and risks to children tend to be middle class, suburban, and white. They drive their children everywhere, and thereby are (somewhat) alienated from the idea of a "local community" beyond the immediate neighborhood (which can only be entered or exited by car.) Things like childcare are purchasable services, not kindnesses that you or your neighbor do for each other when the other's in a pinch. When this is your bubble (or, for the rest of us, the dominant cultural metaphor for responsible parenting), it's hard not to see the world as a foreign and scary place, with unknown levels of unknown danger.
- nr2x 5y agoI lived in NYC for years and saw dicks all the time in public. It is a real problem, and very good reason to shoo away even potential creeps.
- woodruffw 5y agoI grew up in NYC, and saw lots of things as a kid, including very mentally unwell people running around naked. Is it a problem? Yes. It's a problem for them; they were very clearly unwell. Was it a problem for me? I didn't really know how to react as a kid, and more than anything else I remember being sobered rather than traumatized by what I saw. If anything has maladjusted me, I don't think that was it.
- alistairSH 5y agoNo, it isn’t. We aren’t all guilty of perversions because a few guys can’t keep their dicks in their pants. The solution isn’t treating us all like criminals, it’s to get those few perverts psychiatric help.
- denkmoon 5y agoHow much damage did that cause? Seeing people's penis, that is. Can you quantify it for us?
- orionblastar 5y agoI am 53, when I was a child they let me walk to the library, pool, and park alone. Only problem I faced was bullies. My father before me as a child would buy a bucket of beer from a bar for his father. He would be given money to buy things at the butcher or bakery. Now you can't do that because of the creeps.
- shruubi 5y agoI'm not a parent, but if I was I'd rather have security tell everyone, regardless of their motives to move along and not be anywhere near the children and offend a bunch of innocent bystanders than the alternative. The way I look at it, if the standard you set is to tell everyone to move along, then you are creating the systems and processes necessary to prevent bad actors from doing what they will try and do, and that outcome is infinitely more important than some passer-by's feelings.
- oneeyedpigeon 5y agoOr, maybe this is the classic 'bad actors don't stop being bad, but everyone gets punished' setup that seems to be more prevalent now than it ever was.
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoEven if she had been taking photos, that would have been her right: https://dinalitovsky.bulletin.com/590041038798261 https://dinalitovsky.bulletin.com/590041038798261 > If you are in the United States, what matters is where you photograph from. If you are standing on a public street, then everything and everyone clearly visible from your vantage point is fair game. No distinction is made about WHO is being photographed. Celebrities, tourists, children, senior citizens, Times Square mimes — all are equally permissible. That playground which photographers avoid glancing at lest they be turned to stone? Fair game. Same goes for subways, bridges, airports and any private property visible from a public space (with exceptions for military and nuclear facilities).
- leetrout 5y agoShe, not he.
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoFixed, thank you.
- maccard 5y agoAnd even if it is fair game, the last thing I want in the middle of the day is some stranger calling the police and me having to spend an hour explaining why it's my right to do so.
- lowbloodsugar 5y ago"Am I free to go?" No? That'll be $$$$ then. No need to explain anything to the cop, and in fact you shouldn't say anything. "Am I free to go?" "No?" "Ok, I invoke my right to silence and I want my lawyer". The media and propaganda have done an amazing job convincing citizens that we have to explain our totally legal behavior. No. It is up to them to identify a crime that is being committed and if not, then just ignore them. Be prepared to get arrested. Now, if you aren't absolutely sure that you aren't breaking the law, then stop fantasizing about winning an argument with a cop (GP).
- kccqzy 5y agoWatching kids play literally improves my mood and makes me happy. It reminds me of a bygone era without too many responsibilities or too much stress. I live not far away from a public park with a small playground; sometimes when I am tired of coding I take a short walk there, watch the kids for a bit and come back refreshed. Kids are so energetic, but somehow the sight and sound of kids playing can impart energy to me. Vladimir Nabokov had a beautifully written description of kids playing: > What I heard was but the melody of children at play, nothing but that, and so limpid was the air that within this vapor of blended voices, majestic and minute, remote and magically near, frank and divinely enigmatic—one could hear now and then, as if released, an almost articulate spurt of vivid laughter, or the crack of a bat, or the clatter of a toy wagon, but it was all really too far for the eye to distinguish any movement in the lightly etched streets. I stood listening to that musical vibration from my lofty slope, to those flashes of separate cries with a kind of demure murmur for background, and then I knew that the hopelessly poignant thing was not Lolita’s absence from my side, but the absence of her voice from that concord. (In the novel the protagonist abused Lolita and was feeling remorseful for robbing her of a proper childhood playing with other kids.)
- mayregretit 5y agoI hear you but quoting the most famous book about pedophilia is not the best look.
- throw7 5y agoYour description reminded of a short song by M83 called I Guess I'm Floating. btw, I agree with you.
- jacobsenscott 5y agoAnecdotal clickbait coupled with easy "back in my day we had common sense!" comments is the winning combination.
- vmception 5y ago“I’m calling security, Allied Universal!” I would have laughed just to see how high the settlement gets. Dollars would have been counting upwards in my head, analysis of how to survive the situation would have been done so that I would ensure enjoying the settlement, I would have scanned for bystandards stuck in bystander syndrome “you in particular, I’ll split the settlement with you if you record this” New drone assimilated The woman’s musings would have been muffled in my head, replaced by the narrator in Disco Elysium “Stay on the public sidewalk as you are, hands clearly viewable, no sudden movements, now the public will have to pay you, or maybe the private sector, stay focused but patient”
- dqpb 5y agoSo put screens on the fences.
- ggm 5y agoLeast cost solution to KPI outcome. Distinguishing good from bad is hard. Ban everyone, problem solved. (by inventing a new problem) If you want better outcomes, need to make them either low cost, or inject "funds" (which may be effort) to improve
- iepathos 5y agoThey could say what they want to you, but at the end of the day if they tried to physically remove you from the sidewalk under these conditions you would be able to sue the shit out of the school and win.
- jaredandrews 5y agoAnd then everyone clapped... I grew up "free range" and looking around where I live this is still the predominant approach to parenting. So I really can't relate to the vibe in this whole thread. (all in Massachusetts and Maine btw) That being said, the last thing my "free range" friends and I wanted growing up was some weirdo adult observing our "unstructured freeplay". As soon as we determined this lady wasn't a cop we would have created a lot of reasons for her to leave. Kids aren't monkeys in a zoo for you to observe lady, move along or get some feces in your face.
- dubswithus 5y agoDo the police allow kids to harass law abiding citizens there?
- jaredandrews 5y agoPossibly a regional thing, but among Massholes it is considered rude to "watch" people you don't know for a sustained period of time. It wouldn't be considered rude or "harassment" to call someone out for doing this.
- dmead 5y agoreason.com is a huge red flag for me. I though the article was going to be some self righteous libertarian not liking being told what to do. Boy was I right.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoMy hobby is watching trains. I was hanging out by a railroad line that has both freight traffic and, on separate tracks, regional commuter trains. I was right by the platform of one of the commuter stations. Commuter rail security came over and asked what I was doing. That was fine. Then they said they'd like me to leave. Well, I'd seen too many articles recently about authorities acting like it was illegal to photograph passenger rail operations (not that I was photographing, but it felt the same to me). So I told them that I was on private property, and it wasn't their private property, so I didn't particularly care what they would like. They looked a little surprised, and left. Note well: They were not police. I don't take that kind of line with police, and I don't recommend that anyone else does.
- jimmydeans 5y ago
- nickstinemates 5y agoI'm immediately suspect of anyone who has an experience that would benefit them politically or financially that they just so happen to mention neatly tucked into the middle of a post on social media. > As I have said since I founded Free-Range Kids in 2008, and since starting Let Grow in 2017, our society is set on overestimating danger and underestimating kids. Gives real "That Happened" vibes.
- sen 5y agoI'm a stay-at-home disabled dad to 2 kids (toddler + 2nd grade), and quite literally can't count the number of times over the last 8 years that I've had people at parks threaten to (or actually do) call the police on me, verbally berate me, etc. I've been verbally assaulted (proper screaming-levels of verbal attacks) for being a pedophile because I'm at a park playing with my own daughter. I've had groups of mums surround me while they call the police, and force me to wait for them to arrive. I've very regularly had people pull their kids away from my kids and not let them play together, while all the other kids with mums there are allowed to play amongst each other. I've been told I'm "assaulting" my wife by "forcing" her to work and miss out on the all-important motherhood experience. Doesn't matter that mum works in ICU/surgical saving lives, and absolutely loves what she does (and works 3 days a week, so gets plenty of mothering time). I've been followed for blocks and blocks by people videoing me on their phone saying they're reporting me for kidnapping. I've been told to leave the park more times than I could ever count, because "it's a place for mums and their kids". I've been rejected from library story time and family centres because I'm not the mum. I've had the police turn up to my door because neighbours saw me tending to a crying kid in the yard (fallen off the bike) and the police were told I had kidnapped them and was assaulting them... I could go on for many more paragraphs. In all these situations I calmly explain that I'm the father, and just try move away from the people or leave the park to save my kids having to experience this stuff. People are fucking crazy. Edit: To clarify, I'm in Australia. I have also run into various other stay-at-home dads who have similar stories. It does seem to be more in the inner city suburbs, as we move a lot and I haven't had it nearly as much in more rural areas (though it does still happen).
- cmckn 5y agoIt sounds like there’s a torrent of gossip in your neighborhood about you, and I’m really sorry you have to suffer the consequences. Have any of the parents at the park ever just…chatted with you while the kids play? Its very strange that everyone seems to recognize you and have the same, unhinged opinion of you.
- sen 5y agoThis has happened living in multiple places (in AU), we move lots. Yes I've had some nice people too, usually more curious chats about a stay-at-home dad being odd. I've run into other SAHD's and they've all shared similar stories.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- DeathArrow 5y agoGood thing she's a woman. If it were for a male, they would probably call the police and accuse him of something.
- tradertef 5y agoI don't think this actually happened.. or what happened was exaggerated. I read the book by the author (Free-range kids); it is a good book but these "self-help" books exaggerate things and love telling stories which are hard to verify.
- albedoa 5y ago
- tsimionescu 5y agoThis kind of insinuation is not a good fit here. You can either explain the pertinent details that would explain the experiences described in a different light, or you can leave it as is. Insinuating something more sinister without explaining anything does not advance the conversation in any way.
- sen 5y agoI guess he's confused me with someone else, as I'm on the other side of the planet to him. Happens a lot with short usernames in general.
- keeganpoppen 5y agohonestly, you are being far too charitable. it comes across as downright creepy, advancing the conversation or no. i wouldn't be comfortable saying any of the things in that comment to someone that i claimed to know to their face under basically any circumstances. it pretty much implies directly that OP is some sort of sexual predator, which makes the whole "lovely wife" thing sound something between creepy and vaguely threatening.
- throwaway290 5y agoThis is not dissimilar from cases where people publicly complain about their Google/PayPal/etc. accounts getting banned: they could well be genuinely innocent, or they could in fact have done something incriminating that provider’s systems became aware of but we aren't. If the latter is true, they are not even lying by simply omitting that information in their complaints (it may have slipped their mind, too), yet it can change the outlook drastically. I find the case in TFA pretty damning, but I try to catch myself before I dole out blame on anonymous complaints with little context. The possibility that it (account banning, or what OP described) could happen to a completely innocent person makes the status quo pretty dismal already though, and well deserves discussion.
- spicyramen_ 5y agoI have kids, 2 boys, the author failed to explain if she has kids or not. I believe the overprotective reason is valid. It's very common to hear about child trafficking, kidnapping and missing kids. The reality is that this exists and we need to accept it first. If there is a probability of something happening to your kid, you want to take all measures possible to avoid it, at the end they are the most vulnerable people in our society which we need to defend & protect at all costs. I agree with security at school that there is no reason to observe kids for joy, i would see them and continue my way, just the thought of it seems creepy.
- boneitis 5y ago> I agree [..] that there is no reason to observe kids for joy This is the saddest thing I've heard in a really long time.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoI would have probably made this "security" person call the police if I were on public property that wasn't school property. But, then, I have that option because I'm a normal-looking white dude.
- Asooka 5y agoMy question would be why isn't the fence solid? If you're worried about people peeping on kids during recess, the fence should be solid and quite high. A voyeur won't helpfully sit next to the sidewalk, salivating, with his hand in his trousers, beating his leg on the ground and howling like a wolf. No, he'd be 200m away in a secluded place with a binocular. Have the bathrooms got windows? Do you know how easy it is to just take pictures from a neighbouring building of a child pulling down its pants? In short, I don't think you're taking the security of these children seriously.
- captainbland 5y agoI suspect the thing is that, sure, there's a reasonable chance you're innocuous enough. But say, in an unrelated incident, a kid had gone missing, and beforehand there was a suspicious stranger with no attachment to any of the kids watching them from outside the grounds. It later turns out the person was watching them to identify a target to kidnap. Then say the school did nothing because "they're allowed", on the basis of everything described. But now a child is missing and the school didn't act on an obvious potential red flag. Would the parents find that acceptable? No. Would politicians and their voters find that acceptable? Probably not. Heads would roll. Ultimately the school is managing its risk level by taking action in that situation.
- 0daystock 5y agoThe author should have pulled out out their phone and recorded the ridiculous Karen interaction, made it viral and made sure this power-hungry chaperone is dethroned.
- Auracle 5y agoI was once hired to photograph a teacher at a school in her classroom and a few headshots outside by some magazine or the like. When I was setting up for the latter portion the vice principal came outside to make sure I wasn’t getting any of the kids on the playground in the shot. She was very stern about it. I wanted to tell her I could go over to the sidewalk with a big zoom lens and take as many pictures of the kids as I wanted, but instead I just assured her the building was the backdrop and everything behind the teacher would be very out of focus anyways. I was also hired to secretly photograph an engagement right next to a kids playground, which meant I had to act sneaky with a big zoom lens. I brought my wife along and she had to calm a woman down about what I was doing.
- MollyRealized 5y agoAt the risk of sounding arch, the founder of Free-Range Kids relates an experience that perfectly supports the hypothesis of her organization ... ? What a coincidence. I don't think she's necessarily wrong, but the bias has to be factored into judging the content of the article.