5 ms·
Didn't Russia (last month) threaten Finland/Sweden with 'consequences' should they decide joining NATO? Wondering what would those be. Putting both countries in
by nymalt 5y ago
Didn't Russia (last month) threaten Finland/Sweden with 'consequences' should they decide joining NATO? Wondering what would those be. Putting both countries in a new list of 'very unfriendly countries'?
- kreeben 5y agoWorse! The enemy list. But what are they going to do, is what I want to know. Baltic sea will soon be pretty much closed for them and they sure could start WW3 over that but would they? They don't seem to have that in them.
- rendall 5y ago> Baltic sea will soon be pretty much closed for them Why would the Baltic Sea be closed to Russia? How would this be enforced?
- baq 5y ago...just look at the map?
- kayodelycaon 5y agoDenmark controls access to the Baltic Sea. https://www.google.com/maps/place/Baltic+Sea/@55.685476,11.0498096,7.54z/data=!4m5!3m4!1s0x46f4d7d988201b2b:0xb43097ae8474cb3!8m2!3d58.487952!4d19.863281 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Baltic+Sea/@55.685476,11.0... And Estonia and Finland control access to Russia's only ports in the Baltic Sea. https://www.google.com/maps/place/Baltic+Sea/@60.5931556,25.2688527,6.63z/data=!4m5!3m4!1s0x46f4d7d988201b2b:0xb43097ae8474cb3!8m2!3d58.487952!4d19.863281 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Baltic+Sea/@60.5931556,25....
- CRConrad 5y agoWell, Königsberg.
- rendall 5y ago> "Estonia and Finland control access to Russia's only ports in the Baltic Sea" Not a true statement, your map notwithstanding. Denmark has an ironclad, centuries old agreement with the international community called the Copenhagen Convention never to restrict shipping or charge toll. Did you not know this?
- kayodelycaon 5y ago> Did you not know this? I did not. I don't know exactly what to look for, but all I found was a single paragraph on the Sound Dues article on Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sound_Dues#Copenhagen_Convention https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sound_Dues#Copenhagen_Conventi...
- rendall 5y ago"Just look at the map" and related responses are non-sequiturs. Without a declaration of war, what is the legal mechanism by which Russian ships would be restricted from the Baltic Sea?
- qayxc 5y ago> Putting both countries in a new list of 'very unfriendly countries'? My best guess would be exactly that. The last thing Putin wants is a repeat of the Finno-Russian wars of 1917 and 1941, which resulted in catastrophic losses on the Soviet side.
- tovej 5y agoYou mean the war of the winter 1939-1940 and the 1941-1944 war. 1917-1922 was the Russian civil war and 1918 the Finnish civil war. IIRC, some of the White Finnish raiding parties ventured into Russia, and the Bolsheviks supported the Finnish Reds, but you can't really speak of Soviet losses, the Russian Soviet Republic was founded in 1917 and only gained power due to the civil war.
- qayxc 5y agoDuring the Finnish Civil war, which ultimately ended in Finish independence, the White Finnish forces ended the Russian presence in Finland and Soviet (yes, Soviet) soldiers who fought on the side of the Finnish Red Guard left the country. If you insist on nit-picking years, I only supplied the years of the start of the conflicts. You can go as far to include every border conflict, but that's completely besides the point. The forces that supported the Red Guard during the 1917-1918 war were all part of the Soviet forces in any case. > the Russian Soviet Republic was founded in 1917 and only gained power due to the civil war. They lost Finland and any influence on the country, which gained independence during that time, seeing that as "only gaining power" is a weird and twisted view on history.
- tovej 5y agoTsarist Russia/The Russian Soviet lost Finland, and Lenin acknowledged Finland's independence in 1917 before the Finnish civil war (in the hopes that the revolution would spread internationally and bring Finland and others back into the fold). So I take issue with the claim that it was the war that caused Lenin to lose Finland. The Bolsheviks and their Red army (not the Soviets, the Soviet Union itself was not founded until 1922) supported the Reds, but the boots on the ground were Finnish both for the Reds and the Whites, with German boots being decisively added in the landing at Hanko. The war was not a war for independence, but a war born out of the circumstances of the breakdown of Tsarist Russia, a famine, a lack of police force, and a general dissatisfaction among the working class, largely fueled by ideas from the Russian revolution of course. >If you insist on nit-picking years, I only supplied the years of the start of the conflicts. 1941 was not the start of the conflict, it was the second in a series of two wars. The entire interbellum time was used by both sides to prepare for further conflict. It is not a nitpick to say that Finland was involved in the winter war (1939-1940) and the continuation war (1941-1944), these are the two main wars that Finland was involved in during the second world war (the third most important one being the Lapland war against Germany). 1918 was an incredibly short civil war that caused no direct losses to the Bolsheviks, except that a Red government would have been sympathetic to the USSR and possibly joined it. On a more general note, using terms like "twisted view of history" is not a sign of a good-faith discussion, be civil.
- vegai_ 5y agoYear ago, 6 months ago, 3 months ago, started a war, 1 month ago, last week, yesterday. At one very specific point it stopped meaning anything.
- tyleo 5y agoAgreed. “You are now on the unfriendly list,” says Russia. Except Ukraine was on the friendly list and look at where that got them.
- dijit 5y ago> Except Ukraine was on the friendly list [..] Once, maybe, but not since the revolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolution_of_Dignity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolution_of_Dignity
- noir_lord 5y agoDouble secret probation probably. All Russia can do is bark, continue the "we aren't doing" cyber/disinformation attack or start lobbing nukes. #1 and #2 are business as usual, #3 is the end of civilisation.
- tremon 5y agoRussia has been threatening Finland/Sweden with consequences for years. As the Finnish PM mentioned in his speech with Boris Johnson a few days ago, Russia has shown with Ukraine that complying with Russia's threats is not a guarantee that the future will be consequence-free.
- jgrahamc 5y agoAs the Finnish PM mentioned in his speech I am pretty sure Sanna Marin is a woman.
- brabel 5y ago> Russia has shown with Ukraine that complying with Russia's threats is not a guarantee that the future will be consequence-free. When did Ukraine actually comply with any threat from Russia since at least the Maidan Revolution??
- agent008t 5y agoCrimea was effectively allowed to be annexed by Russia.
- mint2 5y agoWell in the run up to the Russian invasion Ukraine wasn’t provoking Russia, and Russia officials continually denied it had plans to invade until oh wait they’d had plans for a super long time. I’m not sure about Ukraine complying with Russia orders, but they weren’t really antagonizing them other than by existing and not being completely subservient like Belarus. So yeah after top Russian officials spent so much time lying about the plans and showing they had no sincere intention to negotiate, it’s no wonder Finland and Sweden have decided not to trust Russia.
- dhdjjd 5y agoSetting them as targets for nukes in the quite likely nuclear war. Russia doesn't have many arguments left.
- password54321 5y agoThey have made a threat for just about everything now.
- JacobiX 5y agoMany military analysts predict that Russia will come out of the conflict as a much weaker country especially with the recent flood of heavy weapons that are being sent to Ukraine. In comparison NATO expenses are at least 70% of Russia's GDP and we can see from the past that NATO has already coordinated military operations (in Operation Allied Force, NATO deployed 1031+ aircraft and 30 warships & submarines, and in 2011 it performed an operation that lasted 222 days with virtually no impact on the coalition members). With that said, one can expect that there will be no possible 'consequences' if Finland/Sweden join NATO.
- desproges 5y ago