3 ms·
One issue with georgism is that it significantly penalizes Urbanization and productivity that goes with it. People are incentivized to spread out and live on le
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
One issue with georgism is that it significantly penalizes Urbanization and productivity that goes with it. People are incentivized to spread out and live on less costly land and take a hit to their income or less lucrative jobs.
You would have Urban workers paying most of their income and taxes, and remote white collar workers paying essentially zero taxes.
- xvedejas 5y agoThis is maybe true for the landowner, but it's much less true for the renter. Since land is more available (due to fewer underproductive uses), you can expect more competition to put renters in land efficient configurations (high rises) in the densest cities. Sounds like urbanization to me? And more affordable than the status quo.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoStill sounds like a lot of blue collar workers who need to be close to jobs crammed into tiny high-rises, paying for the tax either directly or through rent, and white collar works living in remote mansions with no tax. alternatively, if blue collar workers cant keep up with the tax, then they are commuting 2 hours each way to drive in from the countryside
- xvedejas 5y agoThere's a lot of analysis out there showing that LVT is the one kind of tax that is not transferred into rent. On the contrary, it's expected that rents would drop under LVT, since land would become less scarce where people are willing to pay rents.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIt sounds like a perpetual motion machine. 100% of Revenue comes from land but somehow this isn't passed on to those occupying the land. It also ignores entire segments of the economy that don't have significant land requirement: Finance, services, digital Commerce. Google on Googlers pay no taxes but plumbers and homeowners in urban areas pick up the slack. Sounds highly regressive
- xvedejas 5y agoThe landowners pay the tax. Because of the vertical supply curve (land supply is fixed), it does not get passed on. This is true for any good that has fixed supply when the tax is equal to the gain in having exclusive rights to that good.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoBut the Assumption of a vertical supply curve is absurd. Land quantity is fixed but desirable land is flexible. From the outside this sounds like crazy cult thinking. May be applicable for a but Island like Singapore or Hong Kong but not the United States with vast swathes of usable land. Someone can go from Prime real estate in downtown San Francisco to rural Montana. As I said before, this ignores the fact that a remote googler can buy 100 acres with near 0 alternative land use value. It also ignores the regressive nature of the tax. Many places have a vertical Supply for water, but that doesn't mean raising tax revenue based on water consumption isn't regressive
- imtringued 5y agoThe reason for that is that the renter's are already paying economic rents and taxing those economic rents does not increase them. Ground rent is a residue that is left over after everyone else took their cut (income taxes reduce land value taxes for example).
- TimPC 5y agoGeorgism lowers the cost of achieving density and removes subsidies paid from cities to suburbs and rural areas from the tax system. In exchange for that, some variations of the system which offer a citizen’s dividend make it possible to subsist on rural land due to its low tax value. Doing so results in significant wage losses for the vast majority of the populace so it’s unclear how popular such a strategy would be.