8 ms·
Listening to the audio of the conversation, it doesn't seem like the passenger has no flying experience... At minimum they must have spent significant time aro
by whimsicalism 5y ago
Listening to the audio of the conversation, it doesn't seem like the passenger has no flying experience...
At minimum they must have spent significant time around aviation or be ex-military.
e: From another comment on Reddit
> Examples:
> The passenger knew what button to press on the yoke to transmit to ATC.
> The passenger knew aviation phraseology and phonetics “333 Lima Delta”.
> The passenger knew where the altimeter was and his altitude “I’m maintaining 9100 feet”
> Passenger was able to identify the transponder and enter a squawk code.
> Passenger knew what the vertical speed indicator was “I’m descending right now at 550 feet a minute passing 8640 feet”.
> My wife, who flies with me regularly, might get one or two of those items, but probably couldn't point out the transponder, much less enter a squawk code without instructions.
- medion 5y agoNone of these observations seem impossible for someone who is able to maintain low stress levels, think rationally and understand the overall general mechanics of how planes fly and what is important - altitude, speed, etc.
- egwor 5y agoI reckon I could do most of those things except transmit to ATC and squawk. I suspect I could google the rest or call someone to tell me how to. If there's a manual up there, then maybe that will have info?
- littlestymaar 5y ago> If there's a manual up there, then maybe that will have info? I can't imaging myself getting anything from an unknown manual full of jargon in such a stressful environment!
- verelo 5y agoNot sure if you've ever seen the POH for a C172, but it is thick. Example: https://www.montereynavyflyingclub.org/Other%20Docs/Cessna-172N-POH-1978.pdf https://www.montereynavyflyingclub.org/Other%20Docs/Cessna-1... Personally, ATC is your best bet here. I'd say a lot of people who have ever flown a flight simulator can get the plan low and slow enough to not cause death upon impact. I would anticipate a bumpy landing, some injury and a lost plane...so this outcome is pretty impressive imo.
- littlestymaar 5y ago> Not sure if you've ever seen the POH for a C172, but it is thick. Example: https://www.montereynavyflyingclub.org/Other%20Docs/Cessna-1 https://www.montereynavyflyingclub.org/Other%20Docs/Cessna-1... Thanks for the link, it's definitely not the kind of things you're supposed to discover while attempting to pilot a plane for the first time.
- to1y 5y ago73 pages isnt that bad, I was thinking 500pg+ for some reason. Guess simplicity is paramount.
- verelo 5y agoYeah, it’s just dense. Lots of great info in these things but you should know most of it from memory or only need it on the ground. It’s a legal requirement to carry in the plane but i don’t think I’ve ever needed one while in the air…yet
- jrockway 5y agoYeah, also not a pilot and I could do those things. But I am an enthusiast, kind of on my list of things to do but haven't done yet.
- DocTomoe 5y ago> If there's a manual up there, then maybe that will have info? Many (most?) airlines have abandoned printed manuals and paperwork in cockpits and have switched to tablets - often iPads - for weight considerations and because they are easier to just keep updated, and those are usually non-accessible to random passengers. Notable exception are emergency checklists.
- kenrik 5y agoAll planes are required to have the original POH onboard. However those don't really tell you how to fly the plane it's more focused on things like Vspeeds minimum flap extension speeds etc..
- sokoloff 5y agoThat varies based on the certification rules. My older 182 only had to have the operating limitations and weight and balance info (“O+W” in ARROW), but they did not have to be original. My later year A36, I believe needs the original AFM/POH. (In any case, I do carry it.) If you didn’t know how to fly, you couldn’t read enough of the book to figure it out before the aircraft departed controlled flight (if not on at least a wing-leveler autopilot).
- kenrik 5y agoI'm also an owner of an older 182 (1966 - 182K) I agree with you the POH won't really teach someone enough about the aircraft to fly it let alone operate the radios.
- buildsjets 5y agoAs noted, on an airplane without an AFM (Approved Flight Manual) the POH does not need no be on-board, only a placard with the operating limitations. The cutoff for the AFM requirement are individual aircraft that had their first flight after 1 March 1979. As the owner/operator of an early 1979 build aircraft that does not have an AFM, I’ve had this discussion with maintenance/airworthiness inspectors so frequently that I keep a printout of 14 cfr 21.5 in my POH. https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-14/chapter-I/subchapter-C/part-21/subpart-A/section-21.5 https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-14/chapter-I/subchapter-C...
- mikeryan 5y agoTotal spit ball here but just “riding” in a small Cessna seems like a pretty intimate experience. I wonder if he had spent a bunch of time in the passenger seat (as a job as a surveyor or ranger or something) and just got to know his way around a bit.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoI feel like the only thing a manual would be good for would be distracting you from flying the plane just long enough to enter some position that you (as someone with no training) won't be able to recover it from.
- bayesian_horse 5y agoFiguring out how to talk on the radio would be easy, even if nobody told you how to do it. And in an emergency situations ATCs tend to be really understanding and helpful. They even read the manual for you. In any case, landing a real plane in this scenario is even a little easier than in a simulator (though more dangerous, of course). You get all the vectors for the approach from the ATC, they tell all the other traffic to scuttle off and so on.
- adventured 5y agoFrom another article: "Morgan [controller] learned the passenger on the line had never flown a plane -- but had been around aviation and seen other pilots fly."
- AtNightWeCode 5y agoI think most people would be screwed cause there seems to a lot of different ways to get the radio to work in the first place. At least for larger planes.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoThe pilot would have had the radio tuned to the appropriate frequency already and talking is just a button on the yoke.
- eru 5y agoOr the pilot would have turned it to some frequency where somebody else was listening, and chances are the guy on the other side could give you instructions for how to get help.
- AtNightWeCode 5y agoAnd pushing the button does nothing. I believe you must hold it. Considering the amount of Zoom, Teams, Huddles and Google meets meetings I been into over the last couple of years I would be surprised if a majority of people fix this.
- CydeWeys 5y agoI have zero experience flying planes (or being near people flying them), but I do have ham radio experience. Sounds like that might actually help a lot. I've even spent some time listening to the ~120 MHz AM aviation bands.
- hgomersall 5y agoGenuine question, is my experience playing Microsoft flight simulator any use in being able to answer those questions, because it certainly feels like I can say something sensible about them.
- TomVDB 5y agoYes, it would be very helpful. My instructor encouraged me to buy MS FS, pedals and a yoke.
- runjake 5y agoFWIW, I grew up playing 80s/90s flight sims and later went into the military and worked on planes and got the opportunity to use military flight simulators and was able to make my way around the cockpit and takeoff/land pretty much immediately. I think my key for landing was learning flaps and throttle and getting a feel for stall speeds in sims. Now, would I want to test that in an actual plane in a life and death emergency? Not really. But I'd wager my odds are good.
- kenrik 5y agoPilot here: It could help with some familiarity but generally in MSFS you can get away with ignoring the gauges and just mess around. The tutorial might gloss over some of it. Having an unbelievable number of hours in MSFS when I was a kid ... landing a real plane is considerably harder and a ton of instruction time is just focused on getting you to land reliably. I finished my PPL in just over 40hrs which is close to the minimum. Most people will fall into the 60-100hr pool. I'm dubious that this passenger really had zero experience it takes a good 6-10hrs to get decent at landing (as in not bending metal). MSFS does however offer a reasonable feeling for the cruise portion of a flight.
- chronogram 5y agoBoth your comments were "dead", you could maybe mail HN to have your account set to not be shadow banned.
- 5y ago
- water-your-self 5y agoIt was a cessna with two passengers. I would assume that the passenger at minimum has a pilot/ flight enthusiast in their life.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago> I would assume that the passenger at minimum has a pilot/ flight enthusiast in their life. Or mostly uninterested spouse.
- picsao 5y ago
- mcculley 5y agoI have flown enough as a passenger with a single pilot to know some of those things. While I have held the wheel a bit, I have no formal training and no experience taking off or landing. If I were in the same situation, I would tell ATC, "I have no idea what I am doing" to err on the more useful end of expectations for assistance.
- ddingus 5y agoBingo. As would I. And with no real flight experience, I believe it is accurate to say. Having seen some stuff is a far cry from knowing things.
- efitz 5y agoI have 30 minutes and 2 touch-and-go’s in my log book. I suck at Microsoft Flight Simulator. In 30 minutes of the instructor sitting next to me, I successfully landed and took off in a Cessna 172, learned to trim power, elevators and flaps, learned how to transmit and how to “squawk ident”, and what channel to use in emergencies (1202 IIRC). Operating the airplane was very straightforward. Without the instructor or someone talking to me, I would not have known what to do when, but I can completely see how someone reasonably smart, calm, and able to follow directions could land such an airplane in good conditions.
- antmldr 5y agoIf you mean voice communication channel for emergencies, it's 121.5 MHz, 243.00 MHz for Military (double)
- a-dub 5y ago1200 is null as i understand i think 7200 is emergency? as a curious stem type who used to fly with other curious stem types back in the day, i remember asking for all the details and being given them. edit: 12xx is vfr no code assigned with various modifiers. 7700 declare emergency. 7600 radio out. 7500 mutiny.
- hodlfnejsns 5y ago1200 is VFR. That doesn’t mean null. 7500, 7600, and 7700 are used for various emergency purposes. These are transponder codes, not radio channels. It’s a code returned when the transponder is painted with interrogative radar.
- tialaramex 5y agoThis being Hacker News: The reason the digit 7 seems important here is that these are actually Octal. Under the hood this is a digital system, but the user interface is four octal digits ie 0000 to 7777 is a 12-bit value. Most modern aircraft are capable of providing a lot more data over their radio transponder, including a system unique identifier, but it turns out that "squawking" a four digit code is a useful amount of discretion to give humans. If you could do it over maybe a decimal code would have been better, but too late now.
- dominotw 5y agoHe was also so calm. Making me think he knew there was a way out if got some help.
- ddingus 5y agoCould have been a gamer
- travisgriggs 5y agoGot my PPL 2 years ago (almost), and love taking people for rides to various nearby destinations. It's my "Sunday Drive" and a chance to share with others. These questions often get answered pretty quickly. We get talking on our headsets, now I'm about to taxi, and so I make a call. Shortly there after, when I'm talking to my passenger, there's a nervous 'Can other people hear me??' 'Nope, I push this button right here to broadcast to everyone, otherwise it's just you and me.' 'Where is that button? Is this it? I don't want to push it.' In a small airplane, any interested passenger will ask a number of questions that help that acclimate. If this guy was a friend of the pilot and flew a bit with him, he had some familiarity. Is there a full recording up anywhere yet? I would love to know how fast they landed him. My inclination would be to talk someone through a landing that was a little faster than usual, because you have more control, and don't have to worry about the flair so much. Just drive it gently onto the runway and then slow it down after that. Which works fine for a little plane on a big runway.
- eru 5y agoDo you mean flair in a technical sense, or just in the sense of 'looking good'?
- jccooper 5y agoProbably "flare" in the sense of "pulling up for landing".
- travisgriggs 5y agoYes I did mean flare. Though I always try to flare with flair. :)
- bayesian_horse 5y agoFAA will eventually put out a full incident report ...
- trollied 5y agoVASAviation have posted the full ATC: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8MDwzNtDMlA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8MDwzNtDMlA Unfortunately, the instructor-led talkdown was done via a phone call.
- Macha 5y agoThey're in a cessna, with one other person piloting. I think spending a significant time around aviation is a given, but I also wouldn't call that flying experience. It's not like being in the cabin in a commercial airliner, you'd see the pilot doing these things, and honestly as far as plane interfaces go, the Cessna is not bad. https://external-content.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=https%3A%2F%2Flearntofly.ca%2Fwp-content%2Fuploads%2F2010%2F03%2FCessna-172-Instrument-Panel.jpg&f=1&nofb=1 https://external-content.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=https%3A%2F%2F... Here's the instrument panel. While I wouldn't say every untrained person can just "figure it out", I think there are a decent number who would at least be able to get an altitude, heading, and vertical speed reading out of that. Especially if you'd spent some time in the last 30 minutes looking at them while your pilot friend is focused on flying. I've spent a signficant amount of time flying cessnas in MS flight sim and XPlane, but I wouldn't assume that would automatically carry over if I ended up in a situation like that, and I certainly would err on the side of caution and risk ATC thinking I had less knowledge than risk overstating it and risk something going wrong because they end up thinking I'd be confident performing an ILS approach or something.
- vonseel 5y agoThe dials are in the middle and literally labeled altitude, airspeed in knots, etc. Not a great point from the Reddit armchair scientists but the guy who landed the plane obviously holds up well in stressful situations.
- Terry_Roll 5y ago> but the guy who landed the plane obviously holds up well in stressful situations Thats what you need a cool head when everyone else is losing theirs. Not only that if the pilot had any sense he would give any passenger in the front a TLDR for emergencies just as a common courtesy. TBH I'm surprised the various Aviation Authorities have not mandated some sort of TLDR emergency/safety guide for small planes and their passengers, unless of course they dont really care if one drops out of the sky killing everyone!?! Not a pilot, but taken control of a biplane, & helicopter, biplane is so easy, doing the nose dives like you see in the old war movies, bringing them up to stalling point etc, the plane even makes the same noise as you here in the movies, but its bloody cold even with your sheepskin coat on. Helicopters, now they are sensitive and the pilot wouldnt let me do the pedals, but it was a hover test, ie seeing how long I could keep it hovering. Have flown with ex red arrows doing the same stunts as a passenger, I think they tried their best to get me to use their sick back but they didnt succeed, haven't done any fighter jets yet, or any Air Racing but never say never! I would imagine the acceleration from a flight deck catapult must be on a par with a Porsche 911 Turbo S on launch control, maybe a bit better who knows?
- cryptonector 5y agoWhere's the audio? TFA has very little of it. EDIT: Never mind. You can find it downthread.
- stevage 5y agoWhere? I can't find it.
- Trufa 5y agoI honestly kind of know what all of that is and I have seriously NO idea how to fly a plane.
- dghughes 5y agoYeah as a former student pilot (and that is all) I was curious about their specific knowledge and terminology. Maintaining altitude was what I found most difficult as a student pilot my instructor drew a line on the windscreen with a marker to help me. I could vary 1,000 feet or more up or down before the instructor told what was going on. Knowing how to get the frequency for the tower or just knowing they had to was telling. And landing is tricky knowing to aim at the end of the runway as if you're going to crash and then flare as if you're going up again. All counter-intuitive to anyone who is not aware that's what's done. Not to mention speed, flaps, rudder control. And the barf oh the barf!
- rejor121 5y agoI lean towards aggreing with you. It’s possible he was prior military. I was an AE and worked on basically all of the flight systems in my eight years in the navy. The fact he knew phonetics just makes me believe he served or at the very least, was heavily exposed in another function.
- Hamuko 5y agoOr just wanted to know phonetics for any other reason. They're not that hard and they're pretty useful on the phone.
- stevage 5y agoI find these days they're pretty common with regular old customer service reps spelling out anything over the phone.
- well_actulily 5y agoI was an Army combat medic and I know the NATO alphabet, despite never having been in an airplane cockpit.
- aix1 5y ago> The fact he knew phonetics just makes me believe he served or at the very least, was heavily exposed in another function. This is just one data point, but I'm a random software engineer with no military or aviation background or interests, and I know NATO phonetics. I think it's not that uncommon. (My main use case is spelling things over the phone.)
- inopinatus 5y agoI learned the NATO alphabet for no better reason than it seemed useful over noisy communication channels, such as when on the phone in a data center with the HVAC going hard. And so it has proved. That was maybe fifteen years ago; I'm so accustomed now, that I'll use it reflexively with everyone. Anecdotally, I have observed that certain professions are inclined to treat those that use it with more respect.
- stevage 5y agoI would love to hear the full audio somewhere. Maybe there was a lot of extra information about how to use those controls. He was also very comfortable with the radio, dropping in terms like 10-4. A similar episode a few years back: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rzhKczNcB_c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rzhKczNcB_c (There's the full audio for that somewhere but I can't find it right now)
- Abishek_Muthian 5y agoMay be transmitting to ATC with proper terminologies was learnt by watching the pilot do it? I assume there's not much to do as a passenger in a small aircraft like Cessna 208? Btw, This got me curious and looked into Rowan Atkinson's (Mr. Bean) similar plane incident[1] where he supposedly maintained control of the aircraft mid-air when his pilot was incapacitated and the pilot recovered eventually to land the plane. All information on this incident points to Rowan not having any prior flying experience. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rowan_Atkinson#Plane_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rowan_Atkinson#Plane_incident
- mike978 5y ago
- ChicagoBoy11 5y agoAs a pilot that was my first instinct as well... it just sounded like he knew his way around an airplane... fully concede he may not have been a pilot, but he was clearly way too familiar with the situation to be described as someone who had "no idea how to fly", imo.