8 ms·
Is this really anything new? I think most people who actually talk with their neighbors about various topics can see that most people aren't as extreme as their
by giantg2 5y ago
Is this really anything new? I think most people who actually talk with their neighbors about various topics can see that most people aren't as extreme as their party is represented to be in the media.
There are hundreds of millions of party members. Did anyone truly think that a member of either party supports every policy the party supports, or that there are different factions within the party that take opposing stances on specific issues? There's no way we're able to fully map 100M to 1 on an innumerable amount of topics/solutions.
- jqgatsby 5y ago>>Did anyone truly think that a member of either party supports every policy the party supports? I see you haven't met my in-laws.
- giantg2 5y agoSorry, I shouldn't have used absolutist language. You're right, there are likely a small minority that agrees with everything that at least their faction of the party says.
- banannaise 5y ago(hopefully) relevant perspective from a transgender person: It is irrelevant to me that most people are not extremists. There are a lot of "non-extremist" people who consider me a loon because of my appearance and gender. Those people seem to get along perfectly fine with "moderates" who are more accepting of me... and that really doesn't help, because the typical result is that both of them will agree to treat me as an extremist. For existing.
- twofornone 5y ago
- a_shovel 5y agoYeah, that's my position as well. People make fun of leftists for infighting and "cancel culture" and "eating their own", but the alternative seems to be allowing the worst parts of "your side" to keep and even expand their influence over the political landscape, and that seems to be what the right has done.
- Shish2k 5y agoThis is what happens with a first-past-the-post voting system — you agree to band together behind your side’s resident extremist, or you lose :/
- zmgsabst 5y agoI think that’s because you don’t denounce actual extremists within the transgender movement. I think you’re conflating both groups denouncing those extremists as denouncing you, because those extremists are who represents your group on the mainstream narrative.
- banannaise 5y agoSo now I'm supposed to spend my time proving that I'm mainstream enough to be acceptable, because my existence makes me guilty by association? This is the "Black people should have no issue proving they aren't criminals" argument. Also, transgender people aren't a movement. We're people.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zmgsabst 5y ago> Also, transgender people aren't a movement. We're people. I’m not saying it’s fair or right… But transgender people are a minority whose voice has been appropriated by a political movement to force their radical agenda under euphemisms like “inclusion”. I’m not saying that you need to be outspoken about it — but if the only exposure most people have is that extremist view from TV, they will associate you with that due to how humans work. > "Black people should have no issue proving they aren't criminals" The equivalent would be black people debouncing the neo-racism of Democrats under euphemisms like “equity” and publicly denouncing nonsense done in their name, like de-policing. Again, I’m not saying it’s fair or right… but I’d tell a black Democrat who was upset about being associated with that idiocy the same thing: You’re tacitly letting your identity be used to push dumb policies — and you’ll be associated until you stand up and say “no, this doesn’t represent me”.
- arkaniad 5y agoRadical agenda like... being able to safely receive healthcare? Being safe from violence? Being able to grow into a happy and successful human being? Ah, but yes, you're right, that's preposterous.
- giantg2 5y ago"There are a lot of "non-extremist" people who consider me a loon because of my appearance and gender. Those people seem to get along perfectly fine with "moderates" who are more accepting of me... and that really doesn't help, because the typical result is that both of them will agree to treat me as an extremist." I'm curious, why would these people not be considered extreme for treating you like a loon or treating you as an extremist? I've seen similar stuff on other issues. For example, there are people who hate guns who treat gun owners as loons and extremists regardless of their actions/positions/etc. Just saying that some people treat others as extremists just because they hold an opposing view. My guess is it's often to prevent cognitive dissonance in examining their own beliefs (most people don't consider themselves extremists even if they hold extreme views).
- banannaise 5y agoI think you're on to something here, but my (admittedly anecdotal) experience (in person, not online) is that these people are not generally considered extremist. You make a very good point in your last sentence: this extremist view is held by a lot of people who are otherwise non-extremist, and it's hard for most people to differentiate between "extremist views" and "extremist people". So it ends up being considered much less extremist than it should be, which also means it gets much more mainstream acceptance than it should.
- giantg2 5y agoYeah, you said it better than I did.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- SpicyLemonZest 5y agoAnd I encourage everyone to keep whatever circles make them happy. But if a devout Christian said she doesn't like anyone who hangs out with atheists, or a meat-eater said he doesn't like anyone who hangs out with vegans, I don't think you'd struggle to identify these as extremist attitudes. The expectation that a person is guaranteed to mistreat me if any of their friends disapproves of me or think I'm a loon seems like a clear example of miscalibrated contempt.
- hedora 5y agoI could say everything you said, as a person hoping the planet will remain habitable for my children. (Substitute the bit about appearance with "because I think we should immediately stop new fossil fuel exploration / capital investment and institute atmospheric carbon recapture taxes of $1-2 per gallon-of-gasoline-equivalent emissions") Anyway, I think the premise of the article is flawed: I don't care whether voters in some red state are queer-bashing, abortion-banning putin apologists that want to strip mine for coal. (Want them for neighbors, or not? Move!) I care that the people they've voted in and appointed to the supreme court are all of those things, and this planet is not large enough to let the rest of us escape from their idiocy.
- mistermann 5y ago> I care that the people they've voted in and appointed to the supreme court are all of those things... Do you care whether this belief (which may have the appearance of knowledge) is objectively and flawlessly true?
- watwut 5y agoThe abortion banning part is provably true at this point. And it is very fair to guess it was plan from the start, despite pretention not. Despite calling those who guesses it 100% correctly exaggerating and hysterical.
- mistermann 5y agoThe claim was: >> I don't care whether voters in some red state are queer-bashing, abortion-banning putin apologists that want to strip mine for coal. (Want them for neighbors, or not? Move!) >> I care that the people they've voted in and appointed to the supreme court are all of those things > The abortion banning part is provably true at this point. a) Not comprehensively for all people, as was claimed. b) It is supreme court justices that would be banning it, not elected representatives. c) How might one prove it for any given elected representative, short of an explicit confession? d) Abortion banning wasn't the only claim. > And it is very fair to guess it was plan from the start, despite pretention not. "Fair to say" and "correct/true" are very different things. > Despite calling those who guesses it 100% correctly exaggerating and hysterical. Where "100% correctly" refers to perception of reality, but is typically perceived as reality itself. Human beings are silly, I would say without exception - News at 11.
- mistermann 5y ago> There's no way we're able to fully map 100M to 1 on an innumerable amount of topics/solutions. There's no way to do it accurately, but the mind "does it" all day err day without breaking a sweat, as it evolved to do. This phenomenon is what this paper is describing, is it not? Possibly relevant: https://www.simplypsychology.org/context-and-state-dependent-memory.html https://www.simplypsychology.org/context-and-state-dependent... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31338304 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31338304