6 ms·
So you expect roughly 50% of people to hate you, and for you to hate about 50% of people? Seems a miserable way to look at it. The fact is that choices are lim
by giantg2 5y ago
So you expect roughly 50% of people to hate you, and for you to hate about 50% of people? Seems a miserable way to look at it.
The fact is that choices are limited. Things like ranked choice voting might start to change that. Maybe we could see other major parties at some point. The fact that we have only two main parties is a product of your (and most people's) sort of game theory mindset - that you have to oppose the other side even if your choice isn't great.
- banannaise 5y ago[flagged]
- peteradio 5y ago> a political party whose agenda includes literal genocide of transgender people That's pretty loaded, almost flaggable, but I think in this thread I'll ask what are you talking about?
- bitwize 5y ago
- peteradio 5y agoI think you have extreme views, but I'm not going to assume all LGBTQ and allies hold the same.
- orangecat 5y agoThis is exactly the sort of catastrophizing that the study is talking about. Yes, I'm sure you can find a few lunatics on the right who have said something like that. You can also find nutjobs on the left who want a literal Communist revolution. Neither is anywhere near the views of the vast majority of conservatives or liberals.
- bavell 5y ago> literal genocide of transgender people Did I miss something or is this just inflammatory rhetoric? I know about the literal genocide happening in Yemen but I haven't heard anything about transgender genocide.
- breadbreadbread 5y agoFlorida's HB 1557 doesn't go that far, but the rhetoric that people use to support it has echoes of fascism. All of the right-wing talking points around trans issues equate teaching kids about lgbt issues to pedophilia. For many supporters, even walking around as trans is seen as sexual deviant and dangerous. When a bill is passed that enshrines into law that "it is bad to tell kids about this person", and the supporters casually say "breaking this law is pedophilia", what do you think is going to happen to trans people trying to live their lives in Florida?
- banannaise 5y agoPretty much. I try not to go down the "dehumanizing language = genocide" path, because dehumanizing language has sadly become par for the course, but there has been a rapid escalation on two fronts, reflected directly in state laws: 1. Moving from simple dehumanization to "trans people are groomers and pedophiles and we must protect our children from them at any cost". This is still only an escalation toward violence, but it certainly is an escalation. 2. Forcible detransitioning of trans people, with the direct aim of eliminating out trans people as a population. It remains to be seen what will be done with people who refuse to detransition, but imprisonment appears to already be on the table. And when you imprison a population for their identity and/or customs, then, well... that's genocide.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoExactly where and how are trans people being forcibly detransitioned?
- banannaise 5y ago
- mananaysiempre 5y ago> The fact that we have only two main parties is a product of your (and most people's) sort of game theory mindset Or of a winner-take-all electoral system? I can’t say that the systems I’ve seen which have you vote for an amorphous entity instead of a tangible and somewhat accessible person are better in every sense, exactly, but I think of the sort of environment which would develop the word bipartisan to mean universally supported and can’t shake off an overwhelming feeling of stupid.
- kansface 5y agoWe’ve always had this system. We haven’t always hated each other.
- lapcat 5y agoFrom the linked paper: "Time spent watching partisan media (controlling political orientation) predicted greater overestimations of the prevalence of extreme views"
- mperham 5y agoI'd encourage you to read the People's History of the United States. Who's "we"? I don't think a single Black American would agree with your statement.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- disgruntledphd2 5y agoPR does not mean a list system. Ireland has multi member constituencies, PR and no list system.
- breadbreadbread 5y ago
- giantg2 5y agoI think we also need to move primary voting to the same day nationally. Right now just a few states narrow down the primary choices. By the time it gets to the later states there's only one or two left. "voting Republican in America gives power to a party that believes that it is evil to tell children about the effects of slavery or the fact that queer people exist and deserve rights." That's the same sort of extreme view that the paper was talking about, and mischaraterizes the party's position (even if a small faction does believe it). Don't you think that some Republicans think all Democrats want to abolish the police or take their guns?
- breadbreadbread 5y agoMy opinion of Republican values regarding LGBT rights comes directly from spoken statements from sitting members of congress and state legislators. If Republicans can point to actual legislators that say "no one should have guns", I'll listen. But typically I find that gun-control "debates" involve a nuanced "common-sense" gun control side and a "they want to disarm you and take your stuff" side. Which again, comes down to disinformation spreading among the right and preventing good-faith arguments for gun-control.
- giantg2 5y ago"Common-sense" is a highly opinionated phrase. I do sympathize that it's hard to find a good debate due to the misinformation or poor arguments on both sides. Without good debate it is tough to get a good view of the issue. Even then, there can be points that come down to philosophy or law around how the action can/should be implemented. And of course, there's very little nuance or compromise being investigated by either side. That said, which LGBT rights do you think they oppose? Do they oppose all rights or just "common sense regulations" (see where I'm going?)? What one person sees as a right, someone else might see as a privilege. Or what they see as reasonable regulation another might see as infringement. The sides have to convey their reasoning for why something is a right, or why they see it the way they do. It's supposed to be an effort to understand each other to make things work for both sides through compromise. There are a lot of vehement and downright ridiculous comments out there. Perhaps you see more of them on the LGBTQ issues. Perhaps gun owners notice them on gun issues. So perspective can matter. You have people like Beto O'Rourke saying they will confiscate certain arms. There the DNC committee member that said she thinks nobody should have a gun (Bonnie Schaefer). Many have declined to answer whether they believe if owning a gun is a right, including Hillary Clinton. If they can't answer the question, then people will think it's a bad sign. There are a lot from Feinstein that I'll put at the end. And this doesn't even cover all the misinformation (what was used in a specific crime, things that are already illegal), frivolous laws (a folding stock isn't making a difference), and wrong terminology (assault rifle, clip/mag, etc). It's hard to write intelligent legislation if the terms aren't used correctly or the subject isn't well understood. I assume you've seen the same on cis people writing LGBTQ laws. Many gun organizations have supported past restrictions. Maybe we could implement "universal" background checks by creating a free to use system that can be used for other types of checks as well and doesn't keep a record of what the check was for (maybe using a zero trust pattern or some one way hashing which industry/watch group oversight)? This would address the concerns the concerns of building registries or abuse of power while making a seller civilly liable if the person they sold to was prohibited. Why doesn't anyone in power suggest such a thing as a compromise? There are tons of options out there. "Common sense" has just become a marketing term by politicians on both sides to appeal to people without actually proving out their issue. I'll leave you with some quotes from Feinstein: “Banning guns addresses a fundamental right of all Americans to feel safe.” – Associated Press, 18 November, 1993. “If I could have gotten 51 votes in the Senate of the United States for an outright ban, picking up every one of them; “Mr. and Mrs. America, turn ‘em all in,” I would have done it.” – 60 Minutes on CBS, 5 February, 1995. "All vets are mentally ill in some way and government should prevent them from owning firearms."
- renewiltord 5y ago“Hate” is too much. I can exist in a society with opponents and allies pretty smoothly. But morally, I’m going to bucket people, yeah. If you vote one way, you don’t care all that much about key issues that matter to me. I do. It’s relevant to my life. It doesn’t matter what you say. The truth is you don’t care as much as I do. I don’t have to oppose anything. That’s you projecting. Knowing who is opposing me is not opposing them. It’s just knowing the landscape. I’m quite comfortable not opposing someone even if they oppose me, but I do insist on knowing they oppose me.
- nybble41 5y ago> So you expect roughly 50% of people to hate you, and for you to hate about 50% of people? You don't have to vote either Republican or Democrat. Third-parties, write-ins, and simply abstaining in protest are all perfectly valid alternatives which would get you out of that 50%. I more-or-less agree with the GP here: If you vote for a candidate knowing that they will use the power you give them in ways which are harmful to others, you're contributing to the problem. That's true even in FPTP voting systems where the winner will almost certainly have an (R) or (D) next to their name no matter what you do. Overall turnout (voter engagement) and the percentage that actually voted for the winning candidate both matter even if they don't change the official result of the election.
- giantg2 5y agoYes, you don't need to be part of the 50%, but that doesn't get you away from that effect of the 50% either. There are causes in both major parties that someone is likely to find themselves on the receiving end of some law or regulation that they don't like. So you could still end up opposing that 50% if you're lumping them all in with the politician on that side. "If you vote for a candidate knowing that they will use the power you give them in ways which are harmful to others, you're contributing to the problem." Can you name any candidate that wouldn't harm any group? It seems they all have ideas about what laws would make things better, and those laws tend to involve control of people's actions or inactions.
- nybble41 5y ago> Can you name any candidate that wouldn't harm any group? No, I can't. That's the problem with voting for representatives or officials—you inevitably end up voting for a politician. The candidate pool is made up of people who see force as a reasonable means for solving problems, real or imagined; those who don't see it that way have more productive things to do than run for political office in a system they consider immoral. Occasionally you get an idealist who thinks they can change the system from within, but it's too well entrenched—the corruption ends up infecting them instead.