12 ms·
A common sunscreen ingredient turns toxic in the sea – anemones suggest why
- wrycoder 5y agoToxic to anemones, that is.
- dtagames 5y agoThe concern is that it's toxic to coral, an important part of the food chain in the ocean. The risks of sunscreen chemicals to coral has been known for years in reef communities like Cancun and Hawaii, but it isn't widely known elsewhere. Of course, many tourists still use these chemicals when they swim in the reef.
- mherdeg 5y agoWe're all-in on zinc oxide for sunscreen (90%+ of the time avoiding other chemical alternatives). I don't know if the *-benzones or the other ingredients actually pose any health risks to humans and I doubt the risk is greater than the risk of melanoma after sunburn. But it doesn't cost us much extra to stick to a single ingredient, it's something we already smear on our kids all the time (as Desitin), and it's only slightly more inconvenient to apply without looking like a spooky ghost, so why not?
- UncleOxidant 5y agozinc is also toxic to corals. https://beachapedia.org/Reef_Friendly_Sunscreens https://beachapedia.org/Reef_Friendly_Sunscreens
- mistrial9 5y agozinc is toxic to humans, too.. in not-too-much larger amounts. probably need some rational weighting on some of these reactions chains, including dilution, persistence and bio-accumulation, among other things..
- wrycoder 5y ago> Oxybenzone — a chemical linked to coral bleaching — transforms from a UV-blocking agent into one that damages cells when exposed to light. The article subhead, copied above, suggests that oxybenzone, once exposed to seawater, could damage cells. Without qualification, human cells. That was my initial takeaway. It turns out that anemones convert oxybenzone to a molecule that could damage coral. That’s very different.
- lostcolony 5y agoHow common is oxybenzone (or octinoxate for that matter) currently? Just a couple years ago it seemed to be in nearly every container of sunscreen (and all the articles I can find about it were from then), as I actively tried to avoid it. I went looking for sunscreen just last week, and I literally didn't see it listed once, even in the most commodity brands like Banana Boat and Sun Bum.
- gruez 5y ago"Amazon's Choice" for "sunscreen" contains 6% Oxybenzone. https://www.amazon.com/Neutrogena-Ultra-Dry-Touch-Sunscreen-Spectrum/dp/B005IHT94S/ref=sr_1_5?keywords=sunscreen&sprefix=sunscreen%2Caps%2C100&sr=8-5 https://www.amazon.com/Neutrogena-Ultra-Dry-Touch-Sunscreen-...
- lostcolony 5y agoI don't know if I believe that, actually. If you look at one of Amazon's "best sellers" in the category, https://www.amazon.com/Sun-Bum-Moisturizing-SPF-Hypoallergenic/dp/B004YAUZFW https://www.amazon.com/Sun-Bum-Moisturizing-SPF-Hypoallergen..., you see the description says both Oxybenzone and Octinoxate free, but that the image of the ingredient list shows Octinoxate. They clearly updated the product, but not the images. If I search for the particular sunscreen you link and go to Neutrogena's website, I get https://www.neutrogena.com/products/sun/ultra-sheer-dry-touch-oxybenzone-free-sunscreen-lotion-broad-spectrum-spf-70/6868770.html https://www.neutrogena.com/products/sun/ultra-sheer-dry-touc..., which is, as you'll note from the URL, Oxybenzone free (and Octinoxate as well). Searching more broadly, I can't find -any- reference to the 70 SPF ultra sheer dry touch with Oxybenzone on Neutrogena's site; I can find the 100 SPF at https://www.neutrogena.com/products/sun/ultra-sheer-dry-touch-sunscreen-broad-spectrum-spf-100/6887310.html https://www.neutrogena.com/products/sun/ultra-sheer-dry-touc... (via Google), but as you'll note, that's discontinued. I can also comment, in Target, I looked at every Neutrogena product. I can't say for certain I saw the 70 SPF, but I can say I definitely checked out the ultra sheer dry touch line. No Oxybenzone. So my expectation is that either that item on Amazon is old stock, or they haven't updated the product details (I don't see an indicator it's being filled by a third party else I'd also suggest it might be a formulation for another country that doesn't have regulations/awareness around oxybenzone). It's not actually being sold by Neutrogena in the US any more.
- ravenstine 5y agoI never use sunscreen at the ocean, both because I just hate putting it on and because I always thought it was probably not the best thing to put that crap directly into the ecosystem. Unless I'm spending a ton of time at the beach, which rarely happens, I feel like I can deal with an hour or so of that kind of sun exposure every now and then. If one is spending a ton of time in the sun, then yeah, use sunscreen. Since I'm indoors most of the time, I rarely find sunscreen that helpful. Anecdotally, I think I became more sun tolerant after changing my diet. In short, I highly limit eating processed foods and stick to meat and some plants that are low in natural defense chemicals. Since that's a low-inflammatory diet, maybe that explains it. But I'm purely speculating.
- fullstop 5y agoI would look like a tomato if I were exposed to 1 hour of mid-day sun at the beach.
- nkingsy 5y agoI burn about as easily as anyone, but 20 mins on each side with my face and neck covered doesn’t result in a burn for me. I do wear mineral sunscreen on my face, neck and arms for normal outdoor activities.
- fullstop 5y agoThe sunlight reflecting off of the water and the sand doesn't help.
- dymk 5y agoGetting the sunburn has nothing to do with your body’s inflammatory response. Like, taking aspirin won’t keep you from getting sunburnt. Same way it won't prevent you from getting burned if you touch a hot stove. It makes no sense.
- _yb2s 5y agoActually aspirin totally does have a powerful effect on sunburns... the aspirin probably doesn't actually protect your skin from damage, but it reduces the painful inflammation afterwards, which is the part we actually feel and consider a 'sunburn.' I know several people that take aspirin instead of using sunscreen.
- simiones 5y agoHow toxic can this be, compared to the enormous dilution it would reach in the ocean? If this is indeed a major cause of the coral reef issues, I would expect that there is some entity dumping large amounts of the stuff directly into the ocean. Intuitively it seems very unlikely that the amount that will wash off swimmer's skin would be a major contributor, at least for anything that is not living right next to the beach side.
- x86_64Ubuntu 5y agoLiving organisms are SUPER sensitive to chemical and temperature changes. The fact that oil spills, algae blooms from ag runoff have wide reaching effects shows that dilution is not as significant as we want it to be in making problems go away.
- shakezula 5y agoNot to mention places like Hawaii have outlawed certain chemicals in sunscreens specifically because of these types of issues. It’s not really a question of if anymore but how much and how bad.
- tsimionescu 5y agoPeople have also outlawed plastic straws, for no good reason whatsoever, while doing less than nothing to stop plastic pollution from fishing equipment. Making it seem like you're doing something for the environment while not doing anything hard can win plenty of points.
- hall0ween 5y agoYea. If it’s not a perfect solution, let’s do nothing! Where have people outlawed these straws, and what is your source for it (if it happened) doing less than nothing?
- tsimionescu 5y ago
- mrfusion 5y ago10 internet points if you can point me to a sunscreen that’s sweat resistant, non greasy, and non toxic (physical) I’ve been trying to find one for months.
- pbhjpbhj 5y agoIt's it possible to have sunscreen that is sweat-resistant and non-greasy?
- lacrosse_tannin 5y agoHat
- easyat 5y agoLightweight clothing covering your skin is the best way
- dymk 5y agoUnfortunately my hands, feet, neck, and ears sunburn easily, and can’t really be covered when swimming or on the beach, so a sunscreen is still needed
- causi 5y agoZinc oxide for the best protection, titanium dioxide for less oil, less visibility, and less irritation of skin acne. At least 8% content for both. If you want to go expensive, La Roche-Posay Anthelios 60, if you want to go cheap try Coppertone Water Babies SPF 50 or Equate Ultra Protection SPF 50. Reapplying every few hours is important.
- dymk 5y agoThis is gold, thank you
- alsdjfklasjdf 5y agobeware with La Roche-Posay line! Well, most mega corp cosmetic chem corps have this exact same problem. They use the exact same brand/package design/names for completely different products, depending on where you are. For example, USA you get "Anthelios 60 Mineral", with 8% Ti dioxide and 6% zinc ox. In the EU you get 6% Ti diox and 12% zinc ox. In south america you get Oxybenzene and no minerals :shrug Now, guess which one you will end up getting on the cheaper listings on amazon even in the USA.
- belval 5y agoThe comments here seems to be missing the point, yes the article is not technically clickbait, but it also explicitly mentions that while oxybenzone causes bleaching, it is not responsible for THE coral bleaching that we are seeing in most reefs around the world. > The study lacks “ecological realism”, agrees Terry Hughes, a marine biologist at James Cook University in Townsville, Australia. Coral-bleaching events on Australia’s Great Barrier Reef, for example, have been linked more closely to trends in water temperature than to shifts in tourist activity. “Mass bleaching happens regardless of where the tourists are,” Hughes says. “Even the most remote, most pristine reefs are bleaching because water temperatures are killing them.” And this gem as a final note: > Hughes emphasizes that the greatest threats to reefs remain rising temperatures, coastal pollution and overfishing. Changing sunscreens might not do much to protect coral reefs, Hughes says. “It’s ironic that people will change their sunscreens and fly from New York to Miami to go to the beach,” he says. “Most tourists are happy to use a different brand of sunscreen, but not to fly less and reduce carbon emissions.”
- pentae 5y agoIndeed. I imagine it would be pretty hard for people to enjoy swimming in these places without taking a commercial flight
- dymk 5y agoThis is why we need a net carbon tax. Behavior won’t change unless people start paying the real cost of emitting carbon.
- sfe22 5y agoMaybe we do indeed need that tax. My only request would be the decision to be democratic and making sure the revenue doesn’t go to to the monopoly that injected people with plutonium. Instead it can be used to reverse the damage and with any excess being returned to their rightful earners.
- treeman79 5y ago
- hadlock 5y agoOxybenzone studies have in the past been funded by a sunscreen company in hawaii, and used those to push for the ban of Oxybenzone sunscreen sales in Hawaii. Since Hawaii is an island, everyone needs to buy sunscreen on arrival after landing at the airport. Oxybenzone studies have been questioned previously based on the amount used in sunscreen, dilution in The Ocean, and those used in the study. Follow the money.
- dave5104 5y ago> Since Hawaii is an island, everyone needs to buy sunscreen on arrival after landing at the airport. If you're implying this is somehow enforced at the airport, this is not even remotely true. Source: Brought my own sunscreen from outside of Hawaii and used it all last week while visiting.
- jdminhbg 5y agoI think the implication instead is you can't carry on sunscreen since it's a liquid, so you'd have to buy when you get there. But you're right, if you're checking a bag, you can bring all the sunscreen you feel like schlepping.
- ocschwar 5y agoConfirmed that enforcement is lax. And also that there is a horrifying amount of broken coral washing ashore at Waikiki.
- dave5104 5y agoI'm still having trouble finding any sort of indication that there's a law on the books that prohibits travelers from bringing whatever sunscreen they want into the state via air (or boat, I suppose). Nothing on banning possession either. Do you have a source? Best I can find is that Hawaii prohibits the sale of sunscreens containing oxybenzone or octinoxate, which took effect in 2021. https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/Archives/measure_indiv_Archives.aspx?billtype=SB&billnumber=2571&year=2018 https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/Archives/measure_indiv_Archiv...
- ODILON_SATER 5y agoCheck out EWG's sunscreen list, it rates sunscreens based on toxicity and UV protection. https://www.ewg.org/sunscreen/ https://www.ewg.org/sunscreen/ They rate most products found in North America. It is my go-to resource for sunscreens
- nate 5y agoThanks for this! This explains so much. I've been allergic to various sunscreens for years, and now I see why :)
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoIt was recently publicized that a lot of sunscreens (even popular ones like Neutrogena) have benzene. Choose one without it: https://www.consumerlab.com/answers/cancer-causing-compounds-benzene-benzophenone-in-sunscreen/carcinogens-sunscreen/ https://www.consumerlab.com/answers/cancer-causing-compounds...
- lesgobrandon 5y ago
- robocat 5y agoFor better technical details see https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/05/corals-convert-sunscreen-chemical-into-a-toxin-that-kills-them/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/05/corals-convert-sunsc... TLDR: oxybenzone from sunblock gets glucose attached, which turns oxybenzone into a UV light driven catalyst. The catalyst doesn’t degrade, and the UV light catalyses biological molecules of the coral, damaging or killing the coral, particularly bleached coral lacking protective symbiotes.
- kleton 5y agoEveryone really should only be using "physical" blockers like zinc oxide, like is in the baby sunscreens. You might not like how Zuck looked on his board with face painted white, but it's coming out that the organic compounds that absorb UV are bad news.
- galangalalgol 5y agoAnd make sure its not blend-in nano-particle zinc oxide, apparently it blends in by crossing into your bloodstream. I've been mostly using the fern pills that are advertised to stop sun damage. They absolutely prevent and even reverse a sunburn, but I have no idea if they are actually preventing dna damage that leads to melanoma.
- redytedy 5y agoConsidering the majority of the female population in Japan has been using chemical sunscreen for a generation now, I figure it can't be THAT bad..
- tintedfireglass 5y agoDo we need a sunscreen? I've lived in the tropics most of my life and only hearing about sunscreens from Europeans and Americans. Is it due to the white skin or something? I don't understand.
- ossyrial 5y agoYep it's something with white skin, see [0]. Generally the whiter the skin the easier you burn, which has health risks (skin cancer, faster aging). [0]: https://www.weatheronline.co.uk/reports/wxfacts/The-UV-Index.htm https://www.weatheronline.co.uk/reports/wxfacts/The-UV-Index...
- tintedfireglass 5y agoWow, thanks!
- iostream24 5y agoMelanin does indeed absorb and blunt the effects of UV on human skin. It also lowers vitamin D production in low sunlight climes. I’m trying to figure out what messed-up melanin strategy freckles are, spot protection? All this said, sunburns are symptomatic for skin damage that can result in melanoma, and yes, dark skin can burn too, etc… Sunscreens are relatively recent as far as products go, but mud and mineral skin protection is ancient. Many tribal hunter gatherers use such protection against a variety of threats including sunburn and insect bites.
- tintedfireglass 5y agoYeah, the Bedouin cover their heads for sun and sand protection but the Polynesians,South East Asians, central/southern African tribes all don't show any mention of protection from sunlight, they even wear minimal clothing. The only place I see ancient people protecting themselves from sun is in sub Sahara Africa and Middle east
- astura 5y agoYes, it's due to the amount of melanin in one's skin. Have you ever seen someone with a sunburn? It's painful, the skin is red, hot to the touch, and the person feels generally unwell (flu-like symptoms). The skin hurts for days and the it will blister and then peel. The blister/peel stage is extremely itchy. Wouldn't you want to avoid that if possible? Even ignoring the risk of long term harm. I prefer wearing long sleeves and a wide brim hat to chemical sunblocks but that is not possible when swimming.