3 ms·
Even if you somehow are pro-IP, implying that archival shouldn't use patented codecs makes no sense since they are going to expire sometime in the future anyway
by userbinator 5y ago
Even if you somehow are pro-IP, implying that archival shouldn't use patented codecs makes no sense since they are going to expire sometime in the future anyway (and especially for archival, the timescales for patent expiry seem very soon --- 20 years at most, basically.)
- londons_explore 5y agoI believe the fashionable thing in the patent world is "evergreening" - Ie. Doing everything to make sure that patent doesn't expire. That often involves filing a few more patents 19 years later. Yes, there was prior art, but do you have deep enough pockets to go up against their lawyers to prove that? Other techniques involve using copyright (the bitstream decode tables could be considered copyrightable for example). Future techniques might even involve trying to use trademark law (for example, the first frame of any encoded video is the 'MPAA' logo in big bold letters, but without decoding that frame you can't decode the other frames). Trademarks don't expire.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> That often involves filing a few more patents 19 years later. Yes, there was prior art, but do you have deep enough pockets to go up against their lawyers to prove that? At most that means you'd need to use old versions of software. An old publicly available file can't violate a patent issued 5 years later. For the rest, Sega v. Accolade? And just putting a trademark inside the video wouldn't mean a decoder is using the trademark...