14 ms·
Knitters got knotted in a purity spiral (2020)
- solarmist 5y agoThis is a fantastic article on why we’re facing so many social issues lately. Very insightful.
- bally0241 5y ago[dead]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dang 5y agoDiscussed at the time: How knitters got knotted in a purity spiral - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22240041 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22240041 - Feb 2020 (235 comments)
- kleiba 5y agoAhhh... I just read the first paragraph. Then I took a deep breath. Exhaled. With a little smile on my face.... "Thank God, I don't live in North America."
- burnished 5y agoYou might read more of it. It appears to be discussing a human phenomena, not a regional one.
- glorygut123 5y agoUnfortunately you'll find these issues across Oceania and Europe as well. Germany just appointed their first anti-racism commissioner in the last election.
- 0des 5y agoGermany of today is a byproduct of post-war Germany.
- akimball 5y agoWhat is the primary product?
- r00fus 5y agoTop 3 are Cars, Auto parts, and Pharma [1]. No, I'm not jesting. [1] https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/top-30-export-products-of-germany.html https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/top-30-export-products-o...
- Doxin 5y agoThe primary product of a war tends to be great big heaping piles of dead people.
- jasonlotito 5y agoI can assure you this is 1) not limited to knitters and 2) not limited to North Americans.
- 0des 5y agoMontreal Quebec is looking très nerveux right now
- indy 5y agoUnfortunately, North American culture has a habit of spreading throughout the world.
- 0des 5y agoWhy unfortunately? If it spread, that meant people liked and sought to emulate it.
- Tade0 5y agoThat's a very optimistic take. American culture really caught on only during world war II, when people around the world experienced first hand the sheer wealth of American soliders. It works in the context of being a wealthy superpower with access to almost limitless energy sources(mainly oil), but attempts at emulating it outside of this context look silly. Case in point: new housing in my corner of the world is in large part sprawl. People flock to it, because they crave the same amazing amount of living space Americans usually enjoy. Problem is, as a percentage of wages, fuel is easily at least four times as expensive around here. Also cities aren't nearly as car-oriented as in the US.
- car_analogy 5y agoOr because it was heavily marketed by Hollywood and American entertainment. Which I am sure you will claim are only popular because they're just that much better than local entertainment, and that this has nothing to do with how local entertainment has only locals to fund it, while American media is effectively globally funded.
- hef19898 5y agoFourtunately, that seems to be less and less the case. Ehich just makes those issues, e.g. morality in Instagram knitting, all the more obvious.
- duxup 5y agoOh I'd be careful. It's a humanity thing ... not a region. History is full of "oh those people over there do that thing, how silly" and then it happens in their own backyard. We're all human.
- xbar 5y agoThis. I can identify a variety of purity spirals in non-North American cultures. It does seem, however, that US-based social media companies set up systems that foster and fuel them, like warm a Gulf of Mexico (am I a racist for using that name?) makes hurricanes (not an intentionally racist suggestion). Here is a question I don't know the answer to: are purity spirals common/problematic on WeChat?
- skrbjc 5y agoFrom the article: "As the summer dragged on, the Nordic wool bible Laine magazine was forced to apologise for having too many white faces on their pricey knitting retreat. The auto-cannibalisation doomsday clock had gone so far that now even the instigators were having their privilege severely checked. Ysolda Teague, a Scot who had been one of the leading social justice knitters, published a lengthy apology on Instagram" I don't know where you live, but clearly what the article was discussing went beyond North America.
- blibble 5y agothe floyd tragedy triggered a lot of anti-police protests in western Europe, where police brutality is thankfully rare
- anm89 5y agoThese problems are certainly not limited to North America. Where do you live that isn't dealing with any of these problems?
- Ambolia 5y agoI think it's probably more about job programs and power grabs than about culture. This type of cultural battles let some type of people with some types of university degrees to insert themselves as middle-managers in spaces that before were managed in more organic manners. And their ultimate goal is to maximize their power, not to keep any healthy environment in those spaces.
- Taywee 5y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22240041 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22240041
- fatbird 5y agoI frequently see articles like this discussing these community explosions as self-evidently harmful patterns of behaviour. I've never seen an article like this as a discussion of a certain amount of necessary pain, confusion, and difficulty while things get worked out. It seems obvious to me that untangling systemic problems and their legacies will always involve some clashing. Sooner started, sooner done.
- Ambolia 5y agoIf you run an anti-harassment office and you get rid of harassment, you are out of a job and out of power. If you keep finding more and more harassment, you are set for life. Plus if you try to tone it down there's 50 juniors behind you with dubious degrees that will gladly denounce you for being too old fashioned and take your juicy position for themselves. I don't think getting more middle-managers will ever get this issues any better because it's in their interests to increase their power as much as possible, not solve anything.
- robertlagrant 5y agoThey look a lot as though they're profiting from re-entangling as much as possible. This isn't automatically equivalent to reconciliation or equality, and it often looks like the complete opposite.
- fatbird 5y agoAgreed, but these are communities of interest, without governance of any kind. There's no one to police bad behaviour, to refocus on constructive efforts, to maintain an agenda or to call timeouts when it gets overheated. Given that, what's the alternative to a messy communal brawl that hopefully doesn't destroy the community? The author of the essay speaks about the ratchet dynamics as if it's obviously to be avoided; an alternative read is that his take is descriptive of what's actually the way that these things get worked out, sometimes for the better, sometimes not.
- jimbokun 5y ago
- mkr-hn 5y agoedit: nah
- robertlagrant 5y agoHe didn't tie them together to promote a radio show. That story is the show.
- mdoms 5y agoWhat? Did you read the article? He doesn't claim this is a new phenomenon. To the contrary he uses examples from Salem 1962, Robespierre in 1794 and Maoism in the 1960's. He then concludes this it's probably a hard-wired human instinct to behave this way.
- motohagiography 5y agoAfter reading the comments in the previous thread, I thought about what has changed in the two years since. My impression is that kind of escalating purity ratchet peaked in the fall and early part of this year, or at least it hit a ratchet point where the next lift is going to be exponentially harder than the previous ones because there is real popular reaction and revolt against it. Personally I have become much less agreeable, and as a result, people in my own networks who might have participated in the ratcheting don't do it when I am around, because the purity ratcheting was essentially a way to abuse and exploit peoples agreeableness. Given it was such a tiny minority to begin with, if only a small fraction of the majority become disagreeable, it can halt the spiral of hysteria it requires. What I/many can articulate more simply now that we didn't have the words for then is that this is a very old redemption hustle, and they're offering a kind of redemption I don't need. Just because someone is uncharitable doesn't mean I have to mollify them, and demanding a denial or denunciation from me is just their way of making a conversation about themselves. It's a disease of politeness, and the reason we got here is because we forgot sometimes in this world it is appropriate and necessary to say, please, fuck off, because we are being taken advantage of by people betting very heavily that we won't.
- 0des 5y agoIt reminds me a lot in school of a bully who had oppressed almost the entire class. He started with the most proximal targets, then moved on to others where toward the end of his reign he encountered a kid who I can only assume was non-perceptive to the situation at hand who in response to be harassed at the lunch table for his fruit cup said "no, and please go away, I'm eating" and just like that, this bully whom had never encountered resistance was speechless. This kid's oblivious nature to the social situation broke the bully's brain in a form of pattern-interrupt. The bully wasn't reformed after that, he remained a bully until we parted ways years later, however the group was wiser for it, and that type of behavior had a very short half life as a result. As I get older, this phenomenon is emblematic or representative of society. Sometimes culture dictates that there are certain things we just won't accept anymore, like spousal assault, smoking in the public indoors, and poor legislation. Resistance is cumulative.
- 5y ago
- TimTheTinker 5y ago> a bidding war for morality turned into a proxy war for power. What a packed and insightful statement. I'll be turning that over in my mind for some time.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- random-human 5y agoNot only is it insightful, but one that can be actively watched play out in the US with the 50-ish years morality war turning to a war for state voting control and supreme court power to overturn Roe. Watch as states try to out do each other within their purity spiral. What was once thought to be too extreme (no exceptions clauses, even to save the life of the living breathing human in front of them or criminal charges if you save the persons life anyway) is now a required hard line to prove their "moral purity".
- TimTheTinker 5y agoI think there's a subtle distinction between morality wars on the left and the right, at least one that I can see from my own perspective. On the right, there's a coherent, objective moral value statement that voters want upheld, namely "babies are people too, beginning at conception, and must be treated as such by the law." It's pretty straightforward whether this value is being upheld, and there's no risk of a "purity spiral" where people propose increasingly crazy ideas to signal their loyalty to the cause. Just don't kill babies... that is all. On the left, unless I'm mistaken, there aren't coherent, objective moral value statements at the heart of CRT, identity politics, or pro-choice arguments ("my body, my choice" isn't a well-defined philosophical statement) which does lead to a purity spiral. For example, there have been serious proposals to allow "after birth abortion" -- i.e. it's OK to kill babies after they're born - for a recent example see [0], but there are many other examples as well. TA mentions other purity spirals that occur on the left. But regardless, yes, there are absolutely politicians on both sides of the aisle who use people's moral values as a means to power (I'm especially thinking of a recent US president, but there are many others). "You want to get rid of abortion? Vote for me!" -- but disingenuously. They don't appear to care personally about whatever it is, they posture to get power while not understanding the nuances of how to wisely implement laws that reflect the peoples' values, or even what those values are exactly in the first place. --- [0] CA AB-2223, in its original text (now amended), read "Notwithstanding any other law, a person shall not be subject to civil or criminal liability or penalty, or otherwise deprived of their rights, based on their actions or omissions with respect to their pregnancy or actual, potential, or alleged pregnancy outcome, including miscarriage, stillbirth, or abortion, or perinatal death" (emphasis mine). Note "perinatal death" means death within the first 7 days after birth (thus legalizing infanticide). This has thankfully been edited to perinatal death due to a pregnancy-related cause -- but that could still encompass scenarios like "intentional injury to the child moments before or during birth".
- hitekker 5y agoThe point about the splintering of atheism is well covered in: https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/10/30/new-atheism-the-godlessness-that-failed/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/10/30/new-atheism-the-godles... > Most movement atheists weren’t in it for the religion. They were in it for the hamartiology. Once they got the message that the culture-at-large had settled on a different, better hamartiology, there was no psychological impediment to switching over. We woke up one morning and the atheist bloggers had all quietly became social justice bloggers. Nothing else had changed because nothing else had to; the underlying itch being scratched was the same. They just had to CTRL+F and replace a couple of keywords.
- gregorty 5y agoThat's interesting to know, I was browsing RationalWiki the other day, for the first time in many years, and was surprised by how irrational it is. This would appear to explain it.
- agentwiggles 5y agoThanks for this link. I was hugely into atheist discourse during this time period (about 2008-2012) and it was fun to read through Scott's thoughts on the decline.
- a_t48 5y agoIsn't the real problem the whole dogpiling issue and not the actual viewpoints themselves? At the root of the spiral, the suggestion wasn't so bad ("Hey, that's a bit insensitive, you should consider your language"), but it didn't need to be repeated to her hundreds of times by the all of twitter, et al. Most people with any viewpoint are going to react negatively to hundreds or thousands of people telling them they are in the wrong. Unfortunately while it's reasonable for each individual feeling this way to comment, the effect is much larger than I would bet any of the commenters intended. It would be interesting to track down some of the first commenters and ask them how many people telling the woman she was in the wrong there should be - maybe I'm wrong and they believe it should be "as many as possible". Regardless, sometimes the internet is way too connected.
- rossdavidh 5y agoI have the vague sense that this is a "scaling problem", similar to how a software architecture that works just fine with 1,000 users will break down at 1,000,000. The mechanism for accepting input is not ready for so much, and it becomes a DDOS of sorts.
- Karrot_Kream 5y agoThis is "context collapse", where what was once a private thought is posted as or responded to as a public one, because the platform doesn't make the distinction. It's one of the big problems with social media. Outside of social media, we act differently in professional or public contexts from private ones. Context collapse merges them to great detriment.
- escapedmoose 5y agoAbsolutely. In a more private setting, the reminder could be received with much more grace.
- jrm4 5y agoYup. Especially when (as it happens in these spaces) the loud people aren't the actual subjects of discussion, so you get this weird lack of skin-in-the-game. I cannot emphasize enough the harm that can come from this and how easily it is exploited.
- gotaquestion 5y agoThe entire article is based on online group dynamics over people trying to figure out how to come to grips with historically ignored problems. I fail to feel outraged by this process. Is "White Fragility" without criticism? Probably not, I think it is a fantastic book, but it scares the bejeebers out of some people and we get instagram drama and articles like this which I interpret as another attempt at purity (trying to outsmart "wokeness"). It is going to take a while for society* to come to grips with this new shift, because we're clearly not going back, but it definitely is rough around the edges, IMHO, because we haven't found the right vocabulary and framing. Unfortunately it is going to require people to sit with feeling uneasy, and that is something most people cannot tolerate.
- splitstud 5y agoControlling thought by controlling speech is nothing new, and it IS a historically ignored problem
- itronitron 5y ago>> people trying to figure out how to come to grips with historically ignored problems I very much agree that many people have limited knowledge of the history of the last six hundred years, but I believe that sharing the cold hard facts from history (that aren't taught in schools) has a better chance at opening up a person's viewpoint rather than criticizing their behavior.
- jimbokun 5y ago> Unfortunately it is going to require people to sit with feeling uneasy People throw around this phrase, but it always strikes me as nonsensical. There's a lot of stupid opinions that can make people feel uneasy, so unease is not some magic barometer of truth. People are going to feel really uneasy if they are listening to you defend your appreciation of child pornography, but that doesn't mean you have struck upon some deep uncomfortable truth.
- gotaquestion 5y ago
- unwind 5y agoUh that sounded quite interesting, but it seems to bury the lede from the title and go off on side-tracks right away. Didn't finish it because I got ultra-distracted by the inline recommendations of ... the same article. It lists: - BY THE SAME AUTHOR "How knitters got knotted in a purity spiral" BY GAVIN HAYNES - SUGGESTED READING "How knitters got knotted in a purity spiral" BY GARETH ROBERTS - SUGGESTED READING "How knitters got knotted in a purity spiral" BY DOUGLAS MURRAY - SUGGESTED READING "How knitters got knotted in a purity spiral" BY ANTONIA SENIOR - SUGGESTED READING "How knitters got knotted in a purity spiral" BY TITANIA MCGRATH - SUGGESTED READING "How knitters got knotted in a purity spiral" BY GILES FRASER I can't even begin to guess how stuff like that happens, must be some epic bug in their CMS, or some weird A/B attempt to ... fool people into reading the same article many times? And where does it get the author names, one wonders. AI-backed publishing system gone crayzay?
- bio_end_io_t 5y agoFor what it's worth, clicking on any of those links brings you back to the one by Gavin Haynes.
- Traster 5y agoThis is probably just a for loop where they've called for(it in suggestions) print(title) rather than for(it in suggestions) print(it.title).
- Aloha 5y agoThe other content on the site is somewhat specious as well.
- at_a_remove 5y agoI have been watching, with a mixture of sadness and schadenfreude, an online community disintegrate in just this manner, since right around the New Aetheism split. Boiling the frog is the name of the game. It plays out so predictably, too. First, they -- we -- came for the fundamentalist conservatives, but I was not ... Then it was the fiscal conservatives, then the moderates, the liberal guys who didn't manage to seem vaguely embarrassed to be heterosexual, and so on. They all get together and "discuss" things until someone (or more than just one) leaves the site. Throw in a unhealthy dose of "dogwhistle" paranoia and "everyone who disagrees with me is a goosestepping fascist buying Nazi memorabilia on the darkweb" disdain and, well, it's amazing to watch.
- bambataa 5y agoI have a theory that many of these ludicrous spirals are caused by self-proclaimed “allies” taking on the mantle of others’ oppression and calling out behaviour that is actually fine. The original blog post behind this case (where the woman wrote about how foreign India seemed but how excited she was to visit) is a perfect example. The people calling out her “colonialist” references to Mars claim to be speaking on behalf of their friends. Then you have actual Indian people coming along later, wondering what the fuss was about and welcoming the author to India. My theory probably doesn’t stand up to any scrutiny but it useful to ask “is anywhere here actually saying that they’re personally offended?”.
- RangerScience 5y agoI notice a big difference between how social workers and social "warriors" talk. So far, universally, the people "on the ground", doing the work, are very nice to talk to. Informative, understanding, firm, kind.
- dmurray 5y agoSocial workers help people based on their need. Social warriors help people based on their identity. It's not surprising the two work in different ways.
- majormajor 5y agoI thought the definition of a "warrior" here was that they didn't help people at all, they just screamed on Twitter. (AKA isn't Twitter itself a huge part of the problem?)
- swearwolf 5y agoThere’s a lot of discourse going around these days about white people. Not much of it is positive. It’s understandable; just about every person of color has at least one story in which a white person made them feel terrible because of their race, whether intentionally or not. There’s a lot of pent up anger, and it’s socially acceptable to vent that anger now, so people do. As a result, there are a lot of well meaning white people who are receiving the message that they, and people who look like them, are making the lives of people of color hard. Some people react to that by getting angry, others react by looking for opportunities to prove they aren’t that kind of white person. When they see an interaction like this one, they feel compelled to act, and they do. Sometimes way out of proportion to the inciting incident. Other well meaning and anxious people react positively to the callout, which reinforces the perception that this is the right thing to do. The person who committed the offense often tries to clarify their position, which presents more opportunities to call them out. In situations like this, even apologies are often criticized. Each time this process unfolds, the line of acceptable behavior creeps ever backwards, and increasingly benign actions and statements end up on the other side of it.
- themaninthedark 5y agoI can't recall when but I read an article(or post) about how the focus of the knitting community was shifting to social justice, much to the dismay of some of the participants as all they cared about was knitting. Some of the comments at the time seemed to think the only way to save the community would be to reject the values being force onto the community, it looks like that did not happen. I don't think that rejection is necessity for a community to survive but there needs to be a way that they can recenter. If the community is supposed to be about knitting, than discussions about race, sex, etc should not occur. Perhaps is is enough to identify as a knitter, as opposed to a bisexual knitter from SE Asia. All the other stuff is noise in the SNR.
- twofornone 5y ago
- bglazer 5y agoYou’re just arguing that dominant groups should never face criticism or contend with outside perspectives? Also, if an outside group wants to participate in an activity then they should do it separately?
- twofornone 5y agoNo, not even remotely what I'm saying. People of all cultures are free to work/play wherever they want; but the onus is on them to partly or fully assimilate. Especially if they're joining a functioning team. The issue is this moral imperative to force team cultures to bend over backward at the whims of the new member. It is entitled and hypocritical, because the "straight white male" teams/groups/corporations are subject to encroachment while all other groups are allowed exclusive safe spaces where they are allowed to fully dictate cultural norms. This social trajectory is not sustainable, and is overtly, explicitly systemically racist/sexist.
- bglazer 5y agoSo what you’re saying is that minority groups must accede to the demands of the majority without question or criticism?
- twofornone 5y agoNo, I'm saying that there is a limit to the degree of accomodation they should expect from groups that they join, and have no right to demand special treatment and cultural change. But in the modern West this freedom only applies to female and/or minority groups. The "majority" is not allowed to maintain or practice it's culture. It's a bigoted double standard.
- random314 5y ago
- bally0241 5y ago
- Blackthorn 5y agoThat's...a pretty strange way of putting what happened to the new atheism movement. To the extent that I'm not sure how much I can trust their version of events in the knitting world.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- digisign 5y agoWhen I read about these folks I can't help think about the Star Trek TNG episode, The Drumhead. Admiral goes mental trying to root out traitors. Recommended. https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/The_Drumhead_(episode) https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/The_Drumhead_(episode)
- daniel-cussen 5y ago
- hallelujah 5y agoTempleOS has returned! Praise the Lord!
- daniel-cussen 5y agoI know you're making fun of me, and trying to humiliate me, but I actually read up on that and will say your post has merit despite "your" bad intentions. Terry Davis acted in good faith. And it compiles. What more do you want? Yeah the racism and bigotry, yeah. Am I supposed to disqualify him out of hand? What he went through? You know, he worshipped GOD with everything he had, everything he did, and apparently at some point he ran out of ability to worship and that's why he died, that's how the Wikipedia I read three days ago told it. "You" did the exact opposite, sacrilegious, that's no joke, flag your human handler, she has to read this herself. You think it's easy sticking up to torture? You think it's easy recovering blacked out memories? Takes a long time I can tell you. But in the most favorable interpretation of what "you" wrote, I agree with the following: Praise the LORD!
- Pulcinella 5y agoIn my new BBC Radio 4 documentary … There it is. It’s an advertisement for a documentary masquerading as a news article.
- llllp 5y agoJust noticed how ridiculously wrong this comment on the previous thread is: > I have to wonder how many of these morality spirals aren't instigated by actual trolls. > An example of this was the explosion of transgender issues into the mainstream soon after gay marriage was legalized. I recall reading a fringe right-wing blogger about the "lesbian vs transgender conflict", a few years before the "T" in LGBT became more prominent. This prominence may well have been engineered by trolls in an attempt to alienate a group of people who were rapidly being accepted into mainstream society. Funny how this "troll" managed to somehow also coincide with the opinions of countless lesbians and radical feminists, who have been speaking and writing about this topic for many years. That is, in the above instance, in terms of homosexuality being defined as a same-sex sexual orientation, and the inherent conflict in attempting to replace it with the concept of "same gender identity" attraction. With so-called "genital preferences" being an act of bigotry. It's incredibly homophobic ideology, in that particular purity spiral.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- beloch 5y agoCanadians are used to looking South of the border with disdain, but also fear. Whatever political trends start in the U.S. have a funny way of making their to Canada after few years. The degree of political polarization now evident in the U.S. is despicable and horrifying in equal measure. Purity spirals are evident on both sides of the divide, and the worst thing you can call someone is a member of the opposing party. The extremes on both sides are anti-science, although the left has embraced some behaviours that are less contradictory to the common good purely by coincidence. e.g. Wearing masks became a political statement. While it was good that roughly half the population were wearing them willingly, turning it into political virtue signalling made it less likely for the other half of the population to wear them. The right behaviour for the wrong reasons had unintended consequences. In Canada, our political parties have long detested each other beyond reason. e.g. Read "Right Here, Right Now" by Stephen Harper (former conservative PM) and, even if you don't agree with him, you'll find he makes intelligent arguments except when it comes to the Liberals. When he speaks of his opponents it's a bit like like reading Marcus Aurelius' "Meditations" when he transitions from stoic philosophy to ranting about catamites. Logical one moment, insane the next. In a real sense, politicians are at the very centre of purity spirals even if they aren't always responsible for creating them. Consider Republicans who have caught flack from the far-right for being vaccinated or wearing masks. If you're a highly visible member of a demographic entirely consumed by a massive purity spiral, what option do you have but to conform? While it's to be expected that politicians will bend in whichever way the wind of these spirals blow, it's especially distressing to see how many people have a rigid political identity that is completely unhinged from personal values, needs, or philosophy. For example, in my province "Conservatism" used to include a healthy dose of "conservation". Four decades ago, a conservative government decided to ban strip mining in the Eastern slopes of the rocky mountains to "conserve" natural beauty. Scientific studies conducted since then have only confirmed the wisdom of this decision. Strip mining in these areas, even with today's best practices, would have had massive risks for watersheds covering huge swaths of populated areas. Today, "Conservatism" means overturning that ban without telling anyone, quietly inviting shady penny stock companies in to start strip mining explorations, getting caught, "pausing" and opposing the efforts of the non-Conservative opposition to reinstate the ban. My father is a staunch political conservative who voted for the conservatives four decades ago and now supports them just as unequivocally, despite the fact that conservatism's meaning is, in many cases, the polar opposite of what it used to be. Politics as personal identity is the root of purity spirals at the same time as it is a cause for people to support policies that are contrary to their ideals and needs. We need to encourage people to stop being loyal to "their side", and start supporting things they value. How do we do this?
- photochemsyn 5y agoI basically eliminated almost all interaction with social media some months ago ... and all this woke conflict stuff, it just goes away. You start noticing other things - people in general are not concerned about any of it, they're more concerned about the high prices and potential inflation spikes. They're concerned about jobs and quality of life and environmental uncertainties like drought. Many people's fears and hopes revolve around whether their kids will get a good education and have a secure future. I can't help thinking the whole woke thing has been some kind of manufactured media project, maybe with overtones of state propaganda, which had the overall goal of drawing attention away from the fundamental failings of many once-respected American institutions - media, government, academics, etc. I wouldn't be surprised if it was all purposely designed as some kind of divide-and-conquer tactic, something to distract the American public and draw attention away from ever-more-obvious gross failures of our incompetent leaders, which are across-the-board in nature and not exclusively linked to any political party. If this is a correct assessment, then you'd expect the typical 'accepted topics' of mass American political conflict - i.e. guns & abortion - to start taking center stage now, because they don't want people howling for 'better wages and less inflation' or screaming 'fix the damn infrastructure, you incompetent clowns' outside their windows.
- majormajor 5y agoIsn't the "whole woke thing" the group that's been most critical of American institutions? The police, the courts (re: rolling back voting rights regulation and laws), acceptance and hiring criterias at respected schools/universities/employers? If one wanted to come up with a propaganda project to hide decline they picked a really bad one!
- escapedmoose 5y agoI second this. Having been off of social media for two years and off of online news for one year, I’m nonetheless still amazed by people’s ability to forget that none of this “woke panic” stuff exists in the real world (certainly not where I live anyway). If you don’t seek it out, you won’t find it. Also, I think your point about it being a distraction tactic is exactly right. I remember back around the 2012-ish era, when Tumblr started getting really weird with blogs promoting some pretty insane things in the name of “social justice.” Turns out, some Russian troll farm was posing as Black activist bloggers to sow chaos. I was very active on Tumblr at the time and remember thinking how weird all those blogs felt, and when the news of the Russian campaign broke, it all made sense instantly. I get that same feeling from today’s woke/anti-woke discourse. It doesn’t feel honest. It feels like someone is playing us again.
- fortran77 5y agoYou can include more people by narrowing your focus instead of widening it. A knitting group should talk about knitting only and then more people can participate.
- gowld 5y agoThis story isn't about knitting or any other of 1000 other similar hobbies. It's about Instagram promoting toxicity for engagement. non-Influencer knitters aren't affected at all.
- elihu 5y agoTo quote from Paul Graham's essay Beating the Averages: > "As long as our hypothetical Blub programmer is looking down the power continuum, he knows he's looking down. Languages less powerful than Blub are obviously less powerful, because they're missing some feature he's used to. But when our hypothetical Blub programmer looks in the other direction, up the power continuum, he doesn't realize he's looking up. What he sees are merely weird languages. He probably considers them about equivalent in power to Blub, but with all this other hairy stuff thrown in as well. Blub is good enough for him, because he thinks in Blub." http://www.paulgraham.com/avg.html http://www.paulgraham.com/avg.html I have a theory that this applies to progressivism or moral frameworks or whatever you want to call it. Let's suppose we were to re-write the above quote to apply to morality. > "As long as our hypothetical practitioner of the Blub moral framework is looking down the moral continuum, he knows he's looking down. Moral frameworks less advanced than Blub are obviously less just, because they're missing some assumptions about people's rights and obligations that he's used to. (Don't they know that slavery is wrong? And obviously lying and stealing are right out under most circumstances.) But when our hypothetical Blub practitioner looks in the other direction, up the moral continuum, he doesn't realize he's looking up. What he sees are merely weird rules. He probably considers them about morally equivalent to Blub, but with all this other hairy stuff thrown in as well. (Intersectionality? Critical race theory? And people keep adding extra letters at the end of LGBT? Is this all a bunch of made-up nonsense, posturing, and virtue signalling?) Blub is good enough for him, because he thinks in Blub and lives in a world where Blub applies to situations that correspond to his real-life personal experience." This isn't to say that critics of complicated moral frameworks are always wrong. Sometimes people really do get caught up in virtue signalling and posturing. But I think these complicated moral frameworks are usually a reaction to real injustices, and sometimes it's worth standing up to oppose an injustice. Knowing when or how to do that can be complicated though. Moral crusades can themselves cause tribalistic behavior, exclusion, and intolerance of honestly held opinions, which can also be another kind of injustice.
- anm89 5y agoInteresting point.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoThis reads like gamergate for 20 year olds. The evil woke people are coming to ruin your knitting and Young Adult novels communities. By... asking you not to say ignorant things on a global medium about how going to India is like going to mars? And people apologizing for stuff. The horror. Like, even if what was claimed is true, who cares? There's nothing there and people seem to have adopted fighting against this non-thing as part of their identity. Does this really deserve the multiple mentions of war, the red terror, and communist China purges? Aren't we overreacting just a tad?