10 ms·
So You Wanna Be a Chef (2010)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- curiousgal 5y agoTangent but if you're looking for a good movie suggestion I recommend Boiling Point.
- phnofive 5y agoPreviously... 2010|63 comments|259 points|https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1709693 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1709693 2018|72 comments|138 points|https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18375148 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18375148
- mdp2021 5y agoGood for the comments, but the submission link in those is broken (this one is the archived WayBackMachine page).
- dang 5y agoThanks! Macroexpanded: So You Wanna Be a Chef (2010) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26012566 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26012566 - Feb 2021 (10 comments) So You Wanna Be a Chef (2010) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18375148 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18375148 - Nov 2018 (72 comments) So You Wanna Be a Chef - Anthony Bourdain - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1709693 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1709693 - Sept 2010 (63 comments)
- buggythebug 5y agoMaybe someone touched upon it on previous comments but: You want to be a business owner first - and a chef second. If you just want to be a "chef" - that's equivalent to being the head programmer at startup and not getting any equity and makes no sense.
- Tinkeringz 5y agoThis goes against Bourdain's experience per his book Kitchen Confidential. Most new businesses fail, especially in the restaurant industry, where the equity will be worth 0 (maybe even less). There will always be a constant stream of new restaurants needing a chef and will pay (cash) for their services. Change restaurants for startups and chefs for programmers.
- ethbr0 5y agoFood truck or popup / shared restaurant seems like the sweet spot for risk:reward.
- vageli 5y agoOr ghost kitchens.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoPossibly, depends on location, niche, and various other factors outside of your control like if there's going to be a pandemic that forces restaurants to close. Plus it's still a big risk in the upfront investments you need to make.
- ethbr0 5y agoThe upfront capital requirements and lock-in to choices seems more flexibly balanced with those approaches, vs a traditional "heavy" brick and mortar restaurant. Or as we say around here, better to fail small and quickly. It's unclear what benefits a high-capital restaurant would have these alternatives, that would merit the increased risk. Fancy service? Nobody cares anymore. Economies of scale? Maybe, but seems dubious. Building a brand? Useless when your landlord is fine with selling the building for conversion to residential on any given year.
- moate 5y agoLiquor, and the ability to sell it. So many places would go under if not for their ability to sell you marked up beer/cocktails. Now, depending on local it may be hard to get a liquor license (shout out New Jersey!!!) for a building and in others you may be able to sell drinks from a truck. But that's one major profit center advantage that building have over trucks.
- debarshri 5y agoThis is quite close to my heart. I have been cooking since 15. At one point in my life I wanted to be a chef, but ended up in CS and now in engineer. Last year, I saved up enough money to open a cafe in India. Soon, I realised how hard it is to be a chef. Person who is the head chef at the cafe works almost 10h a day, 7 days a week. You have to be on your toes all the life, deliver consistent food, deal with stress, deal with customers returning food, have no ego, make decisions on the stop, planning things ahead of time, foreseeing things short term and long term. Being a good home chef does not make a ready to pursue chef as a profession. It is pretty brutal. PS. This is the cafe https://www.instagram.com/maharishi_boutique_cafe/ https://www.instagram.com/maharishi_boutique_cafe/
- zikzak 5y agoI went the other way, working full time at night when I was a teenager through high school. I got out of cooking when I was in my mid-20s (mid/late-90s) because of a health issue and pursued computer science (was programming as a hobby). The pay is significantly better and I don't have to work evenings and weekends.
- Ntrails 5y agoI failed school (personal/motivation reasons) and went into Kitchens full time as it was the only skill I had. Working 50+ hours a week for borderline minimum wage as a salaried employee is hard. Knowing that next week will be exactly the same, and the week after and the week after is just kinda bleak. I eventually chucked it in, went back to uni via an access course / foundation year (so greatful that it existed) and graduated with a good degree and started a career as a grad where my salary was over twice what I earned as a chef without even approaching the same level of hard graft. It's an interesting perspective to have, and unusual amongst my peers.
- gernb 5y ago> nowing that next week will be exactly the same, and the week after and the week after is just kinda bleak. Sounds like software engineering job. It just happens to pay better
- eps 5y agoA good sub to go with this is https://old.reddit.com/r/KitchenConfidential https://old.reddit.com/r/KitchenConfidential. Highly recommended if you have an interest in professional cooking and restaurant business.
- troelsSteegin 5y agoI wonder what a correspondence between Anthony Bourdain and David Foster Wallace would have been like. My impression is that they were pulling water from the same well.
- ransom1538 5y agoI lived in SF for 15 years and would talk to many of the restaurateurs there. What I hear almost all of them say: "I should have never opened a restaurant - I should have just opened a bar." Every. Time. Apparently the margins on food in restaurants is close to zero. However, any money they manage to make is from alcohol sales. So - eventually they realize - just sell alcohol.
- caoilte 5y agoThe other side of this coin (as the maxim goes) is that the margin on drinks in bars is close to zero and that the only way they make any money is by selling food.
- bogomipz 5y agoThis is completely false. The standard measurement bars use is called the "pour cost" which is inventory usage(in cost) divided by sales. The pour cost average for a bar is between 18-20%. That's a gross margin of 80 to 82 cents on each dollar a customer spends on drinks. That's a pretty spectacular margin. A well-run bar on a busy night is practically printing cash.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- moate 5y agoAs someone who spent a LOT of time working in/running professional kitchens in the US (NJ specifically) I would just like to say: CITATION NEEDED
- asdff 5y agoA bud light at a bar is like $12 now at most bars. The case at the gas station across the street is $18. The splash of coke in the $10 well drink that begins with a cup scooped full of nearly free ice must have been about five cents of syrup and one cent of CO2, the pour probably came out of a bottle that costs like $15. Maybe that maxim was true back in the day when people could actually afford to get drunk at bars, but not anymore.
- the__alchemist 5y agoFrom the article and every other bit of info I hear, working as a chef sounds like a terrible career by most metrics: low pay/benefits, long hours, high stress, low job security.
- savanaly 5y agoThere's a deep love for cooking in many people, raising the de facto salary of being a chef. For the most devoted it raises it astronomically high. So competition drives down prices in the only way it can-- nominally and through intangibles like negative perks and job security. You can see at jobs where it's the opposite those same things are through the roof.
- gernb 5y agoI agree with this. There was an NPR piece https://www.npr.org/transcripts/15732097 https://www.npr.org/transcripts/15732097 Where a girl goes to Paris to learn to cook thinking it will be glamorous like the movie Sabrina and instead it's like military drilling to be efficient but even with all of that she says feeding people makes you feel like a god. I think the concept is similar for software engineering. Not feeling like a god but some people think "how could you possibly stare at a computer screen for so many hours a day. Sounds mind numbingly boring" where as to some software engineers it's the most creatively freeing environment there is and they thrive in it.
- elorant 5y agoMy dad used to work as a maitre at a five star hotel/restaurant some decades ago. Payment was excellent, but everything else was crap. I always remember him coming home beat from exhaustion. You spend too many hours standing up, the environment is always under pressure because everyone needs to be served in a limited time frame, you have to organize a myriad of people who are also overworked and exhausted, and on top of everything the kitchen per se is a very hostile place because you can really hurt yourself if you’re careless.
- gernb 5y ago
- mattzito 5y agoI grew up in a restaurant family, and it's a rough business. Long hours, often seasonal revenue swings, subject to forces outside your control, etc. Sadly, many of the things that make your life easier or increase your revenue often decrease the quality of the restaurant. Buying pre-chopped cole slaw saves time and effort, but it's never as good as what you chop yourself. Making your own stock is 10x better than buying stock, but it requires bones and time and labor to make it happen. This is why the most successful restauranteurs tend to be some combination of perfectionists, savvy marketers, and wealthy. There tends to be a streak of ADHD too, where they thrive on being constantly in motion and moving from problem to problem - certainly I've seen that over and over again in restaurant kitchens and offices.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoIt's a tradeoff between quality/time spent/money invested and sales volume, isn't it? e.g. do 10x a $100 meal, or 100x a $10 meal.
- wackget 5y agoTBH if I was doing any kind of significant volume the first thing I'd invest in would be a Robot Coupe prep machine: https://youtu.be/2dVAAc1ad5U?t=19 https://youtu.be/2dVAAc1ad5U?t=19 Coleslaw would go from 20 minutes to 2 minutes.
- kinghtown 5y agoyou’re forgetting time for cleanup, assembly, put everything back, move shit out of the way, precut veg into pieces which fit in the machine.. etc etc. Specialized equipment in a kitchen is all about the time trade offs.
- KevinGlass 5y agoRobocoupes are easy to clean and setup and take up little space when not in use. An amateur making coleslaw (or whatever) can process 10x the amount of produce then an average pro chef with a knife and cutting board. Yes, some gadgets are not worth the hassle but there is a reason these are in near every professional kitchen.
- floppydiskette 5y agoI got a culinary degree after high school and worked for a chef for nearly a decade before I changed careers to CS. I actually read Bourdain’s book while I was in school and he described life in the restaurant industry, and it just fueled my desire to do it more. I wanted to prove myself, I think. I have a lot to say about those days vs. now, but I can’t emphasize enough how much I love my job as a software engineer. I’ve been doing it now for as long as I was a chef, and it’s better in every single way (for me) and going through those years has given me so much perspective and so many more ways to appreciate what I have now. I’m just so happy.
- moate 5y ago"I’m not telling you that culinary school is a bad thing. It surely is not. I’m saying that you, reading this, right now, would probably be ill-advised to attend—and are, in all likelihood, unsuited for The Life in any case. Particularly if you’re any kind of normal." This is the most important quote in the whole piece. Restaurant Life is a thing people outside of it DO NOT understand fully. Most well meaning, normal people are not compatible with it. Do you do recreational drugs? Are you an alcoholic? Do you have a criminal record? Are you in the country illegally? If no, how are you going to deal with the fact that 75% of your coworkers meet one if not all of those criteria? How are you going to deal with the intense pressure? How are you going to make your rent, because if you want to do this in a major US metro at this point, you're going to have a hard time affording housing. How will you adapt to your new role when, inevitably, someone rage quits during their shift and you get field promoted to running their station? I've been out of the industry for 6+ years at this point, and when I get super stressed out at my current tech job, I dream about running a restaurant. That's not to say that I want to go back, but that my mind inherently links "you are stressed out" to "you are the chef of a 2 million/year restaurant". I have never had a stress dream that involved a computer, to the best of my recollection.
- floppydiskette 5y agoI have stress dreams about working in a restaurant all the time! It’s insane. I haven’t worked the line in almost 10 years at this point, yet I still have nightmares that the tickets are overflowing. > Do you do recreational drugs? Are you an alcoholic? Do you have a criminal record? Are you in the country illegally? If no, how are you going to deal with the fact that 75% of your coworkers meet one if not all of those criteria? This resonates so much. I was never able to connect in any long term sense with my coworkers due to these reasons. Not getting drunk or doing other drugs after my shift meant that I wasn’t bonding with my coworkers.
- lordleft 5y agoI can listen to -- or rather read -- Bourdain's takes on literally any topic (especially his expertise, the restaurant industry).
- jpgvm 5y agoSeeing Bourdain pop up always hits the feels. His show inspired me to pick up my shit and travel the world to experience food culture. As someone that also struggles with chronic depression his passing was also a wake-up call to start doing something about my own problems. RIP mate, miss you all the time.
- eschneider 5y agoThe lessons of this article are also frighteningly true for software...
- bern4444 5y agohow so? Software is significantly easier physically, you can sit the entire time. The hours are far more reasonable, often <8 hours a day. Unless you work in a very early stage startup, the pressure is relatively low. It is very easy to switch jobs today and move around. There is very little in this article that is true for software imo.
- enahs-sf 5y agoThe part that resonated with me is the ageism and general suspicion (by your potentially younger boss) of those with families and responsibilities. Startups tend to expect you to put everything you have into work, but for some folks that's just not possible.
- nbaugh1 5y agoYeah, I'm 2 years into my new career as a software engineer after 20 years of working in restaurants and couldn't be happier, for pretty much all of the reasons explained in this piece. I can say will 100% absolute certainty that I do not want to be a chef. People love the idea of these types of jobs, but half of them wouldn't last a month doing the actual work and the other half wouldn't put up with the lack of income
- kinghtown 5y agoI’ve worked in the kitchen, not as long as you!, and yeah it’s not easy. Most obnoxious part is service staff tend to make more money.
- technothrasher 5y agoI was curious what it might be like to run a restaurant, so as a limited experiment just to get a small piece of the feel of it I tried running a little private ‘restaurant’ for a night. I spent about a month creating a menu of three courses each with three choices of dish, then invited three couples over, bought a ton of food and supplies, set up tables and lighting out by my pool, enlisted my wife to be the waitress, and waited for the guests to arrive. Holy heck was it way more work and stress than I had expected. It was a lot of fun, and I think I pulled it off reasonably well, but I can’t imagine cleaning up from the evening and then starting again the next night, let alone managing multiple meal times in one day, having more diners, or a larger menu… and then trying to make money at it. Gave me a lot of respect for folks who run restaurants.
- gernb 5y agoIt's certainly very hard but it also is certainly easier than doing it once. You had to buy supplies for 1 meal instead of supplies for say 10 (so 10x the work). You had to setup tables (those would already be setup in a restuarant). Much of the stuff you did it was probably your first time so you were likely both not used to it and inefficent. But still, running a restaurant seems like super hard work and it really makes me appreciate people who choose to do it.
- technothrasher 5y agoYou make a good point that inefficiency due to inexperience likely increased the workload. Although a lot of the stress only came after the guests arrived, as suddenly everything had to be timed correctly and the guests seemed to be doing everything they could to screw up my predetermined plans. I don't think they really were, it just felt that way. When main course orders came in and I had more orders than people, I had to ask my server what was up. Somebody ordered the beef but with a side of the pasta, and I had to suddenly figure out how to plate that to look good as I'd only worked on plating the dishes the way I had planned on. Stuff like that kept happening through the whole meal. To your point again, experience would have helped, but thinking on your feet is clearly a big part of the deal.
- AlbertCory 5y agoPersonal experience: I'm related to a youngish (now) executive chef, who works for a very large food service company that runs cafeterias for companies. I've driven with him down to his place of employment on an off-day, so he could take a load of chicken out of the freezer. His job is mostly managing the young, fit people that Bourdain describes, and sticking to his budget. He went to a not-top-tier cooking school, and then worked in some respected but not top-tier restaurants. Now he's at the Big Company, where you don't have late nights and you don't have weekends (except as noted). It's mostly a day job. Or so it seems. He was thinking of opening a pizza restaurant, and I mentioned the unending nature of it, and he said, "well, I'm doing that now." So maybe it's not as regular as it seems. This isn't exactly idyllic, or typical, but it's not as hellish as Bourdain makes it seem.
- Mikeb85 5y agoAs someone who's been a cook/chef (still am, ish) in some legit good restaurants (including a world's 100 best spot), plus done business school (finance/economics), some consulting, been self-employed and so on, being a chef is a very mixed bag. It can be everything Bourdain describes and worse. Or it can be a lucrative career (does require you to have ownership however) with pleasant working conditions. I will admit though, more restaurants are the former since most restaurateurs aren't very business savvy not educated. There's a reason most restaurants fail while a few can have many outlets and grow to billion dollar companies. Most restaurants languish at 1-3% margins (the actual average is 3 I think) while some do 20% easily. It's a good business to be in, however you need a strong business model, good execution and very good people skills.