4 ms·
Recycling is more of a dream than reality. Lets never forget that recycling economics usually never add up.
by ekianjo 5y ago
Recycling is more of a dream than reality. Lets never forget that recycling economics usually never add up.
- epistasis 5y agoThat's a pretty strange statement. Lead acid batteries have near 100% recycling. If lithium prices stay high, recycling is a great source of materials. All it takes is a small amount of policy if we want to have recycling be standard practice. And there are already a ton of lithium battery recycling startups, but there's so few old batteries that they are pretty much limited to recycling batteries that fail QC.
- SECProto 5y agorecycling economics is largely a product of material value, homogeneity, and technical feasibility. Look at some classic examples: Steel: high value, reasonably homogeneous, easier than raw ore --> almost all get recycled. Paper: low value, moderately homogenous (different fibre lengths can't easily be separated), quite feasible but results in lower quality of material than inputs. Plastic: low value, very heterogenous, complex organic chemistry means significant manual segregating of inputs is needed making financials not work. Lithium: Very high value, reasonably homogeneous, technical details not fully worked out but I expect low difficulty - no complex long chain organic compounds to worry about maintaining.
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agoThe hard part of recycling lithium will be doing it reliably in safe and low labor. It's totally possible, and possible to do profitably, but it will just be really complicated to do it cheaply and reliably.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoHigh labor costs for recycling are almost entirely due to heterogeneity. In the future, car batteries will be quite homogeneous. Currently Lithium isn't recycled because there's not much of it in a battery, and it used to be cheap. Nickel was what was driving the economics AFAICT. Today's high Lithium price is changing that.
- SECProto 5y agoLooking at it another way, the value of plastic and wood/paper comes from the molecular structures. The value of steel, aluminum, lead (from lead acid batteries), and in future lithium/nickle/cobalt (from LiIon batteries) comes from the raw elements. The latter tend to be economically recyclable, the former do not.
- imtringued 5y agoYou don't seem to be aware of how difficult it is to extract "virgin" lithium. Plastic recycling doesn't add up because a lot of plastic feedstock is a byproduct of petroleum refining. Turning mixed plastic back into feedstock is not viable because there are cheaper sources of feedstock. So the only way you can recycle plastic is by separating it which means "game over" because that is a difficult problem. It's better to just return the plastic back into the soil and let geological processes compress it into coal or oil over thousands or millions of years.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoPlastic recycling, yes. Plastic is nearly impossible to recycle because it degrades so much in use (and it's usually attached to other things, contaminated by food, etc.) The vast majority of iron and steel has a very high recycled material percentage. This is a problem for applications where low radioactivity is a requirement, as almost all iron and steel around the world is now contaminated with fallout from decades of atomic testing. Copper, heavily recycled because of its high value. Aluminum also has high recycling because of the immense energy needed to smelt it out of its ore. There are at least two companies providing near 95% recovery of materials from lithium ion batteries. With prices low, there wasn't much economic incentive. Now there's massive economic incentive.