5 ms·
An electric car uses 5 - 30 kg of Lithium, which can be recycled. A gas car uses 25 tons of gasoline, which can't.
by bryanlarsen 5y ago
An electric car uses 5 - 30 kg of Lithium, which can be recycled. A gas car uses 25 tons of gasoline, which can't.
- tonymet 5y agoyou’re comparing the fuel to the tank . how much fuel is spent to put energy into the lithium ?
- bryanlarsen 5y agoI'm heading off the criticism that electric cars aren't green because of resource mining. But compared to gas cars... And to answer your question: none. New electricity generation capacity in the States is expected to be carbon negative over the next two years because of retiring coal. We're adding mostly renewables, but some NatGas too. However, the duty cycles of NatGas generators are expected to decline as they switch to a peaking role as renewables cover base energy.
- ekianjo 5y agonatgas is not carbon free so not sure where you get to carbon negative in 2 years
- bryanlarsen 5y agoAccording to projections, we'll have more natgas capacity, but the plants will be running less often because they're only supplementing renewables rather than providing base power. By carbon negative I just mean that generation will emit less carbon two years from now despite generating more power.
- morsch 5y agoThat still doesn't mean no resources are spent producing the electricity that powers your electric car. (Which is what you claimed: "And to answer your question: none.") Just fewer resources than would have been required it electricity production had been as carbon intensive as today.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoEvery time I hear new "country/state X achieved Y% of renewable power generation for Z hours", it's usually during warmish sunny weekeds (usually sundays) with relatively low power use and high sun and wind generation. If we switch eg. 30% of the current cars to electric, and most people charge them in the evenings/during the night, the math for renewables is a lot different, and without building nuclear, totally unsustainable.
- adrianN 5y agoYou'd have to build a lot more wind turbines while you switch cars to electric, and/or invest in some grid scale storage.
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agoyes. And?
- adrianN 5y agoThe math doesn't change at all, you just need to build things so that supply keeps up with demand. It's not rocket science.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoPlease show that math. There's no math that can justify capital costs of $20B and a 20 year delay for 1.5 GW of capacity. Especially since wind power is stronger at night than during the day, and it's trivial to tell electric cars to charge when it's cheapest to do so.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoReduce corruption maybe? In slovenia (back then yugoslavia), in the 1970/80s with all the communist bullshit and bureaucracy we built one in 6-7 years, and it still works.
- 5y ago
- imtringued 5y agoIt's just a matter of time until the energy put into oil extraction exceeds the energy gained and must be "subsidized" through nuclear power and renewables.
- chrisco255 5y agoImportant to note that the lithium does not provide energy, it merely stores it. A lithium battery is equivalent to a gas tank, not to gas itself.
- epistasis 5y agoExactly, it's such a massive improvement over oil pumping infrastructure, which requires absolutely massive and complex and expensive logistics to move around all that physical material. Pushing electrons is superior in pretty much every way. This weekend had to take the gasoline car for the first time in a long time, and along the way I had to stop and get gas. After months of always having a full charge from the comfort of home, pulling off the freeway to fill up and deal with all that messy infrastructure felt incredibly primitive. Ideally I could live my life with only occasionally driving in a year. Second best will be switching to full electric. Gas cars and gas infrastructure can not die fast enough. It's like steam engines or horses.
- chrisco255 5y agoYou do realize how much of the world's energy is produced by fossil fuels / chemical energy, right? The electrons don't materialize out of thin air. The energy still has to come from somewhere. And if the world's gas-powered auto fleet were to switch to electric overnight, we'd have blackouts for decades because we do not have the raw power generation capability to make up for that much energy deficit. Nevermind the massive amount of lithium and cobalt mining necessary to do so. That just gets us to square zero. You also need to build nuclear power plants, massively, in order to make up for it. But we're led by complete idiots who didn't see this coming 6 months or 6 years ago. I gotta tell you, I travel 50K+ miles a year, and stopping every two hours for 30 minutes to fill up my car would be a primitive nightmare not much better than riding a horse. I also cannot envision an emergency infrastructure built on electric in its current form. What are you going to do, run ambulances and fire trucks on electric, when the power grid goes out during a natural disaster and people need help the most? At any rate, I'm actually pro-electric hybrids. I think hybrids make the most sense of any tech I can imagine, but no one seems to really want to invest in the concept. My roommate had a Volt for a while and it seemed to be the best of both worlds (charging for inner city transport, with gas as a backup for longer distance travel). Until batteries get probably about 2-3 times more dense in storage capacity, there's no way they can supplant gas cars and diesel powered semi trucks. And we should still be massively expanding nuclear power supply, 10 years ago.
- thereisnospork 5y agoImagine how cheap cars would be if they only needed 1 kg of gold. Mass is not predictor of cost across materials.
- jeffbee 5y agoGold is 3 orders of magnitude more expensive than lithium so this seems like a somewhat useless analogy.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoLet's phrase it a different way then. A typical car used to use about $30,000 of gas and $50 of Lithium. Gas prices have doubled and Lithium has gone up 10X.
- ekianjo 5y agoRecycling is more of a dream than reality. Lets never forget that recycling economics usually never add up.
- epistasis 5y agoThat's a pretty strange statement. Lead acid batteries have near 100% recycling. If lithium prices stay high, recycling is a great source of materials. All it takes is a small amount of policy if we want to have recycling be standard practice. And there are already a ton of lithium battery recycling startups, but there's so few old batteries that they are pretty much limited to recycling batteries that fail QC.
- SECProto 5y agorecycling economics is largely a product of material value, homogeneity, and technical feasibility. Look at some classic examples: Steel: high value, reasonably homogeneous, easier than raw ore --> almost all get recycled. Paper: low value, moderately homogenous (different fibre lengths can't easily be separated), quite feasible but results in lower quality of material than inputs. Plastic: low value, very heterogenous, complex organic chemistry means significant manual segregating of inputs is needed making financials not work. Lithium: Very high value, reasonably homogeneous, technical details not fully worked out but I expect low difficulty - no complex long chain organic compounds to worry about maintaining.
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agoThe hard part of recycling lithium will be doing it reliably in safe and low labor. It's totally possible, and possible to do profitably, but it will just be really complicated to do it cheaply and reliably.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoHigh labor costs for recycling are almost entirely due to heterogeneity. In the future, car batteries will be quite homogeneous. Currently Lithium isn't recycled because there's not much of it in a battery, and it used to be cheap. Nickel was what was driving the economics AFAICT. Today's high Lithium price is changing that.