3 ms·
At a certain point should projects like this be investigated by some authority? $450m is not far from double GTA V’s budget. 10 years is 3x as long. Something
by MBCook 5y ago
At a certain point should projects like this be investigated by some authority?
$450m is not far from double GTA V’s budget. 10 years is 3x as long. Something just doesn’t seem right here.
I’m not saying they’ve made nothing. But have they made reasonable progress given the scope, timeframe, and budget? It doesn’t seem like it.
- alar44 5y agoThat's what I'm thinking. If this is legal, I'm going to hire an artist and an animator and just have them make press releases and eat people's money.
- vinyl7 5y agoThat's pretty much what a lot of kickstarter indie games are.
- iancmceachern 5y agoThat's pretty much what a lot of startups are.
- acomjean 5y agoI’m not sure how they’ve structured the game sales and add ons (ship sales). Over charging people isn’t illegal..it’s a shame though. But if at some point enough people start asking their credit card companies for charge backs, this won’t go on too much longer. Though I suspect the higher ups have paid themselves well enough, it won’t matter to them. I suspect the majority to just forget about it, or be too embarrassed to make a fuss and just walk away from the money they’ve spent. There are a huge amount of slightly older games out there for good prices..,
- wedn3sday 5y agoA few differences between starcitizen and GTA: when GTA started development it was being made by an existing studio, SC when it started was like 5 dudes, so they've had to build the studio at the same time as they're building the game. GTA is an improvement on a previously done format, breaking very little new ground. The SC devs literally had to re-write large parts of the Cryengine to add 64bit support so they could build whole solar systems (at about 1/10th scale, but still quite large). Comparing the two is like saying, Ford was making a million cars a year 20 years ago, Tesla is a scam because they cant make a million cars a year.
- zeeZ 5y agoI don't think those comparisons are fair to make. GTA V has been developed by an established studio, while CIG has been built up from scratch. Rockstar already had an engine trailered to them ready made with the support from several of their studios. CIG have been running and supporting a live multiplayer environment since 2015. Also all three of your variables - scope, time and budget - have been dynamic and mostly increasing, while progress has been made. There's obviously a problem with scope and time management, but I don't think criminal levels. Apples and Oranges (with a development goal of pumpkins)