4 ms·
This is a challenging transition that all countries should prepare for and debate how to handle. But ultimately this is good news. Population cannot keep incre
by mytailorisrich 5y ago
This is a challenging transition that all countries should prepare for and debate how to handle.
But ultimately this is good news. Population cannot keep increasing and evidence is that it is unsustainably high now. So Less pressure on the environment, more space, hopefully increased productivity and wealth per capital (by harnessing automation).
Japan specifically is overcrowded (coubtry is not that big and most of it is actually montains with people crowded in coastal plains), so this is an opportunity to increase individuals' quality of life.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoI’m always curious who downvotes these opinions, who looks at a world with 8B people headed to 11B people by the end of the century and thinks depopulation is a problem. Less people is good for a strained planet, and this sort of population decline is the least harmful option for realizing a more steady state world (versus unsustainable growth).
- mytailorisrich 5y agoI always wonder as well. My hypothesis is that population growth is so embedded in the common psyche, from economics to culture and religion, that suggesting otherwise is anathema and rejected by Pavlovian reflex.
- zmgsabst 5y agoI think it’s because no one ever bothers to support it. You declare that we have “too many people” and “need fewer humans” — but don’t demonstrate that’s true. It seems more like an article of faith among a certain crowd. But to people who don’t think that’s true, saying we need fewer people and enacting policies to achieve that seems dangerous: you’re trying to destroy other people’s families for no reason but your religious beliefs.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoWhat supporting citations would you like? There are 121 million unintended pregnancies globally annually. 2.7 millions children in foster/institutional care. 689 million in poverty and destitution. Rainforests are being clear cut, the planet is well beyond its carbon budget (and Herculean efforts will be required to pull us back from 2C), and there is ample evidence climate change is going to cause famines and heatwaves that will inflict suffering on wide swaths of the global population (with the developing world being hit particularly hard). This is not the fiction that religion is, these are verifiable facts (ourworldindata.org, UN reports). Isn’t it dangerous to have large numbers of people we’re going to just let die when resources are further constrained? It seems a lot safer to argue for family planning for all but the most capable and emotionally invested parents and let everyone else age out with a decent quality of life to responsibly transition to a lower human run rate. No one is arguing for eugenics, family destruction, or similar distasteful policies.
- zmgsabst 5y ago> Isn’t it dangerous to have large numbers of people we’re going to just let die when resources are further constrained? You haven’t shown anything like this — merely asserted it based on unrelated facts. You cited raw numbers, but eg, portion of humanity in starvation conditions has gone down as population went up, because the increased wealth of nations allowed for feeding more people. Neither unintended pregnancies nor a fraction of children in foster care seems like something that is solved by having fewer people. In fact, that will get worse (like hunger) as society regresses and we are less wealthy as nations. > No one is arguing for eugenics, family destruction, or similar distasteful policies. You are: Planned Parenthood was founded by a noted eugenicist; the policies to support your vision require massive taxes that stress the young and prevent them from breeding even if they otherwise would want to; etc. You’re just denying your role in that destruction through social policy based on some kind of religious apocalyptic fantasy.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoI think this is demonstrated. We have a global climate and environmental crisis in a world where most human beings are still quite poor and with population still increasing. We're being told that we should travel less, eat less meat, this, that, when most people on Earth actually still struggle to afford these things (I.e. consumption per capita is increasing as people leave abject poverty worldwide) Believing that global population level is fine is not even an article of faith, it simply is denial of reality because it is something some people somehow simply refuse to hear. Lastly, no-one here suggests that we should kill people or whatnot. In Japan and other developed countries population is decreasing naturally, let's just let it instead of panicking.
- ur-whale 5y ago> Less people is good for a strained planet. I do agree with the general sentiment on this, but it's unfortunately kind of ignoring the huge, short and medium term social problems this population decline will bring about. Specifically, in many places, much of infrastructure (social and otherwise) was designed on assumptions of growth. Re-engineering entire countries infrastructure to meet these new demographics deals is going to be costly. Even to the "blood in the streets" level in some cases, I believe.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoYes it is a challenge but ultimately less costly than the alternative... Moreover, if you accept that population cannot increase infinitely in a finite world, the transition will have to happen one day. So the sooner the better and rich, developed countries are equipped to deal with it.
- adventured 5y ago> I’m always curious who downvotes these opinions The expanionists that recognize some of the ponzi qualities of how a lot of the modern welfare states are stacked. That those systems will begin to fail if populations don't perpetually increase enough. They dread that population decline is going to wreck how the welfare state functions (lie to voters, over promise on entitlements, pray population keeps expanding forever so new workers can pay for retiring workers, kick the can down the road; Japan has done this for two decades for example, the US is actively doing it, and lots of affluent European nations are doing it). It forces a reckoning with very poor decisions from the past, the bill comes due, and almost nobody likes that. Predictable population expansion helps politicians paper over a lot of various fiscal mistakes (they rely heavily on fiscal lies to function, telling people things that are irrational fiscally but popular). Britain, France, Japan, the US - four of the world's largest economies, and they all function by using the same scam (pull future potential output forward, eat it / distribute it today, fake the present standard of living for re-election at the cost of the future context). These are things for example Macron has wrestled with frequently in France, and absolutely no politician in the US wants to go anywhere near talking about how the trajectory on entitlements is going to bankrupt the US Government de facto (requiring forever low rates from the Fed, $50t in new debt over the next 30 years, and leading to a raft of bad follow-on things economically).
- inglor_cz 5y agoIt is not just welfare, but also the healthcare systems. Older people are, on average, much less healthy and need more medical attention. IDK if this can be solved by medical/nursing robots, but we almost certainly do not have enough living medical professionals to care for countries whose average age climbs over 50.
- slibhb 5y agoThese posts get downvoted because anti-humanism is a repulsive sentiment. I don't see any solid evidence that the planet is "strained" or, if it is, that it has anything to do with population. People have been talking about overpopulation since before I was born. I think people who go for that stuff have a dim view of humanity and that's where their beliefs come from, not from any kind of serious empirical analysis.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoYou said yourself: > Civilization is humans, who are animals, pretending they are not animals. This pretending is often very hard. — slibhb Anti-humanism is the wrong characterization. It’s the lack of self awareness and self preservation in aggregate as a species that is repulsive imho.
- slibhb 5y agoPretending we're not animals is the right thing to do! Civilization is good and we only have it as long as we pretend we aren't animals. I don't think it's a serious analysis that predicts that mankind will go extinct due to overpopulation. People who have that view truly are anti-humanists. They view humans as rapacious monsters that inevitably exploit and harm other living things and the planet. The truth is that we don't know what humans will make of the planet. Maybe the pessimists are right. But it's a higher form of behavior than pessimism to live your life in a way that confirms that mankind is good.
- licebmi__at__ 5y agoThe main objection to this kind of arguments is that the earth is enough for everyone but the problem is that the wealth is not distributed. Thus this kind of argument is viewed as a way for wealthy nations to deflect blame. And while I personally don’t share the more optimistic side of the argument, I’m definitely sympathetic to the second part, specially when I see the moralistic arguments against poor nations trying to create wealth, by those who already depleted their own, and are also mostly enjoying the fruits of poor nations resources in form of cheap goods.
- car_analogy 5y ago> Thus this kind of argument is viewed as a way for wealthy nations to deflect blame. But it's the wealthy nations that are the ones undergoing population decline. And instead of being praised for their responsible family planning, they are told "No! You must grow! And by 'grow' we mean import people from abroad."
- licebmi__at__ 5y agoI don’t think the people who are defending a maltussian like argument (which is the one I’m criticizing) are the ones also arguing for more population on the first world.
- zo1 5y agoI know this is not a comfortable or popular opinion, but I think that for the most part, the descendants of nations need to inherit the nations created by their ancestors (good or bad). Not foreigners, and especially not ones that don't "become" fully integrated with their host culture.
- yodsanklai 5y agoMany HN readers tend to downplay environmental issues and resource scarcity. Some think religiously it can be be solved by innovation, which is fuelled by growth.
- Tiktaalik 5y agoIn the 1970s the pressing issue of the time was that everyone thought over population was going to mean we were gonna run out of food (see: The Population Bomb, Soylent Green). The troubling slant to the discussion of course was that it wasn't our growth that was the problem but elsewhere in the global south. Of course we didn't starve to death and this fear was completely unfounded. The problems we face today of course have nothing to do with that. They stem rather from excessive CO2 emissions, and these emissions are dominated by rich nations with relatively small populations. This could have been limited and prevented in the 1970s but people made other choices. It's possible that there is some point where over population is a real problem, but that is not now, and we can solve our most pressing problems in other ways.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoCO2 emissions are only one aspect of the the issue (and they are rising in all developing countries as they develop), which is a global environmental crisis. This crisi is caused by excessive exploitation of resources, which is still increasing because of a compounded effect: we're rightly eradicating poverty and we're more and more. So yes we are feeding everyone, among other improvements, but we are destroying the planet in the process. Even we're the efforts we're making in rich the consumption of resources is not really decreasing while it is increasing in developing countries. Population is the root cause of the problem. I don't see why this is controversial. Less people enjoying a better life in a better environment sounds like an ideal world.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> But ultimately this is good news. Less pressure on the environment, more space, hopefully increased productivity and wealth per capital (by harnessing automation). I agree with the sentiment of this comment regarding the end state, but I fear the transition will be a disaster. Demographic changes are of course happening at very different stages around the world. Many 1st world countries are seeing dramatically shrinking populations, but many third world countries are exploding - Nigeria is expected to nearly double their population to 400 million by 2050. The shift and resource wars thèse changes will cause will result in a lot of suffering. > Japan specifically is overcrowded Not really. A few of Japan's megacities are overcrowded, but tons of other areas have seen rapid depopulation and demographic collapse where there are hardly any young people.