4 ms·
It turned out that the guy with the Youtube video complaining that the US didn't have a dredge big enough for the job had calculated wrong. Donjon-Smit, out of
by Animats 5y ago
It turned out that the guy with the Youtube video complaining that the US didn't have a dredge big enough for the job had calculated wrong. Donjon-Smit, out of Houston TX, brought in dredges and cranes, unloaded about 500 containers in a few days, did enough dredging to free up the now-lightened ship, and towed it out.
The Ever Forward spent a few days in Baltimore being unloaded and repaired, and then went on to Norfolk, then New York, and is now waiting to transit the Panama Canal.
The US doesn't have huge dredging capacity because it has good deepwater ports. Compare the Port of Shanghai, where 32 km of bridges, artificial islands, and extensive dredging were needed just to get to deep water.
- barry-cotter 5y ago> The US doesn't have huge dredging capacity because it has good deepwater ports. I suggest reading the article. Dredging the Mississippi five inches deeper would increase profits of the soybean industry alone by over $2 billion a year, IIRC. There’s a lot more than soybeans that travels on the Mississippi and reducing carrying costs would make all kinds of freight cheaper.
- Animats 5y agoFive feet deeper.[1] The big holdup on that was a deal which exempted Louisiana from the usual requirement that the state pay half the cost. Now, the Federal government is paying three-quarters of the cost. There's a big barge lobby. Barges don't pay for US waterway use. There's a tax on fuel, but it pays maybe 10% of the cost of maintaining waterways. [1] https://garretgraves.house.gov/media-center/in-the-news/dredging-mississippi-river-50-feet-clears-corps-approval-hurdle https://garretgraves.house.gov/media-center/in-the-news/dred...
- barry-cotter 5y agoThank you for the correction. Re:barges and paying for infrastructure. Who cares? User pays is nice in principle but if there are massive positive externalities of doing something the government should do it. That’s what taxes and the idea of the public good are for. The benefits of cheaper transport do not accrue mostly to barge companies.
- Retric 5y agoCommand economies are simply inefficient. The US overuses highways for long haul trucking because trucks pay a lower percentage of infrastructure and externalities costs than trains do. Barges are just another way to move cargo, if lower shipping costs are worth the investment they can pay for the majority of it.
- schrectacular 5y agoAlso because of the little-known Jones Act from 1920 which states that any shipping between US ports must be shipped solely aboard vessels that are U.S.-built, U.S.-citizen owned, and, registered in the U.S., which means crewed by Americans. It's incredibly expensive to ship anything domestically in the US even though the geography is quite good for it.
- Retric 5y agoThe Registered in the US bit seems like it would place it on an even footing with other forms of transportation which is definitely a good thing economically. U.S.-built and U.S.-citizen owned are presumably good to get rid of economically, though it has some national defense implications.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- everybodyknows 5y agoTo complete the triangle, if barges are subsidized more heavily than trains, some cargo will, as with your truck comparison, overuse the less-efficient transport, at cost to the general taxpayers.
- dahfizz 5y ago> The US overuses highways for long haul trucking because trucks pay a lower percentage of infrastructure and externalities costs than trains do. Source? The US has a massive freight train industry. We have more railroad than any other country - and almost double second place (China). I guess "overuses" is subjective, but we use commercial freight way more than anyone else. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_rail_transport_network_size https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_rail_tr...
- mcculley 5y ago> Barges don't pay for US waterway use. There's a tax on fuel, but it pays maybe 10% of the cost of maintaining waterways. Do you have a citation for this 10%? I operate a tugboat company. We move barges. We currently pay an excise tax of $0.29/gallon of fuel burned on inland routes. There is no good tracking or enforcement, but the tax is there.
- Animats 5y agoThis is a long-standing political issue. Much has been written on waterway cost recovery, but most of it is old. Congressional Budget Office study from the 1980s says "User fees now in effect recover approximately 10 percent of the Corps of Engineers costs of operating and maintaining the inland waterway system."[1] The Waterways Council (the barge industry's lobby) talks a lot about cost-benefit ratios of barge operations and why their infrastructure should be subsidized.[2] They argue that lower pollution and less infrastructure cost per ton mile justifies Federal spending. They're probably not wrong. [1] https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/98th-congress-1983-1984/reports/doc08_1.pdf https://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/98th-congress-1983-1... [2] https://waterwayscouncil.org/media/press-releases https://waterwayscouncil.org/media/press-releases
- mcculley 5y agoThanks for that CBO document. Yeah, I wish I knew what the percentage was now. Certainly the tax is higher than in the 80s. There are some perverse outcomes. In South Florida, I see boats doing nothing but advertising, floating billboards, causing drawbridges to open. I have no idea if they are paying the excise tax.
- alimov 5y agoUnless I missed something, the article said $461 million per year (See below). So if it’s going to make that much money per year and that’s “independent of supply and demand” then why should the U.S tax payer help fund the project? (I believe you said that gov would find 75% of the cost…edit: it was another responder actually). And if it reduces carrying costs for other goods then that seems like more reason for companies to cover the costs (imo) > Digging the depth of the lower Mississippi from 45' to 50' could generate $461 million annually for the U.S. soybean industry — independent of supply and demand.
- barry-cotter 5y ago> So if it’s going to make that much money per year and that’s “independent of supply and demand” then why should the U.S tax payer help fund the project? Because growing the economy by $461 million a year grows the economy and hence tax receipts, which then can be spent on good things or on reducing taxes. Note that that’s $461 million for one industry. Reducing shipping costs has benefits that accrue to everyone who uses goods that are shipped on internal waterways or sells them, i.e. everybody. Doing things that benefit everyone is very much in the bailiwick of the government.
- anamax 5y ago> Because growing the economy by $461 million a year grows the economy and hence tax receipts Growing the economy by $461M grows tax receipts by significantly less than $461M.
- andi999 5y agoIf this were true, couldnt the soy bean industry order from a us shipmaker to build one for like 1 billion?
- jon-wood 5y agoThe US soy bean industry isn’t one entity that can make a decision like that, it’s presumably thousands of discrete farms, each of which would have to pitch some in and then presumably endlessly bikeshed about precisely what needs to be done.
- barry-cotter 5y agoCoordination is hard. The overwhelming majority of traffic on the Mississippi is not soybeans. The soybean industry is not terribly concentrated. Why should they pay all the costs only to receive a small portion of the benefits? This kind of problem with large positive or negative externalities and myriad actors is usually the province of governments to solve. For another example see climate change.
- Amezarak 5y agoConsidering the soybean industry is a massive environmental and health disaster, I am glad they aren’t able to profit more and would oppose anything that encouraged its expansion.
- Kim_Bruning 5y agoI wonder how Donjon-Smit happened. (Smit is a famous real world International Rescue, headquartered in Rotterdam)