9 ms·
Per the Federal Reserve, total Household Net Worth before COVID-19 was $110 trillion. Two years later on 12/31/21, it clocked in at $150 trillion - a 36% increa
by paulpauper 5y ago
Per the Federal Reserve, total Household Net Worth before COVID-19 was $110 trillion. Two years later on 12/31/21, it clocked in at $150 trillion - a 36% increase - the largest increase ever over such a time period.
Isn’t it odd that during a period of economic turmoil, household wealth increased by the most on record? Indeed this strange dichotomy can be understood in large part by low rates and QE.
What would explain the increase of household wealth pre-2008, before QE was even invented? The economy was in turmoil for a few months but then everything picked up again. GDP, corporate profits surged. Unemployment fell.
Home prices and stocks surged in the 80s and 90s despite high interest rates.
The fed raised rates from 0% in early 2016 to 2.5% by late 2018 and the stock market and economy did fine.
Correlation does not mean causation, as it's said. 0% interest rates forever didn't help japan until possibly only very recently. why is it suddenly different here.
- jgeada 5y agoNice, but aggregates like this hide the distribution: who got that increase matters, and the distribution is likely extremely lopsided towards the upper extreme. The more you had, the greater your percentage increase.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y ago> What would explain the increase of household wealth pre-2008, before QE was even invented? The economy was in turmoil for a few months but then everything picked up again. The economy was in turmoil in 2007? There were problems at a few banks, but other than that, spending and investment was extremely optimistic. House prices hadn't started to decline, and they were coming off their biggest 6-year increase in a long time. HH wealth was at an all-time high for most of the year.
- paulpauper 5y agoi meant turmoil in 2020 due to coivd.
- flenserboy 5y agoYeah, but that $150T is no longer worth $110T (and that number itself was illusory).
- jeffbee 5y agoThat is the curse of inflation. Your household is now worth millions but you can't afford a house. This has always been the lie of compound interest and savings. You're always told that if you don't buy a Big Mac and put the $2.99 in the bank instead, you'll have ten dollars in 30 years. But in 30 years a Big Mac is going to cost $12, so you just played yourself. The whole system is an illusion.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> You're always told that if you don't buy a Big Mac and put the $2.99 in the bank instead, you'll have ten dollars in 30 years. But in 30 years a Big Mac is going to cost $12, so you just played yourself. There's more to it than that. You also get to pay taxes on your $7 of capital gains.
- deathanatos 5y agoYou'll get to pay taxes on that Big Mac too.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThe point here isn't so much that all taxes are unreasonable as that, in this scenario, there are no capital gains, but you're paying capital gains taxes anyway. You're paying a 10% tax (assuming capital gains tax rate of 15%) on an investment that is down 17%.
- deathanatos 5y agoTrue enough. Though… the original example is in the bank. If I stick $2.99 in the bank, in 30 years, I'll have $3.08. (Or $0 when the bank decides to add some random fee, which is why my H"S"A is currently giving a negative return…)
- NovemberWhiskey 5y agoThe other thing about that chart is that is it's on a linear scale. If you have productive assets that compound returns, you should expect log structured growth. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/BOGZ1FL192090005Q https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/BOGZ1FL192090005Q You only get 36% if you measure from the bottom of the sharp V-shaped recession in 2020. If you measure from 2019Q4 to 2021Q4 you get something more like 29%. Still sounds like a lot, but compare 2002Q4 through 2004Q4 - that's also about 26%, it's just not so obvious on the linear scale. In fact, if you look at the percentage growth over a two-year look-back, household wealth has grown by at least 20% on multiple occasions on that time series. For comparison, this is what the same timeseries looks like if you plot it ending at the end of 2004: https://imgur.com/EehsZbs https://imgur.com/EehsZbs
- deevolution 5y agohttps://wtfhappenedin1971.com/ https://wtfhappenedin1971.com/
- criticaltinker 5y agoI’ll bite. The data/graphs look suspicious and convincing enough, so WTF did happen? I was hoping for an answer but alas there was none. Anyone have plausible theories? Is this an unexplained mystery or just an artifact of S curve growth?
- bagels 5y agoI always thought the site might imply getting off the gold standard.
- iso1631 5y agoOf course it implies it, but that's been debunked
- imtringued 5y agoI think the gold standard ended because of globalization. After all gold wasn't widely distributed enough to allow a global economy to develop so the USD had to decouple from gold.
- f38zf5vdt 5y agoNixon shock/move to fiat standard instead of gold convertibility.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoA lot happened around that time: Technology and automation really started taking off, sending productivity way up. Global shipping costs plummeted, giving way to a new era of international trade. The first personal computers started entering the market. Trade relations with China opened up around that time. Households started moving from single-earner to dual-income. It was a time of rapid change. That particular website is usually used to suggest that the only thing that changed was the gold standard, but it's been debunked and refuted all across the internet.
- rgrieselhuber 5y agoI suspect we'll start to see more 40 year mortgages to keep the housing market going too.
- duped 5y agoTo be fair, it's still better than renting. I'm curious how long a mortgage has to be before renting is a better buy for consumers, but I'd bet it's closer to 80 years than 40. If you're spending $2k/month on rent vs interest, taxes, and equity, with the idea that you'll get at least the value of the equity back when you sell (and probably more, when inflation is higher than a fixed rate mortgage) you'll come out ahead no matter how long you hold the debt. And frankly 40 year mortgages are probably better than 30 years with debtors that can't afford the monthly rate. It's like 72 month car loans, it's a better deal for everyone.
- whichfawkes 5y agoThe M1 money supply increased by 40% during that time though. We've already realized a ~10% increase in the CPI. Presuming that houses are included in this metric, those are currently pretty inflated in value. As of December 31st 2021, the market hadn't even really started to pull back yet. If you say that household wealth has increased nominally, in terms of there being a bigger number of dollars, sure. But I think you have a pretty hard case if you want to argue that _Real_ household wealth has increased very much.