6 ms·
Social media break improves mental health
- silicon2401 5y agoQuitting social media and the news are some of the best lifestyle changes I've made in my life. Both present constant feeds of "stuff" in ways that make the consumer think it's important. As a result, the consumer does what corporations and businesses want most: they just keep consuming and looking for more to consume. For me, 99% of stuff on social media and the news is simply not worth any time, so while I never had issues with depression or anxiety or things like that, it was a pointless waste of my time and focus. Nowadays I do way more interesting things and enjoy the moment way more. I imagine for people who _do_ suffer from anxiety, etc due to social media, the effects would be even more significant.
- algoatecorn 5y agoExactly how I feel. Social media is robbing people blind (of their time). I also enjoy knowing that I'm not a free marketing resource for companies. Maybe I'm just one potential data point, but it feels good to know I'm not "feeding the machine".
- g-unit33 5y agoYou consider hackernews news or no?
- fullshark 5y agoCould be defined as social media too
- hammock 5y agoAbsolutely, especially if you are a regular commenter, ever glance at your karma, etc.
- apocalypstyx 5y agoAll social media is immoral except my social media.
- kradeelav 5y agoNot the OP, but I don't consider HN to be in the same category as say, facebook, CNN, twitter, anything with a feed for a few reasons. One is the lack of algorithms and dark patterns shoveling engagement-bait towards our way. Upvoted content, while not always pristine, tends to be better quality on average. Two, while HN is a great spot for "tech news", it pretty rarely has the "if it bleeds it leads" shock-bait type of articles that the alphabet networks do. Lastly, this is a little of a life hack, but in the mornings I tend to glance once at the top 3 HN headlines; if there's no major "news-news" (ie not tech news) in the top three slots, then it's pretty safe to say that nothing historic like September 11th happened that day. It's a pretty peaceful way of checking that the world's continuing to keep on spinning. :)
- jl6 5y agoI also don’t consider HN to be in the same category as Twitter and Facebook. Another reason for this, on top of those you mention, is because identity is very weak here. I don’t have any persistent relationship with any HN commenters - I have no idea who you are or if I’ve replied to you before! That cuts out a lot of social dynamics that breed long-term feuding behaviour on other platforms.
- root_axis 5y ago> One is the lack of algorithms and dark patterns shoveling engagement-bait towards our way HN front-page is certainly algorithm driven, it might not be individualized, but stories that displease the algorithm are down-weighted which, in effect, is a tacit promotion of stories the algorithm chooses not to penalize. > it pretty rarely has the "if it bleeds it leads" shock-bait type of articles that the alphabet networks do. I don't agree. HN stories are often baity, inflammatory, and contentious, it is not uncommon to see dang warning the comment section to keep things civil. The type of stories that hit HN aren't always the type we see in the wider media, but the level of toxicity is on par with every other social media site, if only mitigated by careful and rigorous moderation.
- g-unit33 5y agoI love how peaceful of a life you live haha if September 11 or such hasn’t happened, it’s going to be a good day Very inspiring
- silicon2401 5y agoI don't, nor do I consider it social media. I'm aware that we're socially interacting through the medium of HN, but when I say social media I mean things like twitter or instagram; I hope the meaning is clear. The reason I don't consider HN news is because I just see HN as just a link aggregator. By news I mean things like Fox News
- FollowingTheDao 5y agoIf you could help me quit the news I would appreciate it. Social media for some reason was easy for me quit, but the news is a hard one. But here you are on HackerNEWS so maybe I am asking the wrong person for help?
- tablespoon 5y ago> If you could help me quit the news I would appreciate it. Move to an authoritarian country, like China. Seriously. If you live in a democracy, news is pretty important for informing you for performing your civic responsibilities and exerting your influence on the political system. If your influence is literally zero, then there's no point. In places like that, there's even a self-preservation incentive for disengagement, because engagement can be dangerous if it conflicts with the authorities.
- tayo42 5y agoif you read online you can set up blocks for certain news sites, or like only allow them at certain times
- nonameiguess 5y agoI don't want to speak for silicon2401, but at least for me, cold turkey worked fine. But we need to be clear about what needs to be quit. It's any and all news. Consumption of information is important for various reasons, if for nothing else then to satisfy basic intellectual curiosity. But you need to be judicious about where it is coming from and how often you spend your time consuming it, along with the extent to which that consumption is interactive. So no 24 hour cable news channels. No algorithmic content feeds. No consuming news through Facebook or Google. I've never been on Twitter, but I imagine it isn't much better and you should quit it if you currently have an account there. Don't just try to stay away or use an app to block it based on time of day. Delete your account and put the site on your home firewall if you have. Then proceed to consume from healthier. The most obvious is books. Read as many and as often as you can. After that, I still think YouTube channels or something similar on an equivalent platform can still be useful, but you have to be careful. Turn off auto-play. Turn off watch and search history. Don't use the algorithmic suggestion feeds. Block them via custom uBlock rules if necessary. Just ignore them if you can. Subscribe to your trusted channels and let them make word of mouth recommendations for other channels. That is a perfectly adequate level of discoverability. For me, I stick to DIY home improvement, PC and homelab building, car detailing, weight lifting, and some animal information channels. That's it. No current events or culture war topics. Nobody that yells or gets emotional in their videos. After that, blogs. There is where Hacker News is still useful. You can discover quality blogs. They'll be repeatedly linked to here, rise to the top, and not be causing long arguments and flame wars. Facebook honestly used to be useful for the same purpose. But there is always a balance between discovering useful sources of new information and time spent getting sucked into long arguments and rabbit-holing yourself with outrage bait. At some point, Facebook became not enough of the former and too much of the latter. Hacker News hasn't reached that point yet, at least for me. When it does, I will leave Hacker News as well. Meanwhile, since I bookmarked the highest-quality blogs that consistently show up here, I'll just start going straight to the source. A few key reasons I don't think Hacker News is that bad yet include the comparatively small user base, somewhat of an industry focus, active and consistent moderation that is fair and well-explained, and no personalization. Everyone sees the same list of links. The list is still algorithmically sorted, but since the algorithm is largely just upvote count and recency and isn't personalized, I don't find it that bad. At least not yet.
- throwaway22032 5y agoThe tide on mental health seems to have turned to the extent that it's gone from being something we don't speak about, to being used as a catchall for, well, just having a reasonable and balanced life. Doomscrolling is just not that useful when you compare it to like, basically anything else you could be doing with the time, like exercising, reading a book, tidying around the house, just relaxing with your thoughts, etc. The logical extension of constantly doing stupid stuff (like eating bad food, not exercising, not having a fulfilling life) is indeed physical or mental health problems. The answer is just to take a step back and examine your life. Are you spending your time doing things you want to do, or are you being driven around on autopilot?
- pessimizer 5y agoHeroin isn't that useful for people not in acute physical pain, but it's addictive. > The answer is just to take a step back and examine your life. Are you spending your time doing things you want to do, or are you being driven around on autopilot? You can say things like this to heroin addicts, but the first important thing is keeping them from leaving to get more heroin. After they're clean, they might find this sort of introspection to be a reasonable substitute.
- ulisesrmzroche 5y agoThere's acute mental pain, heroin numbs that too, but you're right. That kinda thinking, the new "you're wasting your time on Facebook, go read a book" is just the old puritan "get to work loser". Literally, one of the oldest scripts in the docs to get you to work harder for the man. Damn him. If you're brain is too tired to do anything but watch cartoons or play video games, or just fart around and not do anything, then that's your god-given right and you don't even have to be tired to do that. Facebook gives us social connections and those are critical for humans. Far more important than reading a book or going for a walk.
- fpiazza 5y ago> Facebook gives us social connections and those are critical for humans. Far more important than reading a book or going for a walk. A rather basic take, I'd wager, or if you prefer it, a really superficial analysis, but ok.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kornhole 5y agoI do recognize that shutting off the news and events of the world can definitely increase one's emotional well being. Part of being a social citizen is being aware of, learning, and acting on knowledge. My main issue with this and many similar articles is the use of the generic term 'social media'. The corporate, government, AI manipulated social media platforms mentioned in the article are very different from the human focused free social media many of us have moved to. I regularly tell people that I love social media but not most of the platform social media most people are only aware of.
- FollowingTheDao 5y agoThe news though, how much and how far? The news is just gossip if you think about it. So isn't talking to your neighbor the same thing as the news? Do I really need to know about a flood in Pakistan who I live in the United States?
- kornhole 5y agoYou are right. You are here on HN because you probably are discerning of the kind of news that might actually be useful to enhancing your understanding of our world to help you navigate it.
- spdcbr 5y agoCould you elaborate on the "human focused free social media"?
- kornhole 5y agoMany are free of surveillance, advertising, government censorship, and AI manipulation that keeps feeding people garbage. https://framatube.org/w/9dRFC6Ya11NCVeYKn8ZhiD https://framatube.org/w/9dRFC6Ya11NCVeYKn8ZhiD Here is one resource if you want to explore: https://fediverse.party/ https://fediverse.party/.
- marcodiego 5y agoBeware: although probably less harmful than most, it is very likely that HN, as form of social media, may have the same dangers. I got mostly addicted to it to gain 15k karma points in one year.
- FollowingTheDao 5y agoThis is true for me. HackerNews seems to combine both of these triggers in a subversive way to keep me coming back. It is not about the points for me, but the interaction. I do not care about down votes, just any human interaction is fine with me. Disturbing, sad.
- sdevonoes 5y agoDefinitely. In the same way Twitter/Facebook/Instagram's algorithms catches regular people's attention (celebrities pictures here and there, clickbait titles, etc.), HN does it in an equivalent way (as a developer I don't like superfluous BS, HN gives none; I like clean design, HN provides that; etc.). The "HN algorithm" (or even the lack of it) does catch my attention.
- sys_64738 5y agoAs well as being depressing, social media is a total time suck that provides zero productivity. It is a dumpster of dross that should be set alight. The most terrible organization for this is clearly Facebook or whatever their latest name they try to hide under is. Zuck has a lot to answer for. A lot.
- United857 5y agoDisclaimer: Meta employee but speaking only for myself. I like to think of media to the brain like food to the body. Most of us don't have the resources to gather our own raw news/info so we outsource this to others, just like most of us don't grow our own food but outsource to others. Good stimulating media is mentally nourishing like good food is physically nourishing. But a lot of the media out there, social and otherwise is junk. Like junk food, occasionally good for fun but not a constant diet. Many know how to evaluate the healthiness of food. But many don't have the critical thinking and evaluation skills needed to evaluate the healthiness of media and to ensure a "balanced diet", and developing or teaching these skills something we should be doing more of.
- awsrocks 5y ago
- algoatecorn 5y agoI hear ya, and use the same analogy myself when talking about media, specifically social media. But quantity of media consumed doesn't necessarily make it junk. The quality makes it junk. An athlete needs a lot of calories and tend to obtain those calories from high quality sources. A business executive needs a lot of information. A principal investigator needs a lot of information. Both tend to obtain high quality information. The problem I have with social media compared to other forms, is the slew of low (very low) quality of information. This junk info isn't just present - it is directed towards individuals for the sake of increased user interaction. The revenue model of social media requires gluttony, and its easiest to overindulge on junk. As for the "many people" aspect... That's very subjective and in the context of social media junk food, it is far too many. A balanced media diet, in my opinion, is composed of very little social media.
- United857 5y agoYes, fully agreed, it's about the quality not quantity. I realized my wording was ambiguous and have since clarified my comment to disambiguate that. And yes it's impossible to be substantial in a meme or short video or tweet. Like fast food -- the medium is inherently limiting.
- rvz 5y agoThere you go. A reminder that taking your daily dose of digital drugs like Facebook™, Twitter™, Instagram™, TikTok™, etc is not very good for the mind and only gives you symptoms such as being addicted to infinite doom-scrolling as designed by the creators, involved 24/7 with the outrage machine with brainless parrots reposting or retweeting the same manufactured content and manipulating the discussion and also demoralises what is real and unreal; especially when all of them have an algorithm dictating what is seen and unseen. I know what you are thinking and I get it. It's extremely difficult to leave for good and delete your account(s). The second best way to avoid it is to delete the app(s) or turn off notifications and log out of all of them. If you can handle a week away from it all, then you are on your way to your first step to changing and breaking the addiction.
- awsrocks 5y ago
- deergomoo 5y agoThis is purely anecdotal, but recently I switched from the official Twitter app to a third party offering (Tweetbot specifically) because I was starting to feel like the algorithmic offerings were overtaking the people I actually follow. Third-party apps are, in most cases, just a reverse chronological list of tweets. New tweets load in, you scroll to the top of the list, and that’s it: you’ve read all the tweets. The first thing I noticed was that I would open the app after a few hours away and have 1000+ new tweets, which made me realise I was following far too many accounts. Why am I following my network provider on Twitter? Now I feel I have a much healthier relationship with Twitter. I open it a few times per day, I see if anything interesting has happened, and then I close the app. There are no tricks to keep me scrolling. I think the main difference is that scrolling up to view newer content has an end, while scrolling down to view older content essentially doesn’t. I would like to see that approach tried in more third-party clients—primarily Reddit.
- aceazzameen 5y agoI only use Twitter on the web, so no experience in the app. I have it set to display my feed in chronological order. Recently it reverted to the default algorithm feed without me knowing. I was seeing all sorts of toxic and hateful posts. Most were from followers of followers without the tweet being liked or retweeted. I hated it. It took me a while to realize I was no longer in chronological mode. Once I switched back, all the bullshit disappeared. This confirmed for me that algorithms on social media are slowly destroying society.
- anotherevan 5y agoI use the Choqok client[0] which also just does reverse chronological. The killer feature to me though, is that it remembers what tweets you've read. So I usually just scroll down to where I was up to last time and start reading up[1] - clicking on anything interesting to investigate further in my browser[2]. It's the only client I've found with that feature. It's a bit clunky in places otherwise, but that alone keeps me with it. [0] https://choqok.kde.org/ https://choqok.kde.org/ [1] I don't follow a huge number of people, and also shy away from "prolific" tweeters so my number of tweets per day is not huge. I really treat it like an RSS feel TBH. [2] I also use the Invidition browser add-on to redirect Twitter links to a Nitter instance - so much cleaner.
- ChrisRR 5y agoI can honestly say my anxiety levels massively dropped since cutting twitter, facebook and the most popular subreddits out of my life. Now I'm not constantly bombarded with awful news at every opportunity. Just visit smaller subreddits more relevant to my interests.
- jaegerpicker 5y agoThat's been my strategy as well, smaller focused subreddit's and instagram only following a few accounts and hashtag's I'm interested in. No influencers or celeb's. I've been FAR healthier since I started that 5 months ago. I'll likely never go back.
- iamben 5y agoAnother purely anecdotal comment, but I came off (as in just stopped opening) Facebook about 4 years ago. I missed it for about 2 weeks; it was very habitual to just open Facebook when you think you need something to do. But honestly, it was such a great decision. I found it so hard not to get sucked in to stupid arguments and comments ("hey look! here's actual evidence that disproves this" - followed by a 15 comment argument...) which I then kept coming back to and ended up really draining. I can't imagine how horrendous it's been over the last few years (politics, pandemic, etc). I mostly dialled out of Twitter as well - I'll still check some accounts occasionally, but I gave up on the timeline. I'd be excited to try a Twitter without bot amplification and (perhaps?!) some poster accountability. I still enjoy Instagram. It's easy to tailor that to things I want to see - cats, watches, denim - and I can avoid the comments. I'd hate to been a teen with instagram though. I can imagine you could end up feeling very inadequate pretty quickly. Man, the Internet is a funny thing. On one hand it's so great. On the other- what a disaster. I guess it's like everything, you gotta find the balance that works for you and just keep an eye that it stays balanced.
- ergocoder 5y agoPeople who get into arguments on Facebook seem to have lower EQ. They feel impossibly itchy, and they have to scratch that itch. They cannot hold back emotionally. They have to do something. These people are at the disadvantage in the modern world and need EQ training asap.
- zerop 5y agoIMO it's not just break from social media, but break from digital exposure really improves mental health. I can't do it often, but love spending days without it.
- root_axis 5y agoWe see that social media negatively affects mental health, at the same time there is a movement to enshrine social media into our lives as public utilities and a human right. How do we resolve this incongruity? Certainly, there is a lot of money at stake in this question.
- black_puppydog 5y agoThe assumption seems to be that not the social media in itself is causing this, but rather the way that they are run. Fostering "engagement" (read: addiction) and "providing shareholder value" (read: constant exposure to ads in some form or another) are both things that a public utility wouldn't have incentives to do. I'm not saying I fully agree with this (I partially do, but I'm skeptic that it would "magically" just work) but that seems to be the assumption.
- vedtopkar 5y agoAnother anecdote: I felt my mental health declining from being sucked into "academic Twitter", which frequently devolves into unnecessary soapboxing in response to preprints or journal articles. I unfollowed all humans and now only follow institutional accounts. It really helped me.
- zwieback 5y agoSure, at this point we all know social media is like any other drug. And we love drugs and keep doing them, the wars on drugs continue to be spectacular failures. I don't think legislating or shaming the companies themselves will help. What's needed is finding something else to fill our lives and that's difficult, much easier to complain about your drugs killing you.
- thenerdhead 5y agoDon't stop at social media. Start to really look to moderate all of your screen time. Honestly everything in your life, but screens is a good start. The average American spends 11 hours on a screen. That's 65% of their life not including sleeping (although we're fighting for that too). We're in the attention economy. The messages you're seeing about how to live your life, the ads being implanted in your head, the mindless entertainment keeping you from living your life. Not to say don't participate in these, because they are fun. But do moderate everything you do that includes a screen.