11 ms·
Forests, and even whales, are potentially renewable resources. (The Inuit had hunted whales, sustainable, for many thousands of years, with oil amongst the ben
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Forests, and even whales, are potentially renewable resources.
(The Inuit had hunted whales, sustainable, for many thousands of years, with oil amongst the benefits obtained.)
Fossil mineral resources are literally unsustainable by definition. Any activity described as mining, unless there is some geological process that creates new deposits faster than they are exploited, is entirely uneconomic. Extant value is being destroyed.
Fossil fuels might have served as a bridge resource to a sustainable track. To date, this has not been seriously persued or attained.
Matt Ridley is an exceptionally uninspired apologist for nonsustainable extractive practices, and is not a relaible or credible guide.
- dividedbyzero 5y ago> Fossil fuels might have served as a bridge resource to a sustainable track. To date, this has not been seriously persued or attained. That's why I'm pretty stoked about Germany's push to become renewable and sustainable in earnest (at least for energy), even though it's going to be brutally expensive, extremely difficult and the outcome is not at all certain (not quite the kind of move you'd expect from Germany, actually). But at last someone's giving it a shot, and if that gamble works out, wow. That might completely change our collective trajectory in a crazy good way. And Germany might just be able to pull this off, with its deep pockets and highly innovative engineering base. I have high hopes that a few decades from now, there will be renewables, storage, grid tech that'll make the current stuff look crude and primitive and crazy inefficient, like what has been achieved with CPUs/SoCs since the 80s.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe knowledge that fossil fuels are finite dates to the 18th century. No, not the 21st, not the 20th, not the 19th. The 18th. John Williams. 1789.
- Someone 5y ago> Fossil fuels might have served as a bridge resource to a sustainable track. To date, this has not been seriously persued or attained. Isn’t what we are we doing/trying to do now exactly that? I haven’t seen anybody making the suggestion to go cold turkey and go to 100% renewables overnight. Most solar cells and wind farms are built using (mostly) fossil fuels. Also, many countries close down coal power plants but keep gas plants running, knowing that they need fossil fuel to get to 100% renewables, but trying to minimize their impact (because of the difference in pollution effects, it’s better to end up with X MWh equivalent of coal than with X MWh equivalent of gas in the ground) (and yes, there’s all kinds of exceptions, such as Germany closing down nuclear plants, but keeping brown coal mines open)
- zaroth 5y agoWhat do you mean by “is entirely uneconomic”? Of course it is economic. What do you mean by “literally unsustainable by definition”? Sustainable does not mean supply is infinite. You can sustainably mine a finite and non-replenishable resource by utilizing the mineral or element in a fully re-usable manner. In the absolutist sense nothing is infinitely sustainable, so start with the acceptance that the term defines a spectrum. “Fossil fuels might have served as a bridge” - fossil fuels are the underpinning of modern civilization and indisputably have served humanity exceptionally well. There is absolutely zero question that humanity will find a sustainable energy track, because we’ve proven the technology works and eventually it will work even better than fossil fuels. So I’d say that fossil fuels have provided an absolutely essential and extremely effective bridge to non-fossil energy.
- dredmorbius 5y agoPrices cover costs of production. Which are ultimately costs of creation. If extraction is drawing down a resource, then much as making a withdrawal from a bank, your cost isn't just the effort you put into the withdrawal --- say, Uber fare across town and the price of the slip on which you write the request, but the actual amount by which the account has been debited. If 1 year's withdrawals from the Bank of Fossil Fuels represent 5 million years of accumulation, then the pricing should reflect this. I've answered this in part in another comment (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31291706 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31291706), which gets into the fact that the economic theory governing natural resources largely formed when a large contingent of otherwise intelligent people thought the Earth was no more than about 8,000 years old, and even geologist's considered opinions ranged from 30--300 million years. It wasn't until early work with radiometric dating showed that the age was on the order of one billion years, in the first decade of the 20th century, that the truth started becoming apparent. The central organising principle of geology, plate tectonics, was not officially accepted until the late 1960s. Economic theory, public policy, and models of financing had developed under utterly fallacious understandings of reality. And they still do not, and strongly reject, reflecting the truth. Wishful thinking is comforting, until it's not.
- zaroth 5y ago
- rictic 5y agoWe are still discovering exploitable petroleum faster than we are burning it. Peak oil is going to be peak demand for oil as solar wind and batteries continue their exponential price performance improvement curve. Unsustainability is a terrible argument against oil. The problem is the pollution, not the fact that it's finite.
- dredmorbius 5y agoIncorrect. Proven reserves are occasionally increased in known fields. There are some additional discoveries. Most are small. The total geological resource has been largely constant. New discoveries peaked decades ago. If you have any data to show otherwise, please present it.
- nradov 5y ago"Proven" reserves are largely an accounting fiction in many foreign countries. In Saudi Arabia they change their reserve numbers to suit political purposes in ways that bear little relation to geology or extraction technology. So have we reached peak oil yet? The honest answer is that no one knows for sure.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThat's ... somewhat my point. "Proven reserves" depend on both the actual physical resource and economically viable extraction. The latter depends on both price and technology. Saudi Arabia's well-known manipulations are ... their own special twist, I'll admit. There are several terms used to describe natural resources, and they're confusing to laypersons. (They're also confusing to policymakers, engineers, economists, and oil workers.) The geological quantity itself is a resource. The economic good is a reserve. Resources, in order of decreasing confidence of quantity, are measured, indicated, or inferred. Reserves, in order of decreasing confidence of quantity, are proven or proveable. And whilst oil reserves have (generally) been increased over the past 4-6 decades, virtually all of that comes from upward adjustments of the proved reserves of existing, known, oil fields. Not from major new discoveries, which peaked in the 1950s and 1960s globally. In the 1930s for the US. https://www.geologyforinvestors.com/classification-of-mineral-resources-and-reserves/ https://www.geologyforinvestors.com/classification-of-minera... https://web.archive.org/web/20080527233829/http://www.spe.org/spe-site/spe/spe/industry/reserves/Petroleum_Reserves_Definitions_1997.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20080527233829/http://www.spe.or...
- catchclose8919 5y ago> Forests, and even whales, are potentially renewable resources. The whole focus on sustainable and renewable is a really broken way of thinking... Nothing needs to be either sustainable or renewable! (And nothing actually is, in a long/broad enough context. Live will always live off negative-entropy and that is a limited resource in the universe as a whole. You can say that itself is consumption on exhaustion of non-renewable resource at its core, our "ecological loops" are just small-time/space scale repetitions but it's all winding down in the end...) Everything has a finite life, even our planet - we just need to accelerate our evolution so that when whatever has evolved from us needs to leave (or before that), it's advanced enough to so so and go infect/colonize the rest of the universe. There's nothing wrong with using non-renewable resources, as long as they're not producing toxic pollutants or disturbing the balance of planetary systems like the climate. When one unsustainable resource is exhausted we'll go to the new one: soil uranium, thorium, sea-water uranium, deuterium for fusion etc. So sure, oil is horrible, but not because it's non renewable or unsustainable. Nothing is sustainable, it's a never ending race 'till the thermal death of everything and that's the fun of it. We need a solid experts driven approach to climate problems if we want to have any change... the current crop of eco-heads are most of them severely mentally impaired, infected with really bad ideas that they spread around to others, and focused on all the wrong priorities...
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>the current crop of eco-heads are most of them severely mentally impaired, infected with really bad ideas that they spread around to others, and focused on all the wrong priorities... In their defense, they're a hell of a lot better than the Greenpeace and sierra club types that preceded them.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThere is the question of what the existence of a resource in the absence of some specific influence might be. And we can put reasonable bounds on that far better than "it's beyond comprehension". We're on a track which hugely constrains potential viability of human civilisation, and possibly the species itself, far beyond biological, ecological, geophysical, or astronomical constraints. Ultimately, I'd suggest a goal of at least reasonably matching such potential. In the case of both renewable and nonrenewable resources, we can look at what ultimate limits on their utilisation and/or existence might be. Looking at timelines of the future / far future, we see a number of limiting events: - Heat death of the universe. 10^10^120 years - Last brown dwarfs are exhausted. 120 trillion years - Death of the Sun / immolation of the Earth. 7.6 billion years. - Boiling / evaporation of all surface water on Earth through increased solar irradiance: 3.5 -- 4.5 billion years. - Freezing of Earth's core, and collapse of Earth's magnetic field, increasing solar and cosmic radiation on Earth's surface: 3--4 billion years. - Earth's surface temperature reach around 420 K (147 °C; 296 °F), even at the poles. 2.8 billion years. - Prokaryotic life goes extinct (lower estimate): 1.6 billion years. - Eukaryotic life goes extinct due to carbon dioxide extinction: 1.3 billion years. - Plant life dies out as photosynthesis is impossible, due to CO2 starvation, high estimate. 1.2 billion years. - C4 photosynthesis impossible due to falling CO2 levels: 800--900 million years. - Falling CO2 levels greatly disrupt most plant and animal life. Plate tectonics slow and/or stop in this period as well with tremendous impacts on mineral cycling and weathering: 500--800 million years. - Asteroid impacts and gamma ray bursts capable of triggering mass extinctions are likely in the 100--500 million year range. - Fossil fuel reserves may be replenished in the 50--400 million year range. - Coral reefs and general Anthropocene extinction recover may occur in the 2--10 million year range. - h. sapiens may further speciate by 2 million years. - 10% of anthropgenic CO2 will still remain in the atmosphere at > 100,000 years. - The current interglacial period will end in about 50,000 years, with a new ice age occurring in the Northern Hemisphere. - Planned lifespan of the several "long term" projects, including the Long Now Foundation's several ongoing projects, including a 10,000-year clock, the Rosetta Project, the Long Bet Project, of the HD-Rosetta analog disc, an ion beam-etched writing medium on nickel plate, and Norway's Svalbard Global Seed Vault: 10,000 years. - Maximum planned life for radioactive waste storage: 10,000 years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_far_future https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_far_future At the same time, we're looking at a set of largely endogenous risks --- risks humanity has created for itself, not externally imposed --- which face humans on the timescale of decades to centuries: exhaustion of known key mineral resources, overloading of critical environmental sinks (CO2 and other greenhouse gasses being only the most prominent), mass extinctions, sea-level rise, climate change, population growth, risks of nuclear war (tremendously heightened in recent months), an AI / technological singularity (foretold by Kurzweil, Vinge, Lem, von Neumann, Turing, and arguably as long ago as the 18th century with Condorcet), co-evolving global pandemics (see especially Kyle Harper and William McNeill), among them. A technological human civilisation should have a lifespan and planning horizon of at least 10--50k years, with plausible upper bounds of 2 million (evolutionary drift) to ~500 million (viable continuation of life on Earth). Looking to our past, life has existed on Earth for > 4 billion years, though complex multicellular life is < 500 million years old. Mammallian dominance began 67 mya, and humanity itself diverged from common ancestors of the other great apes ~2 mya, achieved modern anatomical form ~200 kya, and signs of current levels of cognitive ability about 50 kya, coinciding with the last peak glaciation. Agriculture and written history are roughly 10k - 6k years old. There are imposed astronomical limits of another 0.5 -- 1 billion years. We're not at the dawn or midpoint of life on Earth, we're somewhat distressingly near the likely end. With a future reach of 1 billion years, putting the total duration of viable life on Earth on a 24 hour clock, it's about 7:40 pm. If only 500 million years remain, closer to 9:45 pm. With lower bounds, it's even later. And yet those remaining time periods extend greatly beyond present planning or consequence horizons. Development of modernity, which might be placed anywhere from the Renaissance to the modern steam age (roughly 1400 -- 1800) occurred in a context in which many people believed the entire universe to be ~6,000 years old, and even geological estimates suggested age in the millions of years, ranging from tens to hundreds. The first inkling of the true age of the Earth didn't occur until the first decade of the 20th century, when analysis of radioactive decay pointed at a timeline of a billion years or more. The currently accepted figure was not obtained until the mid-1950s, and the theory of plate tectonics was formally accepted only in the late 1960s. That is: the operative models under which the present global technological and economic system developed were profoundly wrong.
- JJMcJ 5y ago> whales . . . sustainable That's maybe 100,000 people doing the hunting. Not a world-wide hunt to support the needs of maybe 50 million people in the developed world as in 1850. Whaling continued into the 20th Century in a big way and grew more intense in the hunting methods as time progressed, e.g. harpoon guns instead of rowing around in small boats.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe word "potentially" was in the original, along with an example using a small sustenance-existence low-technology hunter population. "Sustainable" inherently means utilisation within the rate of replacement. See, e.g., Herman Daly, Ecological Economics and Sustainable Development: Selected Essays of Herman Daly. https://libgen.rs/book/index.php?md5=03FD75FCC8A6F6B40625790C2FA1D55F https://libgen.rs/book/index.php?md5=03FD75FCC8A6F6B40625790... In particular, Daly notes that when extraction rates exceed replacement, adding additional capital does not increase harvest. This situation has been realised in multiple fishing and marine-hunting activities, with catastrophic population collapse of fish, whale, seal, otter, and dophin populations in multiple instances. Which is to say that your comment is in agreement with the one it responded to, though it highlights where nonsustainable practices emerge, and their consequences: nonsustainability. I'm not finding any readily-available estimates of pre-columbian arctic native populations, though the present Inuit population is about 150,000. I'd suspect that the earlier populations would be lower.
- m463 5y agoI've read that ... strangely ... many "mined out" oil wells have been examined after years and have been found to have been replenished. There are also thomas gold's theories
- dredmorbius 5y agoReferences for the first? If existing wells could be economically re-activated, I've little doubt they would be. Abiogenic petroleum formation has effectively no empirical support. Biotic origin has massive supporting evidence, including plate tectonics and fossil remains.