4 ms·
Smil's point was more that it is possible to control a tremendous amount of energetic capacity and consequent power (industrial, economic, financial, political,
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Smil's point was more that it is possible to control a tremendous amount of energetic capacity and consequent power (industrial, economic, financial, political, ...) that literally comes out of a hole in the ground.
This also has implications when considering EROEI --- energy returned on energy input.
I mentioned the First Oil Well, Bahrain. It produced at 70,000 bbl/day (not 80k as I'd stated earlier). Typical oil well casing pipe is about 12" in diameter, let's call that 30cm, giving a wellhead area of 700 cm^2. Let's call that 0.1m^2 just to make the maths easier.
That is roughly 55GW/m^2 of continuous energy throughput.
Solar power delivers about 1kW/m^2, 10 MW/hectare, or 1 GW/km^2. Effectively, that's typically achieved for only about 1/3 of a day. I'm not factoring that into the discussion which follows.
The 55 GW of the First Oil Well are equivalent to the peak incident sunlight falling on a region 55 km^2 in area --- about 7.5 km (4.6 mi).
The net solar PV generation is a very small fraction of that, typically less than 10% net efficiency, so you'd need to expand that to 550 km^2, or 23 km ( 14 mi) on a side.
(San Francisco is 11km / 7mi square.)
Yes, oil fields are far larger, they're also far less prevalent, and unevenly distributed. Sunlight tends to be much more evenly distributed.
The notion that there's more than adequate solar energy arriving on Earth is attractive, but potentially dangerous given various factors:
- 2/3 of sunlight falls on oceans rather than land. Capturing this would prove extraordinarily difficult.
- Net of conversion, we'd do well to capture 10% of the incident energy.
- Transmission and storage further reduce energy. Transmission is surprisingly efficient. Storage has proved quite challenging.
- PV solar infrastructure has a lifetime of ~20 years. Put another way, 5% of infrastructure assuming no growth would require replacement each year.
- There are ecological impacts to very-large-scale land-use changes.
- The human population is continuing to grow, and is anticipated to do so through the end of this century.
- Roughly 5 billion people would like to achieve at least an approximation of a Western standard of living.
The US standard of living, based on ~100 quads (quadrillion BTUs) per year, and 330 million people, is about 10 kW.
The global standard of living, based on ~500 quad/yr and 8 billion people, is about 2.3kW. That's an average, and for a huge population, the net energy rate is a fraction of this.
At a US standard of living, 10 kW/person translates to 2,400 quad/year, 4.4 times greater than total present consumption.
At 0.1 kW/m^2, this is the equivalent of 802,000 km^2.
Or about 895 km on a side.
Since I mentioned net production is about 1/3 of nameplace capacity, we actually need 3x the area. So: 2,700,000 km^2, or 1,600 km (1,000 mi) on a side.
That's ... large. But not entirely infeasible.
In truth, population is projected to grow through ~11 -- 16 billions by 2100. And there are other factors which would further diminish net delivered energy. I suspect the global average per-capita power consumption by 2100 will be somewhat below 10 kW/person.
- zaroth 5y ago10kW isn’t a quantity it’s a rate. Do you mean 10kW of demand 24/7/365 because that’s roughly 7200 kWh a month which is high by I’d say 20x?
- dredmorbius 5y agoYes, it's a rate. This isn't household energy consumption, it's per capita energy consumption. Take the 100 Quad (quadrillion BTU) total annual energy usage of the US and divide by the 330 million population, and convert the result to kW: You have: (100 quad/year) / 330 million You want: kW * 10.131338 / 0.098703643 The net power consumption for each American is 10 kW constant. That's about 10 electric hair dryers running 24/7/365. It accounts for all energy usage --- domestic/residential, transportation, commercial, and industrial. As well as lost (waste) energy. And yes, it's a lot. The 2021 actual total US energy consumption was 97.3 quad. So I'm about 2.7% high. That's still 9.9 kW constant though. https://flowcharts.llnl.gov/ https://flowcharts.llnl.gov/
- zaroth 5y agoGot it! Not household use but total national energy usage divided by population. It’s per capita energy usage but I hesitate to call it per capita consumption. Consumption would probably want take into account the massive trade deficit, and so its even higher!
- dredmorbius 5y agoConsumption would probably want take into account the massive trade deficit, and so its even higher! That would be correct :-/ The true raw material footprint of nations 03 September 2013 https://web.archive.org/web/20130906063246/https://newsroom.unsw.edu.au/news/science-technology/true-raw-material-footprint-nations https://web.archive.org/web/20130906063246/https://newsroom.... The material footprint of nations Thomas O. Wiedmann [email protected], Heinz Schandl, Manfred Lenzen, +3 , Daniel Moran, Sangwon Suh, James West, and Keiichiro Kanemoto-3 September 3, 2013 | 112 (20) 6271-6276 | https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1220362110 https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1220362110 https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1220362110 https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1220362110