8 ms·
> Increasing pop politics seemingly shoe horned into everything I'd turn on :( I know this is a tangent but it’s always sad to see representation treated as i
by Spivak 5y ago
> Increasing pop politics seemingly shoe horned into everything I'd turn on
:(
I know this is a tangent but it’s always sad to see representation treated as inherently political. Like this is the first time in my life I’ve ever seen mainstream shows portray wlw relationships. Or shows portray the reality of how common and casual sexual assault is. Or characters that that struggle with depression as more than just an emo/goth archetype.
I get that in some ways people tune into media to escape from all that but they become a comfort when they show your struggles and it turns out okay in the end.
- rchaud 5y agoThe implication being that anything outside of the anodyne mainstream of cable TV must be a concerted effort to brainwash the public. Netflix has many problems, the big ones being that they lost old shows like The Office and Friends, which hurts retention. And they also kill off promising new shows after 2 seasons to save money on renegotiating cast contracts. If you read comment sections however, you'll get a very different idea. The problem is that Netflix is "too woke" and consumers are revolting. Never mind the fact that Netflix is a global network with millions of customers around the world, and thousands of shows from multiple countries.
- WalterBright 5y agoThere's only so many times you can rewatch The Office and Friends. It can't be a major ongoing revenue source. > brainwash This has been going on forever. Check out "The Brady Bunch". Every episode revolves around a heavy-handed moral lesson. Go back even further and you've got the Hayes Code. Hollywood has always seen itself as morally superior to the rest of us, and hence entitled to preach to us. Though with all the scandals emanating from Hollywood, one wonders how they hold on to that moral superiority.
- ngc248 5y ago>>> Though with all the scandals emanating from Hollywood, one wonders how they hold on to that moral superiority They all seem to have their own personal Reality Distortion fields
- mhh__ 5y agoYou'd be surprised (or not). Personally I find it utterly bizarre but a few people I know literally do just watch the office and friends on a loop. Quality (UK) Vs quantity (US) eh.
- WalterBright 5y agoBizarre, true. When I want moving wallpaper, I'll put on a "cab ride" from yootoob.
- sidm83 5y agoThere may be some truth in the "too woke for normie crowd" allegation. Earlier this year, much before the bad news went global for Netflix, Reed Hastings said this about experience in India during an earnings call: "The great news is in every single other major market, we've got the flywheel spinning. The thing that frustrates us is why we haven't been as successful in India. But we're definitely leaning in there," The general opinion in India is that unlike Prime Video India and Disney Hotstar (Disney Plus' Indian avatar) which created a lot of good local content which served the interest of masses and hence achieved success, a lot of Netflix' local content mostly served the tastes of a sub-segment of the well earning, well traveled elite crowd (read "woke") from the bigger cities like Mumbai, Delhi and Bangalore. Apparently this was because the local producers came from the same group and were not tuned to the tastes of the country at large (or even the affluent segment at large). Many of them have since been fired and Netflix India has also gone ahead and reduced monthly subscription for the standard plan to only INR 199 and a new mobile only plan for only INR 149 (~ USD 2). Has not made much of a difference in the past few months though. Ref : https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-60108294 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-60108294 https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/business/netflix-slashes-its-india-pricing-now-available-at-rs-149-per-month-7822511.html https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/business/netflix-slashes-i...
- solarhoma 5y agoIt becomes a problem though when shows are catering to what 1% (or less) of the population looks like or is diagnosed with. This is what people are getting upset with. Representation is fine. But when every new show you turn on has half of the cast as a trans person, a non-binary person, and a whatever else it gets old. It gets old when historical shows and films have distorted facts or figures to, again, fill some quota. Having people in key roles where they would have never been introduced to those parts of the world at that time. Or, shoehorning some form of sexuality into a historical figure for no reason other than to check a quota box.
- dillondoyle 5y agoGen-z identifies as 20% queer. Each new generation is more willing/able to live their truth. Wouldn't surprise me if we land somewhere around 25-30%. In large part thanks to representation in shows and movies. The us is rapidly diversifying too in terms of race, yet still even more under represented in media. Glaad says only ~10% queer characters on broadcast, and was a decline from previous study. Specifically comparing streaming netflix had 155 queer characters and HBO max 71. You do the math on the massive amount of original content on netflix compared to hbomax. The world doesn't look like HN's demo. [1] https://www.glaad.org/sites/default/files/GLAAD%20202122%20WWATV.pdf https://www.glaad.org/sites/default/files/GLAAD%20202122%20W... [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/14/arts/television/tv-lgbtq-glaad.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/14/arts/television/tv-lgbtq-...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- user3939382 5y agoGen Z isn’t the world. US lgbt pop is 7% according to Wikipedia and that sounds high to me, maybe college kids experimenting with their identity in response to woke culture. I’d guess it’s more like 3-4%
- Spivak 5y agoOh come on, are you really going to look up data about populations expecting it to be low, and then because it doesn’t conform to your world view make up some reason why it must be wrong? And the point about Gen Z is that this is where we’re heading. Millennials are 10% lgbt and growing, Gen Z is around lgbt 20% and growing. My all time favorite concert was Girl in Red who sold out a 5000 person venue in less than 30 minutes packed with young queer women in a red state. This is way way bigger than casual experimenting in college.
- imgabe 5y agoThe whole idea of representation was that minorities were unable to enjoy media because it didn't contain characters that looked like them or that had life experiences that they could relate to. So Hollywood bent over backwards to shoehorn in representation everywhere they could and now they find that the majority of people don't like these shows and movies that are all about people who don't look like them and have experiences they can't relate to. This is surprising somehow? Personally, I never had a problem enjoying a good story regardless of how different the characters are from me, but it seems a lot of people only want to watch things about themselves. The studios also seem to put a lot more emphasis on checking the correct boxes rather than telling a good story.
- zmgsabst 5y ago> So Hollywood bent over backwards to shoehorn in representation everywhere they could > The studios also seem to put a lot more emphasis on checking the correct boxes rather than telling a good story. What you’re describing is the paternalistic racism that Democrats have never confronted, in Northern and Coastal cities. A charitable interpretation is that people don’t like racism: - anime is popular; Korean TV and films are popular; Chinese movies are popular; Bollywood movies are popular; etc - treating race as a defining characteristic is not, as in Hollywood People want a good story where the culture and people are faithfully represented in a reasonable way. They detest products which treat the race of the person as defining or which “paint by numbers” with race. That is, people on average are rejecting Hollywood because it is more bigoted than they are.
- op00to 5y agoI’m willing to bet, however, that most people that have ever been on tv look just like you, though. Even in the last 5 years, most people on tv look just like you.