35 ms·
Netflix’s big power clash and rivalries behind the crash
- WalterBright 5y agoNetflix is always recommending to me the same shows, day after day, week after week. I've passed over them many times. When will Netflix give up on them show me something further back in their catalog? This seems like a no-brainer to me. I get bored with scroll scroll scroll to look past them.
- birdyrooster 5y agoI think they are banking that you will stop scrolling and maintain your membership for exclusive releases.
- WalterBright 5y agoComcast does the same thing. They have a catalog of 4000 movies. If you're browsing, the only way is to start at the beginning and scroll 4 at a time. You'll give up long before you get to the bottom. It would be lovely if they'd just offer a "random sort" as an option.
- birdyrooster 5y agoSad that my movie collection is larger than Comcast or Netflix and I am just a pleb. And yes random sort with 6k movies is pretty crazy
- xenator 5y agoProbably you are more enjoy scrolling than watching. I realized it for myself when I bought a lot of games but never "have time or mood" to actually play them. Sometimes this also happens to content on Netflix. I don't have enough cognitive power to process another setting or just not feel entertained by a show in the middle of it. Lucky I have my wife and sometimes follow her recommendation because she is so excited about this stuff, so I want to share her emotions. Wrote this and feels like I sound a little burned out.
- alickz 5y ago> I realized it for myself when I bought a lot of games but never "have time or mood" to actually play them. When this happens to me consistently it is nearly always depression killing my desire. Although it's never obvious in the moment that's the case, it just feels like I'm not in the mood. Obviously I don't know anything about you or your situation, but if you're consistently not in the mood for things you used to enjoy it's worth considering if you're depressed (or burned out as you said). Depression is not always obvious when you're in the middle of it, and it's not always "woe is me I want to die". Of course could be many other things in your situation you would know better than I, your comment just reminded me of myself and I wanted to share my experience with it.
- ilrwbwrkhv 5y agoApple should buy Netflix and combined they should focus on only few, extremely high quality shows.
- ghaff 5y agoWhy would Apple buy Netflix to do a few high quality shows? That's pretty much (to a degree) the strategy Apple is already following.
- brimble 5y agoWhat should happen, if we're doing "shoulds", is that it shouldn't be permitted for one company to own both distribution and production, nor for such companies to create long-term exclusivity agreements with one another.
- onionisafruit 5y agoIs there any country that forbids this?
- brimble 5y agoUntil very recently (a year or two ago?), the US didn't allow film studios to own movie theaters. Hadn't for something like 70 years. That was due to antitrust action over a situation pretty similar to what's happening with streaming services.
- bin_bash 5y agoit seems to me this market has loads of competition without silly regulation like this getting in the way
- ss108 5y agoInterestingly, competition is worse for consumers in some respects here. It's resulting in fragmentation of the market such that people are too many services for 1-2 shows each
- AlbertCory 5y ago> One of Holland’s last projects for Netflix was The Queen’s Gambit, an expensive period piece that sources say was mocked as “Holland’s Folly” by some in-house. According to sources, Bajaria and her staff were dismissive and even unpleasant to the team that worked on it. What a hellscape to work in. I got on Netflix very briefly, just to watch that show. I can't think of any reason to get back on.
- ghaff 5y agoOh I loved The Queen's Gambit and thought the format was perfect too. However, I can easily see why a producer might have passed on a pitch.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI dislike this format because it makes a 4 hour story into an 8 hour story where 4 hours of it is showing the character in some type of inebriated state. I think flight attendant did this too, and the only reason I can think of is to pad their statistics and it being cheap to film those sequences. But it just ends up boring me. And all the content producers are doing it. I tried Severance on Apple TV+, and I had to stop after 4 episodes because nothing was happening, and this is supposed to be a critically acclaimed show. The new Batman movie was excruciatingly long too. I miss my 100min stories from the early 2000s and before.
- brundolf 5y agoDifferent strokes I guess; I thought Severance was great. I didn't even notice the sequences you're describing, but I guess in hindsight they added flavor/gave me a mental break to process recent plot developments
- lotsofpulp 5y agoSeverance does not have the drunk/high sequences, but it was just crazy slow for me. I might also just be an atypical watcher, but it still feels like a lot of shows/movies are a lot longer than they used to be when I was a kid, and yet the extra minutes do not give me any extra enjoyment. Or maybe I am just getting old and turning into my dad.
- ghaff 5y agoThis chart [1] was making the rounds a while back. Whether you totally agree with its methodology or not, it certainly suggests that many people consider a huge swath of Netflix' content average at best. And for someone like me who doesn't watch a huge amount of video, that's not a great look. Tastes differ of course but my tastes aren't that out of the mainstream. And I'd rather a streaming service had a modest number of high quality shows than a whole lot of meh. [1] https://twitter.com/loudmouthjulia/status/1516794978105794560/photo/1 https://twitter.com/loudmouthjulia/status/151679497810579456...
- whoisjuan 5y agoThat graph isn’t showing that. Sure, Netflix produces way more content than competitors but they also have more shows in the far right (outstanding and exceptional) than their competitors.
- dfxm12 5y agoRight. I don't care about the shows/movies I don't want to watch on a streaming service. I only care if there are enough shows/movies on there I do want to see.
- bawolff 5y agoI also don't want to spend large amounts of time researching what i want to watch. If there is one good show with poor discoverability burried under a mountain of crap, that is still a product failure.
- brimble 5y agoThe ratio of OK-or-worse to good-or-exceptional sure appears to be a less favorable for Netflix than the others. Though people's rankings seem crazy to me. Apparently just producing a Star Wars thing and not totally shitting the bed in the process counts as "exceptional". Then again... yeah, that's kinda true, I guess. From a certain point of view. Still, better than nearly all shows on all those services? Yikes. I dunno about that.
- sytelus 5y agoThis is great insider reporting! Most people have no clue how shows gets selected and blame “wokness” for troubles at Netflix. In reality, the cost-cutting high-volume risk-averse leadership took over initial leadership of opposite nature. Transition from “ gut-driven, risktaking, maverick culture” to “prudent and frequently indecisive” is exactly the story of many other areas. Well put.
- skippyboxedhero 5y agoThis isn't "insider reporting". If you don't how the media works, when the article says "Sources close to Holland" or a "Holland loyalist"...it is Holland (usually journalists will make an effort to disguise that, but the precise events being "quoted anonymously" here make obvious that the main source for the story was one person i.e. when the "anonymous" source quotes a conversation that occurred with two people in the room...it is obvious). There is no real analysis, it is just execs sniping at each other and trying to make sure future employers think it was someone else's fault. On the subject, the problem with Netflix was that they tried to have it both ways. They seemed to think they could significantly increase output without decreasing quality. So saying that the failure of the new strategy is prudence ignores the fact that reckless spending got them into this position...bankruptcy tends to force prudence, but that is ex-post...prudence is not the cause of bankruptcy. I think this should indicate that problems with NFLX are slightly more fundamental. I am sure they have the capacity to produce great shows. Look at their debt, look at how much capital they have committed to production...you can produce multiple "best ever" shows, and it won't get you out that hole.
- ketzo 5y ago> They seemed to think they could significantly increase output without decreasing quality. An executive is quoted, on their strategy, as saying “We succeed if 1 in 10 shows is a hit.” I think it’s pretty clear they didn’t think they were pumping out pure winners.
- subsubzero 5y agoAgree with this assessment, Cindy Holland is bitter she was pushed out and reached out through "channels" to deliver her own take on events. Its not really reporting just highlighting a power struggle from an individuals viewpoint(Cindy). If the events mentioned in the story are in fact a cause of NFLX's decline is another story. People were forced inside(globally) during the pandemic and consumed alot more media than ever before in history. The quality of shows at NFLX has gone down considerably the past 2 years. NFLX pushed a show that alienated alot of people with Cuties. Friends and other hit shows left NFLX. Inflation has hit a 40 year high and gas and food are expensive, people are cutting costs and NFLX seems like an easy cut. Would Cindy have stopped all of the above events? Maybe the quality issue but costs(under her) seemed steep, who can say? I think no matter who is at the top NFLX would have suffered in some way. If Ted had chose Cindy instead of Bela Bajaria we would have a similar article talking about Bela's sources and how Cindy's excessive spending and smaller show lineups are killing NFLX.
- mattboardman 5y agoThis seems particularly well sourced for pretty intimate events. There's also a lot of spin in certain parts that tells a one sided story.
- dec0dedab0de 5y agoIf anyone from netflix is reading, the reason I don't watch as much as I used to is because of the automatic previews. I used to just leave netflix open all day and randomly pick things when I felt like watching. I can't do that anymore. Though I do really appreciate how easy it is to suspend/cancel. I'll be back for stranger things, but who knows how long I'll stay.
- paxys 5y agoYou can turn them off
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dmitriid 5y agoAnd then you can't play trailers. Though Netflix insists on playing on random clips instead of trailers anyway.
- the_common_man 5y agoWhat does trailers have to do with auto play?
- dmitriid 5y agoWith auto play enabled Netflix would show a random clip from the movie/show. In about 5% of the cases they would play the trailer (which is really what you want). If you turn auto play off, there's no way to play anything. You have to just start watching.
- barbazoo 5y agoI don't think so, you can still go to "Trailers & more" and watch the trailer.
- 5y ago
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoNetflix created the bad but successful template that the other streaming services followed: own the streaming platform and the content -- and now they're suffering for it, and so are consumers. As a consumer, I don't want to have 5 different streaming services with subs coming and going depending on what shows happen to be in season. I'd rather choose to subscribe to one of various streaming services that in turn let me source content from many providers and just let me pay per show or whatever (maybe after a free first episode or something, I dunno). In a way I kind of feel bad for Netflix, because they were there "first" and for a long time had maybe one of the more "open" (in terms of content) services. Now the studios are in control again. It's not good for the consumer.
- dmitriid 5y ago> Netflix created the bad but successful template that the other streaming services followed: own the streaming platform and the content Netflix was basically forced into this template when major content owners started pulling out and creating their own services.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoSure, absolutely, I could probably rephrase to make that clear, I don't think it was their "fault" per se, but a result of the asymmetrical power relationship between content producer and streaming service.
- dmitriid 5y agoContent producers have all the power in such relationships, unfortunately.
- stefan_ 5y agoThis seems to be the most obvious explanation. There is simply competition now where there was none before. A good learning moment here for HN, where we mistake lengthy in-depth blog posts for an unassailable tech advantage when in reality this stuff is kinda commodity.
- boredumb 5y agoA pile of mid tier content that i'd flick through before exiting out after an episode Automatic previews Increasing pop politics seemingly shoe horned into everything I'd turn on Horrible comedians that were akin to ted talks/lectures or made for people who don't actually enjoy stand up comedy. Documentaries that were more ideological than interesting Signing and hiring ex politicians Searching is a chore and recommendations are nearly never useful. (Just to have some toggles around metadata like language/genre/public rating and a text box to fuzzy search through titles and descriptions?) I cancelled my subscription a few years ago and I get more mileage and enjoyable content out of free apps like tubi, pluto, vhscast and peacock than I had in a long time with netflix.
- colechristensen 5y agoI likewise would like to watch a nature documentary once in a while which didn’t feel obligated to mention impending doom at least once every five minutes. If anybody had anything to say about said doom above a fifth grade level, I might watch that too.
- lawik 5y agoI was surprised how hard it was to find nature documentaries that mostly showed nature and animals and not talking heads very concerned about the planet. I'm all aboard but it wasn't what I wanted to show my 1.5 year-old. I wanted her to see cool animals. This was across a few platforms, had to really dig.
- edmundsauto 5y agoI would also like to see a Nike documentary that focuses on the cool shoes and doesn’t mention anything about the child labor used to make them. Not covering a recant and pertinent fact is also an agenda.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- avl999 5y agoOne thing I appreciate Netflix for is atleast they are willing to do the bare minimum and give me 720p on Linux. I am also an Amazon Prime subscriber but Amazon is literally forcing me to pirate their shows because they refuse to serve more than 480p on Linux. Was trying to watch Jack Reacher last weekend and the quality was so bad that it was probably 360p, gave up after 3 episodes and ended up torrenting the season, which is a shame because I want to support shows I watch so they get more seasons. In 2021 streamers should be supporting atleast 1080p for Linux but if they can't I can live with 720p like Netflix does, but serving 480p is just disrespectful and looks awful on any decent size modern monitor.
- jra_samba 5y agoOf course the irritating thing is that all of their consumer devices are internally Linux as well, including the FireTV's that happily stream Amazon Prime in 4K. So it isn't like they can't do it, just won't.
- Arcanum-XIII 5y agoBut all consumer device were vetted with quite often drastic DRM. Those that no one will install on their computer given the choice. So it's Linux technically, but not in spirit, hence a different proposal.
- vladvasiliu 5y agoBut you don't even have that choice. I'm OK with running binary blob drivers on my Linux machine (if they work). And since I'm running a reasonably recent GPU, it could be conceivable that all decoding is done on the GPU itself and sent directly to the monitor, which supports HDCP.
- lrem 5y agoI begrudgingly accepted this sad future and got a smart tv. The software is as awful as I assumed it will be. But every single platform trusts LG and just streams 4k without me even needing to keep up with updates.
- barrenko 5y agoNetflix does not have a defined product.
- clpm4j 5y agoCan this really be classified as a "crash"? They're a 20+ year old company, a hugely successful business, and likely to continue to be a major player in both entertainment & tech for the next decade+. Perpetual high growth is a fantasy.
- mgh2 5y agoIt is a crash because the stock tumbled far below pre-pandemic to 2017 levels, with still more bad news to come...
- abvdasker 5y agoWhat's the bad news to come?
- mgh2 5y agoMmm...assuming current stock price already includes forward outlook of 2M additional loss of subscribers this quarter (-200k past quarter), but momentum is usually sticky https://www.ft.com/content/c3b63a57-0d46-41c7-8f6b-c61d388db039 https://www.ft.com/content/c3b63a57-0d46-41c7-8f6b-c61d388db...
- bogomipz 5y agoSure they've been a publicly traded company for 20 years but most of the first 10 of that they were mailing DVDs to people. They've really only been in the original content game since 2012 so just about 10 years. And the latest incarnation of Netflix a full-fledged Hollywood studio operating in a very capital intensive, competitive and increasingly crowded environment is even younger still. The history of Hollywood is littered with companies that have gone out business. It wasn't long ago that MGM one the oldest(1924) and most storied names in Hollywood went bankrupt.
- fullshark 5y agoStock is down 70% year to date!
- moomin 5y agoThe thing is, their strategy is fundamentally flawed. They understood they needed to build up a library, but their metrics chased subscriber uptick that said “Only the first two seasons matter.” So, with a couple of exceptions they’re building up a large library of cancelled shows.
- deckard1 5y agoexactly. They lose the trust of subscribers. What happens then is that no one wants to watch a new show because it's going to get cancelled. So people wait until more seasons or the show is entirely out. Which is also increasingly common. People are getting tired of waiting a year between seasons, when there are entire complete shows they could binge watch right now. So they wait. Which means Netflix never sees the season 1 viewers they need. Some shows just don't hit their stride until two or more seasons in. Parks and Rec had a really rough first season.
- philjohn 5y agoI'm STILL salty that Teenage Bounty Hunters got cancelled.
- ggm 5y agoI'm just here to say how nice the tcp/ip tuning team is. The content may be a battle zone but their internet technology is focussed on tcp optimisations which make sense. They have amazing instrumentation in the kernel, and they give back to FreeBSD. I don't work for them, I have met them. Nice guys.
- qq66 5y agoNetflix had great streaming tech years before anyone else did. I wonder why they decided that the right move was to compete on content. If they had just set up a platform where any content provider could sell their content (on a monthly or one-off basis) for a small cut like 15%, they might have become the default "TV store."
- stingraycharles 5y agoThey had to focus on content as they feared other studios would start their own streaming studios and took their content away (as mentioned by the article). What you’re describing would not work in the movie industry, which is very contract and license heavy.
- asdff 5y agoThey had to. Consumers don't care about streaming tech; in their eyes all the services are the same levels of fine. They do care about content and once content producers started rolling their own streaming services, cutting Netflix out, and pulling their content, they had to do something to keep their shelves looking stocked.
- ralusek 5y agoThis isn't true. I and many others really had a hard time with a few. HBO Go, for example, particularly at the beginning, was too shite to use. Had tons of content I wanted, and I never used it. But I agree that once you pass "good enough," there are diminishing returns.
- hef19898 5y ago
- gniv 5y agoAll these discussions are very US-centric. Netflix made more money from outside US than US (4477M vs 3350M) and membership went up in Asia. I agree that the US-made content on Netflix is not as good as it used to be, but the foreign content is quite good. Plus virtually every country except US is used to read subtitles, so shows have a big audience. For example a lot of great shows nowadays come from Korea, and I assume they are much cheaper to buy than the US-made shows.
- sen 5y agoWe get a lot of Korean Netflix content in Australia and I’ve quite liked it. It’s something different we’d never get through our own TV networks or the mostly-US streaming networks we have access to.
- WalterBright 5y agoI wish Netflix would buy TCM, so I don't have to wait a week to watch the next Noir Alley.
- shp0ngle 5y agoAh, I wondered when exactly Netflix original content changed to "mountain of trash". The article pinpoints it quite well.
- nowherebeen 5y agoThey chose quantity/cheaper over quality/expensive. The problem with this approach is that people don't stick around for low quality shows. It would have been more expensive for the immediate term to spend more on shows and earn less profits. But now, they spend less and lose even more. Once they are on this downward spiral, its going to be really hard to compete with Disney. Netflix may really go the Blockbuster way.
- prawn 5y agoDo they know off the cuff which will be quality? The commission-in-bulk strategy reminds me a bit of YC expanding the startups in each batch, to maximise their chances of unearthing diamonds. And might be hard to avoid when you are increasingly targeting multiple continents.
- nowherebeen 5y ago> maximise their chances of unearthing diamonds By diamonds, I am assuming you mean popular shows. Quality and popular tend to be correlated, but not always. Bad quality scripts can sometime be successful (e.g. Fast and Furious / Transformers, but these are not cheap either), but I think those are usually the exception and not the norm. Given 1 high quality script vs 2 low quality scripts with the same total price, I would rather fund the high quality one. Although the high quality script has equals less choices for the customers, I know there is higher likelihood they might like it and would come back to watch again and again. There is almost certainly not the case with low quality scripts. The script writing is the only variable that they can control. So why give it up just to throw a bunch of shows on the wall and see what sticks? You already know the script is not good, even if it is cheap. What are the chances your customers will like it?
- alimov 5y agoI agree with a lot of the criticisms of content on Netflix, but I also think that it was necessary. I don’t think it would be possible to pump out only A++++ content to fill their catalog in the time that they have been able to grow their offering. So now that they do have a ton of content, they can scale down new releases a bit and focus on providing better content rather than more content. I think they had to push out as much as they could because of all of the new competition in the area. Now they have a large collection of Netflix originals to keep some subset of subscribers entertained, and going forward they can focus on growing that subset by introducing better quality originals. If they focused solely on quality, a subscriber might only stay for a few months or a year or so before they could watch everything (edit: everything “worth watching”) and unsubscribe. Just my opinion. Edit2: as part of the growth of competition in this arena, Netflix was having certain shows pulled (an example that comes to mind is The Office)
- ijidak 5y agoCan someone tell me what the 94% match in Netflix means? I don't understand what in the world XX% match is all about. My biggest complaint about Netflix is there is no simple 5-star rating. Or something like that. I'm not going to watch a trash movie that is a XX% match to some bogus criteria. Even if that match is 100%. Thus, unlike Prime, I explore very little with Netflix. I manually look up the rating in IMDb before I watch anything. (Which is why I prefer Prime. Since IMDb is built in.)
- imgabe 5y agoRoughly, people who liked movies you liked, also liked that movie. If you like Star Wars and Raiders of the Lost Ark, but you haven't seen Ghostbusters, and 94% of people who have seen all three movies and liked the first two also liked Ghostbusters, then it's 94% likely that you'll also like Ghostbusters. I'm sure it's much more complicated and nuanced, but that's the general idea.
- fastball 5y agoThat should be the idea, but the match score never worked out well for me personally. Specifically at some point it seemed like Netflix started weighting all their own content much more heavily than others so the match scores on Netflix shows were much higher, even though obviously Netflix producing a show has almost no bearing on whether I'll like it or not.
- nickjj 5y agoI've never liked a single video on Netflix and I've had them for a number of years. I think with no direct likes the rating system starts at 99% and might also take your viewing history into account to adjust it over time based on third party likes from people who watched similar movies to you. I'll often see a bunch of new Netflix original movies come up with 95-99% matches as soon as they're released but then over time they drop to 64% and eventually never come up again. I wish it started at 0% and worked its way up because the current implementation is really misleading. It's trying to get me to watch something because it's a Netflix original they want to push but really their plan backfired and now I don't watch any Netflix originals unless I know for sure I want to watch it beforehand.
- Traster 5y agoI find the whole premise of this article kind of funny. I don't think Netflix is in anywhere near as much trouble as they're making out. I don't think the content strategy is anywhere near as important as they're pretending either. What Netflix is running into is just normal business - they're very large, so it's possible they are at the peak of their TAM in lots of markets, their competition is strong because they're so successful other people have allocated capital to compete in the market, and the macro-economic trends have gone from incredibly favourable to less favourable. This has nothing to do with Lupin or Queens Gambit. It's an interesting story, quite clearly heavily informed by Holland, but just because Hollywood types don't like Netflix coming in and stopping on their industry doesn't mean Netflix is actually doing the wrong thing, and I don't think the current turn around in the stock price tells us anything about that strategy.
- jeffrallen 5y agoTheir children's content is excellent, and prevents my kids from seeing ads.