13 ms·
24 year old student lights match: Europe versus Facebook
- apitaru 15y agoIf I could drive one thing into the collective minds of FaceBook users, it would be this: "If you're not paying for something, you're not the customer, you're the product being sold" *Andrew Lewis
- Permit 15y agoHonest question: Why is Facebook governed, at least in part, by European law? The reason I ask is that the United States has a lot of trouble enforcing its copyright laws abroad (which is good in my opinion), but Facebook and Google seem to bend to European laws regarding privacy and transparency.
- ruethewhirled 15y agoI think its to do with Irish tax laws being more favorable to large international companies EDIT see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_Arrangement http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_Arrangement
- _delirium 15y agoWonder if tech companies will start to think twice about that particular tax dodge, given the subjecting-yourself-to-EU-jurisdiction tradeoff it involves.
- rmc 15y agoRemember for EU companies, there are limitations to what (personal) data you can export outside the EU. So if FB & Google & Amazon etc. were to 'leave' EU, then lots of EU companies would be legally unable to use their USA services.
- radicaldreamer 15y agoThe answer in a nutshell is that they have servers and offices in Europe.
- lambada 15y agoIt's to do with whether a company has a 'physical presence' in a country. Facebook has a large presence in Ireland as a company, and Ireland is part of Europe. It's less to do with a country enforcing it's laws abroad, and more to do with companies setting up a physical presence in a country.
- tonfa 15y agoIt doesn't have to be a physical presence. Some EU countries block gambling sites without a physical presence (for example, a court can decide that the french law applies, depending on a number of parameters, like among others the availability of translations)
- beforebeta 15y agoThe linked video (in german) explains this. Apparently Facebook has a registered HQ in Ireland (presumably - as someone mentioned in another thread - for tax purposes). Since it is a registered business in Ireland, it is subject to all Irish and many applicable European laws (one of which is data privacy). The 24-year-old Individual feels it's against his data privacy rights that Facebook retains deleted messages. Personally I find his arguments a bit flawed - e.g. in one instance apparently he objects to the fact that Facebook knows when he was ill because he can do a quick CTRL-F on the text "ill" (german: krank) in the text he received from Facebook. My question is - isn't he the one who posted that content in the first place? Secondly, he complains that deleted messages are still retained by Facebook. Could that just be a referential integrity constraint - since most messages require 2 or more parties. Therefore, although he deletes the messages, the other party still has the message in their inbox. Therefore, Facebook cannot simply delete the message. Furthermore, since the message has him linked, even if he deletes it from his side, Facebook needs to retain that information on their side. You know the best solution to protect yourself from Facebook's data privacy policies - get off Facebook or at least be cautious when you post! I personally love the service and think one should be smart about what they post on publicly accessible social networks since that data remains for eternity!
- d0mine 15y agoPeople say if you don't want facebook to know anything about you, then you shouldn't post there. So others reply that it doesn't matter that you didn't give the data to facebook, one of your friends might. So now the statement is that if you don't want facebook to know anything about you, then you shouldn't tell your friends, colleagues, etc. anything - after all, they may enter it on facebook. </quote> http://slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=2481922&cid=37750358 http://slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=2481922&cid=37750358 If you visit pages that might contain Like button then facebook will know about you even without your acquaintances.
- dantheman 15y agoWatch all the tech companies leave Ireland due draconian European laws. I don't understand, why all law must be proactive. Let people try and experiment, let norms evolve. Why must we prelegislate things, wait until facebook or someone else starts doing horrible things before passing a law.
- tonfa 15y agoI don't think comparing copyright enforcement, and companies offering a service targeted to citizens of foreign countries is really relevant. As far as I know, what matters is that Facebook targets EU citizens (by having subsidiaries in the EU, by running ads, by explicitly accepting users from abroad etc.) I think you'll find some pointers at: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conflict_of_laws http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conflict_of_laws
- grecy 15y ago>The reason I ask is that the United States has a lot of >trouble enforcing its copyright laws abroad. Note this is entirely different when a company has a presence in the US, any of the servers are in the US, or even if the DNS servers are in the US.
- w1ntermute 15y ago> If you use Facebook, records of all these visits are linked, through cookies, to your Facebook profile - even if you never click the “like” button. Ghostery[0] prevents this, IIRC. 0: http://www.ghostery.com/ http://www.ghostery.com/
- akanster 15y agoAlso, if you already have AdBlock Plus for firefox installed, try this: http://lifehacker.com/5542041/block-sites-from-using-your-facebook-login-with-adblock-plus http://lifehacker.com/5542041/block-sites-from-using-your-fa... Prevents non-facebook domains from knowing when you are logged into facebook.
- cwe 15y agoMan I want a copy of my report. Considering they're supposedly all about eliminating privacy, shouldn't they want to make all this accessible?
- loungin 15y agoTo advertisers, not you.
- zheng 15y agoAccessible to advertisers, not users. They don't particularly care if you can find the set of friends who visit sports blogs on odd numbered Tuesdays and like chili fries.
- runaway 15y agoIs the "Download a copy of your Facebook data." link under Account Settings not the data you want? It looked complete to me.
- cwe 15y agoIt's a start. It does not include pokes, events threads, posting on other peoples profiles, etc: lots of the stuff that it sounds like these Europeans get.
- rmc 15y agoI've never used either, but remember that this legal disclosure has to be everything that they have on you. For the "Download your facebook", facebook get to decide what to include.
- anigbrowl 15y agoHmmm, I'm an Irish citizen, although I live in the US. I have often wondered at the weakness of US data protection laws, and this might make for an interesting study.
- X-Istence 15y agoI've seen friends try that are currently studying in the US, but are originally from The Netherlands, and Facebook responded saying that they are in contract with the US company, and thus are not eligible to receive said data. I personally plan on getting a VPN in the UK/The Netherlands and asking for my data, to have it sent to my grandparents address. Hopefully at that point they will send me the data as requested. I am technically a Dutch citizen since I still have my Dutch passport, but I live in the United States with a green card.
- twodayslate 15y agoIf you don't like them storing your data, then don't go on the site. They won't have it if you don't give it to them.
- estel 15y agoOne might still wish to benefit from some of the undoubtedly useful aspects of Facebook without needlessly surrendering various rights to their data as enshrined in European law.
- nordsieck 15y agoOne might wish to eat one's cake and have it too. Not all wishes are reasonable.
- rhizome 15y agoAre you referring to Facebook wanting to operate under US laws in other countries?
- estel 15y ago"Expect this company that I'm dealing with to act within the law" is almost always reasonable.
- nordsieck 15y agoYes. But it is not reasonable to expect every (legal) service to be offered in every legal/regulatory environment. This is not to say that Facebook will not or should not offer its services in Europe. Simply that there are possible legal environments where Facebook would be legally allowed to offer its services, but where it would be economically unsustainable for it to do so... and that it is often quite difficult to understand these sorts of effects ahead of time. Edit: clarification
- Natsu 15y agoOne of the complaints is that they have profiles on people who are not users. They can get other people to give them information about you. Specifically, have a look at complaint #2: "Shadow Profiles. Facebook is collecting data about people without their knowledge. This information is used to substitute existing profiles and to create profiles of non-users." http://europe-v-facebook.org/Compalint_02_Shadow_Profiles.pdf http://europe-v-facebook.org/Compalint_02_Shadow_Profiles.pd... http://europe-v-facebook.org/02_Shaddow_Profiles.zip http://europe-v-facebook.org/02_Shaddow_Profiles.zip
- nfm 15y agoI wonder what's in place to prevent you requesting a CD of someone else's data.
- pyre 15y agoAt the beginning of the saga, I remember reading something about them requiring a fax of identifying papers.
- count 15y agoMaybe it's my unenlightened American perspective coming out here, but why is this a big deal? You chose to use the Facebook service, you chose to provide this information to them, and you chose to agree to their terms of service. Facebook isn't a government agency, it's a private organization that has persuaded people to give it armloads of data about themselves, and uses that for whatever completely legal purposes it so desires. It's not like they are taking out credit card applications or anything on behalf of these users. What is it about this completely voluntary relationship that is so inherently evil? I really don't get the harsh kickbacks and complaints against things like "Facebook keeps records of pokes even if the user 'removes' them". So what? How is that something that is litigation or 'outcry' worthy? How much of this data is just persistent in the system because they operate at a scale where data deletion or removal just cannot feasibly be accomplished[1]? Much like google - 'we dont delete anything'. Why should they legally or otherwise be required to verify something is actually deleted, instead of simply ensuring it's inaccessible in their system? Why is nobody complaining about NTFS or ext3/4 not actually zeroing out the file space when you delete something, and instead just 'marking it deleted' or 'removing the pointer in the inode'? How is that fundamentally any different at all? Please, educate me, because I really don't get it.
- OoTheNigerian 15y ago"You chose to use the Facebook service, you chose to provide this information to them, and you chose to agree to their terms of service." Likewise, Facebook chose to operate under the laws of the various lands in which it operates.
- chc 15y agoI'm honestly unclear about this: Does Facebook actually have any operations in the EU, or does it merely not ban Europeans from accessing its servers in America?
- pyre 15y agoIt has a headquarters in Ireland. Apparently Ireland is a popular tax haven. Ireland is also part of the EU... Oops!
- ckinniburgh 15y agoThere are a few comments here questioning why it's really important to actually delete data. This is a serious issue for a few different reasons. If I believe that I've deleted something, then there should be no way for anyone to retrieve the information -- I no longer have to worry about security breaches at Facebook (internally or externally), Government warrants, or Facebook accidentally reinstating the information. As for the idea that Facebook is to big to effectively delete information, that's unacceptable. If you're that big and you can't figure out a way of routinely deleting data then you need to find a way of collecting more data or making your data easier to delete, or not giving the user the 'delete' option. There are a number of alternate verbs which describe the process they are going through, none of which are as clear or commonly understood as 'delete', but which are more accurate. 'Hide' and 'make data invisible' come to mind. I don't have as much of a problem with the saving of messages which others will also read, but on deleting a Facebook account, this could be handled more gracefully if the user wishes. This is a more difficult problem to solve, which would require Facebook itself to store messages with under the covers public key cryptography which sounds like the type of thing they wouldn't do.
- kisielk 15y agoFacebook could make data removable by users if they engineered their site to allow that. The problem is that they haven't, and it appears they've in fact done the opposite. We need data protection laws like this to put the onus on the service providers to make giving users control of their data a priority.
- Lukeas14 15y agoDeleting data in a complicated system is not at all a trivial task as data integrity can easily be impacted. So Facebook's excuse that they can't delete data at their scale is probably not just PR speak. For them there is no downside to keeping data besides a minority of their userbase complaining. Meanwhile the downside to deleting data is potentially huge and a mistake would be nonrecoverable. I wouldn't expect them to start deleting data anytime soon unless legally required to do so. I do agree that the verbage used on their site should more accurately reflect the actions occuring on their backend.
- lukasb 15y agoThe "excessive processing of data" claim, if valid, would seem to make any social networking service a non-starter: "Facebook is hosting enormous amounts of personal data and it is processing all data for its own purposes. It seems Facebook is a prime example of illegal 'excessive processing'."
- DanBC 15y agoSome data-processing is an intrinsic part of running a social networking site. That's not being complained about. What is being complained about is the secret data collection and processing that's happening without the user's permission or knowledge - visiting a page with a like button gives data about the user to Fb even if the user doesn't click the button. Fb then use that information to do stuff. Since the user has no way of knowing if a page he's about to visit will have a Fb like button or not; and the user probably doesn't realise that Fb will gather the data with no user interaction on the button; that seems like excessive collection and processing.
- VladRussian 15y ago"So many people applied for their own CDs that Facebook had to send out an email indicating it was unable to comply with the requirement that it provide the information within a 40 day period." Has Facebook considered using benefits of modern technology and delivering the requested info electronically by, for example, setting up a web site where users could access/browse/download the requested info and may be even let some other users, like their friends, to access the info as well? :)
- grecy 15y agoThe law requires they send a hard-copy. It's one of the little loop-holes.
- mirkules 15y agoThis is a standard customer service trick - externalize the cost (time) and minimize business losses (disclosure of data). Make an action difficult enough to discourage more casual users but stay within the legal limit. This is why checks take up to 14 business days to clear (to make a quick buck in those days), why you have to wait 30 minutes on hold "for the next available representative" (to discourage you calling in), and why most rebates are mail-in (in hopes that you will forget).
- shabble 15y agoI seem to recall (although perhaps folklore) that the GPL condition "[...] by the Corresponding Source fixed on a durable physical medium customarily used for software interchange." was a response to someone trying to get away with offering the source as hundreds or thousands of printed pages to discourage people
- RexRollman 15y agoHack, look how difficult Facebook makes it to delete your account. When I deleted mine a while ago, I only found the link to do it after finally searching their online help (it wasn't in the account management section), and even then there was a waiting period before it actually deleted. Of course, in light of reading about this, I sometimes wonder if Facebook really deleted the information contained in my old account.
- MikeGrace 15y agoWill be really interesting to see what comes of this but I can't help but think back to http://geekandpoke.typepad.com/geekandpoke/2010/12/the-free-model.html http://geekandpoke.typepad.com/geekandpoke/2010/12/the-free-...
- namank 15y agoI don't understand WHY Facebook chose to not reveal the rest of the data on the first attempt. Let it be a sign of good faith! FB is not alone in this, obviously sites that I visit track usage and what not. If its a best practices for business thing (do not bend over more than you have too) then C'MONNN! This is the post baby boomers age, bro - the digital age. Get with the show, be good. Why would they delay sending others the data? In fact, I would use this opportunity to gain the trust that left the building with the long lost battle about privacy (settings) Of course I presume all the data they collect is within the bounds of legal and ethical lines.
- 0x12 15y agoI really hope that nobody here is actually surprised that that is the true purpose of the 'like' button. After all, the users get just about nothing out of it, if you like something that much an email will do just as well (to the select number of people that you think your liking a particular subject will appeal to). The main winners are the publishers (they hope for some more traffic) and facebook (by extending your profile, not just by being able to count the 'likes' but also by the lesser value of those sites that you simply visit). Like buttons and other third party javascript are a huge vector for privacy violations, basically any website that places any kind of third party javascript on their pages is giving full control over the privacy of their users to the party that hosts the javascript component. If that party also happens to host a service that a large number of people have signed up for at some point in the past, and that they are possibly signed in to right this minute the potential for abuse is staggering.
- sek 15y agoIt was so successful because these useless "Social Media Experts" needed a metric to justify their job. Nobody asked the techies if this could be a trojan horse.
- modeless 15y agoSo much outrage, and yet so little actual harm. These people may mean well but they are ushering in an era of government regulation of the internet that will (perversely) entrench incumbents like Facebook.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- nihilocrat 15y agoThere is a cool German word for companies like Facebook or Google, which collect mounds of information about their users: Datenkrake : http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datenkrake http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Datenkrake
- alexhawket 15y agoIs that the modern reference to octopus or the legendary reference to the mythic kraken sea creature?
- ordinary 15y agoThe German word for octopus is indeed "Kraken", and looking at the pictures in the article linked by the GP, I'd bet on the former, rather than the latter.
- loup-vaillant 15y agoThere's a cultural connotation to the octopus: its tentacles reach everywhere. So, a likely translation for "Datenkrake" would be something like "data umbrella". We could also try "Big Data", in reference to "Big Pharma".
- access_denied 15y agore cultural connotation: a Krake is also a type of a monster, that is somebody who intents evil.
- namank 15y agoDOWNLOAD a copy of your personal data here: https://www.facebook.com/settings https://www.facebook.com/settings Click 'Download a Copy'
- saturdaysaint 15y agoWhat's the deal with "Europe" vs Facebook? Is anyone else catching a little bit of nationalism?
- X-Istence 15y agoEurope has strong data protection laws that the US does not have, so it is entirely apt to say that it is Europe vs Facebook. Could you say that it is Max vs Facebook, yes, you'd be just as right, however these rights affect every single person in Europe that is browsing the internet and comes across a site with a Facebook like button.
- Jach 15y agoI find it funny and a little sad that a single US corp is being pitted against an entire continent. We've all known some corps and individuals have had more wealth than entire countries but this is something different. Eventually I think we'll see the EU become more and more like the Federal US.
- jarek 15y agoYep, I am, and it's somewhat disturbing. But I suppose it's a bit catchier than "European Union's Privacy Regulations vs Facebook".
- redthrowaway 15y agoIn Canada, you should be able to request this information under Section 23 of the Personal Information Protection Act [1](in BC), or PIPEDA elsewhere. [1] http://www.leg.bc.ca/37th4th/3rd_read/gov38-3.htm#section23 http://www.leg.bc.ca/37th4th/3rd_read/gov38-3.htm#section23
- jhferris3 15y agoSo, I'm going to make a statement that I think is important for anyone reading anything on the internet. WHAT IS THE PROOF! (also known as 'consider the author', 'read the article', etc) Now I can't say with certainty that any of these claims are false or true, but it occurs to me that a lot of these claims are based on what facebook MIGHT be doing with your data. I decided to take a look at the complaint and attachments for the shadow profiles case, I don't see any evidence that these shadow profiles exist, just that there is the possibility that they exist. And for those that will inevitably say that proof isn't necessary, that means you don't trust facebook. If thats the case, there is nothing they can do to prove to you what they're doing is legitimate short of open sourcing their entire stack (and even then, you must trust that what they're running == the source they give you). So either trust that what they're saying is true, find evidence that they're doing something they aren't supposed to, or stop using the service entirely.
- alexgartrell 15y agoDisclaimer, jack works with me at Facebook, so he's going to be biased (as will I). However, it is true that there appears to be a circular dependency between speculation and outrage here, and that probably isn't the greatest thing in the world. All I can do is tell you to keep looking for evidence (seriously, keep us honest), and we will earn your trust again some day.
- jhferris3 15y agoCorrect. I thought that was in my profile info (it wasn't has since been updated). That said, I was going out of my way to make my comment as general purpose as possible (I think evaluating the bias of anything you read on the internet is generally a Good Idea(tm) )
- drats 15y agoYour boss has called his users "dumb fucks", doesn't delete data about them that he says he does and is tracking all their website visits and more. Can you perhaps see past your big salary to how people are, in general, worried? Given the number of lies already told and weird stuff already done why shouldn't people believe new rumours? Watch the video report he was emailed, by your company, huge amounts of data. Much of that data was supposed to be deleted.
- samirahmed 15y ago1200 pages of information? Why does Facebook as a service (omitting privacy) not have the ability to search through comments etc... they need to get there shit together
- dhughes 15y agoFunny, I had to take a two hour mandatory company privacy training course today and the gist of it was the company could only use personal information customers allowed for the purpose it was intended to be used for. The personal info can't be used for anything else other than what the customer agreed to. When the information is no longer required or whatever it was used for is finished the information has to be securely destroyed, until that point it has to be stored and guarded as securely as is possible. Anyway after all that they proudly said we have a TRUSTe rating and showed other sites which also have it one of which is Facebook. Something seems wrong with that picture.
- vetler 15y agoI remember learning about the law that organizations have to provide all information stored about individuals upon request when I was a kid in school. We even sent out letters requesting information as an assignment. I sent to a bank, I think. Not very interesting back then, but it would certainly be a lot more interesting now!
- tcarnell 15y agoRegarding deleted data: there are clearly two concepts of 'deleted' a). deleted in terms of the application/user interface (ie, it is no longer visible) and b). deleted in terms of physical removal from all permenant storage. Clicking on a button labelled "delete" does not necesarily imply one or the other. For example, if I "delete" an email in google it is not deleted, it goes to my 'trash/bin' folder - is this also a breach of the law? and are we sure which definition the "Delete Forever" button is using? ...I suppose its up to the terms and conditions to define this.
- jritch 15y agoI think there’s a few points here and although some replies have very valid points others completely stray from the issues that "Europe vs facebook" is making. 1. Facebook has bases, and operates, in Europe. Thus they MUST abide by our data laws. This means that, under our European laws they MUST supply ALL information they have on people. Currently this is not being done and as such they are breaking the law by not providing ALL information they hold on people. If they want to have HQ's in Europe and want Europeans to use their service they must abide by our laws, this is regardless if we as a user decide to sign up or not. These laws cannot at anytime be waived REGARDLESS if it is indeed us as Europeans deciding to use their service. 2. Quite simply, if they offer the option of "deleting" posts/likes/mails, then they should do just that, delete it. Anything other than this and they are quite blatantly misleading users. 3. They SHOULD NOT be gathering information on ANYONE who does not use their service. This is not legal and should not be allowed to happen. The old saying "knowledge is power" comes to mind, but these "big corporations" should not be able to gather data on people who have no connection what-so-ever to their company/services. Britain recently has been rocked by such scandals as phone hack etc aswell as the big argument about Google cars collecting data from wireless networks that they were not authorised to do so from. Is facebook gather information on people who have no connection to them any different from hacking someone’s phone and listening to their messages? Or any different from a Google car passing your home and gathering information for your wireless network? My opinion is that it isnt any different. New of the world have had to pay out massive amount of compensation to the people who could prove that their phones were hacked. It is a breach of privacy and more importantly, THE LAW. Google also had to agree to delete all information gathered by its Google cars as this was deemed to be illegally collected. Facebook should be made to adhere to our laws if they wish to be present in our countries. Thus they should be made to supply ALL information held on people who make subject access requests, they should delete all e mails/post/likes that have been deleted by the original (or any recipicants) and should also delete ALL information they have gained about people who no longer/have never used their service. I joined facebook when it first came out as would say i was pretty young and naive, I didnt read all the agreements etc and certainly didn’t know what I was signing myself up for (alot of which has not came out until recently). If facebook want to use the argument that everyone who signs up agree to their t&c then they should respect the fact that only peoples over the age of 18 should be allowed to join in Europe. (this is currently not the case with children as young as 8 and their pet dogs having profiles).... Facebook cant have it all their own way and must respect the laws of the land, PERIOD.
- 01PH 15y agoDoes anybody know when the story hit Reddit for the first time? Not quite sure if this wasn't on HN first.
- poisonbit 15y agoIn Europe, consumers are persons and have rights. In some issues, consumer rights have the same importance than big-fat-company. I don't know if in other continents everybody is pro unscrupulous vendors. Greetings.