5 ms·
Why the wheels of human history seemed to turn faster for some
- twofornone 5y ago>According to Galor, diversity can inhibit economic growth by decreasing social cohesion Surprised to see this acknowledged on Washington Post. >migration distance, geography, disease, culture and political institutions. It's a shame that modern anthropology is dead set on downplaying the influence of culture and politics on national success. I think part of the push back against the horrors of WWII has manifested as an overly anti-nationalistic slant among our institutions, at the cost of objectivity in social sciences, among other casualties.
- Agamus 5y ago>>According to Galor, diversity can inhibit economic growth by decreasing social cohesion >Surprised to see this acknowledged on Washington Post. Agreed, but it is argued as an aspect of an average: "According to Galor, diversity can inhibit economic growth by decreasing social cohesion, but it can also increase growth by promoting specialization and innovation; therefore, regions with an intermediate level of diversity had the highest levels of economic development."
- RappingBoomer 5y agoyeah, it could be said that much of science has been tainted and even crippled by mandatory adherence to certain dogma/narrative talking points
- jay_kyburz 5y agoI assume that diversity here means when you have rival cultures in proximity to each other you are actually at war all the time, and your people are fighting and dying instead of growing in peace and property. You have to spend time making armies instead of houses. Having played a lot of Civ, I can only assume that's what he means.
- shrimp_emoji 5y ago>playing Civ instead of Europa Universalis and thinking you understand geopolitics
- dc-programmer 5y agoDon’t political scientists study those questions? Social capital and trust, rule of law, comparative analysis of institutions are some things I know social scientists study. Anthropologists probably avoid analyzing the causality between culture and national success for the same reasons historians de-emphasize it. It’s an impossible dimension to tease out. Countries don’t exist in cultural silos untethered from history, geography, and foreign relations. If anything the first is the flawed approach. The models that come out of it frequently fail to capture the complexity of reality. And that’s why so many data informed policy interventions fail. And on the topic of applied social science. I don’t think attributing success to culture would even be useful because a culture in one place (or time) can be successful, but would be disastrous in other contexts. On a personal level I would be distrustful of any attempts of the government to optimize culture. Culture is not the domain of Caesar.
- throwaway4aday 5y ago> Technological innovation caused increases in food production, which caused higher population growth — until the additional mouths to feed canceled out the productivity gains, bringing living standards back to subsistence levels. Is this accurate? My understanding was that the cap on human population levels had more to do with survival rate of childhood for which nutrition is only one of many factors. Didn't we see a larger increase in population due to advances in medicine eliminating many childhood diseases? I'd say that this reasoning is rather tenuous, if food production were the only limit on population growth then we should have seen booms in population level with each agricultural advance rather than the slow, linear increase up until the industrial revolution. > the value of human capital reached the point that parents chose to have fewer children and invest more in their upbringing This also seems to run counter to evidence from currently industrializing societies where reduction in infant mortality and increases in education are the big drivers of dropping fertility rates. It isn't that they see more value in their children, it's that they aren't dropping like flies so you don't need to have 8 kids just to make sure 2 make it to adulthood and can help support you as you get older. > Because a subset of a group is likely to be less diverse than the whole group, populations became more homogeneous the farther they traveled This is just lack of genetic diversity and I don't see what it has to do with the following sentence > diversity can inhibit economic growth by decreasing social cohesion, but it can also increase growth by promoting specialization and innovation because that kind of diversity has more to do with appearance, language, culture, religion, etc. than it does with genetics, physical appearance being the only one of that mix that is determined by genetics. > In Galor’s account, Europe escaped the poverty trap in the 19th century because of increased investment in education and the decline of the gender wage gap. This is the first I've heard of it.
- RappingBoomer 5y agoyeah, the article is full of de rigueur dogma & talking points, so much so that it verges on word salad
- malfist 5y agoI stopped reading about three quarters of the way through, it seemed to be so much drivel. It seemed to be dangerously verging on "14 words" nonsense. Hyper concerned as it was about women earning a paycheck instead of making babies and declining birth rates in genetically homogeneous regions.
- tablespoon 5y ago> With the Industrial Revolution, according to Galor, the value of human capital reached the point that parents chose to have fewer children and invest more in their upbringing. Longer life spans made human capital even more important. As women’s wages began to approach those earned by men, it became more costly for them to leave the workforce to have children, further reducing birthrates. This demographic transition allowed technological progress to vastly outstrip population growth, producing our present world of material plenty. I wonder if some of this is the demographic equivalent of having a fantastic time feasting on your seed corn. IIRC, pretty much all these populations are at sub-replacement level, and some by quite a significant amount.
- danuker 5y ago> feasting on your seed corn Assuming the ratio of the average salary to the average pension in my country stays the same, and that I will work for 40 years and retire for 10 (which is the expected case in Romania, but I expect I'll live longer), the return of the national pension fund is -78.6% of what I contribute. There's no way I will get a meaningful pension, especially given the fact that the country is undergoing depopulation. I have to manage my own wealth.
- jltsiren 5y agoI don't think there is anything particularly new in that. For most of human history, cities relied on migration to maintain population levels. Both because cities were so unhealthy places to live in and because people had better things to do.