8 ms·
> The issue is that the decision was not final Wasn't it? From the descriptions I've seen of the process, the decision draft starts circulating once the decis
by masklinn 5y ago
> The issue is that the decision was not final
Wasn't it?
From the descriptions I've seen of the process, the decision draft starts circulating once the decision has been taken. The language can be softened or hardened, but from what I understand here Roe would be dead regardless.
I'd think the possible changes would have been with respect to the "blast radius" aka the references to (and explicit targeting of) Obergefell, Lawrence, Eisenstadt.
- aw1621107 5y agoAs far as I know the decision isn't necessarily final after the initial vote following arguments. A prominent example of this is National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius, where Chief Justice Roberts was reported to have initially voted to strike down individual mandate of the Affordable Care Act (a.k.a. Obamacare), but later changed his mind.
- not2b 5y agoYes, this is exactly what I meant when I said that justices have switched sides before. I understand that there was a draft opinion overturning the ACA when Roberts switched sides, though I'm not certain how complete it was.
- cudgy 5y agoIn fact, knowing how and why these opinions change during this phase could be quite illustrative and interesting. Would also be interesting to see if Roberts received a windfall during his deliberations. Insurance companies surely appreciate the individual mandates … it’s the closest thing to printing money they could achieve. Earlier today I heard someone state that historically the Supreme Court rules in favor of the large corporate interests. My thought at the time was it did not make sense, since technically supreme court justices are beholden to Noone. What explains this bias on the part of the Supreme Court, if it truly exist?
- cortesoft 5y agoThey are beholden to no one AFTER they are appointed. They are only appointed, however, if their views match the people who are doing the appointing, who are beholden to many.
- cudgy 5y agoYet there are numerous examples of justices not rendering opinions meeting their appointee’s expectations. Many of these justices serve for decades which is plenty of time for any human to change their viewpoints.
- rascul 5y ago> They are beholden to no one AFTER they are appointed. Article V of the US constitution makes them ultimately beholden to the states. It describes how the constitution can be amended. Such an amendment can possibly threaten the supreme court. Seems very unlikely to happen, though.
- cortesoft 5y agoCongress also has the power to impeach a justice
- datavirtue 5y agoThey are beholden to the people and the people's perception of their credibility. At any time we can dispel that court--or just stop taking it seriously. They are terrified of being waved off. Imagine all the politicians that would jump on board if they saw a large enough groundswell (energized voting bloc) calling for the "non-constitutional illegitimate third branch" to be disbanded in favor of state courts. We are witnessing the same with the "election fraud" Trump populist fervor right now.
- fsagx 5y agosupreme court justices are beholden to Noone. What explains this bias on the part of the Supreme Court, if it truly exist? The people who nominate and confirm them may very well be beholden to any number of interests. Lower federal judges are also appointed for life. It would be logical that those who nominate and confirm would select judges with a record that aligns with whatever issues they (and the ones they are beholden to) find important.
- lumost 5y agoThe leak itself is enough to shape legal precedent, it's made clear that the majority of the court believes that "Roe was deeply flawed". The only way for this to change would be for the court to explicitly rebuke the arguments in the leaked draft in the new majority opinion.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoI don't think "precedent" works the way for first sentence seems to think it does. The final decision will be precedent; drafts are not. And, "the majority believes that Roe is flawed" is interesting information, but it also is not any kind of precedent. Decisions are going to depend on the details of the case before the court.
- Maursault 5y agoPrecedent occurs when a decision is challenged and upheld. If Roe is struck down, that will not be precedent, but overturning precedent, since Row was challenged and upheld in Casey. For a decision overturning Roe to become precedent, it would need to survive at least one future challenge.
- rayiner 5y agoOverruling a case isn’t an all-or-nothing thing. Upholding Mississippi’s 15-week ban would simply require the Court to acknowledge that Roe’s protection of elective second trimester abortions turned out to be an error that continues to defy international norms and attract public opposition. Overruling that part of Roe doesn’t require a meandering rant about abortion rights writ large.
- ss108 5y agoInternational norms?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Buge 5y agoAccording to [1], in 1973, Roe v. Wade said abortion is legal US-wide at 27/28 weeks and earlier, then in 1992, Planned Parenthood v. Casey said abortion is legal US-wide at 22/23/24 weeks and earlier. I'm not exactly sure whether the ages are inclusive or exclusive or how rounding/truncating works with the ages, which is why I made them fuzzy with the slashes. According to [2], there are 203 countries listed. I'll look at "on request" abortions. * North Korea is marked "unclear". * 6 allow abortion at 23 weeks (24 weeks is also an identical list): China, Colombia, Netherlands, Singapore, South Korea, South Ossetia * 2 additional allow abortion at 22 weeks: Iceland, Vietnam * 191 ban abortion at 22 weeks. * Australia ranges from completely prohibited to no limit, depending on region. * Canada ranges from 12 weeks and 6 days to 24 weeks and 6 days depending on region. * United states ranges from (ignoring the recent laws that prompted the ongoing cases) 20 weeks to no limit depending on region. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roe_v._Wade#Planned_Parenthood_v._Casey https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roe_v._Wade#Planned_Parenthood... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abortion_law#Independent_countries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abortion_law#Independent_count...
- ss108 5y agoInteresting, thanks. I feel like nobody brings up other countries when it comes to abortion, but the context seems pretty helpful (as it is for most issues, I suppose). Esp since, looking at Australia and Canada, people get on and tolerate internal divergences, and maybe we should too. I suppose is it's because they accept that their federalism is much less centralized than ours.
- dillondoyle 5y ago100% I think this is blind wishful thinking. Roe was dead the second Republicans got their justices. How could one know about the history and beliefs of these justices, hear their questioning, see who has pushed them onto the bench, read their speeches, hell seen that their significant other believes in q crazy, and yet somehow think they'll change their mind or find some reasonable compromise. You are correct in the danger of this blast radius. This is TERRIFYING to me. I'm skeptical here that this leak any differences though in that: How can they make this ruling otherwise? What changes could they make that don't set a scary and dangerous precedent? without just flat out telling their truth that this is a religious decision and giving fetus' rights greater than actual living humans. Their argument rests on their narrow view of "deeply rooted in the Nation’s history and traditions." If that is the logic, as you say, what is left to protect states from outlawing gay marriage, contraception, anal sex, and SOOOO much more. What moderation could be added to this draft on this fundamental issue? It's disgusting to me that they argue they are making some ethical stand to overturn 'egregious' decision equating this to Plessy, using this historical traditions argument. We all know what the constitution actually did say and even worse the practices of the time. What does history and traditions even mean too. It's obvious to me and not even slightly veiled. Hint it probably doesn't include indigenous history or the history of any non-white, wealthy, christian males in power, nor any traditions created or changed within the last 50 years. Because if the standard is the status quo of 200 years ago, they will either let a few extreme states say no to basically every right we have lived for the last 100+ years OR they will just be hypocritically veiling their true reasoning.
- Buge 5y ago>this is a religious decision and giving fetus' rights greater than actual living humans. How is that? There still would be no federal law against killing fetuses, whereas there is a federal law against killing born people.
- Brybry 5y agoIt doesn't really have to do with a law (which is a large part of the issue, the dysfunction of congress forces these controversies). It's about unenumerated rights and interpretation of liberty under the 14th Amendment. > nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law So in the past the court said liberty includes a right to privacy, which also includes things like having a right to buy and use contraceptives (Griswold v. Connecticut). This was extended to include women having a right to an abortion, with some qualifiers (the right was not unlimited, it said states did have some interest in protecting both the mother's health and fetus health). The current court decision says that, while those other unenumerated rights have been found, they're different because they don't involve an "unborn human being".[1] Thus they imply that a few cells (under some state laws this would be from the moment of fertilization) have rights that supersede (or at least conflict) with an actual person's right to have their liberty protected from the State. The Louisiana state legislature has a bill introduced right now that seems to make abortion homicide, both for the mother who receives the abortion and anyone who administers it. [2][3] [1] https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/21835435/scotus-initial-draft.pdf https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/21835435/scotus-initi... [2] https://www.legis.la.gov/legis/ViewDocument.aspx?d=1276214 https://www.legis.la.gov/legis/ViewDocument.aspx?d=1276214 [3] https://www.theadvocate.com/baton_rouge/news/politics/legislature/article_da97f936-cbf8-11ec-b752-c346925ba701.html https://www.theadvocate.com/baton_rouge/news/politics/legisl...