24 ms·
Mechanical Watch
- zerop 5y agoWho had invented mechanical watches?
- quantum_state 5y agoA wonderful article … Thanks!
- ocimbote 5y agoThis article is everything I want the Internet to be: high quality contents and high interactivity so that the matter is more "palpable". This is peak Internet, huge congrats to the author(s).
- DangitBobby 5y agoI have favorited just a handful of things on this site. TFA and another one on the same blog about internal combustion engines. Prepare to be wowed. https://ciechanow.ski/internal-combustion-engine/ https://ciechanow.ski/internal-combustion-engine/
- CryptoPunk 5y agoI think it also points to compensation for creators, so that they can dedicate their time to creating their works, mattering. I think him being on Patreon, and knowing he can count on income as long as he keeps creating this kind of content, contributes to the quality of what is produced. I believe when someone no longer needs to concern themselves with financial consequences for taking time out of their day to create content for the public, and knows that there is reciprocity in the relationship between themselves and the rest of the world for whom they produce content, they can dedicate themselves more completely to their craft.
- 1-6 5y agoCertainly a labor of love. Well done!
- hexo 5y agoThere are no images, like, why? :(
- hexo 5y agoYour downvotes didn't bring images back on site.
- natly 5y agoThis guy deserves way more patreons than he has: https://www.patreon.com/ciechanowski https://www.patreon.com/ciechanowski
- JohnBooty 5y agoWell, he just got one more. What an absolute treasure.
- xjconlyme 5y agoThis one is insanely good.
- noduerme 5y agoReally cool stuff. The author has come up with a wonderful way of really imparting an understanding of how things work. I loved the one they did on internal combustion engines. If there's one thing I'd love to see, it would be a similar breakdown of manual and automatic transmissions.
- _fat_santa 5y agoThere's something magical about mechanical watches. Maybe it's just knowing that you have this perpetually winding machine on your hand (in the case of "automatic" mechanical watches). Also knowing that the thing will last forever, take care of it and it will probably outlive you. Can't say that about an Apple Watch. If you want a good mechanical watch that won't break the bank I suggest picking up a Seiko SKX (though prices have been going up), a Vostok Amphibia (might be hard with the ukraine conflict) or a Timex Marlin.
- zppln 5y agoAn SKX isn't gonna outlive you and once it fails they'll just replace the entire movement anyway. Mechanical watches are still indeed cool though. :)
- ghostpepper 5y agoAs an owner of an SKX who doesn’t know much about watch longevity, how long can I expect it to last? Are there other automatics that will outlast a person’s life? It still blows my mind that you can take the SKX scuba diving, especially when you factor in the price. This may sound cynical but as I get older and see the world becoming more and more digital and connected, I find myself appreciating analog, mechanical things like watches and old cars more and more.
- criddell 5y agoIf you are going to take your SKX diving, you probably want to have a watchmaker pressure test it once in a while and make repairs as needed. The seals dry out and water will get in.
- jstanley 5y agoI think maintenance requirements are overstated. I wore a relatively cheap (~£120) mechanical watch continuously for about 8 years, and never had a single problem with it. I only stopped wearing it about 2 years ago when I finally bought a smartwatch. It still works fine, I just don't wear it except on special occasions. If your watch is a sizable investment then maybe you care about maintenance more, but otherwise I wouldn't worry that it's going to stop working in short order.
- avestura 5y agoThis man is marvelous. Even though I know how top-notch he is at writing interactive blog posts, he surprises me with his quality every time I open his new blog posts. Bartosz is a huge inspiration for me.
- Liron 5y agoHe’s elevated technical explanations to a delicious art form
- leeoniya 5y agosame with https://www.youtube.com/c/3blue1brown https://www.youtube.com/c/3blue1brown
- pcurve 5y agoI don't make this comparison lightly but I'm reminded of Leonardo DaVinci. How much talent does one need to create something like this? It's not enough to be just 'good' at engineering, design, watchmaking, and writing... you have to be amazing at it ALL of it. AND have motivation to do it. I'm just in awe.
- lupire 5y agoYou don't have to be watchmaker, just need to read and learn about it and understand it.
- moffkalast 5y agoI read the GPS one a few months back, he absolutely amazingly explained the whole thing to a depth I never would've expected.
- aliljet 5y agoThis may not be the most valuable comment, but my goodness, the quality of this writeup and it's interactive descriptions of complex mechanical components AND their interactions is radically impressive. The treatment of complex topics in deeply visual and partially interactive ways, for me at least, is a remarkably helpful way to learn.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tomtheelder 5y agoI almost couldn't believe the quality of this while reading it. Not just animations, but simulations? That perfectly illustrate the concept being discussed? Incredible. Not to mention the incredibly clear and articulate prose.
- surement 5y agoThe author calling this a "blog post" really undersold it!
- causi 5y agoTrue multimedia is a lost art. We had it back in the 90s when software came on discs and it was a high-density, polished product that combined text, audio, video, and interactive elements on the same page. The internet taking over turned everything back into text, and then as bandwidth grew the only thing we thought to use it on was higher and higher bitrate video. When I was a kid I thought the future was going to be fully-integrated data. Like I would be able to pause a movie and click on anything I was seeing to get more information. Click an actor, get his bio and interviews about the movie and bloopers. Click a vehicle and get its model. Click a special effect and see how it was done or an animal and learn about that animal. Imagine watching Lord of the Rings and being able to instantly read the original lore of any object, location, or character just by clicking/tapping it. Hell, even the smallest things can radically change your experience. Imagine if Wikipedia articles had appropriate background music. I guess there's just no market.
- 5y ago
- herodotus 5y agoMr Ciechanowski's articles are themselves complete works of art. Another brilliant article and collection of interactive animations. My favourite escapement is the detent escapment. I saw a cutout model at the Imperial Science Museum in London. Even after staring at it for ages I could not figure out how it worked!
- nodesocket 5y agoWhat a fanatic writeup. I’ve been fascinated with mechanical watches for what seems like forever. I browse YouTube at night and see collections by Mr. Wonderful and John Mayer (mostly very high end collector grade Rolex, Patek, AP, IWC). I actually splurged and purchased a new Omega Seamaster Professional Diver 300 automatic and absolutely love it. It does have a see-through back making watching the caliber 8800 movement hypnotic.
- tpl 5y agoLove the diagrams. Great write up!
- mettamage 5y agoI hope Nicky Case puts this in his list of explorables :)
- freeCandy 5y agoThere's also a subreddit for aggregating interactive explanations like these: https://old.reddit.com/r/explorables https://old.reddit.com/r/explorables
- 99_00 5y agoHow difficult is it to bootstrap the ability to manufacture mechanical watch parts? It was only in 2017 that China joined the elite club of countries capable of making ballpoint pens. Is it that hard? https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2017/01/18/finally-china-manufactures-a-ballpoint-pen-all-by-itself/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2017/01/18...
- criddell 5y agoThat depends on how many parts you want to make and to what tolerances. https://www.gearpatrol.com/watches/a636135/greubel-forsey-hand-made-1-watch-2019/ https://www.gearpatrol.com/watches/a636135/greubel-forsey-ha...
- WHA8m 5y agoLooks like a fun website to spend a hour or two. Thanks! Regarding tolerances, your OPs article states that they were actually able to produce them before, but not at a satisfying quality. I don't know what a 'good enough' quality is, though. It's a good story nevertheless :)
- alfalfasprout 5y agoVery hard. And it comes at an outrageous price. Independent watchmakers usually go one of four routes: 1) Source a movement from a big manufacturer (eg; ETA/Valjoux or a japanese/chinese movement) and use it as is but design the case/dial yourself 2) (1) but modify the movement adding functionality, replacing parts, or refinishing it to your own standard 3) Designing a custom movement around specialty movement parts from a supplier like Jaeger LeCoultre. They make some of the trickier parts (gears, balance springs). They can also manufacture special parts on a swiss screw machine. 4) Going through a bespoke movement maker like agenhor. You tell them what you want and they have both the machinery to make many custom parts and source the rest from elsewhere. They also provide movement design expertise. Actually machining the watch parts isn't the hard part... the tricky part comes in things like hairsprings and escapements which are made from sometimes exotic materials like silicon. Some tiny watch parts are made using electrical discharge machining which costs $$$$$$$$ as well.
- rabuse 5y agoThat's it, this is gonna make me pull the trigger on a skeletonized watch. I've been wanting one for a couple years, but never really sat down and browsed, but I appreciate the mechanics so much more after reading this.
- vngzs 5y agoIt's like a clear hood on your car. On a nice enough car, it shows the beauty of the engine. But on a cheap one ... Skeleton watches can be uniquely telling of the price of the watch. Worth mentioning, most mechanical watches will have a sapphire back, so when you take them off you can admire the movement privately.
- sebmellen 5y agoJust imagine the utopia that would emerge if all education were conducted through web-essays like this. Bravo!
- tomaskafka 5y agoI believe that for every Bartosz Ciechanowski (huge kudos and thanks to him!) there are 100 similarly abled people, who can't create essays like this, because they need to do something else to keep the lights on. A collective loss.
- elxr 5y agoSounds like something basic income could help alleviate.
- _asummers 5y agoI love 1940s/1950s instruction videos. Here’s one from Hamilton that shows how they work that I really like. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rL0_vOw6eCc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rL0_vOw6eCc
- jagger27 5y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20220504151534/https://ciechanow.ski/mechanical-watch/ https://web.archive.org/web/20220504151534/https://ciechanow...
- beeforpork 5y agoAmazing! He's done it again, I am blown away! Thanks you very much for this unmatched level of documentation quality!
- cbdumas 5y agoThis page got the HN hug of death it seems. Absolutely deserves all the traffic he is getting, Mr. Ciechanowski's blog is an absolute gem.
- KaiserPro 5y agoThis is a most excellent writeup. Its so very clear, understandable, but also precise. A word of warning, diving into watches and clocks can be a time/money sink. If you're not careful you'll end up building something like this: https://www.secretbatcave.co.uk/projects/electromechanical-clock/ https://www.secretbatcave.co.uk/projects/electromechanical-c...
- eggy 5y agoI started with Greg Daniel's masterpiece: Watchmaking. https://www.amazon.com/Watchmaking-George-Daniels/dp/0856677043 https://www.amazon.com/Watchmaking-George-Daniels/dp/0856677...
- dutchbrit 5y agoI was about to post the same book. Pretty much a must have if you get into watchmaking.
- eggy 5y agoMy late Uncle Vic taught me how to repair clocks and pocket watches when I was young. I let it go, and returned to re-learning it with this book. I still dream of completing my first, from scratch, pocket watch.
- anfractuosity 5y agoI've heard of that book before, it sounds really interesting too! Creating your own mechanism sounds extremely complex, is that what you're doing?
- mananaysiempre 5y agoLinked at the very end of the long, long page (which, incidentally, is long).
- wrycoder 5y agoThat is an absolutely amazing book - how to design and make the highest quality watches from scratch. At the time, all watch fabrication was by division of labor, no one made an entire watch from scratch. Daniels also wrote a riveting autobiography. He rose from the most abject poverty to world eminence, largely because of the British guild system. He also collected, restored, and raced old cars. He used to drive his Blower Bentley to his gentlemen's club (!) in London[0]. All this is described in his autobiography. He needed to do business in Switzerland, so he simply drove his restored Rolls-Royce across the Continent. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bentley_Blower_No.1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bentley_Blower_No.1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Daniels_(watchmaker) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Daniels_(watchmaker)
- ThePhysicist 5y agoI was curious how he did those visualizations so I looked at the source code. Turns out he codes everything by hand in WebGL [1]. Absolutely impressive stuff. Source code is non-minified so you can have a look and understand everything as well. [1]: https://ciechanow.ski/js/watch.js https://ciechanow.ski/js/watch.js
- sha-3 5y agoYep, that's why the visualizations do not run on my hardened Firefox. I disabled WebGL.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bananabiscuit 5y agoYou should considering enabling it for this site. I don’t see what the downside here would be.
- sha-3 5y agoAnd it was worth it.
- panzerboiler 5y agoHe does it "the right way™". Use the platform. Don't use any framework or generic library. Go straight to the point and code what you need, when you need it. Don't minify or bundle anything, and let the people who are learning and courious a straightforward way to connect the dots, without forcing them into a github repository with 90% of the code unrelated to the thing and existing just to glue 1000 pieces written by 10000 people together. Every essay by Bartosz is so top-notch and a such breath of fresh air! He gives me hope in humanity and I am immensely grateful for what he does.
- 10000truths 5y agoI mostly agree with you, but I don’t mind minification when appropriate, as it can serve a functional purpose with tangible end-user-friendly benefits (less downloaded over the network = faster response times). But if you want to be friendly to the tinkerers, you could always host both the *.js and *.min.js versions, and have the webpage just pull the latter - anyone who wants the unminified source can remove the “min” part from the URI, while the majority of end users will still benefit from pulling the minified js.
- leeoniya 5y agoi'm continuously astounded by how accurate the Omega Aqua Terra is. it will be within 90s over a 30 day period after 4 years of daily use with no servicing. the fact that something mechanical and so tiny operating at 3.5hz can do this is mind blowing to me. it has a cool [8800] co-axial escapement: https://www.kapoorwatch.com/blogs/through-the-scope-the-omega-co-axial-escapement-for-dummies/ https://www.kapoorwatch.com/blogs/through-the-scope-the-omeg...
- CydeWeys 5y agoIf you want absurd accuracy in a watch powered by mechanical energy (without just resorting to a battery-powered quartz), look into Grand Seiko's spring drive. It's super interesting technology, and the result is a smoothly sweeping second hand (as in it's actually continuous, not merely a higher number of beats per second).
- leeoniya 5y agoyep, i've considered that one; insane engineering for sure. but the watch's aesthetics don't do it for me. also, it does feel a bit like cheating ;), if an EMP were to go off, i dont think the Spring Drive would come out okay like a purely mechanical watch would. another crazy one is Zenith's all-silicon oscillator: https://masterhorologer.com/2017/09/14/zenith-defy-lab-the-worlds-most-accurate-mechanical-watch-equipped-with-a-new-oscillator-that-beats-at-108000-vph-15-hz/ https://masterhorologer.com/2017/09/14/zenith-defy-lab-the-w... https://monochrome-watches.com/zenith-defy-lab-revolutionary-oscillator-technical-review-video-price/ https://monochrome-watches.com/zenith-defy-lab-revolutionary...
- CydeWeys 5y agoTo be clear, there are literally hundreds of different models of Grand Seiko watches that are powered by spring drive that have been produced over the past two decades plus, with wildly varying looks across the range. It's not just one watch I'm talking about here.
- 5y ago
- shepherdjerred 5y agoEvery post from this site is gold. I've learned so much from it.
- marcodiego 5y agoNice! Now show us how a mechanical watch with a 3-axis tourbillon works: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5TveIl2whXY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5TveIl2whXY
- stephenanand 5y ago[dead]
- zander312 5y agoStunning visuals and interactivity!
- anuvrat1 5y agoWords aren't enough to describe Bartosz's work, every one of them is a masterpiece. Twitter: https://twitter.com/BCiechanowski https://twitter.com/BCiechanowski Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/ciechanowski https://www.patreon.com/ciechanowski
- spaetzleesser 5y agoI got this wooden clock for Christmas a while ago: https://smile.amazon.com/ROKR-Mechanical-Building-Supplies-Best-Birthday/dp/B07HSZ9LYJ/ref=mp_s_a_1_5?crid=14TB49Y2YCNVG&keywords=rokr+clock&qid=1651684699&sprefix=rokr+clock%2Caps%2C147&sr=8-5 https://smile.amazon.com/ROKR-Mechanical-Building-Supplies-B... Definitely helped me to understand how clocks work. And it’s fun to watch it.
- FR10 5y agoAs usual Bartosz with another extremely high quality post, I have one question, in this bit: > However, when the driving gear can’t rotate because it’s blocked by the rest of the gear train, the cannon pinion can overpower the friction of that tight fit and rotate on its own. This lets us set time without interfering with the gear train, which could break the delicate parts. How can the cannon pinion (green) both overpower the friction to slide freely and also be attached to the driving gear (blue) when functioning regularly? Does this imply that the driving gear and cannon pinion wear each other out every time you adjust the time?
- boesboes 5y agoWow very comprehensive & well done. If mechanical watches tickle your fancy, there is a ton of watch repair video on YT. I particularly enjoy wristwatch revival (https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCD80T1s2Za4K682CQDGwEKQ https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCD80T1s2Za4K682CQDGwEKQ). A warning though, if you consider to get into that hobby. I tried, it's really hard, expensive (I spend close to €1k and that is with b-quality stuff. Good stuff is 5-10x more expensive.) and can be rather frustrating. Finding parts to buy can be complicated depending on your locale, loosing parts is very easy and destroying parts, even when gentle and careful is par for the course. I hat to put my repair hobby on halt after running out of practice pieces. All now have broken or missing parts. your milage may vary ofcourse :)
- gganley 5y agoLove Marshall's stuff! I also suggest their Magic: The Gathering podcast [Limited Resources](https://lrcast.com https://lrcast.com) for those int TCGs.
- antiframe 5y agoI shared this blog post with him and he said "That's the coolest thing I've ever seen". I can't say I disagree with him.
- germinalphrase 5y agoIf you wouldn’t mind answering a question, how difficult is it to swap a dial/handset/movement set into a different case? I saw a custom mod watch that paired the face/movement of a Marathon navigator with an O&W diver case*. Is a combination I find desirable (as the Marathon bezel is too chunky for my use), but the maker won’t respond to emails. Is it possible that the combination could be “ drop in” or is it likely to require significant modification? *https://westcoastime.com/m16typidivbe.html https://westcoastime.com/m16typidivbe.html
- coredog64 5y agoDepends. The ETA-2824 is a fairly common movement with inexpensive Chinese clones, so dials and hands are reasonably cheap and common. If the target case also uses the same ETA movement then it’s simple: Unscrew the back, remove the crown stem, drop the movement. Assembly is the reverse of removal. Where it gets tricky is if the target doesn’t use the same movement. In that case, I’d just buy an AliExpress watch with the same dial size and an ETA clone movement. Otherwise you have to ensure your target is the correct size and you’ll probably need to 3D print a movement holder.
- elorant 5y agoI'd gladly pay for content like this. It's so informative. I've watched yt channels of people who disassemble and fix automatic watches, but never understood all the intricacies in such detail. This is what journalism, or writing in general, should be about. Explain things and go into details.
- JohnBooty 5y agoThe author has a Patreon, so we really can pay for his content. =) https://www.patreon.com/ciechanowski/posts https://www.patreon.com/ciechanowski/posts
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- JohnBooty 5y agoI am absolutely astounded. This is incredible craftsmanship, on par with mechanical watches themselves. This creator is absolutely among the best at his craft. I lack the words to properly describe my admiration.
- subsubzero 5y agoAs someone who has been into mechanical watches since I was kid, this article is beyond amazing and explains everything about how a watch is powered with excellent interactive diagrams and cool animations. The author should try to go after other areas of mechanical movement like operation of a car or a plane. So well done!
- modeless 5y agoHe didn't do planes yet but he did the internal combustion engine: https://ciechanow.ski/internal-combustion-engine/ https://ciechanow.ski/internal-combustion-engine/ and boats: https://ciechanow.ski/naval-architecture/ https://ciechanow.ski/naval-architecture/ I could post more but just go to the archives and see. Every single one is a treasure and there are few enough that you can read them all: https://ciechanow.ski/archives/ https://ciechanow.ski/archives/
- soheil 5y agoCrazy to see this thing with the spring is constantly rotating so furiously all the time all so just that the second hand would move ever so slowly once a second.
- sarang23592 5y agoWhat an insanely cool demo of the workings. This is so informative. I mostly dismiss such stuff thinking I won't understand it but this one was easy to follow even for me. Loved it
- gjvc 5y agoThis is what the web should be all about.
- nintendo1889 5y agoI always thought a compass that floats in water, and is also a sundial would be neat. Not super accurate but very good for military, offgridders and preppers, wherever there's limited access to power.
- michael1999 5y agoWhat great work. The only thing I had to read twice was how energy is restored to the oscillation. The text doesn't discuss the role of the slope on the jewel fork teeth. But everything else was so clear as to be transparent. What a loving gift.
- tamiral 5y agoThis is such an easy to follow understanding on mechanical movements. WOW! From someone who tinkers with watches all the time and has to explain a simple mechanism over and over I've found my resource to send to friends now.
- chairmanwow1 5y agocached version of the page: https://web.archive.org/web/20220504151534/https://ciechanow.ski/mechanical-watch/ https://web.archive.org/web/20220504151534/https://ciechanow...
- gotaquestion 5y agoThere are many centuries of engineering behind this. I went to the Museum of Horology in Austria. It has examples of the first mechanical clocks, up to today's timepieces. It is fascinating looking at the giant, wrought-iron town clocks that kept shitty time and bent and rusted, and seeing different parts of the clock evolve over the years, especially as engineering & metallurgy improved. https://www.watchtime.com/featured/watch-spotting-at-the-vienna-clock-museum/ https://www.watchtime.com/featured/watch-spotting-at-the-vie...
- rotanibmocy2 5y agoAmazing animations and incredibly well explained. Best ELI5 of a mechanical watch EVER
- muh_gradle 5y agoEnjoyed this one very much. I am hoping to get a blue dial Orient Bambino to wear for my wedding. I've always loved that watch. I'll have to refer to this article to explain the "but why mechanical.." question.
- s3ctor8 5y agoI didn't know I sas going to learn about watch mechanisms today, but I couldn't stop reading!
- moffkalast 5y agoIt's so insane how they figured out all of this. The self winding one way gears are even like a mechanical full bridge rectifier. How was any of this even manufactured at such miniscule scales...
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoThis is breathtaking, couldn't stop reading until finished. It'll be my go-to example of the best possible educational material.
- esaym 5y agoIf this makes you think mechanical watches are cool but you don't really want to wear one.. you can go the other direction. Ebay is full of old mechanical driven (be it pendulum or wound springs) wall clocks that are looking for new owners.
- barbazoo 5y agoI couldn't quite figure it out from the (excellent) writeup but when you wind up the watch, you wind up the barrel AND the balance wheel, right?
- vanshg 5y agoSame question. The balance wheel/hairspring has to be losing energy overtime to friction (however miniscule). Otherwise we have ourselves a perpetual motion machine
- panki27 5y agoThis is mentioned in the article. The pallet fork gives the balance wheel a small push after unlocking, giving it a tiny bit of extra momentum.
- alfalfasprout 5y agoTo add to the other answer, that friction (and the intertia of the balance wheel) is actually factored in when regulating the watch. The pallet fork gives the balance wheel a nudge on every "Tick" then the pallet fork stays stuck until the balance wheel swings around and back and jolts it in the other direction (the tock). Basically a little bit of energy is released from the mainspring via the escapement to the pallet fork to the balance wheel on each tick/tock.
- praash 5y agoThe balance wheel gets a small energy push through the escapement on each tick. The barrel's mainspring has enough force to just kickstart a stopped balance wheel. The balance wheel doesn't really need much "winding" - it's equivalent to the pendulum of a grandfather clock. It's really fascinating seeing this mechanism alive, even in a simple mechanical kitchen timer with plastic gears. When wound up, the balance wheel starts to swing a little and quickly accelerates on each tick.
- sillysaurusx 5y agoDoes anyone know how the author supports themselves? They have a patreon, but it’s not enough to make a living: https://www.patreon.com/ciechanowski https://www.patreon.com/ciechanowski The hardest part for me when doing open source work full time was giving it up and getting a day job. I was fortunate that my wife was the breadwinner, and that I got to see what it was like to be a stay at home husband. I’ve often wished to go back to it. Did the author figure out a way, or is he wealthy? He could also be a Superman, being able to do this with a full time job or contracting work. I spent a few days studying their blog. The work is so good that when I retire, I’ll make a conscious effort to copy their style as closely as possible. It seems like the optimal way to transmit knowledge. I wish there was an equivalent to YouTube sponsorships for blogs. If this had a 3 minute preroll ad, they would be rolling in money.
- wlesieutre 5y ago> I write interactive articles about physics, math, and engineering. It's a weekend hobby of mine, so I only end up making a few articles per year. Superman it is!
- erikig 5y agoA cursory search indicates that he's a game developer in the UK which explains the WebGL chops.
- badindentation 5y agoI think that's a different guy because his twitter profile (from the website) says he lives in California.
- moritonal 5y agoThey made anywhere from £470 to (using a rough sharp-tail model) £1666 per article. Whilst I agree that the amount of time required do this doesn't professionally cover that, it's a very nice hobby which makes somewhat real money (very much depending on how many sharp the tail of £54's are) and garners some serious traffic whilst building a very solid credability in the industry. Plus I signed up, so now they make £2.50 more!
- yumraj 5y agoThis was fantastic, for the first time in my life I actually understood what jewel means and what n jewels refers to when it comes to a mechanical watch. If Bartosz is reading this, I'm genuinely curious how much time did it take him to create this post. It looks like an insane amount of work with all the knowledge acquisition, write up, animation and so on..
- richardlblair 5y agoDid not read, but I did play with all the slidey things. They were fun.
- clord 5y ago> when we pull the crown all the way out to enter the time setting mode, that stop lever blocks the balance wheel, which stops the watch in an action known as hacking whoa, is this the origin of the word "hacking" in the "throw something into the wheels to make it work" sense? very interesting.
- e1ghtSpace 5y agoWell, you can also hack away at a tree with an axe.
- ramtatatam 5y agoIf I was born 20 years before I was born I would be able to enroll in clock-making faculty in University of Technology I graduated. They discontinued this faculty, and the only remaining part was a course of precise mechanics I received.. This article is pure gold. It makes me thinking how much of know-how is already lost and how much can we find in some old book stores... I'd buy a book about clock making.
- 1970-01-01 5y agoInteresting content, interactive, ad-free, and social-media free. The entire site is a great example of how the old Web was better than it is today.
- modeless 5y agoYour definition of "old web" includes WebGL? Stuff like this is a smaller percentage of the web these days, but in absolute terms there's more of it than ever before and a lot of it is higher quality too.
- 1970-01-01 5y agoFlash, ShockWave, WebGL, Java applets, and Silverlight was great when it worked.
- rotten 5y agoThis bumps up my desire to build my own mechanical watch using one of the kits here: https://rotatewatches.com https://rotatewatches.com (something I've had bookmarked for a while as a possible rainy day project)
- mjard 5y agoOne of my isolation projects was to put together a watch using an ETA 2824-2 movement from EBay. You might want to consider buying the parts you want individually. Match a case to a movement or it's clone. Find a dial that matches the movement complications and the case diameter. Find hands that match the movement and the case diameter. Most of the work is in the identification of parts, putting the watch together is really just like slapping a small sandwich together (minus putting the second hand on, that... is a test of dexterity, perseverance and commitment, the shaft you have to set it on is ~0.25mm). Often a seller will be a small time watch maker and their components will all fit together, a good way to save on shipping. Result: it's become my favorite watch, I wear it every day. Next project was to use a bunch of cheap clone parts and a 3d printed dial, still working on that one :)
- exhilaration 5y agoI'd love to see a picture of your watch!
- sakopov 5y agoA few months back I stumbled upon a YouTube video of a watch maker servicing a mechanical watch. This started a mild obsession with watch making and I've been watching these videos ever since. For anyone interested, here's an awesome video [1] of a guy putting together a watch and explaining how all 60 parts of a typical mechanical watch work together (by the way the tools he uses are as cool as the movements themselves). It's surprisingly easy to follow for a noobie. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hkK6e4tb5Qk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hkK6e4tb5Qk
- naikrovek 5y agoNormally I would crap (pretty hard) on web tech, because normally, it's only ever used to make websites harder to follow in the name of design, or to create new ways for ads to be served to me. This site, and the most recent blog entries on this site, are excellent examples of why web technologies are not all bad. People seeking new ways to make money make everything bad, eventually, and thankfully there are bastions of utility without sales still to be found, sprinkled around.
- yakshaving_jgt 5y agoPeople trying to make money is actually what drives rather a lot of the innovation that you enjoy every day. The “capitalism bad” trope is a tired one indeed.
- naikrovek 5y agonah, people trying to make enough money don't create Facebook. people trying to have enough to live comfortably don't create Amazon. monsters create those companies, and monsters grow them. growing larger and more profitable at any cost is called metastasis, and that's what's happening. lives get worse for most while the cancers grow and grow, almost unabated.
- naikrovek 5y agoI'll add that if you work at a place like this, you are part of the problem. your votes do not absolve you.
- tomaskafka 5y agoWhat is wrong about trying to find ways to produce a nice stuff and keep being to able to pay the rent and raise kids? I run a small and nice visual weather app for Apple Watch and iPhone (https://weathergraph.app https://weathergraph.app). Some people in reviews object to price, but if I wasn't able to charge a subscription (because weather data costs money continuously), there would be no app. And if I wasn't able to make (about 50 % there right now) a living, I would work for a corporation like I did before, and I wouldn't be able to dedicate enough time to make it great ¯\_(ツ)_/¯.
- mattmoose21 5y agoInteresting to see why seiko calls their automatic line 21 jewels.
- tadzik_ 5y agoThey don't call it that. "21 jewels" just describes the amount of rubies in the watch movement.
- Razengan 5y agoIs there a “gearpunk” hobbyist community anywhere? Where people design mostly un-electrical contraptions or even mechanical computers etc.? Would be a pretty fun and rewarding hands-on craft.
- BadassFractal 5y agoIncredible work with this article. I didn't realize experiences like that were even possible in the browser without a whole company backing the effort.
- jIyajbe 5y agoWow. I had no idea how intricate and CLEVER the mechanism of a mechanical watch is. Being no engineer, I cannot imagine how someone could think of all these clever designs. (Yes, of course the mechanism evolved over time. Even so.) I have been wanting to buy an old mechanical watch. When I do, I will never again complain about how much a watch repair shop charges. Also, the explanation, presentation, and animations are top-notch. Amazing work by the author!!
- SOLAR_FIELDS 5y agoYou know, I had the somewhat opposite impression reading the article. For me, what is interesting isn't the absolute genius of the design (which of course, it is). I find it more interesting that the watch has had enough staying power as a useful machine in society over hundreds of years to have gone through thousands of design iterations to arrive at the "genius" design. If you have enough smart engineers over several hundred years working at a problem, such an elegant design seems almost an inevitability to me. I would call it "clever" if one or two engineers created this over perhaps a decade or so. With thousands of engineers over several hundred years, however, it just feels like the natural evolution of things. I feel that a lot of things happening in today's society will be the "watch" in 100-200 years. A marvel of complexity at first glance, and then an acknowledgement of how much "standing on the shoulders of giants" contributes to things that are enjoyed on a daily basis.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoThat's very cool. One of my favorite memories, as a kid, was visiting a museum in Toronto (I think it was the Science Museum). Many of the exhibits had buttons that you could press, to make them go. I remember a giant steam piston. That was cool.
- smusamashah 5y agoAll of articles from this blog are worth archiving and putting in a library in this exact interactive form forever. I never understood mechanical watches before. Now I know exactly how they are made possible. Thanks for explaining it visually while interaction with the visuals.
- jonsen 5y agoI was reminded of the great video lecture Gerald Sussman Teaches Mechanical Watch Ideas at MIT: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=TWQN8Yf1g70 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=TWQN8Yf1g70
- krosaen 5y agoThanks for this!
- wardedVibe 5y agoBug report: the balance wheel animation when run on Firefox on my android eventually becomes a forced oscillator, with the slider running off to infinity
- niviksha 5y agoThis blog itself is a work of art, like mechanical watches themselves
- archon810 5y agohttps://ciechanow.ski/archives/ https://ciechanow.ski/archives/ - the blog archive is full of such marvels.
- rammy1234 5y agoI found this interesting. For more mechanical watch reference - https://www.timezone.com/2003/10/04/mechanical-watch-faq/ https://www.timezone.com/2003/10/04/mechanical-watch-faq/
- justAlittleCom 5y agoMechanical watch nerd here. This describe an ETA (swiss) movement, I really prefer the Japanese movement (I know mostly seikos). The mechanism are more simple and more robust. For instance, on ETA the crown mechanism is really sensitive, a lot of tiny fragile parts with a lot of tension in them, it go wrong easily. Also, seeing this web page I got frustrated by the fact it doesn't tackle what got me the hardest time: how can the crown move the hands without any clutch mechanism (some have) ? It's a matter of friction and torque, so it's hard to get while reasoning on a "perfect" mechanism.
- elSidCampeador 5y agoHi where can I learn more about the Japanese movements?
- rssoconnor 5y agoIt doesn't go into a lot of detail but the article does say: > Notice that when we turn the minute wheel only the cannon pinion turns. That pinion fits tightly inside its driving gear – it usually turns with that gear. However, when the driving gear can’t rotate because it’s blocked by the rest of the gear train, the cannon pinion can overpower the friction of that tight fit and rotate on its own. This lets us set time without interfering with the gear train, which could break the delicate parts. Personally, I was wondering how one can wind the watch from the crown without engaging the weight of the autowinding mechanism. I'm guessing that winding with the crown causes the ratchet to slip on both pairs of blue/yellow gears.
- ngcc_hk 5y agoIn fact the issue do not change the time around 12 is a bit of mystery to me. Is that applied to all mechanical watch or just European ?
- mc4ndr3 5y agoThe canvases occupy so much of the screen (on small phones) that it is sometimes difficult to scroll the page. Otherwise, amazing article.
- Linda703 5y ago[dead]
- wumms 5y agoBug report: on page load, the play/pause button for the stop lever interaction [0] shows the play icon albeit the animation is already playing. (The div needs the class 'playing' added, e.g. <div id="stop_lever_interaction" [...]> [...] <div class="play_pause_button playing"></div> </div> instead of <div class="play_pause_button"></div> ) [0] https://ciechanow.ski/mechanical-watch/#stop_lever_interaction https://ciechanow.ski/mechanical-watch/#stop_lever_interacti...
- mananaysiempre 5y agoOK, if we’re piling up here :) > This mechanism protects the fragile tips of the balance shaft from braking when the watch experiences a sudden jerk. “Breaking”, presumably. More generally, am I the only one who finds that the temporal aliasing in the fast repetitive animations just before the balance is introduced looks funny to the point of being misleading? Might be my combination of mobile hardware, though, I wouldn’t normally expect it to synchronize to the framerate to this extent, but I’m seeing that it does. (I appreciate the immense effort it would take to make this account for aliasing with motion blur or similar. I just went “huh?” when fiddling with the speed slider there, because it really was confusing at first.)
- jnord 5y agoAn absolutely amazing article, detailed explanation and beautiful graphics. Thanks so much for posting!
- lvturner 5y agoFor those interested in watch assembly (I'm differentiating between assembly and watch making), I can highly recommend https://diywatch.club/ https://diywatch.club/ I bought one of their kits and was super satisfied with it. You could do it cheaper by buying random parts off eBay or Taobao, I did this for a second watch - using the following video from the "Watch Repair Channel" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rieKmfaKMCY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rieKmfaKMCY But having your initial attempt somewhat de-risked gave me the confidence to dive head first into other concepts and ideas. I'm not quite ready to do a tear down and service of a movement, but with a timegrapher on the way... it won't be long before I'll end up scratching that itch too!
- joshwcomeau 5y agoThis fits into a category of thing known as “explorable explanations”. They’re an amazing form of media. This one is particularly brilliant! Check out this site for many others: https://explorabl.es/ https://explorabl.es/
- MengerSponge 5y agoThis is lovely! While there's a lot of watch content on YouTube, I'm amazed that no one has called out Clickspring's skeleton clock build. It's also a masterpiece, just in a different medium: Full build playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLZioPDnFPNsETq9h35dgQq80Ryx-beOli https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLZioPDnFPNsETq9h35dgQ... Direct link to the first episode: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B8Y146v8HxE&list=PLZioPDnFPNsETq9h35dgQq80Ryx-beOli&index=1 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B8Y146v8HxE&list=PLZioPDnFPN...
- xwdv 5y agoWow, I didn’t expect I would read all that but the visualization was so great and made it easy to follow, I learned more about mechanical watches than I ever thought I would! If every subject could have visualization like this I could learn anything!
- bacon_waffle 5y agoFor folks who are interested in the subject matter: electronic tuning fork movements, like the Accutron 214, are amazingly elegant bits of engineering. Both the time regulation and motive power are provided by a tuning fork (vs the balance wheel and mainspring), which is kept oscillating through electromagnetism (vs the escapement) in one of the first consumer applications of the transistor. The movement was designed and started being manufactured in the late 1950s. Max Hetzel's patents are a good starting point - https://www.accutrons.com/tuning-fork-watch-patents https://www.accutrons.com/tuning-fork-watch-patents
- zerop 5y agoSince everyone is appreciating the. writeup for details, comprehensive and animation done by author, I was thinking if there is any library/platform to build such tools/animations so that masses of teachers, who can write good content, can write and animate like this. This would really make learning experience impressive.
- alanbernstein 5y agoI always enjoy reading these, but this one is special for me because it relates to two back burner projects I'm thinking about recently: 1. building a custom mechanical timer, which I want for practical use. 2. designing a real-world alethiometer - a fictional watch/compass device with chaotic (magical) behavior - which runs entirely on clockwork. I've been wondering how to incorporate a source of significant entropy into a watch movement. One idea, for example, is something like a double pendulum, but made from torsion springs.
- veltas 5y agoWould love something like this for cars.
- komposit 5y agoHe has one on the combustion engine
- rocqua 5y agoI have a mechanical watch. I wish it was quartz. I simply could not find any quartz watch in a style I liked. I even prefer thin watches. I feel like the field of actually nicely designed quartz watches is dead from competition with mechanical and smart watches. Where smart watches are just ugly, and mechanical watches look amazing but are more hobby or conversation pieces than actually good for telling time.
- smetj 5y agoWill we still be able to find and consult this mesmerizing piece of documentation art in let's say .... 100 years? Pretty sure mechanical watches will still exist then.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoThe GPS post blew me away but this one about watch movements is just so incredible.
- amai 5y agoIn 20 years we will see similar visualizations about car engines which used petrol instead of electricity. We will be awed by the complex mechanisms, which were necessary at that time to make a car drive as we are awed now by the complexities of mechanical watches.
- zwog 5y agoYou don't have to wait 20 years, he did one last year: https://ciechanow.ski/internal-combustion-engine/ https://ciechanow.ski/internal-combustion-engine/
- vladde 5y agoThey have other blog posts as well, all equally interesting and detailed.
- zlippslip 5y agoMy brother is a watch maker and fixer. It's an art that's becoming rarer and rarer with the advent of smart watches. Although his job is surprisingly secure because very wealthy people tend to pay a lot for their very fancy watches to be fixed or made. It's kind of sad how far we're moving from watches which last hundreds of years as heirlooms with minimal maintenance, to electronic waste generating items with components made as cheaply as possible and at most last several years before their irreplaceable battery dies and you purchase another. Watches are robust technologies that work without internet connectivity, are crafted/maintained by people paying attention to mechanical parts that are sometimes about as thin as human hairs. Humans have used them for hundreds of years and they are really freaking cool. If you think the animation is awesome(it is), consider owning the real thing. Not just for my brother's sake, but maybe for your families.
- jagged-chisel 5y agoThat scale can’t be right. Pocket watches are bigger than a quarter.
- sunpazed 5y agoWhat an awesome explainer! I love mechanical watches. I have a relatively cheap Stowa Antea which runs a simple hand-wound Peseux/ETA 7001. It’s so thin, the entire watch is less than 7mm thick. All of what you see in this explainer is crammed into that tiny space the size of a stamp.
- adulion 5y agomechanical watches fascinate me, i joined /r/seikomods and assmbled one form parts i found of ebay.
- jrh206 5y agoThis article is fantastic. Beautiful illustrations and comprehensive explanations. Creating something like this takes a lot of work. Consider supporting the creator on Patreon if you want to enable them to create more of these: https://www.patreon.com/ciechanowski https://www.patreon.com/ciechanowski
- overlisted 5y agoThis author author is like 3B1B but with engineering
- ubermonkey 5y agoThis is really, really beautiful and cool.
- tokujin 5y agoHow can I save the page with the interactive animations to my computer? I'm using wget --page-requisites \ --span-hosts \ --execute robots=off \ --adjust-extension \ --convert-links \ https://ciechanow.ski/mechanical-watch/ but I get "Loading..." messages in place of the animations when I open the saved html on Firefox.
- s1mon 5y agoOne thing that hasn't been mentioned is how the parts were modeled. I asked @BCiechanowski on Twitter and the response was "Modeled in Shapr3D [0], animated manually in JS". Another person asked about the gears, and he said "Gears are just generated programmatically, it made it very easy to tweak their shape as needed". Overall, a fascinating workflow. [0] https://www.shapr3d.com https://www.shapr3d.com
- andoli 5y agobrilliant work in every aspect, really blew my mind
- Teknoman117 5y agoAs much as I might like features of smartwatches, my favorite watch is a skeleton style mechanical watch my grandparents bought for me a number of years ago. Watching the teeny tiny gears moving around is somewhat cathartic.
- mayapugai 5y agoThis is a wonderful article! Thank you to the author for taking the time to write and animate all this. I want future generations to have access this so I have to ask - how can I back up this page with all of the interactive 3D animations still operational? Simply saving the HTML file doesn't seem to work.
- tempestn 5y ago> Once the pallet fork unlocks the balance wheel, that wheel has to start spinning very quickly. This is why gears in the gear train have holes in them – it reduces their moment of inertia so that the barrel can accelerate them more quickly. I think that should say "unlocks the escape wheel", not the balance wheel.
- slavoingilizov 5y agoThis is genius. Attention to detail and quality of the writing and delivery is amazing. The fact that the watch in the first animation also shows accurate time reminds me of the 9:41 in each iPhone screenshot when Steve Jobs was doing the Apple demos. Sweating such details indicates a labour of love.
- mbubb 5y agoReally beautiful site. Made my morning. I wear mechanical watches on a daily basis (I rotate between a few Maratec/CountyComm models) I like the size, weight and the sound and the feeling of the counter weight moving around. And the feedback of the bezel as I time an egg or a load in the dryer... I really like the correspondence between the respect for the ingenuity of this technology and the "handcrafted" WebGL. Last line: "With creative use of miniature gears, levers, and springs, a mechanical watch rises from its dormant components to become truly alive."
- sprobertson 5y agoI wish there as much detail on the escapement as on the springs. The bouncy sliders are a fun way to draw in the attention but springs are already intuitive... I'd like to see that kind of visualisation effort applied to the harder concepts.
- krzat 5y agoThis is random, but a lot of these parts exist because of the way it is constructed. I wonder how minimal this kind of watch could be if you had a unrealistically accurate 3d printer and the design was essentially optimal (done by machine learning perhaps).
- blacklion 5y agoOh, wait, is it same author who wrote excellent GPS explainer?! Yes, it is! Another masterpiece, then. I've understand mechanical watch internals thanks to hundreds of hours of procrastination spent on watch-repairing youtube channels, but I wish I had such presentation several years ago. Same with GPS - I've deep-dive into GPS when I've bought my first receiver, I think in year 2002 or something like this, and it was HARD at these times (there was Internet, of course, but good texts on GPS were very hard to find). Now, thank you to Bartosz, I have two excellent links to hand out if I'm asked about these topics. I understand them well, but I never ever will be able to explain them so clear and accessible.
- leoheck 5y ago