13 ms·
Airbnb Q1
- simonebrunozzi 5y agoWhat will they launch on May 11th?
- rdtwo 5y agoCan anyone say genuinely that the product got better? Seems like they just cut a lot of useless shit but didn’t fix any of the core fraud and poor customer service problems
- atlasunshrugged 5y agoWhat was the fraud? I'd consider myself a super-user and the main issues I encounter are lack of reasonably priced listings, a shift to hotel-like professional listings which are boring and defeat the purpose of using airbnb, and exorbitant cleaning fees and the like.
- onphonenow 5y agoThe cleaning fees not being included in the first sort / visible price is ridiculous.
- atlasunshrugged 5y agoI agree, I guess I'd call that a dark pattern or misleading, but fraud to me implies illegality edit: grammar
- fshbbdssbbgdd 5y agoI’d say if the fee isn’t disclosed before you confirm the transaction, it’s fraud. If they just show you a teaser rate then add the fee when they show the total, it’s slimy but par for the course.
- seattle_spring 5y agoThey are included unless you don't include dates. Why would you be searching for a place without dates?
- enra 5y agoThe fees are included in the nightly/total price if you include dates for the search. It's challenging to show the cleaning fees without the length of stay or would have to show the nightly price + fees all the time and it would get kind of confusing. I think there is now the total price if you click that it shows you the break down. Context: I used to work at Airbnb, and some point designed one version those listing cards as well. There was never a goal to have some dark pattern choice not to include the fees or somehow try to mislead users. There is just limited space for the price. Also each city, country and might have different fee structures and pricing regulation so we actually had to design the card as something supports those different cases. Like in Australia you always have to show total price where as in US it's common for hotels to show nightly price without taxes or resort fees. In some cities or countries there is now a tourist fee. Unlike in hotels where the cleaning fee is included in the price, on Airbnb, the host sets it. Also each rental is unique like one might be 10 bedroom house with pool and jacuzzi and some might be one bedroom rooms so the cleaning needs vary. Also in some places cleaning is very cheap and some places it's very expensive to get someone to clean your house.
- a2tech 5y agoThere's tons of fraud on AirBNB (and increasingly VRBO). We've rentals on both service in the past year try to redirect us to 2nd locations or get us to pay 'damage deposits' on shady third party websites. AirBNB's customer support immediately said 'definitely sounds like a scam' when we reported it, then held our $6k for a month. My wife had to threaten to sue to get them to release it. At no point during that month did AirBNB take down the fraudulent listing (even while the reviews piled up saying that they were redirected to a run down loft instead of the nice house they had rented). VRBO refunded our money in a couple of days when we reported a host trying to get us to pay on a third party site.
- bradly 5y agoWe still prefer Vrbo for hosting our rentals. Airbnb will still give people full refunds after the cancellation deadline and then host is out that money. Vrbo allows us to set our cancellation policy and will not override it.
- thimkerbell 5y agoWhat's a basic portable security system that will notify you if someone goes into the room while you're out, and does not rely on the host's wifi?
- vageli 5y agoHaven [0] can turn an android phone into just that, though you'll need a separate sim for it. [0]: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.havenapp.main&hl=en https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.havenapp.m...
- atlasunshrugged 5y agoI think one of the key takeaways for me is just how important the 29 day+ stay is for them as an emerging category which sounds right to me... in part because I enjoy that style of travel but also because lower than that Airbnb is just not very economical and many of the short term listings are basically like hotel rooms anyways, so why not go there if you're only in a city for 5 days and need to check in at 10pm.
- DantesKite 5y agoThat's one of the reasons why I picked AirBnB. Let me stay in a foreign city for work for a few weeks for a very low cost. Wouldn't have been able to do that without them.
- vmception 5y agosame! daily rates at hotels and airbnbs add up way too fast monthly stays at airbnb's are much closer to the local rental price, usually 10-20% above a local lease, but without the issue of actually leasing monthly stays are also furnished (whereas it can be very hard to find a furnished place to lease at all!) monthly stays also get around most short term stay restrictions created specifically in reaction to AirBnB, which makes it much more comfortable for someone that booked to not have to worry about who we talk to in the building or nearby I love being a situation to travel this way. Its pretty amazing to see that its currently become a crucial portion of their revenues.
- phphphphp 5y agoVery much not my experience in Europe. I’d happily live in Airbnbs full time if the price was +~20% long term lease but in my experience the price is >100% even for 1 month stays. The problem, at least in Europe, is that so many Airbnbs are now being operated as “rent to rent” where a company (or individual) rents property long term specifically so they can then in turn rent it out on Airbnb (often through an intermediary that manages the property for them). The margins they need for confident profitability (considering voids etc) are ~100% over the long term rental cost. I’m astonished you’ve found that the prices are so similar: which location(s) is this in? I just moved out of an Airbnb I stayed in for a month where my average nightly cost was, quite literally, 200% over the amount that I would pay if I leased the property myself — and that’s not in peak season, and after negotiating. 5 years ago the cost was pretty similar but not now that Airbnb has become an industry and people have worked out how to squeeze every drop of profit out of it.
- danhak 5y agoI love Airbnb and have booked dozens of stays through them. I listened in on the earnings call yesterday and heard lots of good things. But as a prospective investor my main concern is how they plan to deal with increasing circumvention of the platform. There's professional short-term property management services in every market now, and they don't want to give Airbnb a cut. I am literally typing this comment from a cabin that I discovered on Airbnb but booked direct to save money. The listing contained text inviting you to visit their website to book direct and avoid fees. I've also re-booked properties I've stayed at in the past by contacting hosts directly, and received offers from hosts via Airbnb message to book outside of Airbnb for a discount. So a major problem for Airbnb is that they don't really own the relationship between hosts and guests.
- pphysch 5y ago> So a major problem for Airbnb is that they don't really own the relationship between hosts and guests. I don't see how this is a "major" problem.
- danhak 5y agoWell, Airbnb's business model is to make a market and take a cut of each transaction. If hosts and guests discover one another on the platform but cut Airbnb out of the transaction then Airbnb is losing money. Losing money is a major problem for a business that seeks to make money.
- atlasunshrugged 5y agoReally? That's interesting, I often use Airbnb instead of these other platforms or direct relationships because having them as a guarantor is usually worth the premium that they demand, especially in foreign countries. Maybe this is a larger issue as they move towards longer stays but at least for short to midterm (e.g. under 3 months) I'm usually happy to use Airbnb and they're reasonable for booking more than a month at a time
- bsimpson 5y ago
- TedShiller 5y agoAirbnb is so much better than hotels
- hirvi74 5y agoWhy do you think so?
- TedShiller 5y agoI can rent the best house. For hotels I guess you could get the Four Seasons but that’s more expensive than what it gets you
- wanderr 5y agoAs a user, Airbnb is hostile. The price you see is never the price you pay. It's impossible to tell which listings are actually the cheaper or more expensive than others. The only reason to use them is selection, they have properties that VRBO & others don't. So focusing on improvements for their hosts is smart, but feels like it will still bite them in the long run. I already avoid Airbnb when possible.
- atlasunshrugged 5y agoAlso sometimes even which listings are still active. I've had a few times where I've booked and the host responded not even knowing their listing had been up.
- milkshakes 5y agouse airbnb.com.au. they are legally required to display the real price, and break it down in search results :)
- dannyw 5y agoAussie here, never realised this was a complaint. Everything I see across nearly every site is always the total price.
- themanmaran 5y agoJust did a quick test. The US version has the nightly price as the first number with the total under it, and the AU site has the total price listed instead. Interestingly, the AU price was a couple dollars more than the US price. Threw together a quick side-by-side: https://imgur.com/a/DJwG5z9 https://imgur.com/a/DJwG5z9
- teaearlgraycold 5y agoAlso US and I see the nightly and total. That’s good enough for me. Lets me understand what an additional day will cost. Basically they give you the full y=m*x+b instead of just y.
- 5y ago
- paxys 5y ago> In 2021, around 20% of our nights booked were for stays of a month or longer, and nearly 50% for a week or longer This one is surprising, but not totally unexpected I guess. Airbnb is slowly replacing short term leases and sublets, and I imagine this will be a huge growth driver for them as remote work and the nomad lifestyle becomes more common.
- adamjb 5y agoI find this to be an unintuitive metric, as nights that are part of longer bookings are oversampled as there are more nights in longer bookings
- btheshoe 5y agoyes, but also more money changes hands in longer bookings, so maybe num bookings is the unintuitive metric. Def worth pointing out that both are biased in one way or the other though.
- Tiktaalik 5y agoGoing to be interesting to keep an eye on that urban vs non-urban mix. Major urban centres around the world (eg. Barcelona, Berlin, Vancouver) are facing severe housing affordability challenges, and as part of the solution have enacted regulation against sub 30 day vacation rentals in apartments intended for long term rental to people who live and work in the cities. You'd think that these regulations will keep a lid on Airbnb growth and force the company to place more emphasis on non-urban and tourism oriented towns that have less severe housing pressures.
- animex 5y agoIt's crazy how hidden fees quickly blow up a $99 property to $328... $159 cleaning fee? $60 mysterious service charge? I just go with Hotels...much more consistent experience.
- encryptluks2 5y agoAgreed. I stopped using the service when I realized the prices listed don't reflect what you're actually paying. A price may look great until you read the fine print and see that you'll be paying $100 more. If they had transparent pricing I doubt as many people would use the platform. There is also a more reliable source of reviews for most hotels. You could stay at a descent rated host on AirBnb and then go look at the reviews and see things like... "Dirty bathrooms and the bed was soiled. 5 out of 5 for the authentic homely experience."
- Phlogistique 5y agoAirBnB makes that worse by refusing to show you the full cost for the trip - so the prices it displays are actually meaningless. Booking.com has many dark patterns but at least it allows you to actually display and sort by full price!
- dzhiurgis 5y agoHotels for short term or travelling alone. Airbnb for long term and for families.
- devoutsalsa 5y agoIt's also good to figure out how to negotiate with locals. I was recently in Macedonia. I was looking at one listing for an apartment that was around 1000 euros/month for 3 months on Airbnb. My friend, a local, was able to find & contact the owner directly. The owner's price for my friend was 300 euros/month.
- dzhiurgis 5y agoA place I stayed just a week ago in Fiji is listed for $1500 a day while we got same place randomly for $400… That said Fiji is still recovering from Covid - in places like Hawaii you’d struggle to get anything!
- ergocoder 5y agoHost removed internet after I booked. Airbnb confirmed that this happened. I asked for refund immediately. Airbnb waited 7 fucking days. They claimed they wanted host to correct the situation. I told Airbnb I didn't want to wait for that as I don't trust the host anymore. Fortunate for me that the host didn't reply to Airbnb. The whole thing is just anti-consumer. Host changing details should grant me the right to cancel with full refund immediately. I was very disappointed at the ethical standard at Airbnb. I hope Airbnb fails. I can't support them anymore.
- thehappypm 5y agoWhat do you mean removed internet?
- LordAtlas 5y agoProbably means availability of Wi-Fi / Internet access, something that should be a given at any room rental. But as I've found out while searching, sometimes it isn't. That's why I always add "Wi-fi" in the filters. I agree with OP though. If you change the available amenities after the booking has been made, you've deceived the customer and they should be eligible for an immediate refund.
- ergocoder 5y agoThe booking said that there was internet. After I booked, internet was removed from the booking. Airbnb even confirmed this was true but refused to refund because they wanted to "give equal footing" to the host (e.g. waiting for host to respond). I was like wtf?
- mempko 5y agoWhat's striking and sad is how much of their business is now people living in an Airbnb staying longer than a month. Signals something wrong with housing and the economy.
- umeshunni 5y agoGetting a short term lease is incredibly difficult and a very manual process involving credit checks, filling in random forms and faxing them, landlords contacting my employer and so forth. With AirBnb, I just enter my credit card number and book it.
- mempko 5y agoTo be clear, I'm not saying AirBnb is a problem here. I'm saying there is something wrong with our housing system where people are using AirBnb as a place to live on an increasing basis.
- Liron 5y agoClearly a great company in many ways, but if I attempt to quantify how great in terms of a reasonable market cap, I get maybe $30B, not $100B. Does anyone have a plausible model of how Airbnb can ever make over 5x more revenue than it’s making today? Is the $100B market cap building in an assumption that it’s going to invent new business lines and push them through its distribution channel, or what? Top line needs to keep growing 30%/yr for next 5 years, then reach a stable state of 30%/yr earnings+growth yield... Then if that optimistic scenario comes true, congratulations, you can expect a modest 10%/yr yield investing at $100B today. I believe that’s roughly the math.
- ddorian43 5y ago> Does anyone have a plausible model of how Airbnb can ever make over 5x more revenue than it’s making today? By doing it's own hotels/properties.
- jedberg 5y agoFor the past few years they've been getting into longer term rentals. Imagine as a landlord you could just hire AirBnb to manage your rental house, and they could handle making it short or long term based on demand, managing the whole thing, doing leases and buying furniture as necessary, etc. Basically if you own a property you say "Hey AirBnb, use this to make money and give me some of it". That is a huge addressable market, and one that is adjacent to their existing market and only getting bigger.
- daydream 5y agoThat is very interesting. Do you have a link to more info about this? The only thing I could find was where they advertise their third party property management partners, not where they do it themselves. The service you describe could be incredibly attractive and have huge potential.
- jedberg 5y agoRight now their platform just lets you rent for longer terms, but what I'm saying is that they could get into property management as a way to continue growing.
- poisonarena 5y agoSince 2017 I have been living in Airbnbs, more than 80 at this point always for 1+ month long stays, and sometimes renting beyond in private arrangements with owner. Mostly good experiences. I was also part of the last group of stays before Japan more or less outlawed it, feels bad. Some bad parts include scorpion infestations in jungles in colombia, bedbugs in russia, roaches in brazil, rocket attacks in israel and mold in South korea. But mostly the worst thing is knowing im paying 20-50% more than a local in some countries.
- londons_explore 5y agoI wonder how much of that profit is 'stolen' from hosts and guests through poor customer service? There are multiple occasions that I've booked an Airbnb only to find the house doesn't exist and the host's phone number is no longer connected, yet somehow Airbnb won't issue a refund without lots of hassle. Possibly 5% of my bookings on Airbnb have turned out to be fraudulent in some way which disadvantages me financially and leaves Airbnb with more money in their pockets. If I'm not unique, that's a big contributor to the company bottom line!
- helsinki 5y agoThis feels like they are so full of themselves. They should have simply summarized it as, ‘Revenue greatly dropped in 2020, and the subsequent increase is inversely correlated to the level of society’s fear of covid.’ Instead, they have to throw in a bunch of self-aggrandizing startup bullshit.
- encryptluks2 5y agoStartups like AirBnb are in a fake it till you make it mindset from the get go.
- wdb 5y agoAfter being burned multiple times by AirBNB abroad. I prefer to use apartment hotels; can cook my own meals. Best of both
- lysecret 5y agoI did a lot of longer term stays (usually 1 month at a time) when I was traveling around and working. And I have to say. Compared to finding a normal rent it's just insane how much more convenient it is.