4 ms·
A Twitter replacement shouldn't be federated. It should be fully P2P. Federated platforms can still be censored and walled off. Not all Mastodon instances are
by echelon 5y ago
A Twitter replacement shouldn't be federated. It should be fully P2P.
Federated platforms can still be censored and walled off. Not all Mastodon instances are peers, and your data isn't portable. It still has most of the same pitfalls as the platforms we complain about today.
P2P is naturally efficient. The best ideas will gain traction within their memetic networks, and you can branch out and explore anything and respond to it.
Sign and publish with a pubkey so you have pseudonymous identity and can keep track of peers. Publish and consume through a gateway proxy or VPN if you want to keep your IP private.
Supernodes can help with scaling, especially for mobile clients.
You can block whomever you dislike or share only with your direct network. You can write your own prioritization algorithm to cut down on noise and create high signal channels. You can archive whatever you like easily.
It should have been P2P all along.
- anderspitman 5y agoP2P is just a special case of federation, where n=1. IMO PKI is simply not a realistic identity platform for the average person. You have to back your private key up with some reliable third party and their recovery system is going to be based on email so you may as well just use email for identity.
- elitepleb 5y agothere's a project brewing hoping to do just that by july https://liberapay.com/Revolver https://liberapay.com/Revolver
- grishka 5y agoNo, P2P is impractical and it inevitably leaks into the UX, making it significantly more cumbersome. With a P2P system, you can't just send someone a link to something you found — you either expect them to have a client for the service, or use a web proxy. > Sign and publish with a pubkey No, absolutely not. Public keys make terrible identifiers. You leak it and anyone can impresonate you, with you having no recourse. You lose it and you have to start a new life basically. Account recovery and the ability to revoke access are not "nice to have" things — they're hard requirements for any identity system that is to be used in the real world by real, including non-tech, people. Trust me, I worked at the largest Russian social media company, they have a dedicated account recovery department for a reason.
- Ambolia 5y agoCouldn't this be solved by chains of trust and "blacklisting" accounts? This is pretty much how it already works in the most annonymous corners of the internet, and those are the best corners.
- echelon 5y ago> No, absolutely not. Public keys make terrible identifiers. You leak it and anyone can impresonate you, with you having no recourse. You lose it and you have to start a new life basically. Most average people can't even get the platforms to deal with ATOs. I'm not into crypto, but it's also accepted in that community that you must safeguard your keys. But beyond the status quo, I can easily imagine dozens of mitigations and protections and additional proofs: revokable cert authorities and peers, multiple signatures, portable / updatable keys, etc. etc.
- grishka 5y ago> I'm not into crypto, but it's also accepted in that community that you must safeguard your keys. Of course it is accepted, but so it is with passwords. And people are terrible enough with passwords, yet here you are suggesting that they use something that can't even be (easily) memorized, can't be invalidated, and has to be stored reliably yet secretly, as "the" identifier. You're putting too much trust into your average user. None of these cryptography-based identity schemes can possibly work in the real world, period.
- pgeorgi 5y agoTry [Scuttlebutt](https://scuttlebutt.nz/ https://scuttlebutt.nz/), which is fully peer to peer. You'll experience the limitations soon enough.
- rglullis 5y agoNo, we don't need to do P2P, we just need to separate the identity from the application server, like HTTP and DNS. If I own my identity, I can use any service provider and I can attest data ownership at any time.
- vidarh 5y agoActivityPub is mixed. It's peer-to-peer for follow/follower relationships, with you yourself deciding whether you want to sign up to an instance operated by someone else, or your own. It only need the federation for the "firehose" of public messages. But you don't need that to be 100% distributed, as long as there are enough publicly accessible endpoints. Nothing also stops you from gatewaying between the current federation mechanism for it and a fully peer-to-peer model if you invent a more distributed model.