4 ms·
This is the bigger problem. There is a process and some people seem to think circumventing it is the right response. The courts will make a decision and then
by refurb 5y ago
This is the bigger problem. There is a process and some people seem to think circumventing it is the right response.
The courts will make a decision and then it's up to Congress to draft new laws if it wants.
Undermining the process of the judicial branch is not going to end well at all.
- maxerickson 5y agoThe leak could have been done by someone who favors the draft.
- zdragnar 5y agoThat is extremely unlikely. There's nothing to be gained by breaking the trust of the supreme court justices by leaking a draft of a decision you are in favor of. Now, the justices will be facing intense public discontent from those who want a different decision to be made before the draft is finalized (not that I suspect anything can realistically be changed at this point). If you favor the decision, then it also speaks to money not getting a significant motivating factor (taking money to leak would betray someone they are supporting, which seems less than likely). By this line of reasoning, I am assuming it was done by someone who deeply opposes the result.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> There's nothing to be gained by breaking the trust of the supreme court justices by leaking a draft of a decision you are in favor of. Yes, there is. You potentially lock in someone who’s been waffling on their final vote by making their initial vote public.
- zdragnar 5y agoThat could just as easily, if not more certainly, backfire.
- altcognito 5y agoIt could make the discussion about the leak, not the decision. It could soften the criticism of the decision itself. Seems to be working quite well, I'd say a success overall.
- themacguffinman 5y agoI doubt it's a success. Outside the HN bubble, the overturning itself is the main subject of discussion in places like reddit. In fact, if you take a quick look at the HN "new" queue, you'll see plenty of flagged/dead submissions that directly mention the decision but this one is the only one that gets through because HN disdains mainstream partisan topics like abortion.
- usernomdeguerre 5y agoReleasing a draft stops many avenues of compromise among the decision makers. Regardless of the industry/institution. When members do not have a way to change their opinion and save face, they won't change their opinion. Politico should have been more thoughtful about its disclosure if they preferred to see changes because now the names on that opinion will never change and we could very well see the exact language become the published opinion.
- themacguffinman 5y agoUS Supreme justices are appointed for life, the only "face" they have to lose realistically is their legacy reputation, how they are seen by future generations. They are not really vulnerable to populist attacks of hypocrisy or flip-flopping or whatever.
- cudgy 5y ago> They are not really vulnerable to populist attacks of hypocrisy or flip-flopping or whatever. They are humans that have to live in society just like the rest of us. No one is completely invulnerable to society. I imagine being the target of some of these radical abortion groups (anti or pro) would be scary, especially for officials that are normally not in the limelight.
- KerrAvon 5y agoTell me more about these radical pro-abortion groups of which you speak. I’d really love to know if there’s an equivalent to the violent murderers on the right wing.
- zdragnar 5y agoLast estimate I'd heard of abortions since Roe v. Wade is 60 million. I haven't a clue how accurate it is, but let's use it as an example. Pro-life / anti-abortion people believe that a fetus is a unique human life; from their perspective, that's 60 million murders committed against the unborn. Of course, for any who do not think a fetus is a living human, it is a hollow argument.
- WillPostForFood 5y agoUnlikely. The more obvious intent is to provide a tool to campaign on for the next several months and boost the sagging approval of the president. Something to rally around.
- cudgy 5y ago
- kadoban 5y agoThe judicial branch already disregarded the process. See the current court's use of the shadow docket, and hell, _this decision_ itself.
- refurb 5y agoThis decision is disregarding what process? This is the power vested in the Supreme Court. Edit: No, no law is “settled” and impossible to overturn. The comment said “casually overturned”, not “never overturned”. It’s how it’s supposed to work You don’t get to pick and choose what decisions you like and then attack the ones you don’t. If you do you undermine the decisions you don’t agree with AND the ones you do.” And again, there is nothing stopping Congress from turning around and passing a new abortion law that maintains the status quo. It may not be perfect but if you don’t respect the process then you might as well throw the whole system out the window.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> This decision is disregarding what process? Stare decisis, aka precedent. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/health/is-roe-v-wade-settled-law-justices-earlier-assurances-now-in-doubt https://www.pbs.org/newshour/health/is-roe-v-wade-settled-la... "During his confirmation to the Supreme Court, Brett Kavanaugh convinced Sen. Susan Collins that he thought a woman’s right to an abortion was 'settled law,' calling the court cases affirming it 'precedent on precedent' that could not be casually overturned."
- zdragnar 5y agoThere is precedent for overturning precedent. Stare decisis is not supposed to mean that a decision is set in stone for eternity.
- ceejayoz 5y agoCertainly, but one of the deciding votes here won their seat very recently claiming precedent in this specific case made it settled law. That appears to have been a lie.
- 8note 5y agoThe current court is made up of members in their position by ignoring process. Does the process still matter?
- giantg2 5y agoI'm not sure what you mean by the ignoring process part. Is it the way they were appointed or something to do with the justices themselves? Government is ignoring processes and right at all levels to some degree. I sympathize with the idea that rule of law has become a joke since nobody can enforce it on the people in power.
- xeromal 5y agoThis post is gonna be too hot to make reasonable arguments, but I think they're talking about how Garland was never confirmed when Obama appointed him. At least one of these seats should've been someone else.
- cocacola1 5y agoBeyond that, it's probably also that McConnell used the excuse of the upcoming election to delay that nomination, but not when RBG died. Which, while perhaps unethical to someone on the other side of the political debate, doesn't contravene any rules as far as I'm aware. Same here, so I think the leak is fine.
- sjg007 5y agoIf the Supremes overturn Roe vs Wade they will lose all of the legitimacy they’ve spent the last 70 years building. At that point the Court itself is fubar. It probably already is fubar since Trump anyway. Clarence Thomas and his wife’s Jan 6th involvement is just the cherry on top of a shit show. In the end they are falliable humans like the rest of us so perhaps we hold too high an opinion.
- rayiner 5y agoThe fact that liberals peg their views of the Supreme Court’s “legitimacy” on a cluster fuck of an opinion as Roe v. Wade speaks volumes. Roe is so bad that it has long united libertarian conservatives (who hate it because it makes up a right out of thin air) and social conservatives (who had abortion on the merits). In addition to that it manages to be wildly out of line with international norms, which: 1) Generally recognize abortion as an issue for the legislature. 2) Typically draw the line for elective abortions at the end of the first trimester, not viability. The abortion laws in Denmark, Germany, Italy, France, and Spain would be unconstitutional under Roe.
- maxerickson 5y agoI think I've actually asked you something like this before, but is there a compact way to write a constitutional amendment that creates a right to privacy?
- sjg007 5y agoA racist would make the same argument about Brown vs Board.
- tbrownaw 5y ago> In addition to that it manages to be wildly out of line with international norms Isn't our take on freedom of speech rather out of line with international norms? And probably also our take on bearing arms being a right? I don't think I buy the implied claim that being out of line with norms is necessarily a bad thing.
- capguy255 5y agoHand-wringing about "process" is a POLITICAL argument designed to deflect attention from substance. It's an argument that politicians make to change the topic and not an appropriate argument for the courts. Stop trying to change the topic. And even if accepting this framing -- which "process" exactly has been undermined? Has someone suggested stripping the courts of jurisdiction for certain cases? Have the courts been defunded or had their staffers taken away? Have the number of courts been reduced or the justices circulated to another court? These are all "process" changes well within the power of the other political branches, that aren't happening here. In short -- quit changing the topic and perhaps read the draft opinion, which waxes philosophically about the value of public debate on controversial opinions.
- refurb 5y agoAre you aware of “judicial independence”? Are you aware of “separation of powers”? Are you aware that no such leak has ever occurred before it interferes with judicial independence? Are you aware that the courts job is to decide if laws are constitutional/valid and Congress’ job to actually create law? You hand wave away “process” when the entire function of the government is based on process. If you throw away process you throw away the entire system.
- capguy255 5y agoThis stuff has happened before. It will happen again. I assume that you must believe that the violation of the nine person sacred debate club is far worse than any of the substantive consequences from the actual decision, right? Specifically -- are you aware that before the Roe v. Wade decision was released in 1973, that news of the decision leaked to the Washington Post? The idea that this has "never occurred" is absurd when a) it has, b) it literally happened in the case that this will overturn. Are you aware that there was a series of leaks during the Berger court and that everything ended up fine? > Judicial independence, separation of powers If the leak came from within the judiciary, how does this threaten the independence of the court?
- refurb 5y ago