5 ms·
This sort of leak, likely from a law clerk given that it was a draft opinion, is not a good development. Nobody has any loyalty to their institutions anymore. E
by rayiner 5y ago
This sort of leak, likely from a law clerk given that it was a draft opinion, is not a good development. Nobody has any loyalty to their institutions anymore. Every institutional loyalty has been subjected to team red or team blue.
- magpi3 5y agoDon't you think it was for money? A law clerk would be risking their entire career for this, and I can't imagine they would do that just to get the news out early. I wonder if politico will acknowledge whether or not they paid for the leak.
- showerst 5y agoI’m doubtful of that; politico lives and dies on having friends in government willing to break things (whether by leaks or just telling their reporters public facts first). Looking like a tabloid has only downside for politico — either people will start to want money for scoops, or they’ll get cut off.
- jimmygrapes 5y agoI'd venture it was deemed "worth it" just like the absurd amount of leaks just after Jan 20, 2017. In this case, it's possible that an intentional leak of a draft is aimed to encourage politicians and activists alike to ~~threaten~~encourage various Justices to change their minds before the final decision, ala ACA/Roberts
- fundad 5y agoThis could just as likely to be to distract from something petty but embarrassing about to drop.
- sjg007 5y agoMaybe something about the Thomas’s …
- ceejayoz 5y ago> There's a third possibility, which might be most plausible: Roberts is doing his institutionalist best to court Kavanaugh and/or Barrett away from a full overrule of Roe and someone wants to deter that defection by documenting that they both initially voted to end it. https://twitter.com/stevenmazie/status/1521298950011207680 https://twitter.com/stevenmazie/status/1521298950011207680
- theoldlove 5y agoNo one does anything relating to Roe purely for the money. Whatever the reason for this leak, it was (at least in part) motivated by principle.
- fundad 5y ago
- elliekelly 5y agoIt could also have been leaked by a sitting Justice in which case the source would have risked nothing at all.
- magpi3 5y agoJustices can be impeached. I'm not saying they would be, but it's possible. Why risk it? The opinion is going to come out anyway.
- boringg 5y agoNot in the current political climate - can't get garner the votes to impeach.
- elliekelly 5y ago> Why risk it? Because the opinion can still change. The votes can still change.
- dragonwriter 5y agoGiven the absolute destruction this will wreak on internal institutional trust at the Court, there is only one sitting Justice that would really risk nothing at all by leaking it.
- 5y ago
- StanislavPetrov 5y ago>Don't you think it was for money? A law clerk would be risking their entire career for this, and I can't imagine they would do that just to get the news out early. We can only speculate until (unless?) the details come out. It certainly could be for the money. On a hot potato political issue like this, someone who is seen as "helping the cause" could easily make millions from a Gofundme or a book deal. There is also the social capital to be gained among those who would view this person's "sacrifice" as heroic. And of course there are always true believers like Reality Winner who are blinded by ideology and fail to consider the potential consequences of their actions.
- cudgy 5y agoSuch clerk would be heralded as a hero by many in the far left. They will write a book about it and make millions. Oh and get a show on a liberal network or at least be paid handsomely as a contributor. Perhaps I’m being too cynical.
- PolygonSheep 5y ago> A law clerk would be risking their entire career for this I see two likely outcomes here: 1) The leaker is not publicly identified and their career goes along as well as it would have had they not leaked. 2) The leaker is identified. They lose their clerkship but the leak will end up pleasing about half the country and they get a really nice job with some ideologically aligned law firm/NGO, a book deal, and a lucrative speaking career as the one who bravely risked their job to save the right to abortion.
- refurb 5y agoThis is the bigger problem. There is a process and some people seem to think circumventing it is the right response. The courts will make a decision and then it's up to Congress to draft new laws if it wants. Undermining the process of the judicial branch is not going to end well at all.
- maxerickson 5y agoThe leak could have been done by someone who favors the draft.
- zdragnar 5y agoThat is extremely unlikely. There's nothing to be gained by breaking the trust of the supreme court justices by leaking a draft of a decision you are in favor of. Now, the justices will be facing intense public discontent from those who want a different decision to be made before the draft is finalized (not that I suspect anything can realistically be changed at this point). If you favor the decision, then it also speaks to money not getting a significant motivating factor (taking money to leak would betray someone they are supporting, which seems less than likely). By this line of reasoning, I am assuming it was done by someone who deeply opposes the result.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> There's nothing to be gained by breaking the trust of the supreme court justices by leaking a draft of a decision you are in favor of. Yes, there is. You potentially lock in someone who’s been waffling on their final vote by making their initial vote public.
- zdragnar 5y agoThat could just as easily, if not more certainly, backfire.
- altcognito 5y agoIt could make the discussion about the leak, not the decision. It could soften the criticism of the decision itself. Seems to be working quite well, I'd say a success overall.
- smt88 5y ago
- jaybna 5y ago
- fundad 5y agoSCOTUS picked their team 21 years ago
- westernmostcoy 5y ago
- aaomidi 5y ago
- capguy255 5y agoYou think it's a good thing that the judiciary is an ivory tower with absolutely no regard for public perception? These nine people are unelected and appointed to their positions for life. They are insulated from political pressure by the other branches of government. But it is incredibly damaging to a democratic republic if government is unaccountable to the people. Not to mention, the basic premise of THIS OPINION is that public debate about controversial issues is healthy. Anyone complaining about this leak being damaging are doing a great job of undermining the basic premise of the opinion.
- refurb 5y agoYou think it's a good thing that the judiciary is an ivory tower with absolutely no regard for public perception? Yes! That the entire point of the Supreme Court. It’s amazing how many comments don’t even understand basic civics and how the US government is structured.
- capguy255 5y agoFactually inaccurate. Your statement could be said about the political branches as well, given that direct elections didn't exist when the Constitution was originally drafted the Congress/President were appointed by state legislatures. But more specifically -- when the country was founded jurisdiction of the court was limited in nature and mainly involved mediating disputes between state governments. The idea that the Court was the ultimate arbiter of constitutional interpretation was a radical idea that was essentially imposed by the first Supreme Court justice. If you think that the Court shouldn't be concerned with public opinion, well, the court staying out of public opinion is a large part of Alitio's reasoning here and that belies his argument. If being tasked with issuing public and controversial opinions, the justices shouldn't be political activists who are imposing their own personal agendas regardless of political opinion.
- refurb 5y agoHuh? Your argument is "that role for the Supreme Court wasn't decided until 1789"? I mean, that's correct, but isn't that relevant to the discussion of the Court's role 230 years later. I think what you want to say is "when the court rules the way I like, it's correct, but when it doesn't, the court is acting incorrectly". It doesn't work that way And what’s most hilarious is nobody actually read the draft opinion it says “Roe vs Wade has not resolved it, far better to have Congress resolve it”. How is that an opinion worthy of attack? HN likes to think it has as a more intelligent and logical discussion but looking at these comments it’s clear about 90% of it typical social media commentary you’d find anywhere. The few well thought out comments are downvoted to oblivion.
- cudgy 5y agoPerhaps because institutions care not about their people? Granted that Leaking of information by a law clerk when the clerk should be aware that they are not going to like many of the decisions made while clerking is unprofessional at the least.
- usrn 5y agoI don't think the MBAs appreciate just how destructive decisions that effect the employee's trust in the organization are.
- cudgy 5y agoTrue. MBA’s are short time horizon creatures. The impacts of their decisions are closely measured related to the number of years they expect to be employed at that company. Why should they care about anything else? Unfortunately, most of the executive compensation measures at corporations support this type of thinking.