3 ms·
People argued about this a bunch. here's a simple summary that is consistent with the reality: Google (Jeff's docs) says that Timnit offered her resignation (o
by dekhn 5y ago
People argued about this a bunch. here's a simple summary that is consistent with the reality: Google (Jeff's docs) says that Timnit offered her resignation (over the paper withdrawl demand and a refusal to let Timnit confront her internal reviewers) and Megan accepted it. In reality, Megan terminated Timnit for cause, but used Timnit's offer to resign against her. At google, resignations are normally triggered by the employee explicitly resigning in a system, but experienced leaders at Google like Megan know how to get around this.
I spoke to a wide range of managers at Google afterwards and the most commonly expressed opinion was "I'm amazed that Megan did that, it normally takes at least a year to fire individuals". What Jeff did led to a significant exodus of Google researchers (including some very preeminent ones) and Zoubin has to do all the cleanup.
- Manuel_D 5y agoI mean, if you say "do X or I quit" and the company responds "we're not doing X, bye" is it incorrect to say that the employee quit? That's the situation here, Gebru issued demands and said she'd quit if they weren't met. Google said, "we accept your resignation".
- dekhn 5y agoYes, that's not a resignation. At google, to technically resign involves filling out a form on a website, it's not something you can verbally state to your (manager's) manager. Again, Google can still say this and probably even thinks internally that's what happened, but having resigned twice from Google, that's not how it really works.
- Manuel_D 5y agoI'm pretty sure if you say to your manager "I quit" and stop showing up to work, regardless of what internet forms you fill out, it's a resignation. The fact that Gebru gave her resignation in the form of an ultimatum rather than whatever website form you're talking about is a pedantic point. "I resign if you don't do X." "We're not doing X, we accept your resignation." This is a resignation the way I understand it.
- bluefirebrand 5y ago> "I resign if you don't do X." > "We're not doing X, we accept your resignation." This approach from her managers can be criticized because it immediately closes the door on the possibility of her changing her mind and walking things back. However, it sounds like she was causing a lot of internal problems so perhaps they were already working to get rid of her. Accepting the implied resignation may have just been expedient, and saved the company a bunch of severance money.
- abduhl 5y agoYou can certainly criticize Google for taking someone at their word when that person issues an ultimatum, but then you’re tacitly admitting that the person offering the ultimatum is approaching the negotiation in bad faith. Google should not have to assume its employees are acting in bad faith when they communicate internally, especially when it comes to the future of that employee’s career. The real question for your framing is: Should Google have to say, “ok that’s it for real this time, no take-backsies”? I think that google should never have to say this any time someone says “or else I quit” because the threat of quitting tells us that they’re not willing to continue operating within Google. I honestly don’t see the reasoning behind drawing the line anywhere else.
- themacguffinman 5y agoShe never gave Google any reason to believe that she had wanted to walk things back or change her mind. That's the nature of delivering an ultimatum by threatening to resign: you are explicitly offering an immediate end to the negotiation. Don't be surprised if management takes you at your word, they're not mind readers. If she wanted to signal to managers that she might not actually quit over this, then she shouldn't explicitly say that she will quit over this.
- dehrmann 5y ago> the possibility of her changing her mind and walking things back. The George Costanza scenario: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IW78swzn_Bs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IW78swzn_Bs
- 5y ago
- faeriechangling 5y agoYes, under California law a legal notice of resignation requires an end date. She did not legally resign, and thus she was fired.