6 ms·
The fungi guys will tell you that running out of mineral fertilizer is bullshit on roughly 95% of the arable land because all of the minerals your food needs ar
by hinkley 5y ago
The fungi guys will tell you that running out of mineral fertilizer is bullshit on roughly 95% of the arable land because all of the minerals your food needs are right there in the sand and clay. I once heard it described that conventional agriculture is essentially a hydroponics system using partially sterilized soil as the substrate.
Nearly every symbiotic relationship fungi make is based on buying sugars from plants by selling them minerals from biological weathering of rock (particles). What happens in conventional agriculture is that we murder all of the fungi.
There are a few places with strange soil compositions that are actually lacking in particular minerals. We could either elect to do something else with that land, or transition everyone but them to a post-green-revolution strategy.
- cryptonector 5y agoOK, that may be, however, that doesn't change that our method of agriculture is about to come up short, and that to switch to other approaches will take time.
- etrautmann 5y agoThat's interesting, but a slight oversimplication since nitrogen isn't coming from the minerals. As long as nitrogen fixation can still occur (via decomposition of something organic, etc), I think the general principle seems reasonable, though not an expert.
- giantg2 5y agoOr from crop rotations of legumes with nitrogen fixing microbes. But that too would require a move away from intensive industrialized agricultural practices.
- mcguire 5y ago"Fifty-six percent of all land used for corn, soybeans, wheat, and cotton was on farms that used no-till/strip-till on at least part of their cropland in 2010-11: 23 percent of land was on farms that used no-till/strip-till on all land in these crops while 33 percent was on farms that used a mix of no-till, strip-till, and other tillage practices." (From the report summary.) https://www.ers.usda.gov/publications/pub-details/?pubid=44030 https://www.ers.usda.gov/publications/pub-details/?pubid=440... Industrialized farming practices are capable of changing.
- hinkley 5y agoToby Hemenway forwarded a notion that water cycles are sufficient to transport nitrogen from nitrogen-rich plants to their neighbors as a continuous basis instead of on an annual one. The model he builds from research he had read goes something like this: After a rain, as the soil goes from waterlogged to dry, there are phases that are hostile to root hairs and ones that are conducive. So the plant roots pulse with these cycles, advancing and retreating, sometimes arriving at places vacated by other plants. By this mechanism, any plant can scavenge some of the nitrogen left in the decaying root hairs of their neighbors. I would also warn that thinking nitrogen=legume is a potentially limiting strategic error. While something like 7% of all plants fall into the Fabaceae (legume) family, some other pockets of the Fabales order also have root nodules, in particular, alder, and up into the Rosids clade (buckthorn, ceanothus), and then a few odd stragglers like borage, which makes me wonder if it's a taxonomic problem, parallel evolution, or what. And then there's mondo grass (asparagaceae), which nobody expects to have root nodules. I knew about that plant for about two decades before someone pointed out it's nitrogen fixing, and that's not even in the wikipedia article. And in fact I'm having a dickens of a time finding a citation for that.
- tagami 5y agoYes. Nitrogen fixing bacteria (i.e. R. leguminasarum, s. meliloti) love the sugar exchange legumes offer. Cover cropping and inter cropping have potential to rethink the 113-year old haber-bosch solution.
- mcguire 5y ago"Cover crops were in use on less than 2 percent of total cropland (for all crops) during 2010-11 (6.8 million acres), with adoption rates higher in some regions (e.g., the Southern Seaboard and the Mississippi Portal). Although the benefits of cover crops and no-till/strip-till are enhanced when these practices are used on the same fields, the low cover crop adoption rate suggests that these benefits are realized on few acres." (From the report summary.) https://www.ers.usda.gov/publications/pub-details/?pubid=44030 https://www.ers.usda.gov/publications/pub-details/?pubid=440...
- bluGill 5y agoCover crops have come into style though since then. They are a lot more common. Not nearly as common as they should be, but they still a lot more than 10 years ago.
- hinkley 5y agoI don't know if this is my theory or just heavily implied but rarely stated in the literature: chemical fertilizers are giving plants something for 'free' that they used to pay for, and the reason the crops get bigger is not strictly because of the fertilizers, but because they get to spend those calories on more fruit. There have even been a few studies that warn that some strains of conventional crops are losing the ability to make this exchange. When we hit peak phosphorous and start taxing anhydrous ammonia production, these strains are at risk of going extinct (hopefully not enough of any crop to take us with them). The wrong question is, "how many calories of <X> can I get out of this field in a year?" The right question is "how many calories can I get total out of this field in a year" and there are a number of people out there demonstrating that they can get about 50% of the conventional yield from an acre, but for 4 different crops, and a few other things thrown in to get over 2x the total yield. The "problem", in scare quotes, is that these solutions take more thinking and knowing than scourging your fields every year. But since running a farm practically takes a bachelor's degree these days, that's not really a problem of lack of resource in that area. It's more a problem of perspective and focus.
- hinkley 5y agoI'm not the one oversimplifying, it's 'modern' agronomists that are oversimplifying. Nitrogen is 70% of our atmosphere. When you remove all other plant life in order to get the last 20% of theoretical yield from your land, you end up having to manually provide all of the services that were provided by the plants you killed. The Green Revolution is a petrochemical revolution. Cooking allows us to use lignin calories to recover more calories from our existing food supply. Livestock do the same, either by converting grasses (ungulates) or recycling unpalatable foods (pigs). When the petrochemicals become expensive we will have to go forward and/or backward to some other solution (most likely old solutions with new twists). The sibling comment with the huge bibliography points to some of the more coherent voices in the world of polyculture agriculture, although Gabe Brown exists in a sort of grey area between aggressive crop rotation and polyculture.
- tastyfreeze 5y agoFor anybody that is interested in reading more on the symbiosis of plants and fungi: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhizosphere https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhizosphere https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1906655116 https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1906655116 https://regenerationinternational.org/why-regenerative-agriculture/ https://regenerationinternational.org/why-regenerative-agric... Some proponents of regenerative agriculture to learn from are: Joel Salatin - https://www.polyfacefarms.com/ https://www.polyfacefarms.com/ Ray Archuleta - https://soilhealthacademy.org/team/ray-archuleta/ https://soilhealthacademy.org/team/ray-archuleta/ Gabe Brown - http://brownsranch.us/ http://brownsranch.us/
- triyambakam 5y agoAnd Entangled Life by Merlin Sheldrake (also available on Audible) for a more pop science overview.
- fredgrott 5y agoAre you familiar of why India and China move to fertilizer in them 1980s saved the from starving? I assure it is not BS. without fertilizer you do not the explosive yields that we get all over th world including the United States. And it is in fact well documented in a huge collection of science journals.
- zdragnar 5y agoIt's an interesting point, but using China as an example of rational agricultural planning is a pretty poor choice considering how recently the famines resulting from the Great Leap Forward were at that point in time.
- hinkley 5y agoI think you should look at what's going on with agriculture in India right now. There was a lot of bankrupt farmers in the US in the 80's, and that's happening in India over the last decade. Graphically, some farmers are taking their lives by drinking leftover pesticides when they realize they can't afford their crops this year. India is, by many accounts, likely to switch to a new-new form of agriculture sooner than some of the rest of us. The combination of bigger problems and a shallower 'tradition' of western farming practices makes that easier. There was a post here about California covering its irrigation canals with solar panels. A couple of us politely pointed out that a couple of provinces in India have already been doing this for a while.
- 5y ago
- hedora 5y agoMost of the nitrogen in currently living humans was captured from the atmosphere via the Haber Bosch process. That is the primary contribution of synthetic fertilizer, and there aren't scalable natural processes to match it. Countries used to go to war over nitrogen stores (such as islands covered in bat guano).
- christophilus 5y agoI know farmers who grow velvet beans and other nitrogen fixers and have huge yields. They’re somewhere between permaculture and organic farmers, though, so not industrial scale. It’d be nice if we could come up with a good way to scale permaculture.
- lasc4r 5y agoBased on playing Civ I just assumed they were mostly valuable for their use in making gunpowder.
- bluGill 5y agoYou seem surprised that a game simplified the mechanics of the real world until they are unrecognizable.
- lasc4r 5y agoIt did indeed make more sense to me to go to war for a strategic, scare and faraway military resource than to go through all that effort for fertilizer.
- throw0101a 5y ago> […] all that effort for fertilizer. Food to feed your troops (and workers in armament factories) is a strategic military resource. You have to either grow it yourself or import it. Artificial fertilizer allows you stop importing nitrogen (which could be blocked by embargoes) and make it locally, which would allow you to potentially grow food locally and not import it either (again, embargoes).
- oasisbob 5y ago> There are a few places with strange soil compositions that are actually lacking in particular minerals. pH and temperature are pretty easy and common ways for soil to keep essential minerals away from the plant life which could utilize them.
- hinkley 5y agoMicrobiome needs to be a more commonly known word. I bought some property that was practically concrete at the beginning of the dry season. I hurt my hand and damaged a tool trying to take a soil sample to send to the lab. A couple years later you'd never know, except that past me was apparently smart enough to take a video that I found when trying to free up some disk space. Plants, bacteria and fungi all manipulate soil PH for better or for worse, and you can steer that. And keeping soil covered, especially with tall plants, can drop the temperature tens of degrees Celsius. A forest floor is much closer to ground temperature, for a host of reasons.
- rosetremiere 5y agoCan you share the before/after, and your strategy?
- Melatonic 5y agoYea the way we do mass farming now is MASSively flawed. It produces huge yields but has tons of fragility - monoculture crops being a huge flaw as well. The one that fascinates me the most is the way the Mayans did it - Chinampas. That and aquaculture growing lots of smaller fish seems like a create combo if we could get small backyard pond/farms going
- giantg2 5y agoI dream of having land with a pond. Properly managed, it could produce about 50 pounds of bluegills, etc from a 1/2 pond every year, with little input and infrequent work.
- arthurcolle 5y agoDo bluegills taste any good?
- psychlops 5y agolol, good question. Blackened bluegill if not. You could always do tilapia or catfish.
- arthurcolle 5y agoTilapia has always been pretty tasteless in various dishes I've tried so not really a big fan. Catfish can be ok sometimes
- Trisell 5y agoTilapia is the tofu of fish. It tastes like nothing on its own but is a massive sponge to flavors you throw at it.
- benji-york 5y agoThere are better-tasting fish, but yes.
- rmah 5y agoThey could prove their case by actually doing it at commercial farm scale. But as far as I know, no one has. Which, to me anyway, shows they're probably (but not certainly) wrong.
- m_coder 5y agoThe comment farther up the thread (at this point anyhow)[1] references Gabe Brown. He is using very little to no commercial fertilizer on his farm and has been for years. I am guessing his audience among cash strapped young desperate farmers has increased a lot in the last 3 months. 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31237965 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31237965
- hinkley 5y agoThere are a couple of particularly noteworthy things about Gabe. His philosophy was a baptism by fire. He ran out of money via a combination of bad decisions and getting hit by a statistical cluster of bad years where the world seemed to be saying Fuck You in Particular (there were 4 years with catastrophic hail storms, and none of his neighbors got hit by more than 3 of them). Some of his crops are targets of opportunity. They're a cover crop and if the weather is just right and he gets it planted in time, he might be able to harvest it, or at least graze some livestock on it, but if not, then that's fine too, because the dividends still made it worth doing. He is a very frugal farmer, both in resources and energy. Mark Shepard, in contrast, seems to be more interested in the energy side of frugality, and is so open in his disdain for people throwing good money/time after bad that it's practically his personality. In particular he likes to rant about how utterly mathematically unsound the idea of rain barrels is, and the kind of cognitive dissonance it takes to keep telling yourself otherwise.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoThe 55 gallon rain barrels are near useless for small plot irrigation. Larger containers can hold a meaningful amount of water to be useful during sporadic dry spells.