3 ms·
In Iowa we have the opposite problem too much rain. We are in the last week to plant corn before seeing reduced yields.
by bluGill 5y ago
In Iowa we have the opposite problem too much rain. We are in the last week to plant corn before seeing reduced yields.
- bombcar 5y agoWe need the transcontinental pipeline to push water to where it needs to be. Or agriculture needs to move to where the water is.
- dahfizz 5y agoI don't forsee a transcontinental water pipe going over well. I, for one, refuse to subsidize people who want to live in a dessert with my own water table. People should live in areas that can support human life.
- danaris 5y agoWhile I think there should absolutely be limits of some kind, if the water need in places like California could be spread out over the water table of, say, everything else west of the Mississippi, I imagine it could make a big difference to the water-poor places without running the risk of depleting the water-rich places enough for anyone to even notice. Of course, that's assuming that such a pipeline network would be practical to build and maintain. Personally, I suspect that local desalination will end up being better for coastal or near-coastal areas like California.
- CapricornNoble 5y agoThe nuclear power + desalination plant combo seems like a no-brainer to me in particular. Even if it meant sticking them in Oregon or Washington (for reduced seismic risk) and piping the fresh water down to Cali.
- wiredfool 5y agoNope. Washington/Oregon has the same or greater seismic risk to California due to the offshore Juan de Fuca Subduction zone. Less common, but much bigger earthquakes, and generally we're overdue for one. (return period, low hundreds of years. Last one, Jan 26, 1700, magnitude 8.7-9.2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1700_Cascadia_earthquake https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1700_Cascadia_earthquake)
- mindslight 5y agoDoes anyone know how the capital depreciation versus electricity cost of desalinization works out? As in, would desalinization make for a good capacity smoother (for solar/wind and the like), where the plant could produce more fresh water while electricity was abundant and then idle when it was not? Or if desalinization is done by something like reverse osmosis then perhaps storing energy as accumulated pressure, while the filter membranes worked full time. It would seem to make more sense than using lithium for grid scale batteries.
- jandrewrogers 5y agoThe Pacific Northwest does not have reduced seismic risk. It is prone to regular strong earthquakes, both from the subduction zone and from systems of major thrust faults that run through populated areas. Also major tsunami risk since many of the thrust faults run through large bodies of water.
- LBJsPNS 5y agoGrow your own food then.
- bombcar 5y agoThis is a good point - Californias could start buying fruits and foods from states without water problems, and everyone could boycott California produce. This would effectively be the same as shipping water to California.
- dahfizz 5y agoI do have a sizeable garden, and get most of my meat / produce from local farms. I think the only thing I buy from California is pistachios.
- newaccount2021 5y ago
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Grow your own food then You’re saying this to Iowa?
- juve1996 5y ago> Iowans spend an estimated $9 billion on food each year; 90—95% of this food is imported into the state. https://www.extension.iastate.edu/ffed/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/IowaFoodandFarmFacts-2018-1.pdf https://www.extension.iastate.edu/ffed/wp-content/uploads/20...
- 1970-01-01 5y agoSomeone else had an interesting idea: We could set up a transcontinental pipeline to the desert, and in exchange we would receive their solar power.
- dahfizz 5y agoWell, first of all, most of North America already has an interconnected grid. So if CA has surplus solar generation, we already get it today. If we wanted to build a dedicated line so that only the places pumping water to CA were getting the electricity, I am skeptical that the economics work out. I'm sure CA is sunnier than the average east coast state, but enough to cancel out all transmission losses and the higher cost of operating a plant in CA?
- Kon-Peki 5y agoIt's only interesting if you live in the west. It's not a good trade. There's plenty of solar energy potential in the midwest, along with tons of wind energy potential. We don't need your solar power.
- oceanplexian 5y agoThis makes sense to me. Water is the most abundant substance on Earth. Build aqueducts and move the water around. If the Romans could do it we can handle it too.
- neverartful 5y agoRunning a water pipeline across the continental divide and through the Rocky Mountains? Did the Romans do anything comparable to that (move water UP)? I was under the belief that aqueducts relied on gravity to move the water.
- exabrial 5y agoA transcontinental I think is feasible, but only if we could do filtering at a massive scale. Taking raw water from one watershed to another is an environmental disaster.
- bushbaba 5y agoToo much rain is bad for many crops. Better to move the water
- imtringued 5y agoThis feels like a bad joke. Apparently Californian farmers have an innate right to water that overrides the water needs of every other state.
- pilom 5y agoA pipeline like this is so naive I can't figure out if the op is serious or not. The cost alone would bankrupt multiple states. For example the Central Arizona Pipeline goes from lake Mead to Tucson. That's it. It cost on the order of $10 billion and provides barely enough water to cover the needs of the cities and farmers along it. Doing a pipeline from Iowa over the continental divide and into the Colorado River basin that was big enough to matter would cost hundreds of billions to a trillion dollars. Forcing water intensive ag to move by actually charging a reasonable rate for water is a far more sensible answer. Just requires political capital.
- MauranKilom 5y agoThis concept is commonly called "river". Except they go downhill from the rockies, not up. It would be just a tad ambitious to somehow build a second Mississippi but in reverse.