4 ms·
I’ve always gotten the impression that Ive may be a truly great designer be he needs an editor. He had that in Steve Jobs. Once he lost his editor the designs
by MBCook 5y ago
I’ve always gotten the impression that Ive may be a truly great designer be he needs an editor. He had that in Steve Jobs.
Once he lost his editor the designs Apple shipped moved more and more towards being perfect designs at the expense of thoughts of usability.
And now he’s known as the guy who helped “ruin” Apple’s products until they kicked him out.
Unfortunate. For the lack of an editor.
- bornabox 5y agoI think your comment on Jobs being Ives editor is spot on. They worked as a team and complemented each others shortcomings (at least to a degree). There was apparently never this kind of relationship between Cook and Ive. But to say Apple kicked Ive out seems wrong to me. They rather wore him out and he left.
- bborud 5y agoWe can speculate why he left. But I think a lot of people agree on the observation that he had probably been irrelevant for a good while by the time they parted ways.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoNot so much irrelevant as superfluous, and possibly a negative influence. To give credit to Cook he listened to the chorus of complaints and acted on it. The results aren't as pretty as the Ive era designs. But they give users a lot more of what they really want, instead of a nice case with missing useful features. Ive actually had a lot of misses, from the gradients and flat look in iOS 7, to the infamous butterfly keyboard and missing USB ports, to the early versions of Watch, to (at a guess) the touchbar. There were also Jobs-era failures like the hockey puck mouse and the Siri Remote for Apple TV. And personally I'm not a huge fan of the current Apple typography and branding. So - not really missing his influence. I'd love to see Apple find a new design head who could inject more personality than the current products have, but I don't think Ive's departure was a terrible loss in any way.
- neighbour 5y ago>The results aren't as pretty as the Ive era designs Not saying Ive hadn't had some great designs in his time at Apple but saying the new designs aren't as pretty is highly debatable. From what I can tell, I don't think many people found the touchbar to be particularly "pretty".
- Affric 5y agoIf there is one thing the Touch Bar is it is pretty. Aesthetically it changes the entire look of the keyboard and wraps it together. My next computer is having function keys though, so make of that what you will.
- JohnBooty 5y agoIve actually had a lot of misses, from the gradients and flat look in iOS 7 Lot of people thought that was a major win, compared to the childishly skeuomorphic interface (largely a product of Jobs' taste) that it replaced!
- jkestner 5y agoOnce it settled down, agreed. But iOS 7 initially swung too hard at a look that was not as discoverable or accessible. Thin font, UI elements that were hard to distinguish, low contrast. https://www.macworld.com/article/221357/why-ios-7s-design-is-bold-but-flawed.html https://www.macworld.com/article/221357/why-ios-7s-design-is...
- eropple 5y ago> The results aren't as pretty as the Ive era designs. I'm not sure they're supposed to be. The design aesthetic of the new MacBook Pro is...chonky. And that has to be intentional. They've made a work machine. It kinda looks like one. And despite being very clearly of the same design lineage, the MacBook Air doesn't have that vibe, to me. It's a much lighter-feeling thing that feels closer to the older designs. > And personally I'm not a huge fan of the current Apple typography and branding. The font kills me. It's just not nice to read.
- Rapzid 5y agoYeah, Apple would have made him irrelevant so he could go without tanking the stock.
- masklinn 5y ago> There was apparently never this kind of relationship between Cook and Ive. That seems obvious, Cook was never the "taste" person, which is what Jobs was (brutally so). Cook has always been the ops guy (his original role was SVP for worldwide ops, then EVP for sales and ops, before becoming COO).
- HNHatesUsers 5y ago
- omnimus 5y agoThis is not how design process works. There is not single genius outputing some designs that get implemented. There are teams of people making and testing thousands of variations. Dont think these teams dont know about the issues with their designs. Theyve dealt and solved questions we cant imagine. Ive as design lead already is the editor. Thats job of art director. What Jobs has done for Ive is that he probably pushed many other departments to do what Ive and his team came up with. Its very likely Ive “fails” are organisation issues and his inability to push things to completion. I am not a big fan of Ive but Apple turned their trajectory completely around because of designs comming from department he was leading. And the big turn around the old iMac was comming mostly solely from him. I wouldnt give so much credit to Jobs in same way as i wouldnt give so much credit to Ive. They are just on top.
- Closi 5y agoI think OP means that without the influence/editing of others this led to asthetic-centric thinking rather than including the right balance of product/function-centric thinking, and the 'editing' was that Jobs could influence him to ensure the right balance was in the products.
- MBCook 5y agoThat’s an excellent way of putting it.
- omnimus 5y agoNo you can read my other comment. I dont agree
- omnimus 5y agoAnd I think this is very narrow view and not how it works. Industrial designers are not some artsy bitsy people who try to draw beautiful things. They are mostly engineers who try to deal with people problems of the product. If your experience with designers are some UI juniors who got the job after being in the field for less than 2 years it might seem like it. But designers doing those products are really juggling hard problems and requirements that other departments give them. Everything is a tradeoff and they are the ones 100% on side of usability. I am sick of this perception that that products made by engineers are functional and products made by designers are pretty. Its designers who make it people functional and its engineers who whip out the specs and clever tech solutions. The aesthetic is sideproduct.
- rodgerd 5y ago> I’ve always gotten the impression that Ive may be a truly great designer be he needs an editor. You aren't a brilliant designer if your design choices make a product less functional. And there's a long track record of Ive doing exactly that.
- educaysean 5y ago> being perfect designs at the expense of thoughts of usability This is an oxymoron. Being a desinger doesn't mean that you focus on making things look good while someone else comes along and reminds you about "usability". A design isn't "perfect" if it has usability problems. Any designer worth their salt will be the first to tell you that.
- Affric 5y agoI agree with your comment and would add that aesthetics impact usability. If a design is for some reason repulsive to a user then it is not good design. I think Ive and Jobs together raised the bar for tech so many times that its easy to forget what computers used to look like.
- saalweachter 5y agoI sometimes feel like authors sometimes get this problem once they get famous enough -- the power dynamic between them and their editor shifts, and the author gets to stand firm for their creative vision and they end up publishing novels that they could have trimmed a couple hundred pages from.
- randyrand 5y agothey still were the best machines imo. Have to give them some credit. build quality was always top notch and it was “just” the keyboard that ended up having too high failure rates, and very meh typing experience. it’s not like the machines were dumpster fires. I think we are too harsh sometimes. but yes obviously the keyboard sucked and i hated that part of the laptop. otherwise it was as good of a machine. great even. slimness is still nice in a laptop - it still performed as good as any other laptop I considered. 4x USBc was a great move too, especially charging from either side. So undoubtedly new ones are better. but we are overly harsh on that era and Ive. it’s not like he was the only one in on the keyboard decision either. Apple thought the keyboard was a competitive advantage at first!