7 ms·
Bitcoin value falls from above $33 to below $3
- AndyKelley 15y agoPorn is to the Internet as selling drugs is to Bitcoin.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- bdr 15y agoOne of these things will happen: (1) A successful attack on Tor, (2) A successful attack on Bitcoin, (3) The Silk Road's (or similar site's) share of the black market will continue to grow rapidly.
- jerguismi 15y agoIt seems pretty inevitable in the longer term. If current technologies break up, new technologies will be popping up. I guess law enforcement has already lost this battle (in the long term), similarly as RIAA/MPAA has lost to piracy. It should also be noted that criminal use doesn't raise the price of bitcoins, since criminals don't necessarily hold their bitcoins. For them bitcoin is just an another money laundering system.
- bdr 15y agoIt should also be noted that criminal use doesn't raise the price of bitcoins, since criminals don't necessarily hold their bitcoins. For them bitcoin is just an another money laundering system. Disagree. There's a "float" period between when the order is placed and when it's completed (service/goods verifiably delivered). The dollar-value volume in this float period sets a floor on the market cap of Bitcoin. I'm clearly fascinated by all this, and a little surprised that more people aren't. The Bitcoin protocol is one of the great recent innovations in distributed systems, and this particular application of it is the culmination of a lot of crypto work into a cypherpunk fantasy.
- VladRussian 15y ago>a cypherpunk fantasy yep. All your transactions are recorded for posterity and law enforcement can access them at anytime. The moment i first time heard about bitcoin i immediately read their paper and this was the instant end between me and BT - it is either a honeypot or an NSA's distributed "calculate these hashes@HOME" project. Most probably it started as the latter and once NSA had gotten enough results and withdrew the funding (which supported the currency valuations stable growth before speculation rushed in), the BT now is only the former.
- DiabloD3 15y agoSatoshi's white paper disproves everything you just said. Either your comment is out of ignorance or out of malice. Go read the white paper.
- VladRussian 15y agoour reading of the same paper seems different (i mean if you did really read it). Well, don't believe me, check this out: http://gawker.com/5805928/the-underground-website-where-you-can-buy-any-drug-imaginable http://gawker.com/5805928/the-underground-website-where-you-... "Jeff Garzik, a member of the Bitcoin core development team, says in an email that bitcoin is not as anonymous as the denizens of Silk Road would like to believe. He explains that because all Bitcoin transactions are recorded in a public log, though the identities of all the parties are anonymous, law enforcement could use sophisticated network analysis techniques to parse the transaction flow and track down individual Bitcoin users."
- DiabloD3 15y agoThats a misinterpretation of what jgarzik said. Basically, if the cops grab your box with your Bitcoin crypto keys on it, they know all of your transactions. This is why you need to encrypt your keys if you're doing something illegal. tl;dr: Nothing ties you to your address but evidence not inside of the chain.
- 15y ago
- pessimizer 15y agoI beg to differ. If people can buy drugs or launder money easier with bitcoin than with coin coin, people are going to want bitcoin.
- ajones05 15y agoHere was Jason Calacanis's take on May 15: "Bitcoin P2P Currency: The Most Dangerous Project We've Ever Seen" -- "We are 100% certain that governments will start banning bitcoins in the next 12 to 18 months. Additionally, we’re certain bitcoins will soar in value and a crush of folks will flood the system and start using them." http://www.launch.is/blog/l019-bitcoin-p2p-currency-the-most-dangerous-project-weve-ev.html http://www.launch.is/blog/l019-bitcoin-p2p-currency-the-most...
- rorrr 15y agoWho gives a shit what some famous spammer says about crypto-currency? Plus, how do you ban something like this?
- esrauch 15y agoI'm not sure what you mean, you ban it exactly the same as you ban copyright infringement or child porn or any of a dozen other crimes that are committed on a computer that simply involve a transfer of information between a few parties.
- Zodiakos 15y agoSo, in other news - governments everywhere ban bitcoin. Bitcoin use soars wildly.
- mikeryan 15y agoNot sure where you make that assumption from. If bitcoin never gets adopted as legal tender for real world goods its value gets severely limited. If Government's explicitly state that bitcoin is not legal tender, and I can't buy a latte at Starbucks with it then its not very useful.
- rorrr 15y agoBut if you can buy things privately or online with bitcoins, bitcoins will be used without government permission, and will have value. SilkRoad works. http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2011/06/silkroad/ http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2011/06/silkroad/ http://gawker.com/5805928/the-underground-website-where-you-can-buy-any-drug-imaginable http://gawker.com/5805928/the-underground-website-where-you-...
- mikeryan 15y agoAs much as bitcoin's gotten some bad press recently, this kind of market volatility will severely hamper bitcoin's efficacy as a stable unit of currency. It needs a consistent and stable rate of growth (even if negative).
- jasonzemos 15y agoIndeed. If it's worth $1 flat it will just be that much easier to do the conversions mentally. Also, vendors won't have to update their site prices as often.
- pessimizer 15y agoI think more that it needs some utility over other currencies within some context. That utility margin will bring stability.
- dudurocha 15y agothis reminds me about the quora post about bitcoin. In a world of where there is no regulation in currency, you dont have a FED, this money will crash. We dont have liquidity in this currency, as so, nobody can 'inject' money in the market.
- jerguismi 15y ago> this money will crash Give it a little more time. There has been more widespread adoption only for 8 months or something. I think the amount of bitcoin related activity is pretty impressive. Let's see after five years if cryptocurrencies are still used.
- synctext 15y agoIt's very simple. As the money creating/coin mining is unregulated. It's not tied to any actual usage. This is a classical deflating bubble which will never recover. Just wait for Cybercurrency 2.0 with decent build-in regulation of coin minting.
- aero142 15y agoGold also has no fed to 'inject' money. It does have miners though. It has not crashed and appears to be more stable that fiat currencies, not less. (not a bit coin or gold standard fan here, just confused.)
- william42 15y agohttp://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/20/US_Historical_Inflation_Ancient.svg http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/20/US_Histor... If you look at this, you can see that gold is more volatile and spiky.
- jquery 15y agoWe can disprove that pretty quickly and easily: show me a broad basket of goods that costs the same in gold ten years ago as it does today. Or tell me this: did everything suddenly go on sale or shoot up in price when gold recently shot up and then dropped 10-15%? No.
- lurch00 15y agoBitcoin is essentially a giant pyramid scam. The early adopters have cashed out long ago. As mining gets more and more difficult, less people will cling to the liquid currency. Why trade with a deprecating currency, anonymous or not? The fact that the exchange rate is below the cost of mining should be alarming for many reasons. I'd assume the creator/first adopters do not care, either way.
- jerguismi 15y agoIt's free market, everyone is free to buy and sell as they wish. It's not a scam since there is the same information to everyone. I'm pretty sure that the early adopters couldn't guess this year's rise in value, and couldn't guess the price drop either. While I believe in bitcoin or cryptocurrencies in the longterm, I'm still pretty sure that bitcoin value will stay very volatile in the coming years. The stability will take time, and widespread adoption for this kind of innovation will take years if not tens of years.
- polshaw 15y agoYour reply missed his point as bitcoin is 'mined' not just bought and sold. The difficulty of that mining is set based upon the computing power of the miners. Add to this the fact that the number of coins available to be mined each day is designed to be reduced over time, and you end up with early adopters (formost of which being the creators) controlling a massive proportion of the total worth of bitcoins.
- jerguismi 15y agoWell, I guess that most startups are pyramid scams, since the founders (early adopters) end up controlling massive proportion of the total worth of the company.
- dpark 15y agoIf the startup founders create the company specifically to sell a worthless product to investors, then yeah, it's a scam. Also Bitcoin is not a company, any more than US Dollar is.
- polshaw 15y agoIt is essential to remember that there is massive inflation of the money supply going on (by design), and that this is the key driver of the price downwards. ~35% increase in the money supply over the next 12 months; proportionately higher over the last 12 (as the same in absolute terms). Its rise to $30 was driven by hype and speculation. The falling prices stop any speculators jumping on board, and there is no significant 'economy' yet. The rate of money supply increase will be halved in 2013, so don't expect any recovery before then.
- jerguismi 15y ago> The rate of money supply increase will be halved in 2013, so don't expect any recovery before then. The value is mostly driven by mass psychology, the inflation caused by miners is only one factor. If some goverment-issued currency would start hyperinflating, bitcoin or similar cryptocurrency would be pretty good choice for people to move to.
- tomkarlo 15y agoSo they should jump out of a highly liquid, government-backed security that's proving untrustworthy to go into an experimental currency that's relatively illiquid? I'd think they'd go towards gold, which seems like the opposite direction. If people are jumping out of a printed currency to avoid inflation, they're going to want something where they know it's easy to convert back into something you can buy things with. Jumping into a cryptocurrency for their cash holdings would require they believe that they can easily jump back out.
- jerguismi 15y agoOf course it would require more infrastructure around bitcoin. There is already an impressive amount of exchanges, and it would be pretty easy to exchange bitcoins with software like android bitcoin wallet. excellent app btw: https://market.android.com/details?id=de.schildbach.wallet https://market.android.com/details?id=de.schildbach.wallet Gold isn't really a good instrument of exchange. Gold-backed currencies are, but the central issuer has proved problematic historically. Of course cryptocurrency used widespreadly is just a nerd fantasy right now, but I believe in it more than to a new gold standard :)
- powertower 15y ago> It now appears the $3 to $33 prices for Bitcoin were due to speculation. Come on. Was it ever attributed to anything but speculation.
- Eyght 15y agoIf it ever was, I would love to see that article.
- william42 15y agohttp://falkvinge.net/2011/05/29/why-im-putting-all-my-savings-into-bitcoin/ http://falkvinge.net/2011/05/29/why-im-putting-all-my-saving... "the currency has increased in value one-thousandfold against the US dollar in fourteen months. Yes. Read that again: one-thousandfold, fourteen months. There is currently no indication it would stop or has saturated; quite the opposite."
- krobertson 15y agoWow. I'd hate to be him. :)
- dennisgorelik 15y agoSomehow Jim Cramer with his infamous Bear Sterns prediction comes to mind: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gUkbdjetlY8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gUkbdjetlY8 Note that Jim Cramer is still running his show.
- alexhaefner 15y agoyeah, I don't understand all the attention given to bitcoin. It's not like it's a system that's immune to systematic manipulation. Anyone operating under the assumption that bitcoin is a stable system is naive. I'm open to being wrong about my assumptions.
- jerguismi 15y ago
- daimyoyo 15y agoAnyone know what the conversion rate between bitcoins and Dutch tulips is right now?
- raganwald 15y agoToday the joke-explainer duty falls upon me: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulip_mania http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulip_mania Even if you are familiar with the expression, the full article is well worth reading.
- gnu6 15y agoIndeed, those who deal with web 2.0 startups would be well advised to read that article.
- hippich 15y agoThese who advise to read this article better read it in full themselves. Especially part where it is explaining jumps from futures contract to options and back. And how this affect price.
- hugh3 15y agoWell, tulips.com will sell you 300 tulips for $347, though I'm sure you could get them a lot cheaper if you pick 'em up from the farm yourself. Roughly three to one, though, would appear to be the going rate.
- joshontheweb 15y agoIs this really a bad thing? Now people can stop hoarding them and start really using them as currency. It never really mattered what they were worth unless you were holding onto them. If you use bitcoins to enable transactions only and keep your money in real dollars then it can be pretty useful.
- jerf 15y agoIt is if the only reason that they have value in the first place was the hoarding and speculating, which seems a reasonable interpretation of events to date. A currency of no value is not useful for trade. I mean that "if" as a true logical statement, not an implied assertion that it must be true. (I do believe that, but I'm not asserting it right now, because I'm not defending it.)
- joshontheweb 15y agoIts apparent that people are finding value in them aside from their speculated worth. They are using them to facilitate anonymous transaction and more easily transact internationally. Whether those use cases are valuable enough to keep people using bitcoins, I can't say.
- epscylonb 15y agoBitcoins utility is a factor in its value. True, speculation and hoarding dominates its usage at the moment but there is still potential.
- corin_ 15y agoIt's a problem because the people who are using bitcoin have seen the value drop to less than 10% of what it was, so why should they trust it to be a currency worth using? For it to be a currency it doesn't need a huge value per bitcoin, nor does it need to be constantly rising a huge amount - but it does need to be reasonably stable.
- fleitz 15y agoThat's a great question as to why anyone would use a currency whose valuation had dropped to 10% of what it was. http://www.kitco.com/charts/popup/au3650nyb.html http://www.kitco.com/charts/popup/au3650nyb.html
- jmvoodoo 15y agoBittulips?
- drivebyacct2 15y agoAll I have to say is "wow". The commenters here are atrocious. If you're going to rage against BitCoin, (and I'm no huge fan), at least bother yourself to have half a clue what they are instead of spouting lies here in some vicious attack on them.
- kellyreid 15y agogood thing I made a bunch of money by trading BC intra-day when it hit mainstream. seriously, did anyone expect this to be a "new paradigm"? it was a fun toy for financially-minded engineers and traders, but I can't say I'm surprised to hear that it's in free-fall. i wonder where the bottom is? Once it drops well below USD1.00, I think I'll buy a bunch on a cheap bet :)
- adrianwaj 15y agoI thought it'd be the new paradigm, but closed my bitcoin blog when I saw how terrible the client was and couldn't see it improving that much. Just waiting on bitcoin 2.0 from lessons learned.
- Murkin 15y agoCan someone give a concrete example of themselves using Bitcoins for something other than speculative trade ?
- powertower 15y agohttp://gawker.com/5805928/the-underground-website-where-you-can-buy-any-drug-imaginable http://gawker.com/5805928/the-underground-website-where-you-...
- tptacek 15y agoHow real is that? Like, I know the site exists, but how many people here know people who have successfully conducted commerce on it? How are they keeping themselves from being exposed?
- spiceapps 15y agoAs the article states, the site is only accessible through the TOR network, which is completely anonymized. All transactions are completed through Bitcoins, which is also pretty anonymous. When shipping the drugs, users are urged to get creative, such a vacuum sealing to avoid smell detection.
- joshhart 15y agoI don't understand how it would be safe at all for the recipient. If the "smell prevention" failed couldn't the police just arrest whomever it was shipped to? I can understand that the shipper is pretty safe dropping the package off but if it's flagged as black-market goods it seems like the buyer is totally busted.
- runn1ng 15y agoEvery bitcoin opposer repeats, that the money will artificially start going up and that is why it will crash. Right now, it is going down, for a long time. So that is not why it will fail. It will fail because noone actually needs it. It has no real value over other means of electronically exchanging money - paypal, for example, is much faster, easier to use and, dwhile it is not free, thanks to the wild exchange rate of bitcoin, one will probably still have more money from paypal than bitcoin money exchange. There is no place to spend bitcoin, because most of the people don't CARE that it's centralized and someone can watch it, because it is infinitely easier to use paypal to just PAY STUFF, instead of going through the pains to exchange bitcoins through shady sites, wait DAYS to get it on your wallet, then wait hours until the blockchain is downloaded, then wait another hours since the block is 6 times confirmed. Maybe it will work in the end, it's nicely designed and all. But I don't see anyone using it right now. There is no real reason to do so.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- weavejester 15y agoEven though users typically don't care whether a service is centralized or not, decentralized services have the advantage when it comes to building infrastructure around them. With Paypal, the same company is responsible for sending, receiving and storing your money. A decentralized currency like Bitcoin could act as an intermediary protocol that would allow users to choose different companies to handle each of these tasks. Bitcoin to me seems interesting because it's essentially an open protocol for transferring and manipulating finances. I kinda feel that talking about deflationary currencies or currency fluctuations is somewhat missing the point.
- dolphenstein 15y agoValue is arbitrary. None of the major world fiat currencies have any inherent value. They are backed by nothing. Reminds me of an episode of This American Life. Brazil's currency was down the toilet, so they invented a new currency and tricked the populace into thinking it had value. http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/423/the-invention-of-money http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/423/t...
- lukev 15y agoI like bitcoin. It bought me an iPad 2 when I cashed out my 3 weeks worth of mining at the height of the bubble.
- hippich 15y agoBitcoin is something completely new and different. It is like open source software. Until people really understand it, it will be toy for geeks with similar market coverage and price. (or someone find design bug and we can forget about it) Biggest hurdle when using bitcoins is not it's high/low price, but rather fluctuation. Fluctuation happens because too many speculate it and not trade with it (well.. currency trading is also trading..) And I would say this is totally expect-able and acceptable. With time if this technology will prove itself, it become major online payment method. And believe me - work on this project is very active right now. All this investing mumbo-jumbo is just a random noise...
- verroq 15y agoNo I think it's because bitcoin's reputation had been thoroughly trashed due how much the early adopters made off with. Any mention of bitcoin now just leaves a sour aftertaste.
- hippich 15y agoanother one... who cares? Do you care federal reserve guys can print as many dollars for themselves? Does it prevent you from using dollars to buy stuff in walmart? Difference from FED is that it happens to bitcoin only once - during initial distribution. After all coins "printed" - no more coins will be thrown into circulation. Initial distribution have to be made somehow. And I believe people who invested their time and money earlier have to be paid accordingly. Read paper. This is not money question. This is technology question.
- verroq 15y agoWell what I'm saying is that people will avoid bitcoin out of spite.
- joeycfan 15y agoBitcoin is proof of concept that an Internet currency will work. It doesn't work yet - but it can work so it will work.
- vrdb2 15y agoTo everyone mentioning the great Dutch tulip debacle: Tulips are a commodity, the coin is a currency. Bubbles can be analogous, but they aren't tautological. Just a thought.