12 ms·
The tragic case of the wrong Thomas James is finally righted
- rayiner 5y agoA letter from the exonerated man with more details: http://justicedenied.org/issue/issue_27/thomas_r_james.html http://justicedenied.org/issue/issue_27/thomas_r_james.html
- stickfigure 5y agoWow, that was written in 2005. Heartbreaking.
- Kaotique 5y agoIt says that the case could not be re-opened because for that you need new evidence, but the evidence was just overlooked during the initial trial. Even if all the existing evidence is enough to prove your innocence you somehow need "new" evidence to reopen your case. This is not the first time this happened either. It is very hard to get justice even when you are obviously innocent.
- macintux 5y agohttps://slate.com/news-and-politics/2015/03/innocence-is-not-cause-for-exoneration-scalias-embarrassing-question-is-a-scandal-of-injustice.html https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2015/03/innocence-is-not... Have to wonder how many innocent people have been executed.
- vmception 5y ago> The final piece of the puzzle came when the main witness recanted her testimony. /Facepalm
- mherdeg 5y agoIt's funny my first reaction was to wonder how the other people involved feel about this: I wonder how the defense attorney feels about this. The July 2021 GQ article says "Chin, now retired, declined to answer questions for this article, citing client confidentiality." I suppose Detective Conley has seen the news too? ("Detective Conley told me through an intermediary that he wasn't interested in talking, either. He wanted to enjoy his retirement.") But on further reflection I guess those people … really don't matter? They're no longer working, they can't hurt anyone else. What is Mr. James going to do now?
- TedDoesntTalk 5y ago> He wanted to enjoy his retirement That’s the real crime, that he ruined at least one man’s life but still gets to “enjoy retirement”. And I bet he sleeps like a baby.
- sdoering 5y agoI don't understand this ad hominem. Why should the policeman not be allowed to enjoy his retirement. I would assume that he has done his job hundreds of times and has provided justice in more than the vast majority of his cases. But yes. For a mistake in which all(!) parts of the system have completely failed, for that then the pawn is to be punished. In a time of cancel culture, mobs on the net, cyber bullying and death threats by idiots online, I wouldn't talk to a reporter either. At least that's how I can imagine the thought process. And there may be another aspect. I don't know, but my pop culture "education" would make me fear that I might expose myself to the risk of a lawsuit for damages if I were to admit a mistake instead of the police officer. Because in my opinion he is not to blame. But he does bear part of the responsibility. And he should own up to it. Unquestioningly. But I know too little whether he would make himself personally vulnerable. In this respect I would not go from the refusal to comment on the case to deny him the enjoyment of the pension.
- kergonath 5y ago> I don't understand this ad hominem. Why should the policeman not be allowed to enjoy his retirement. I think the issue is the contrast between having ruined someone’s life and the “fuck off and let me enjoy myself” reply. And the utter lack of empathy this betrays. A simple acknowledgment and possibly an apology for having caused so much hurt would have gone a long way.
- ars 5y agoIn todays world there is no apology he could give that would make people happy. People online are brutal. It's better not to engage at all.
- aaaaaaaaaaab 5y agoLet’s hope he sues them for a few million dollars.
- thombat 5y agoFlorida pays the wrongfully imprisoned $50k per year - but only if they have no other felony convictions. And Thomas James has one for possession of marijuana in 1989, so by Florida law he's entitled to no compensation at all. Parts of the justice system in the USA are quite unforgiving, which feels at odds with a professedly Christian nation.
- plutonorm 5y agoha, christianity is nothing but a way of social signalling purity. So they can get away with being nasty brutish selfish beings. The world suddenly makes sense if you consider that the majority of people are complete asshats who would kill you for a sandwich and never think on it again -as long as they can get away with it.
- spoonjim 5y agoLOL “Christian nation.” I don’t even think the Evangelicals actually believe this. It’s just a set of coded language they use to gain power, like people quoting their favorite movie.
- moralestapia 5y ago>which feels at odds with a professedly Christian nation I observe and respect the Christian heritage and traditions. Having said that, and from my own experience, the most vile, hypocrite and ill-intentioned people I've met, happen to portray an image of justice and purity based on (their purported) Christian values. I believe it's some sort of mimicry they develop on purpose, to balance out the negative image deserving of their real self. They're also quite easy to spot, though. Most Christians keep what they do, good or bad, to themselves, while these guys preach it out in a way that comes off as unnatural. Anyway, these kind of scumbags, when at the right place/time, could do irreparable damage to other people's lives and then go on with their business and completely forget about it, so be careful when you encounter one, best advice is to just steer away from them. (Thomas couldn't, in this case, and that's part of the tragedy).
- stephbu 5y agoAt what point are "eyewitness testimonies" and "identity parades" going to legitimately be called out as questionable. The science certainly points towards their lack of credibility in many many circumstances. I guess there is no real incentive on the part of the criminal justice system to resolve this.
- rayiner 5y agoEyewitness testimony has been called out for being questionable for more than a decade now. So have the less reliable aspects of forensic “science.” Courts have made progress in addressing both through jury instructions and gate keeping on expert testimony through the Daubert process. For example, here is the current Massachusetts model jury instruction on eyewitness testimony: https://www.mass.gov/info-details/model-jury-instructions-on-eyewitness-identification-model-eyewitness-identification-instruction https://www.mass.gov/info-details/model-jury-instructions-on... It mentions, for example: > People have the ability to recognize others they have seen and to accurately identify them at a later time, but research and experience have shown that people sometimes make mistakes in identification. > The mind does not work like a video recorder. A person cannot just replay a mental recording to remember what happened. Memory and perception are much more complicated.[a] Remembering something requires three steps. First, a person sees an event. Second, the person's mind stores information about the event. Third, the person recalls stored information. At each of these stages, a variety of factors may affect -- or even alter -- someone's memory of what happened and thereby affect the accuracy of identification testimony.[b] This can happen without the witness being aware of it. Eyewitness testimony also just matters less these days. Today, the trial would have involved cell phone location tracking from the accused showing he wasn’t in the area at the time.
- fsckboy 5y agoHuman societies have relied on eye-witness testimony since Cain and Abel. Sure, you can study it and discover that humans are unreliable (film at 11!) but it's silly to think that we are going to have trials and testimony and leave out eye witnesses. What's important about our trial system and juries-of-peers is that the average person feels the system is doing its best to find the truth so that it's not necessary to form vigilantes. Our system is overall pretty good, better than asking all the people who show up at a crime scene or later to protest.
- sebmellen 5y agoNo words, really. Commenting to boost the post in the algorithm. How sickening and heartbreaking.
- userbinator 5y agoYet the end to James’ confinement came abruptly and almost anti-climatically. That's a very good thing, because one would hope that the justice system, after realising its mistake, would correct it quickly instead of dragging things out like it usually tends to do.
- sdoering 5y agoStill they gave the impression of dragging it out. There were protests and it took a very long time for this anticlimactic ending to occur. Basically even with doing everything properly they really took their time. Way longer than it seems it took them to check the facts initially and prosecute him.
- IshKebab 5y agoThey didn't though.
- macintux 5y agoAbrupt != fast.
- citizenpaul 5y agoThis is why I adamantly am against CSAM and will never buy another apple product as long as I live. Once the slow grinding wheels of government start moving against you there is no stopping it. You often find your entire life at a halt. Call it what you want but I"m not carrying a govt fastpass to jail in my pocket.
- School-Cotton 5y agoFor what it's worth, Apple seems to have completely cancelled that project in response to public outcry.
- kergonath 5y agoYou can still count on people to use it as an argument 5 years from now.
- DocTomoe 5y agoGiven the potentially destructive nature of this policy, even suggesting it is a major red flag and it's not unreasonable to take an absolutist approach to the problem. Turns out if you pander to wannabe-autocrats, people will remember.
- citizenpaul 5y agoYou really don't understand the seriousness. The law enforcement job is to find a reason to arrest you, HN posters seem to have a grave misunderstanding of how police work. They will not use info to make you innocent "anything you say can and will be used against you" The courts job is to exonerate you not the police. Once the police start to zero in on you every incentive they have is to find a reason to bring you to court. Now you have to spend potentially thousands of dollars and a great deal of your time to defend yourself even if the case is "open and shut". Anything that makes the process "push button" is terrible for a law abiding citizen and potentially life destroying. This is the difference between tyranny and due process. CSAM Takes away due process by automating the process of guilt. It doesn't matter if its well intentioned.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kingcharles 5y agoWhen I was in jail I ended up in court twice with people who's sibling had used their name during a traffic stop and got caught with something illegal and ended up in jail, then bailed out. Then they forgot to go to court, so weeks later THE SIBLING got arrested for something they didn't do and had to spend a whole bunch of time in jail (because they are now classified as a flight risk for not coming to court) before they could persuade a judge they weren't the right person. And if you run the probability that I ended by chance in the court twice when this happened, then it must be happening much, much more often than I witnessed.
- tpoacher 5y ago> So he went to the records department at headquarters and pulled up a mug shot of a Thomas James i.e. the "Prosecutor's Fallacy" (more typically invoked over DNA, but "we found a 'name' at the scene" is effectively equivalent)
- golem14 5y agoIs the wrong 'righted' though ? He was locked up >30 years, and now was recognized as innocent. Not even sure if that means that his prison time is expunged. How can he be made whole ? Seems almost impossible.
- BizarroLand 5y agoI would say $60,000/yr plus a pension would be a start. At least that way he could have a home and maybe have a family of his own in the time he has remaining. Money doesn't fix everything but better a bandaid and a kiss on the booboo than a "tough luck, piss off", right?
- bradknowles 5y agoWith respect, it's not righted until he gets back all those lost years, and all that pain and suffering. In other words, it will never be righted. He may be out of jail now, but he can never get back all those missed years.