2 ms·
You need carriers to launch planes But are planes the most cost-effective form of throwing high-explosive long distances? Once, they were. They had a much grea
by simonblack 5y ago
You need carriers to launch planes
But are planes the most cost-effective form of throwing high-explosive long distances? Once, they were. They had a much greater range than a battleship's guns and thus obsoleted the battleship.
These days, missiles have double the range of carrier aircraft. So a very inexpensive frigate with long-range missiles is far more cost-effective than a huge expensive Carrier Group. (Most of the Group's ships are there merely to protect and support the carrier. Without the carrier, they are redundant. Sure, a Group looks big and powerful, but cost-effective? No.)
- nradov 5y agoLong-range missiles can only work if you know in advance where the target will be. Manned tactical aircraft are still far better at searching out unknown targets, and at handling dynamic situations like close air support. Perhaps that will change in a few decades as sensors and AI technology improve, but the reality today is that long-range missiles simply can't fulfill the required mission set.