19 ms·
USPS sued by states and environmental groups over purchase of 8.6 mpg trucks
- somat 5y agoI don't think I have ever seen data for mpg in the context of a usps route, so while an 8.6 mpg sounds bad. I have no context of vehicles with an equivalent duty/load cycle to compare with. It does sound like that 8.6 number was the cherry picked, worst possible case number chosen for a dramatic headline.
- MBCook 5y agoNot really. The current Grumman mail trucks get like 8.2 MPG during typical deliveries according to USPS testing. These get 8.6 with AC on (which the current vehicles lack) or 14 with it off in those same USPS tests. I think it’s safe to say postal carriers will use the AC when it’s warm/hot out. The new vehicles do much better on EPA tests, but of course those don’t mirror what the post office actually does. It may be an improvement, but it’s nowhere near enough improvement for me. Maybe DeJoy would have a leg to stand on if they were getting 35. But they’re nowhere close.
- rasz 5y agoAC in a truck with permanently open door where driver stops every 2-3 minutes to step out?
- metadat 5y agoThe cold would still feel nice, and maybe they can just roll down the window to stick it in the mailbox? It sounds wasteful but being stuck in a hot vehicle without A/C is a bit rough, mine was broken in summer of 2015 and I was too lazy to get it fixed, but it was pretty uncomfortable at times. Though I don't mind it hot, was pretty sweaty.
- rasz 5y agoBig fan triggered by seat sensor sounds about right for UPS van use case.
- Matthias247 5y ago> These get 8.6 with AC on (which the current vehicles lack) or 14 with it off in those same USPS tests This doesn't add up for me. A car doesn't spend 40% of its power (we are talking about 2-3 digit kWs) for AC. Even if its massive since its a truck and uses 10kW on peak, everything else would consume way more.
- mrtweetyhack 5y ago
- savanaly 5y agoJust tax the carbon already. The back and forth tug of war over how much gasoline any entity, public or private, individual or collective, "deserves" to consume at current market prices is exhausting and morally asinine.
- oceanplexian 5y agoThere are too many problems with this to count, but I'll point out a few. First, there is no such thing as a global taxation authority, so whatever carbon you tax in the USA or Europe will simply be emitted by China and other developing countries, consequently boosting dirty economies and kneecapping cleaner economies (Actually making Climate Change worse). The second is that it further enriches the pockets of corrupt politicians and government institutions. The third is that it's a regressive tax that disproportionately hurts the poor and working class who can't afford expensive electric cars or energy saving equipment.
- warning26 5y ago> whatever carbon you tax in the USA or Europe will simply be emitted by China and other developing countries, consequently boosting dirty economies and kneecapping cleaner economies This argument has been used against every environmental regulation since the 70s. It wasn't a good argument then and it still isn't. Yes, obviously it would be better if we could get every country to agree on reducing pollution. That doesn't mean it's pointless to reduce emissions even if it's localized to only certain countries.
- massysett 5y agoUSPS does not pay taxes.
- bagacrap 5y agogas is taxed
- noahtallen 5y agoI feel like this is such low hanging fruit. As the public, I think it’s fair to push “publicly owned” services to be at the bleeding edge of new technology, especially when it could have a high impact. It seems like a USPS route is an awesome fit for EVs: - It can charge overnight at the facility - it goes pretty slow most of the time, with a lot of stop and go. No need to go super fast, have excellent aerodynamics, or fancy features. - emissions wise, 8.6mpg is really, really bad. - cost wise, paying for gas for 8.6mpg trucks is really, really bad. - No need for an extreme range. Just driving slowly around city/town blocks shouldn’t take that much energy. - Lower maintenance burden for something that gets used every single day should save money. - More space in the truck for packages because there’s no engine. All of these together mean that a USPS EV doesn’t have the big concerns that normal consumers might have: - No charging at home or at a rental place. - No charging where they need to go. (USPS truck would have a static route, always in range of its home charger) - Crazy features high-tech cars might have. (Can be super basic.) So all in, I don’t get why they wouldn’t do this. I just can’t see a world where an EV is more expensive than a gas truck. Even if it’s a bit more up front, they have to save a ton over time with fuel and maintenance savings. And it doesn’t even seem like range would be a problem on the vast majority of routes. I’m trying to think of an extreme route length, and it can’t be more than 100mi, right? That seems crazy high, and is also super low as far as EV range goes these days. So what gives?
- bnajdecki 5y agoYou’re 100% right. I would like to see the reasoning behind this decision
- netizen-936824 5y ago$$ for friends of politicians
- tedunangst 5y agoThey found one really long mail route that couldn't be serviced by an EV, so it's just a matter of crafting the requirements that every vehicle must handle every route, and you get the preordained outcome.
- tomohawk 5y agoWe so badly need the "English Rule"
- mindslight 5y agoWhile we do badly need the English Rule [0], suits against the government are more properly seen in light of the first amendment right to petition the government, and should thus be exempt. [0] or really, a defensive English Rule where a losing plaintiff covers the defendant's costs, but a losing defendant does not always have to cover a plaintiff's costs.
- pmyteh 5y agoEngland and Wales deals with the footnote issue by sometimes allowing for a 'Protective Costs Order' if the issues raised are of general public importance, resolving them is in the public interest, and the applicant (normally for judicial review) has no private interest in the outcome of the case. This lets the judges cap costs awards prospectively (as low as zero if necessary) if the alternative is that a meritorious case is likely to be dropped to avoid the risk of an unaffordable costs award.
- postalrat 5y agoI wonder on average how many miles one of these trucks travels per day. 20 miles maybe? Less?
- tehlike 5y agoWith that much stop & go, i wonder what a regular car would do.
- leoh 5y agoThis is is the real question