12 ms·
Don't respond to tone rather than content, especially if you're in no position to evaluate the content. Otherwise you'll fall for horseshit spoken in a tone you
by pessimizer 5y ago
Don't respond to tone rather than content, especially if you're in no position to evaluate the content. Otherwise you'll fall for horseshit spoken in a tone you like.
- SubiculumCode 5y agoJudging a book by its cover is actually not the worst strategy for picking a book. And I WAS responding to the content; content like accusing scientists of lying, content like silly photos designed to get you to click. edit: To sum in Bayesian terms, the prior probability of reading a good book is greater if the publisher had sunk money into a high quality cover, because they believe in its content, while a trashy cover might be the only thing a trash book could obtain. Likewise, the prior probability of bullshit is greater if the tone is shrill, accusatory, and exaggerated, while the prior probability of quality content is greater if the scientific commentary is academic, serious, and professional.
- stevenhuang 5y agoBayesian reasoning has its limits. If one is lazy and don't think to reconsider when warranted, it's often accidentally used as a crutch. Works in most cases I grant you that, just user beware. > "The man who has fed the chicken every day throughout its life at last wrings its neck instead, showing that more refined views as to the uniformity of nature would have been useful to the chicken" - Bertrand Russel
- cwillu 5y agohttps://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/heuristics-that-almost-always-work https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/heuristics-that-almost...
- stevenhuang 5y agoI liked that article very much when it was shared, perhaps time for a rereading! Cheers.
- cwillu 5y agoI will tolerate an abrasive tone in an emotionally charged discussion where people's lives are affected. I will do so carefully, because it's incredibly easy to be mislead by emotional content, but I will put in the effort, because important viewpoints can't be usefully distinguished from manipulation by their tone in those arenas. Physics is not one of those arenas. I am not even remotely worried that selecting explorations of QM interpretations based on tone might result in giving me a skewed perception of the topic due to my ignoring the views of those being harmed by them.
- saiya-jin 5y agoThere are numerous problems with approach you mention, ie strong push for emotions to sway opinion. If one resorts to attacking primitive emotions, hard facts clearly are not most important in the discussion anymore. In proper science, that should never be the case.