7 ms·
It's an endless cycle. As the saying goes... Hard times make strong men Strong men make good times Good times make weak men And weak men make hard times.
by zozbot234 5y ago
It's an endless cycle. As the saying goes...
Hard times make strong men
Strong men make good times
Good times make weak men
And weak men make hard times.
- goodpoint 5y ago...and the saying is BS.
- DaltonCoffee 5y agoCare to elaborate?
- Tomte 5y agohttps://acoup.blog/2020/01/17/collections-the-fremen-mirage-part-i-war-at-the-dawn-of-civilization/ https://acoup.blog/2020/01/17/collections-the-fremen-mirage-...
- DaltonCoffee 5y agoStrange because I've always seen the saurdukhar/fremen as a literary interpretation of a real aspect of human nature - the ability (of some) to perserverve and excel in stressful/difficult situations. Some real life examples I've pointed too are the ghurkas in WW2 or Russian hackers.
- Izkata 5y agoIt's the meme version of this: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strauss%E2%80%93Howe_generational_theory https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strauss%E2%80%93Howe_generat... The "Defining a generation" section is fairly short and describes the theory, and the "Timing of generations and turnings" section maps the theory onto the past ~500 years. (Edit: got the indentation wrong, I thought the comment I was replying to was on the quote, not the "it's BS" reply. I don't think this is BS, at least not completely.)
- goodpoint 5y agoThe quote is similar to "what does not kills you makes you stronger", easily disproven by polio. [For the nitpickers: I know, the statement depends on the context] But let's move on: what do you mean with "strong men"? If you mean some sociopath/callous/ruthless emperor or dictator capable of starting massive wars - it hardly constitute creating good times. If you mean men that are successful in current society... then very very few billionaires came from a childhood of hardship and poverty. If you mean men that are capable of taking good decisions while facing difficulties and the stakes are high... then you are describing good education and good mental health, which are does in now way comes from "hard times". All modern pedagogy and psychology sciences indicate that hardships create a lot of broken people and a few hardened narcissists. If you mean that affluent and decadent societies become self absorbed and weaken as a whole - then I would tend to agree... but the term "strong men" would be profoundly misleading.
- bladegash 5y ago> All modern pedagogy and psychology sciences indicate that hardships create a lot of broken people and a few hardened narcissists. Really depends on who you ask in the field of psychology. There have been several perspectives contrary to what suggest (e.g., humanistic psychology, positive psychology, post traumatic growth, etc) and I don’t agree that “all modern pedagogy and psychology sciences” suggests that hardships yield nothing but broken people and narcissists. However, I generally agree with the idea that sayings like “what doesn’t kill you makes you stronger” are a bit silly (they ignore the fact that what doesn’t kill you can severely weaken you for life). I just don’t think it’s particularly helpful to take things to the other extreme either.
- trey-jones 5y agoGood point. Wait, no I disagree and I think history probably does as well. If you'd like to engage in some unmitigated pedantry regarding this topic, check out https://acoup.blog/2020/01/17/collections-the-fremen-mirage-part-i-war-at-the-dawn-of-civilization/ https://acoup.blog/2020/01/17/collections-the-fremen-mirage-... which refers to this exact cycle.
- cwillu 5y agoThe post specifically calls out the saying as “the modern version of this idea has deep roots in Romanticism (c. 1800-1850), a reaction against the reason of the Enlightenment – which makes it more than a touch ironic that this brain-dead meme is so frequently presented as clear logic.”
- taylodl 5y agoI'm not familiar with that saying but it's so true!
- TheOtherHobbes 5y ago"Strong men" make fascism, not good times. It's pretty much the definition of fascism - a delusional paternalistic idiot infecting everyone around him with his own neuroses and narcissism, in the name of "patriotism" and "respect."
- thriftwy 5y agoI hope you realize that strong men (of old times) have nothing in common with delusional paternalistic idiots?
- rank0 5y agoI can’t understand what you’re trying to convey. The terms fascist and nazi seem to have lost all meaning nowadays…at least to the far left.
- _usr1 5y agoGood god, enough with this "fascist and nazi seem to have lost all meaning" nonsense. Let's call it the "No true fascist fallacy". I could bring the corpse of Himmler here and some people would regurgitate the same "Bu-bu-but that's not actually fascist enough!". OP was basically quoting the definition of Ur-fascism by Umberto Eco. Is that historically accurate enough for you? Or should we check beforehand if whoever he was referring to has ever took part in the Salo republic, before we commit the grave sin of not being taxonomically accurate?
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoWell yes, the Goodwin point is now crossed very casually, just like people are using superlatives for the mundane things, such as "I ate the most amazing fries yesterday". This makes for poor debates, where there is little nuance, fuzzy scales and hardly meaningful communication.
- zmgsabst 5y agoThe reason people focus on definitions like “oh, it’s really about toxic masculinity!” is because admitting the truth would make them look bad: Fascism is a collectivist authoritarian system with regulated commerce rather than direct state control, often co-occurring with systemic racism. The reason people don’t want to be honest about the definition is that it’s the platform of modern Democrats, who are gaslighting by calling everyone else a “fascist”: Democrats are collectivist authoritarian. Democrats are pushing for regulated commerce. Democrats are rebuilding systemic racism, from rationing healthcare [2] and government aid [1] based on race to attempting to repeal civil rights laws in WA [4] and CA [3]. Democrats took to the street in acts of arson, violence, and murder to terrorize the public ahead of an election — the modern Brownshirts. [5] Democrats are fascist. Sources: https://nypost.com/2021/06/15/farmers-upset-with-bidens-american-rescue-plan-act/ https://nypost.com/2021/06/15/farmers-upset-with-bidens-amer... https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/01/race-based-covid-rationing-ideology/621405/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/01/race-based... https://ballotpedia.org/California_Proposition_16,_Repeal_Proposition_209_Affirmative_Action_Amendment_(2020) https://ballotpedia.org/California_Proposition_16,_Repeal_Pr... https://ballotpedia.org/Washington_Initiative_1000,_Affirmative_Action_and_Diversity_Commission_Measure_(2019) https://ballotpedia.org/Washington_Initiative_1000,_Affirmat... https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/everybody-down-what-happened-at-the-chop-shooting-that-killed-a-teenager-and-led-to-the-areas-shutdown/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/everybody-down-wha...
- micromacrofoot 5y agothis saying is often used to demean men that don't fit a very narrow definition of "strong"
- rank0 5y agoIt’s a comment about the cyclical nature of prosperity. It’s not an attack on the non masculine.
- juanani 5y ago
- micromacrofoot 5y agoI'm saying that right-wing authoritarians often use it as an attack on people they deem as not traditionally masculine, despite the original intention. It's used frequently enough that some people might mistake association. Search for this saying on twitter, for example. It's been co-opted as fascist propaganda.
- nkingsy 5y agoY’all are taking it way too literally. I take it as hard times make it clear what’s important and inspire people to work towards that. In good times people forget.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoPerhaps the language has evolved to the point that the work needs some translation. Because it strikes me as vague enough to be harmful with folks like Putin aspiring to embody "strong men".
- Izkata 5y ago> aspiring to embody Take note of your own phrasing: it automatically excludes him from that group.
- javajosh 5y agoIf you find yourself in good times, then the key is to make them harder for yourself. Self sabotage by being an outspoken iconoclast, and be hated by everyone! Whee!
- ativzzz 5y agoMakes sense. Strength is useless during peace times, so strong men find themselves out of a job with nothing to channel their strength into. "Weakness" which in this case means classically feminine traits are useless during war times but are far preferred during peace times. We don't need strong men during good times and we don't need weak men during bad times. Although now we are in neither a good nor bad time. What kind of men do we need?
- SV_BubbleTime 5y agoStill strong. But in character and not necessarily muscles.
- javert 5y agoThe quote is about moral strength and virtue, not muscles.
- ativzzz 5y agoVirtue is not what survives hard times, it's grit and brutality. Raw strength. Morals and virtues are what arise during good times once we've secured survival.
- kbelder 5y agoI'd argue that virtue is a strong survival trait, and vice is a sign of weakness. But we may be considering different things, different aspects of life.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- msla 5y agoThis is utter nonsense. Strong men make bad times, as anyone who's lived under a strongman can tell you, and strongman regimes are extremely weak in terms of human development, technological progress, and military power, as evidenced by the utter failures of North Korea and Nazi Germany and the USSR. Whining about how they did some notable things is missing the point: They couldn't sustain, they had no staying power, they achieved some victories and then either got pounded into nothing or stagnated while the rest of the world moved on. You can see in modern Russia what decades of strongman rule, first in the USSR and then under Putin, looks like: Idiot conscripts hyped up on moronic propaganda getting blasted by an actual military fielded by a so-called "decadent" Western nation, with their ships being sunk by land-based weapons (and if you don't get why that's pathetic, you're not worth talking to) and their economy being destroyed by those "decadent" nations deciding to not buy from them anymore. Strongmen create good times? Briefly, maybe, but get out before the piper demands to be paid, if anyone will have you.
- swid 5y agoI mean, even in your own post, you spell strong man different from strongman. Here’s a definition of the word strong for you: “possessing skills and qualities that create a likelihood of success.” Obviously this meaning is divorced from the definition of strongman you provide, so why be obtuse about it?
- msla 5y ago"Strong man" and "strongman" are identified in the meme. I'm just making that explicit.
- paulpauper 5y agonah, strong but insane men make hard times.
- bodge5000 5y agoI've always thought that saying is pretty weak, not only because of the bias that anyone believes it will tend to characterise themselves as one of the "strong men", but also because what one side characterises as good times, another side will characterise as bad. The end of WW2 was a good time for the allies, pretty devastating for Germany, and yet we don't see Germany in current times as on a completely different trajectory than the rest of us, its actually probably the most average of the former allied countries. Also the political perspective, what the left would characterise as good times the right would probably characterise as bad, and visa versa. At that point its no longer strong and weak men, but men of one camp and men of another.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoYeah I'm pretty sure whoever wrote that saw police enforcement and brutality as the only reasonable solution to stability and what makes "a real man".
- bee_rider 5y agoThere are places that have been great to live for multiple generations, and places that have been troubled for just as long, I don't think this model has much predictive power.
- Mindstormy 5y agoThis is one of the most factually incorrect things I see repeated over and over. I know it is quite a long read but it's explained pretty well here https://acoup.blog/category/collections/the-fremen-mirage/ https://acoup.blog/category/collections/the-fremen-mirage/