5 ms·
The whole field of behavioral science is something that exists and looking there for hints what actually works might be a good thing. Afaik the studies say that
by atoav 5y ago
The whole field of behavioral science is something that exists and looking there for hints what actually works might be a good thing. Afaik the studies say that punishment is worse than ignoring wrong behavior in terms of getting you the outcome you want.
Better even is giving positive feedback on positive behavior while of ignoring bad one.
And yes, I had a toddler brother and had to test this based on actual, stressful reality.
- devmor 5y agoMy uncle (RIP), who was a child psychologist was a staunch proponent of treating his kids with respect and intellectual honesty. Like most kids, they still got into trouble and had major screw ups in their young lives. However I've never seen anyone who respected their parents more in my life. There were no beatings, no yelling, no destroying or selling of their property as punishment. And wouldn't you know it, when they got in trouble for something they did wrong - they didn't resent their parents for it. They were always expressive that their mistake (or the general view of society that what they did is a mistake) was the problem. It's hardly empirical evidence but it certainly convinced me.
- donthellbanme 5y agoI get what you are saying completely, and completely agree. I have noticed male children, especially the first born male, who's father is a Psychiatrist end up--well--what's the right phrase? Some seem very angry. It's just something I noticed in my small circle. I'm probally wrong, but it's something I have noticed.
- vosper 5y agoHow many people do you know who are the first-born male child of a male Psychiatrist? I'm thinking your sample size might be a little small to be drawing conclusions :) (that and, how are you sure you're not experiencing confirmation bias?)
- Dudeman112 5y agoThat seemed like an oddly specific filter. Unless there's some condition that make them more likely to know about first born males of male psychiatrists, I would have bet on "definitely small sample" too
- neuroma 5y agoI'd suggest that 1. Psychiatrists and very different to psychologists 2. Intra job variation of personality and parenting style probably exceeds inter job variation 3. Anger at dad may not be a consequence of their job
- louky 5y agoI had one of each (Psychologist, Psychiatrist) as parents. Could have been worse. Almost no anger 40 years later!
- rpod 5y agoAs the first-born son of a psychiatrist, I feel inclined to add the data point that I do not recognize this in myself. I have a fairly neurotic personality, though, maybe that's the word you are looking for? Then again I don't think my father's profession has had a significant impact on my personality. Maybe it has more to do with a type of personality that professions like psychiatry attract? It's hardly disputed that your parents' personalities tend to rub off on you.
- disiplus 5y agoi have two boys, 3 and 5. You cannot ignore what they are doing. If one of them starts to something wrong the other one joins so you have a double chance of trouble. And if we are outside and they start to misbehave in public you cannot ignore them. If they start to throw things at objects or people you cannot ignore them. If they start to say things that are not appropriate, you cannot ignore them (they favourite word right now is shit). when they start fighting i cannot ignore it. Im reading those opinions online and cannot at all connect it with what im seeing with my kids.
- dsego 5y agoOf course you have to stop them if they are misbehaving or causing harm. A good book on this topic is "How to Talk so Little Kids Will Listen: A Survival Guide to Life with Children Ages 2-7".
- Ntrails 5y ago> You cannot ignore what they are doing [all the time] You are obviously correct here and the giant pitfall of parenting advice is generalisation. Your kids are bickering on a car journey? You have choices in how to respond. Your kids are throwing stones at passers by? That has to stop right now as fast as you can apply influence with a transition from verbal to physical based on distance. Don't take anything you read here as gospel. Note the myriad of parenting attitudes and common child behaviours globally. Accept you are doing it wrong, we all have/do/will.
- katbyte 5y agoI don't think anyone is saying ignore it, just that how you address it really matters. I grew up with a sibling and we got up to all sorts of trouble/fights and our parents were severe about it. all the punishment did was make sure we didn't do x or y in-front of the parents. Like it did teach me to be a great liar and sneak and we got up to all the hijinks, but I don't think that is the ideal parental outcome despite how well it has served me in life.
- blub 5y agoWhat studies? Empirically, ignoring wrong behaviour is a clear recipe for ending up with a completely spoiled menace on ones hands. The alternative to punishment is therefore not ignoring, it's explaining things and setting boundaries which will have to be enforced somehow.
- Brybry 5y ago> Parents should also be reminded that physical punishment may cause tantrum behavior to intensify and lengthen. Such parental behavior also teaches children that hitting is permitted when the punishment is physical (Kyle, 2008; Murphy & Berry, 2009) > The best recommendation for parents in this situation is to remain calm, try to distract the child, and ignore the tantrum if possible. [1] https://sci-hub.st/https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23006014/ https://sci-hub.st/https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23006014/ > Ignore the tantrum. [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK544286/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK544286/ > "Getting into it teaches the kid the way to get your attention is to have a big fuss," he said. "If you ignore that outburst, they're less likely to do it." - neuropsychologist w/ lots published on quality and duration of tantrums in toddlers [3] https://www.today.com/health/real-reasons-your-toddler-crying-1C9313670 https://www.today.com/health/real-reasons-your-toddler-cryin... [4] https://sci-hub.st/https://doi.org/10.1097/00004703-200306000-00003 https://sci-hub.st/https://doi.org/10.1097/00004703-20030600... [5] https://sci-hub.st/https://doi.org/10.1037/a0024173 https://sci-hub.st/https://doi.org/10.1037/a0024173 > Any behavior that gets attention will continue - clinical psychologist [6] https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/how-to-respond-to-tantrums-2020051919845 https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/how-to-respond-to-tantru... Obviously there's lots of nuance and this is mainly advice given for tantrums in toddlers, primarily attention seeking tantrums in toddlers without development issues. But it does generally follow 'praise good behavior, ignore bad behavior'.
- dudeman13 5y agoDo you mind sharing how you got those references? I.e. which search strings/websites you used, or if you had them at hand with f.e. Mendeley or maybe already knew about them? I wanted to read some papers in the subject a few days ago but couldn't come up with a good search strings nor good initial references. It's not my field of expertise :x
- bluecalm 5y agoIt's true that punishment as in: "I am going to do unpleasant things to you because you misbehaved" isn't very effective. What works is enforcing consequences of actions: "the rules of this trip are such, it's ok if you ignore them but then you will not be part of it anymore" or "playing time comes after cleaning up after dinner, if you choose not to clean up no one is going to play with you". As long as the rules are clear, make sense and others follow them they work. Another thing that works is making the child aware that their behaviour hurts you. "What you do makes me sad/tired/feel/makes my work harder". You are not angry, just making them aware how their actions affect others. Needless to say you should never ever give in to a tantrum. Giving in to tantrums is not part of the structure everyone abides by. Source: my gf works with children, often with disabilities and is a psychologist interested in behavioral science. Children actually like you more if you're someone enforcing the rules and structure than a pushover who will do as they please if the tantrum is long and loud enough.