4 ms·
What's insane is that some people believe that just because they do something in a state with computers, they are somehow not bound by the state's laws.
by vkou 5y ago
What's insane is that some people believe that just because they do something in a state with computers, they are somehow not bound by the state's laws.
- bpodgursky 5y agoBecause the business engagement not meaningfully in that state, if the only interaction is with a an employee with a computer screen in the state. I get, from a legal perspective, that that's not fully aligned with all court precedent, but it's OK to call it dumb that CA has any say over this situation.
- pavlov 5y agoDoes the employee pay tax to California? Then they're employed in California. That doesn't seem complicated.
- bpodgursky 5y agoNobody is questioning that the employee should pay income tax. The question is whether the 1-person remote "business" has a nexus in CA and should be the treated the same as a company with a warehouse and 500 employees. I'm not sure what you're missing here. I'm calling it dumb and inefficient. Yes, CA seems to have the legal right to set up a dumb system. That doesn't mean it's a Good Thing.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The question is whether the 1-person remote "business" has a nexus in CA It does; that nexus consisting of 100% of its labor force working in the state. > and should be the treated the same as a company with a warehouse and 500 employees That's not the question, since a company with a warehouse and 500 employees in California is not treated the same, as it is subject to a whole lot of rules and mandates that a single-employee remote-only foreign-HQ’d business is not.
- vkou 5y agoIf I open a branch in California, and hire one person, is my firm subject to California's laws? Yes, obviously. The part of my firm that is operating in California is. Why does not having a physical location for the office change anything?
- jleyank 5y agoDon’t forget that city and or county taxes can get involved as well as state and federal. Hence contractors. When I talked to euro companies as a n American it was never hire w/o moving to eu. Could contract but then it was all my problem.
- telchior 5y agoIt's not insane. It's perhaps not perfect, but definitely not insane. Considering: * We have 50 states * ... and if you're doing business online, add 50 countries to that... * ... with their own sub-regions which may have their own laws (see the comment about Quebec above) * Each of these local jurisdictions tends to have a LOT of laws on the books; * Many of which are poorly written and unclear * Many of which have been inconsistently, infrequently or unclearly applied as the internet has grown (you can very easily find examples of even giant companies, with corporate legal teams, running into unexpected issues) Finally, there's the kicker: * Even lawyers will end up telling you that, due to lack of clarity around laws applying to the internet and their enforcement, you might engage in a practice now only to find out later that it was more risky than you thought Granted, OP's case is not the most complicated out there. It has a fairly clear answer: California is extremely aggressive about taxation and will grab any money it can. Hence the nickname "Taxifornia". And, be aware that employment is a particularly risky area. But interstate commerce is really not as simple an issue as you're making it out to be. I've asked my accountant about issues where the answer was "well, you could technically be fined $50,000 and nobody really knows whether the state could successfully apply the fine, but right now they're not doing it sooooo..."
- vkou 5y agoSo? If you are doing business in 50 states, you need to be complaint with the laws of all of them. If you don't like it, you should move to a country with a more homogenized regulatory environment. Just because you are doing things with computers doesn't change anything. If I operated a franchise with 50 different locations, I'd also need to be complaint with 50 different regulatory environments. You can't have 'states rights' (which, for better or worse, is how America claims to govern itself) and also have a single law of the land. If you aren't sure that you're breaking a state law, don't do business in that state. Or do, and live with the consequences.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> You can't have 'states rights' (which, for better or worse, is how America claims to govern itself) No, it's not. “States rights” didn't really enter the political lexicon until it was injected there by the proponents of permanent institutionalization and expansion of slavery, who eventually revolted over it, lost, and whose ideological successors keep raising as a motto for their (usually unsuccessful, beyond the short term) attempts to resist progress on equal civil rights. It is not “how America claims to govern itself”, it's how reactionary dissidents against the way America governs itself complain that they would prefer America to govern itself. In the way America claims to govern itself, people have rights and governments, including those of states, have powers. You probably mean “federalism” or “dual sovereignty” or something like that.