19 ms·
Another problem is from the candidate's point of view: I've already done "It" before. I've been doing "It" for the last decade. If I move companies, I want to d
by ryandrake 5y ago
Another problem is from the candidate's point of view: I've already done "It" before. I've been doing "It" for the last decade. If I move companies, I want to do "It+1" at the very least, more likely "It+2". It's not enough for me to simply do "It" again but at a different company. So many recruiters reach out with that pitch, and I simply ignore them now: "I see you have a great background doing 'It' at 'Company'. We're offering a role doing 'It' here at this company! Isn't that exciting?" No, it's not, actually. Now if you want me to manage a team of engineers doing "It", let's talk. If you want me to be Director of "It", I'll stop what I am doing and get on the phone with you in 5 minutes! But simply "Keep doing 'It' but at our company" is not even slightly motivating.
- HeyLaughingBoy 5y agoPart of the problem here might be that the HN population self-selects for the personality type that wants to do "at least It+1" There's a larger population out there that having mastered "It," will happily do exactly the same thing for the next 10 years.
- daniel-cussen 5y agoThat's very true those peeps for sure exist just not on this forum.
- padobson 5y ago"Keep doing 'It' but at our company" is not even slightly motivating. That's true, but what about "Keep doing 'It' but at our company for half the hours and double the salary"? Then you could take the extra time and money and work on your +1 and +2.
- gonzo41 5y agoI would guess that doing the +1 and +2 is mentally and emotionally easier and more satisfying if it's during a hellish 60 hour work week than in a relaxed 10 hours you freed up by getting more pay and a 30 hour week to do something easy. Like doing programming problems is fun for a bit, but doing work that actually does something, even if it's simpler in complexity is more satisfying. IMO of course. I think the recruiters could be pitching better if they went with, do 'it' here and think about what +1 could be and when you figure what that could be, pitch it to us. This of course assumes the organization sees IT as a value multiplier and not a cost center / plumbing job.
- plorkyeran 5y agoPast a certain point the +1 isn't something you can do on your own time. If you're looking to shift into more of a management role that's obviously hard to learn on a side project unless that side project is a full company with employees. Even pure technical skills can require certain scale; you aren't going to learn how to use k8s appropriately on the side because whatever you're doing on the side almost certainly shouldn't be using k8s at all. "Keep doing what you're doing but half the hours and double the salary" is something I would be tempted by, but it would be with the idea that I'm focusing on something other than developing my career.
- ryandrake 5y ago> "Keep doing what you're doing but half the hours and double the salary" is something I would be tempted by It would be tempting, even given the stake I just placed in the ground:[1] But 1. astronomically few companies will offer to double my comp at this late point in my career and 2. Nobody in tech offers part time work but with full benefits…I’d have to be a contractor and find clients and fund my own healthcare and retirement (yuck). It’s at best an theoretical exercise. 1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31193644 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31193644
- jmharvey 5y agoAre there recruiters out there who pitch based on hours and money? Every pitch I get is all about the vision/team/prospects for success. And, yes, "prospects for success" in some ways means "money" but they're never so explicit about it.
- bradlys 5y agoThis is just fantasy though. No one is offering $800k/yr at 20hr/week.
- maerF0x0 5y agoI suspect there are people who earn this. I doubt any of them are the traditional definition of "employee" though. Consultant/Contractor might be the closest.
- bradlys 5y agoYes - there are people who win the lottery too. My point is that there isn’t enough for this to really be a thing we should put up as anything but fantasy. If you think you’re gonna get a recruiter who lands this in your inbox - buy lottery tickets instead.
- worik 5y agoSenior.... * Accountants doing company liquidations * Trial lawyers * Performance artists Others I cannot think of. Pay rates over $1,000/hr are surprisingly common. Many of the recipients work fewer hours as a result
- majormajor 5y agoI've encountered shops billing $300+ per hour for fairly routine types of software work. And yeah, that's still pretty far away from the $800/hr or so that would be 800k for 20hr weeks, but we're not talking super specialists there. And you're not gonna take home all of that if you're just an employee at that shop, but if you go independent or start your own shop... you suddenly have a higher ceiling for basically just "doing the same thing you were already." It does take a very specific additional skill set to build up a network of clients and have the patience for that to turn into something where you're regularly booked, but if money is the number one thing you want to optimize for, it's something you should investigate.
- agumonkey 5y agoIt's always to enjoy more with more regularity
- malandrew 5y agoAs an expert in a particular area, this is exactly what I want. Even the same total comp and benefits but half the hours would be good. If I could do one week on and one week off or two weeks on and two weeks off that would be awesome.
- eatonphil 5y agoDespite that being my own philosophy as a candidate, I never thought about it this way as a hiring manager. I feel kind of dumb! Thanks for putting it this way.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoI mean I am willing to talk about keep doing it at the next company, assuming increase in rewards for doing it, but I am not going to be incredibly passionate about continue doing the thing that I really know how to do well as some recruiters seem to want, I will instead be pragmatic and professional.
- lazide 5y agoIt’s one of those misaligned incentive issues. Companies often (but not always) want someone to just do ‘It’ with minimal extra management effort. This is because every companies success is generally gated by the available extra intelligence and decision making ability at every level (really every organization). The more management work put in, and the more ongoing thinking required to produce unit X (whatever it is for the company), the less competitive they are. Most companies of course aren’t great at this, but as long as their competitors aren’t much better (and/or other factors add more ‘competitiveness’), it still works out. Most dumb and value destroying things happening anywhere is because someone who is in the position to make a decision doesn’t have the mental bandwidth to make a good decision, or someone with the bandwidth to make that decision isn’t trusted to do so because of lack of consistent mental bandwidth by someone else to supervise, select, or police folks like them. For individuals, like you note, the incentives are often the opposite - to grow, take on individual risk, etc. And most individuals who are not actually entrusted with the scope and scale that would challenge them HAVE extra mental capacity (albeit perhaps not the experience or whatever to actually be successful, but they won’t know that) because they aren’t subjected to those loads generally. Not to discount nepotism (usually caused by trust issues/difficulty with owners managing non family members), corruption (usually caused by those in control not seeing how to produce value while following the rules), etc.
- ratww 5y ago
- playing_colours 5y agoAnother attractive option: “doing it” but for +xx percent to compensation.
- wpietri 5y agoAttractive to whom? Probably not the person you're replying to. I imagine at this point in their career they have already heard of this whole "money" thing. People who are really good at things generally thrive on challenge, because without that you don't persist long enough to get good. For many, me included, no reasonable amount of money will get them through doing years of something where they aren't growing.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoNot to me. I've been doing "It" (shipping software -which is quite different from "writing" software) for my entire adult life. Basically, if you want to actually ship a superb-Quality native iOS/iPadOS/WatchOS/MacOS app, in an astonishingly short period of time, I'm a good person to talk to. What I have learned, is that very few people seem to want to actually ship software. Instead, companies become obsessed with "coding culture," and "process" (which can mean many different things). As it comes time to start preparing for it to go out the door, all kinds of roadblocks start piling up. It's crazy. I was "frozen out" of the industry, because of my age, which really pissed me off, but that has turned out to be a great thing. It's been a real joy, writing my own stuff. Out of necessity, I have to keep the scope humble, but that's fine.
- hhmc 5y agoDefining "It" to be shipping software feels so broad as to be useless. In perticular, you're not working in the same semantic framework as GP, who was talking about "It+1", "It+2" and so on
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoActually, no. It has been my experience that actually delivering, working, high-Quality, supported, documented software (regardless of what the software does), within a reasonable period of time, is beyond the capabilities of many corporations. I suspect that some folks make money by convincing others to invest, then hightailing it, before the chickens come home to roost, as opposed to actually selling a finished and supported product to end-users. In that case, looking like a "shipper," is much more important than actually being one.
- enraged_camel 5y agoI used to work in consulting where I had several hundred projects under my belt, and I think your objection is a bit shortsighted. It is possible to learn a lot by implementing something you have implemented before, but in a different context. Even if the problem turns out to be 80% the same, the remaining 20% can be a valuable learning experience. And if the pay is handsome, why turn it down?
- saalweachter 5y agoI do feel like "do the thing you did before, but fix the glaring mistakes you made before in hindsight" has some appeal.
- jameshart 5y agoIsn’t that one of the problems the article is getting at though? Someone who has done “it” in another environment will have scar tissue formed from issues they ran into doing “it” there. When you hire them to do “it” here, they will avoid things that didn’t work there and try to do things that did - but here is not there and maybe the situation aligns differently and what didn’t work there would work here. Like, maybe they ran into an issue with doing “it” using approach A because it required a more skilled operations team than they had there. But maybe here you have a better ops team and approach A would be much easier.
- danielmarkbruce 5y agoThis is hilariously on point. Frank Slootman (snowflake CEO) has some quote that is ~ "give people the opportunity of a lifetime if you want to hire amazing people". There are obviously downsides, but anecdotally smart + hyper engaged is hard to beat, even if that person hasn't done X.
- vmception 5y agoThis was my experience as a contractor, at least for my niche at the time. I felt like when I was an employee I was being paid to learn and adapt, but as a contractor I had one thing I was good at and only did that over and over again, which meant no room to grow.
- phkahler 5y ago>> I want to do "It+1" at the very least, more likely "It+2". I've managed to do "it+0.5" at a couple places. Most companies are only interested in doing "it" by the book and miss out on so much. At my current place I developed a couple +1 concepts that handle issues automatically, gave presentations with relatively little code needed, got a "hey that's cool" but was never asked to actually integrate those into the product or have someone closer to it integrate it. They're very happy to just do "it", never mind that we have issues that may well stem from not taking "it" to the next level.
- mise_en_place 5y ago> Now if you want me to manage a team of engineers doing "It", let's talk. If you want me to be Director of "It", I'll stop what I am doing and get on the phone with you in 5 minutes! These days, if you want to do that, you'll either need to have your company acquired, or buy the job you're looking for.
- szundi 5y agoLots of people can enjoy this. Being productive, effective, successful.
- bradknowles 5y agoAnd what if I don't want to go into any kind of management?