5 ms·
Majority of mathematicians hail from just 24 scientific ‘families’ (2016)
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoTo be clear, this refers to teacher-pupil relationships, not actual familial heritage.
- rob_c 5y agoBut we need an alex jones style headline to get in on the click bait... If this wasn't nature.com I would give it a free pass and shrug that "huh, everyone else is doing it", but really.... 'C'MON!!!
- ChefboyOG 5y agoI'm pretty critical of click-bait headlines in what are supposed to be more academic journals, but I don't get the frustration with this one. 'Families' is written in quotations, which tells me right from the jump that the author is probably not speaking about literal family units, and the use of "family" or "family tree" nomenclature in discussing matters of genesis and inheritance is pretty commonplace.
- rob_c 5y agoUnfortunately if you do enough outreach it's not long until you encounter some nitwit who claims all "religion of science" is controlled by them (be they lizards, moonmen or voldermort). And articles structured like this don't help trying to people like that.
- smegsicle 5y agoand leading with "Evolution of mathematics traced using unusually comprehensive genealogy database" ? anyway, the more interesting aspect seems to be the drop-off after the top five, they don't even bother naming the others- see the first graph on the page
- wheelinsupial 5y agoI think they name them all in Figure 10 in the actual paper [1]. But it doesn't seem to contain a rank ordering of the mathematicians that is easy to recover. Also, it appears there is data duplication with the first four names appearing twice in the list (first four and last four). [1] https://epjdatascience.springeropen.com/articles/10.1140/epjds/s13688-016-0088-y/figures/10 https://epjdatascience.springeropen.com/articles/10.1140/epj...
- rob_c 5y agoI was hoping not to have to dig through source material but i agree i do wonder how many Ramanujan style (isolated) mathematicians are in the field.
- bombcar 5y agoSo basically it’s an Erdös number post.
- TheCoelacanth 5y agoIsn't that about co-authoring rather than teacher-pupil relationships?
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoYeah, this doesn't surprise me at all, and I think you'd be likely to see similar relationships in any "niche" pursuits that take tons of expertise, e.g. classical musicians, ballet dancers, archeologists, successful startup companies, etc. etc.
- adventured 5y agoThe majority of nobel laureates hail from just two countries.
- sva_ 5y agoUnited States — 400 United Kingdom — 138 Germany — 111 France — 71 Sweden — 32 (tie) Russia — 32 (tie) Japan — 29 Canada — 28 Switzerland — 27 Austria — 22 (tie) Netherlands — 22 (tie) https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/nobel-prizes-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/nobel-pri... Doesn't seem so
- travem 5y agoFrom your link: > Nobel Prizes (including the SRPESMAN) have been awarded 609 times to a total of 943 people and 25 organizations Using the number of 943 people, a majority of Nobel Laureates (meaning more than 50%) would be more than 472 people. US + UK is 538 people which puts them above that threshold of being a majority.
- sva_ 5y agoI guess if you put it that way, the statement might be correct. But the disparity between US and UK being so big, I feel like the argument is a bit weaker. Using the average on such a small set doesn't seem to be so useful if there is such an outlier. There are some interesting lists here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_Nobel_laureates_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_Nobel_lau... I guess you could also look at laureates by country born, considering many people went to the US in WW2. But I imagine it'd just devolve into senseless nationalism.
- adhesive_wombat 5y agoComparing the US against any other Western country (and most others) using absolute numbers is usually an exercise in https://xkcd.com/1138/ https://xkcd.com/1138/. It's physically bigger (except maybe similar to Canada and Australia, both of which have big uninhabited areas) and has more people.
- version_five 5y agoOff the top of my head, Euler, Gauss, Newton, Leibniz, Euclid pretty much cover an undergraduate curriculum and all the math most people would know, and those are just five people. Expanding to the fullness of the discipline and 24 families does not seem surprising at all. It's probably more about how much of a long tail of subjects the field has. (As I said, this is off the top of my head and some obviously build on predecessors work. Descartes and to a lesser extent Fermat are also relevant here, no doubt others that made contributions the people I listed built on - Cardano?)
- sudosysgen 5y agoYou would also need Cantor and Riemann, as well as Pythagoras, Bernoulli, Al-Kashi and Al-Khawarizmi, Yang Hui maybe also Lebesgue, Cayley, etc... There are a lot of small but inaccessible results that are necessary and left out if you only consider sheer amount.
- anikan_vader 5y agoAnd while the list already includes Newton and Leibniz, nobody is proving calculus without Cauchy. There's no calculus without limits -- well, not unless you consider infinitesimal calculus, but that wasn't formalized until the mid-20th century.
- LudwigNagasena 5y ago> nobody is proving calculus without Cauchy Unless you are Heine?
- simulate-me 5y agoCauchy was also a pioneer in complex analysis, which is taught in undergrad.
- Ferrotin 5y agoRiemann and Cantor are both in Gauss’s family.
- 5y ago
- mihaic 5y agoSince this research doesn't mention some hard to quantify ties, it missed on the painting the picture of the most interesting actual family in mathematics: the Bernoullis. Brothers Jacob and Johann sprung up seemingly out of nowhere to continue Leibnitz's work in Basel as some of Europe's greatest mathematicians of their time. The most remarkable part is how Johann tutored the son of a local pastor, a friend of the family. After noticing his talent, he convinced the father to let the young boy focus on mathematics instead of joining the clergy. That young boy was Euler, and when we add Johann's son Daniel into consideration (who turned out to be a mathematician of similar caliber to his father) I'd venture to say that there is an actual family at the core of modern mathematics that would by itself be an object of study.
- huachimingo 5y agoI've always wondered why today we dont have people like them. Is science stagnating (aka Law of diminishing returns)?
- layer8 5y agoThe fruits are hanging higher up nowadays.
- Ar-Curunir 5y agoEach field has folks like these, you just don’t hear of them because fields are super specialized.
- mbrodersen 5y agoI suspect that this is true for any field. Not just mathematics. Think computer science. Think physics. The reality is that only a tiny percentage of people move a field/humankind forward. For every Einstein there are millions of people with zero long term impact.
- Ar-Curunir 5y agoI don’t think that’s true at all. Sure, some folks have outsized impact, but that doesn’t mean that,e.g., only Turing Award winners are have contributed to computer science. In fact, an outsized percentage of work put into projects led by these research “celebrities” is done by oft-forgotten grad students. Also, the article literally shows the opposite: these lineages contain many illustrious mathematicians, and it does them a disservice to classify them all as, e.g., “gauss’s line”
- throw0101a 5y ago> The reality is that only a tiny percentage of people move a field/humankind forward. We just happen to remember the ones that got more press, or perhaps published first. As one example, multiple folks came up with calculus at just about the same time: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_multiple_discoveries#17th_century https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_multiple_discoveries#1... Everyone knows Newton, some folks know about Leibniz, but how many now about de Fermat, etc? Bell is know for the telephone, but what about Elisha Gray? * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elisha_Gray_and_Alexander_Bell_telephone_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elisha_Gray_and_Alexander_Bell... Also Edison and the light bulb versus Swan (and others): * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incandescent_light_bulb https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incandescent_light_bulb
- usrn 5y agoA lot of calculus is intuitively obvious IMO. People make way too big a deal over who "invented" it. Half the people here probably figured integrals out on their own writing video games in their teens.