6 ms·
> I personally hate the idea of face ID I can kind of get why "Windows Hello" camera-based face id isn't exactly great but do you also think the same of Apple'
by Spivak 5y ago
> I personally hate the idea of face ID
I can kind of get why "Windows Hello" camera-based face id isn't exactly great but do you also think the same of Apple's "actually modeling your face" style? Because I was really apprehensive about it compared to a fingerprint reader but I've pretty much flipped 180.
- nicce 5y agoAs long as you think face or fingerprint as an username and not as password, they are kinda fine. You should be able to change your password, so there are not good. They are also public information. For now, they work as they are still hard to fake, but that might change over time in the future.
- spicybright 5y agoYup, just gotta model your threats. I use finger print scanners at home because it's less keystrokes. But not on my phone. Both because my (trusted) friends sometimes need to borrow a phone, and also for the very rare chance police detain me and try to break into my phone without a warrant. Legally, you don't have to tell a cop your password, but they can physically force you to use your finger/face to unlock your phone.
- jeroenhd 5y agoWindows Hello is more than just a webcam, the IR spectrum is a lot harder to fake (compared to, say, facial recognition in many Android phones). You'll need a picture taken with an IR camera, programmed into fake webcam hardware, to bypass it. Still far from perfect, but not as trivial to bypass as people seem to think. That said, the traditional fingerprint readers are more secure and just as easy to use. I don't understand why Apple shifted focus for mobile security onto facial recognition, especially with the development of under-screen fingerprint scanners in smartphones.
- whoopdedo 5y agoGloves?
- ChuckNorris89 5y agoFacemasks?
- spicybright 5y agoI've never worn a glove that feels comfortable using a touchscreen in. Even medical latex-type gloves make keyboard typing near impossible for me (granted that might be because I'm right between sm and md size gloves so I have to wear slightly baggy mediums...)
- jodrellblank 5y agoJohn Gruber / Daring Fireball has written several posts about FaceID, including: > "(Quoting Stratechery) TouchID made it far easier to have effective security for the vast majority of situations, and FaceID makes it invisible. [...] the first time I saw notifications be hidden and then revealed (as in the GIF above) through simply a glance produced the sort of surprise-and-delight that has traditionally characterized Apple’s best products" - https://daringfireball.net/linked/2017/11/08/apple-at-its-best https://daringfireball.net/linked/2017/11/08/apple-at-its-be... > "(Quoting Tom's Guide) I’ve been using Face ID on the iPhone X for more than 24 hours, and I don’t need a stopwatch to tell you that it unlocks my phone slower than when I was using Touch ID on my older iPhone 7 Plus". This is not a “workaround”. This is how you’re supposed to unlock iPhone X. Starting with a tap of the side button is not how you’re supposed to do it — you’re creating a two-step process where you only need one. [...] The best way to use Face ID is to pretend it isn’t even there, and just swipe up from the home indicator." - https://daringfireball.net/linked/2017/11/01/face-id-extra-step https://daringfireball.net/linked/2017/11/01/face-id-extra-s... > "(Quoting Michael Tsai) However, Face ID also has advantages. It works with gloves on, with wet fingers, and with dry/cracked skin. It’s more convenient when the phone is in a dock or car mount where it would be hard to get my hand under it to put my thumb on the sensor." - https://daringfireball.net/linked/2019/03/01/tsai-iphone-se-to-xr https://daringfireball.net/linked/2019/03/01/tsai-iphone-se-...
- jeroenhd 5y agoI wear face masks more often than I wear gloves and I sure hope facial recognition doesn't just throw away half my face. Combine that with the fact that in certain Asian countries it was normal long before COVID to wear masks when you're not well and I'm not sure which one makes more business sense. With under-screen fingerprint scanners, or the power button fingerprint scanners on some phones, that "two step process" turns back into a single step. My unlock process is to put my finger on my screen (where the fingerprint scanner is) and pull it out of my pocket. It's honestly no different from the swipe up that you need to do on iOS. Because the scanner is on the front, it also works pretty flawlessly when it's attached to a mount of some sort. Wet hands are one place where improvements can be made, but modern fingeprint scanners are doing quite well in that space as well. I've used Google's facial recognition system for ages before I had a phone with a fingeprint scanner and it was always pretty snappy for me, but I didn't set it up with this phone and I haven't missed it so far.
- krageon 5y ago> You'll need a picture taken with an IR camera, programmed into fake webcam hardware, to bypass it This is absolutely wrong. I've bypassed it with only a picture (off of a phone, no less). It is bad technology (for securing sensitive information). In terms of convenience of course, it is unmatched.
- dTal 5y agoI've found the convenience to be quite easily surpassed by not ever locking my machines, at virtually no cost to security compared to biometric authentication :)
- krageon 5y agoThat's a pretty solid point, though if you only want to secure against a random hobo that doesn't know you at all (and indeed has never seen you) then face locking is okay.
- dTal 5y agoIf you're leaving your laptop unattended in a place where random strangers have access to it, the likely outcome is that the machine will be stolen. I'm struggling to come up with a threat model that makes sense for biometrics.
- krageon 5y agoI'm not sure what sort of office you work at, but unfortunately all of the ones I've ever been in do indeed have random strangers in them (not employed by the company). Generally you can trust them not to steal laptops, but you are still not supposed to be sprinkling your possibly internal-only communications around. This threat model is well-served by biometrics, though really why you wouldn't just use a password I don't really know. As you say it works against a more robust attack and there are ways of generating them that are (relatively) easily memorisable using mnemonics.
- spicybright 5y agoMind sharing what made you flip? Apple's face modeling is miles better than a webcam for sure, and I'll admit I've never used a system like that before.
- pabs3 5y agoThere is no way to indicate login consent with biometric authentication; when you are asleep, your finger/face can be used without your consent. Really it should be called biometric identification, not authentication.
- scoopertrooper 5y agoWhile biometrics are imperfect (because you can't change or even hide the key), it's not quite as bad as you make out. On iOS at least, it gains affirmative consent by you double clicking a button on the side. It also refuses to recognise your face if your eyes are closed.
- pabs3 5y agoThe attacker could be pressing the button, or even opening your eyes for you :)
- n8cpdx 5y agoIt’s pretty strict and won’t authenticate if I look too tired, so I think you’d have to be pretty careful about how you tape the unconscious victim’s eyes (a conscious victim would just look away from the screen) to fool it. And if someone has full physical control over you such that they can open your eyes without consent, do you really care if they can unlock your phone? Your life is in their hands at that point anyway. You have to assume a persistent attacker with physical access will be able to crack the device regardless.
- pabs3 5y agoI'm thinking children or spouses, you may be able to trust them not to murder you in your sleep, but accessing your device while you sleep to be able to play some games or read your texts is something they would probably do.
- scoopertrooper 5y ago